Takes
Void
PFT Commenter
Roger Federer is the undisputed GOAT of tennis
Roger Federer, now the GOAT. His 20th [Major].
While Federer was the GOAT then, Novak Djokovic and Rafael Nadal eventually surpassed his Grand Slam total.
Loss
PFT Commenter
Roger Federer will beat Rafael Nadal at the US Open
I'm going to go Federer.
Federer lost in the quarterfinals to Juan Martín del Potro, so the matchup with Nadal never happened. Nadal went on to win the tournament.
Void
Big Cat
Roger Federer is the GOAT and the classiest athlete of all time
He's the GOAT, but he's also the classiest. So a lot of class getting thrown around when we talk about Federer. The gentleman. Just the smoothness with which he plays. That is a guy that you want to be dating your daughter.
The 'GOAT' status is subjective, though Federer was widely considered so at the time.