Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Julian Edelman

Julian Edelman

Guest
2017 — 2024
24W·17L·2P·1 open
footballlife43 scored

All Takes

Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Lions are not currently the best team in the NFL because of the Aidan Hutchinson injury

I don't think they're the best team in the NFL... The Hutchinson's injury though does concern me. Like against bad football teams, you don't need a pass rush... but I'm concerned of those games when they have to play against a Lamar Jackson may be in a Super Bowl or you know, a Brock Purdy or, or or a a Jordan Love... can they stop 'em in the red? They need to get a three points in the red area. They can't give up a touchdown. Can they stop 'em in the red area? I don't think so right now.

Subjective power ranking, though the Lions continued to dominate even without Hutchinson for several weeks.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Dan Campbell needs to evolve and stop taking unnecessary risks like fake punts

I love Dan Campbell, but he needs to evolve his play color. His, his, his coaching style. He, he, he can't act like he's a the hunter anymore. He's being hunted. You know, you, you're the good team. Your culture's in place. We don't have to run a fake punt in the opening drive... when you, me, everyone in the goddamn stadium knew it was gonna be a fake fucking punt.

Subjective coaching critique.
Open
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Matthew Stafford is a first-ballot Hall of Famer

I think he's a first battle hall of famer, man. He's a stud... I feel like he's like a Aaron [Rodgers] and [Mahomes] hybrid where like he gets that pop that, that Aaron got. But he also has been changing arm angles and doing No looks back in Detroit 10, 15 years ago.

Stafford is not yet eligible; this will be determined after his retirement.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers lack mental toughness and play like they've already won a Super Bowl

San Francisco's kind of disappointed Me too though, honestly... they act like they've already won the Super Bowl, like the way they play and stuff. To me, they need a little more mental toughness. There's always a a story out there. Someone's hurt, someone's shot, someone's this, someone's that... How can you focus on the games? We don't, we don't focus on anything but what's going on outside the game.

The 49ers struggled with late-game collapses and consistency throughout the 2024 season, lending credence to the idea of a mental or cultural lapse.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Steelers resemble the Legion of Boom era Seahawks teams

Pittsburgh's sneaky man... that team right now reminds me and gives me like, not, I'm not saying they are, but it's like those legion of being boom, super Bowl teams. Russ Wilson throws a teardrop here, deep ball there. He's got an explosive receiver to get a good run game and play really good defensive special teams. Like that's how they won in Seattle.

While the Steelers defense was elite, they did not reach the historical level of the Legion of Boom, nor did they win the Super Bowl in 2024.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick will definitely return to coaching in the NFL

Hell yeah. [Is he going to coach again?] He's definitely gonna coach again... I do think he, he, he loves football and he wants to coach man. I think this could be all part of his, his master trick of trying to get back in and show that he's like young and cool... if I was a gambling man, I think he'd be a, he, he, he [will coach].

Bill Belichick did not return to coach in the NFL. He took the head coaching job at the University of North Carolina instead, surprising many by going to the college level rather than returning to the NFL.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I hate my catch against the Falcons in the Super Bowl because I ran a bad route

I honestly, it's a lucky play. Like, I don't, like, I like watching plays that like, I got blown up or something and I just hung on with the ball... I don't like that play. [PFT Commenter: Why?] Because it was a bad route. I middle read, I didn't bop my guy to the bow route... I bananaed my route. You gotta make him feel like you're hitting that bow route... it was a bad route, so I don't like it.

This is a subjective self-assessment from the player himself.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Drew Bledsoe still throws the ball 1,000 miles an hour even though he's 50 years old

Hey, I threw with Drew Bledsoe. [Hank: He was throwing a thousand miles an hour.] Still zips it, bro. [Hank: Was he just like, here's a catch here, it's going 90 miles an hour?] No, we were literally... and there's a ball there and we just started throwing... that dude's got the centrifugal force on his ball... he's 50 years old and he still could still zip it.

Numerous videos and accounts from the Tom Brady Roast weekend confirm Bledsoe still has high velocity.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Brian Hoyer throws the most catchable ball of any quarterback I played with

You know who actually threw a real catchable ball? Brian Hoyer did... He had this little pat thing. He threw a real catchable ball. Mallet used to throw a real heavy, heavy like hard ball... but yeah, Hoyer threw a real catchable ball.

Teammate preference on ball feel is entirely subjective.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Gronk is actually a savant with numbers

I'm telling you right now. Gronk knows numbers, bro... whenever we used to talk contracts... I would always bust his balls like, yo, what's square root of this, Gronk? 144. He'd be like 12, dude! Like, he really knows numbers pretty well, dude. Not joking.

Gronk's intelligence is a matter of personal observation from his teammate.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Ron Rivera will be fired by the Commanders

Do you think Ron Rivera will get fired? Yeah, I do.

Ron Rivera was fired by the Commanders on January 8, 2024.
Push
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick coaching for a team other than the Patriots is a looming reality

Could you see Bill Belichick coaching for any team, but the New England Patriots next year? I mean, I think it's a reality that's gonna, that's gonna come, you know, I won't believe it until it's done. But it it, when the media starts getting on this and starts talking about it where there's smoke, there's fire. And I just hope it's handled correctly.

Belichick and the Patriots mutually parted ways in January 2024, although he did not end up coaching for another team in the 2024 season.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Jerod Mayo is one of the smartest football players I ever played with

Jerod, he, he's one of the smartest football players I played with. You know, he was the guy that was helping me get lined up when I was playing DB. I'd look at him, he's [saying] cover fucking five, get over there. You know, so Jerod knows football.

Mayo was hired as the Patriots head coach shortly after, confirming the organization shared Edelman's high opinion of his intelligence.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Drops are contagious among wide receivers

Are drops contagious? They are. I, I, I, I honestly think it's not just one thing that you fix it, it, it comes down to, you know, guys working together to execute a play. ... It ultimately comes down to just practice and preparation.

This is a psychological observation from a professional athlete that is widely accepted in football culture.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers are beatable if you run the ball effectively and keep their offense off the field

You gotta run the ball against them. ... You do not want to get on a hole against that defensive line that only has to rush four. And then you can get all that crazy scheme of the defense behind and they fly. ... You gotta keep that offense off the field. You know, and that's what the running game does as well.

This is a fundamental football strategy; the Chiefs used a balanced attack to beat them in the Super Bowl.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Ravens are the biggest threat to the 49ers in a Super Bowl matchup

Lamar Jackson is just a game plan killer. Right. You know, he can go take a game over, you know, and especially if he's, you know, Odell, when when the lights are bright, you know, odells gonna come out and he's gonna start bawling. ... I think they're a scary football team ... Lamar Jackson and the Ravens are 19 and 5 against the spread as an underdog.

The Ravens and 49ers were the #1 seeds in their respective conferences, and the Ravens beat the 49ers on Christmas Day shortly after this take.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Brock Purdy is the NFL MVP

How do we talk about Brock Purdy? Is he the MVP? I mean, right now he, he probably is. That's a, I mean that the MVP's always a quarterback, right. ... You have to give credit to what Brock Purdy's doing. You have to, you have to, you know, the, this whole game manager thing, people don't realize it's more like a game operator.

Lamar Jackson won the 2023 NFL MVP. Purdy finished 4th in voting.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

NFL teams cannot just 'flip the switch' in the playoffs

Guys are just gonna flip the switch and it never happens like that. You are what you are. And that's the honest truth with football... Belichick used to say it, 'You can't just take a fucking Gatorade before practice and turn it on.'... Teams cannot turn it on.

Subjective football philosophy.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill O'Brien is a great hire for the Patriots because he understands the standard

I think it's a great move for the Patriots because [Bill O'Brien] understands the standard. He's been in the situation of being a coach in the organization... and he's also been a head coach... he single-handedly developed Deshaun Watson, made him a $250 million quarterback.

O'Brien's 2023 return as OC for the Patriots resulted in a stagnant offense, and the team finished 4-13, leading to the departure of both Belichick and O'Brien.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Patrick Mahomes will not be able to practice physically before the AFC Championship

I don't think he's gonna physically be able to practice. I mean, they're gonna try to get that swelling out the whole week... I sprained my ankle and it wasn't even a real bad high ankle and I was out for like four weeks.

Mahomes was a full participant in practice all week leading up to the game and played effectively, despite Edelman's skepticism.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers will beat the Eagles in the NFC Championship

I like the Niners against Philadelphia. Niners defense... the linebackers for the Niners are insane. It's gonna be a bloodbath... I'm taking the Niners. I'm taking Kyle Shanahan over Sirianni. That's why I'm taking the Niners.

The Eagles defeated the 49ers 31-7 after Brock Purdy was injured early in the game.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Bengals will beat the Chiefs in the AFC Championship

I'm going with Bengals and it has to do with the ankle of Patrick Mahomes. I mean, that's gonna be a tough task... that Bengals team, they got a swagger, they got a confidence. They don't have excuses.

The Chiefs defeated the Bengals 23-20 to advance to the Super Bowl.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Josh Allen is better prepared than other QBs because he actually plays in the preseason

The bills played in the preseason... you saw Josh Allen go out and lead his team to touchdown drives every time he was out there, he looked very comfortable. Comfortable game looks slowed him. And that's because he is prepared.

Allen and the Bills did start the 2022 season extremely hot, looking like the most prepared team in the league.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Raiders will win the AFC West

Raiders are winning the AFC West. I'm a believer in the ecosystem that they have over there. I think Derek Carr is, I think he's a good football player. Last year they showed a lot of mental toughness... with McDaniels and Devante Adams going over there... they were smooth.

The Raiders finished 6-11, 3rd in the AFC West, and Derek Carr was eventually benched.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Patriots' offense will have a learning curve with Matt Patricia and Joe Judge calling plays

This is gonna be a learning experience. Calling plays on the offense side of the ball is, is very different... the rhythm of play calling and the relationship between the quarterback and play call is a fucking, that's like a skill... it hasn't looked very good in the pre-season I'm not gonna lie. [Mac Jones] just doesn't look comfortable back there.

The 2022 Patriots offense was famously dysfunctional under Matt Patricia and Joe Judge, leading to Mac Jones' regression.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Vikings will win the NFC North

I like Minnesota winning the north. Kevin O'Connell... always a smart guy, always knew Xs and Os. I like, I like, I liked them. I think Jefferson is, is outrageous. Outrageous.

The Vikings won the NFC North with a 13-4 record.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Rams will struggle this year; the Super Bowl hangover is real

I think the Rams are gonna struggle. I think, I think the hangover's real. And something's up with Stafford's elbow. The elbow did not—that doesn't look good. It looks jelly.

The Rams finished 5-12, one of the worst title defenses in NFL history, and Stafford missed significant time with injuries.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Bills will win the Super Bowl over the Buccaneers

Bills versus the Bucks, but the Bills are gonna win. Bills are winning it... If they stay healthy, they're gonna be a problem.

The Super Bowl was Chiefs vs. Eagles. The Bills lost in the Divisional round and the Bucs lost in the Wild Card.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Chiefs' offense will be condensed and struggle more without Tyreek Hill

It's gonna be interesting to see them without Tyreek Hill... [Hill] opens up the field in so many different ways with that speed... When you lose that, it condenses the offense... I want to see if [Mahomes] got better at those things [throwing inside the pocket], because you're gonna have to do that. He's gonna have to have these long methodical drives.

While the offense did change, Mahomes won MVP and the Chiefs won the Super Bowl with the #1 scoring offense in the league.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Bears should have hired an offensive coach to pair with Justin Fields instead of Matt Eberflus

I was looking at that and I was a little conflicted. You have a young quarterback and we've seen with all these other teams when they're surrounding these guys with those quarterback whispers, whatever you want to call it, these offensive minded coaches, we've seen a lot of success... I personally would have went to the opposite direction of [defensive minded].

Justin Fields struggled under Eberflus and was eventually traded to the Steelers, and Eberflus was fired after failing to develop a consistent offense.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Tom Brady has one more year of football left in him

I think he's got one more year. Cause it's like looking at the Bucs roster. It's family. Yeah. That's the family's tough. It's going to have to be really good for him... This is the most I've ever felt like he could probably hang them up, but you know what I mean? It wouldn't surprise me either way.

Brady retired on Feb 1, 2022, but un-retired on March 13, 2022, and played exactly one more season for the Buccaneers.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers will beat the Rams in the NFC Championship Game

I'm going Moneyline... San Francisco 49ers. They're going to win. Jimmy G is going to have a good game. I do. Kyle Shanahan is probably preaching to this guy... just take care of the ball.

The Rams defeated the 49ers 20-17 to advance to the Super Bowl.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

You aren't a true 'dog' until your back is against the wall and you prove the doubters wrong

You can't go out there and be a dog until your ass is against the wall. People are hating on you and you go out and you prove them wrong. That's when you're a dog.

This is a subjective definition of an intangible personality trait.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Bengals are a 'team of destiny' and will beat the Chiefs in the AFC Championship Game

I'm going with the Bengals. Cause they're I think they're a team of destiny. Joe, Joe Burrow. This is the first number one pick to ever go to the AFC championship or a championship game into his third or second year.

The Bengals defeated the Chiefs 27-24 in overtime to reach the Super Bowl.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

NFL teams are over-relying on analytics and should prioritize taking points with field goals to build momentum

I hate that. Refusing to kick a field goal and go for on a fourth down... that caused the [Chargers] their season. There's a time and place. It has to be a win for the guys on the sidelines [to take the points]. You don't get it, and then you're probably going to go for it again.

The value of analytics versus field goal points is a central debate in modern NFL strategy that remains subjective.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I will never become a coach because knowing how it's done at the highest level would kill me

If I'm coaching, we've got some problems, guys. I already know how it's done at the highest level, it will kill me. I wouldn't be able to do it.

Edelman has not taken a coaching role since retiring, maintaining this stance.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Jalen Hurts is not a long-term solution at quarterback for the Eagles

[Jalen Hurts] is gonna make some really good plays with his legs... and he shows he's shown us that he does that consistently. But I mean, I just don't think that's like a long lasting plan.

Hurts led the Eagles to Super Bowl LVII, finished 2nd in MVP voting, and signed a massive long-term extension, proving he was the solution.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The future of the Washington Football Team is on an upward trajectory under Ron Rivera

The future of the organization is looking at an upward trajectory for Washington. I believe in Ron Rivera. I mean, he did it, he had the Carolina Panthers, you know, a pretty good football team for a long time.

Rivera was unable to sustain success in Washington and was eventually fired in January 2024.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Wide receivers are transitioning from college to the NFL at a higher rate than ever before

I think that receivers are actually transitioning at a higher rate in these last five, six years than they have ever before... a lot of these guys, there's so much more information now for younger players on how to train, what kind of drills to train.

The recent explosion of rookie WR production (Jefferson, Chase, Puka Nacua) validates this observation.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Patrick Mahomes is missing throws that he hasn't missed in a very long time

The [Chiefs] are getting hot at the right time when their defense is playing well. That's scary. Their offense still isn't there. They're still missing little fundamental things. And I've seen Patrick Mahomes miss some throws you haven't seen him miss in a very long time.

Hindsight and advanced metrics confirm that Mahomes had a period of uncharacteristic struggles and turnovers in 2021 before the Chiefs' late-season surge.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Colts are a Super Bowl contender because of their opportunistic defense and special teams

I like Indianapolis. That defense is, they got 31 takeaways... They're just so opportunistic on defense. They can stop the run... They have a special teams [block punt]... they're a tough football team.

The Colts missed the playoffs entirely after a stunning Week 18 loss to the 2-14 Jaguars.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers are Super Bowl contenders because Jimmy Garoppolo is a winner and their defense is flying

I'm going with the Niners. I like the way the Niners play. [Jimmy Garoppolo]'s been there, man. And everyone wants to hate on him... The guy who wins football games. You get it to Kittle, if Kittle stays healthy, Deebo Samuel stays healthy... if you watch that defense man, they're playing real well. They're flying right now.

The 49ers made a deep playoff run to the NFC Championship, validating them as legitimate contenders.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I want to see Mac Jones face some adversity and struggle to see what kind of leader he is

I want to see him [Mac Jones] face some adversity, see how he does with that... I hope he doesn't [sprain his ankle], but you want to see the toughness of a guy. I want to see something go wrong. And I want to see the man he is in an adverse situation. That's when you see your best leaders.

Subjective opinion on player development and leadership evaluation.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Mac Jones plays 'on time' which is why he is a successful quarterback

He plays on time. Playing on time is like getting through your reads at the correct time... delivers a catchable football. His eyes are always in the right area. He's delivering the ball when he should deliver the ball... Those are 'playing on time' kind of moments.

Subjective evaluation of quarterback play style and timing.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick makes players change their glove color to match the opponent's jersey to hide holding penalties

[Bill Belichick] would always try to get me to change the color of my glove for blocking in the run game. Because if we were playing a team that had white and the referee, he said, 'the ref could see her goddamn glove on the backside of him. He's going to call holding every time.' So he would literally make like young players, like, 'Hey, you're wearing white today because we're playing against the white team.'

Direct anecdotal evidence from a long-time player under the coach.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Players who wear black cleats and still look fast are the true 'burners' in the NFL

You always know a guy's a burner. If you see a guy wearing black cleats and he still looks fast. That's when those guys are like, they know they're fast. They wear black cleats. That's like a flex.

Inherently subjective observation about player speed and equipment.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

A truly tough football team can run the ball, stop the run, and cover kicks

This is what defines a tough football team. A physically tough football team, from what I was taught from some guy named Bill [Belichick], a tough football team can run the ball, can stop the run and can cover kicks. What teams do that the best? Baltimore, Patriots, Tennessee.

This is a coaching philosophy/definition of terms. While subjective in application, the claim that these are the three pillars of toughness is a verifiable statement of Belichick's philosophy as reported by Edelman.
Win
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Chiefs are getting better because they are taking care of the football and playing more opportunistic defense

I think the chiefs are getting better. They're playing smarter football... the last couple of weeks, what have they been doing? They've been taking care of the football. Their defense has been very opportunistic and playing situationally very well on the third down... they're finding their way.

The Chiefs did improve significantly after their early-season struggles, eventually reaching the AFC Championship game.
Loss
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I am riding with a Bills vs. Packers Super Bowl prediction

[Super Bowl prediction] I said, Bills and Green Bay. I'm going to ride with the Bills. I mean, I got seen some things I got to start to see the offense needs to start getting it going.

The Super Bowl was Rams vs. Bengals. Neither the Bills nor the Packers reached the Super Bowl.
Void
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

I was rooting for the Patriots over Tom Brady and the Bucs

I was rooting for the Pats [over the Bucs]. I mean, my guy [Brady] gets a little sensitive sometimes. He's my best friend, and... I don't think he probably would [say I am his best friend] anymore [because I didn't root for him].

This is a personal rooting interest/opinion, so it is inherently subjective.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers