Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Julian Edelman, Bruce Arians In Studio, The Dodgers Win The World Series, The Jets Are Back + Week 9 Picks And Preview

Friday, November 1, 202421 takes

The Jets are back after winning Thursday Night Football in the ugliest fashion (-). The Dodgers are World Series Champions after an all time meltdown from the Yankees in Game 5 (-). Week 9 Picks and Preview for every game on Sunday, Flacco in primetime, Cowboys last stand, and fantasy fuccbois (-). Julian Edelman joins the show to talk ball, his new podcast, what a dude is, and tons more (-). SB Winning Head Coach Bruce Arians joins the show in studio to talk about coaching, quarterback development, Big Ben getting mad at him, Peyton's rookie season and more (-). We finish with a Halloweeen edition of Fyre Fest of the week (-).

Julian Edelman and Bruce Arians on Jets, Dodgers, and QB Development

The vibes are high following a bizarre Thursday Night Football win for the New York Jets. Big Cat and PFT are trying to wrap their heads around how a team can look so fundamentally broken for thirty minutes and then suddenly look like a playoff contender. While Aaron Rodgers finally found a rhythm with Davante Adams, it was Garrett Wilson’s gravity-defying shin-catch that stole the show. PFT is ready to buy all the stock in the green and white again.

Loss
Nov 1, 2024
#5755
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jets will win three straight games and reach a 6-6 record

I know [the Jets] are all the way back. I think the Jets are gonna win three straight right now... I think we're gonna turn around and the jets are gonna be, they're gonna be six and six.

The Jets lost their next two games to the Cardinals and Colts, failing to reach 6-6.

Memes isn't quite as optimistic, even in victory. He's still reeling from a first half that featured more bloopers than highlights, including a Malachi Corley touchdown celebration that ended at the one-yard line. For Memes, the win doesn't mask the deeper issues within the organization.

Void
Nov 1, 2024
#5756
MemesMemes

The New York Jets are the worst coached football team of all time

This is also the worst coach football team of all time. Oh, that's a lot of, all times. There's so many All times.

Subjective hyperbole from a fan after a sloppy win.

The Yankees Meltdown and Dodgers Dynasty

Turning to the diamond, Big Cat and PFT break down the Los Angeles Dodgers’ World Series clincher. The conversation quickly shifts from the Dodgers' brilliance to the New York Yankees' historic defensive collapse in Game 5. Between Aaron Judge’s dropped fly ball and Gerrit Cole forgetting to cover first base, it was a masterclass in how to lose a championship in one inning. Big Cat notes that the Dodgers simply operated on a different level of competence.

Win
Nov 1, 2024
#5757
Big CatBig Cat

The Dodgers won the World Series because they are a fundamentally better team than the Yankees

The Dodgers did it by just being the better team and being the fundamentally better team. Because like, if you look at it... the Dodgers did, don't make mistakes like the Yankees made mistakes. And that showed a hundred percent in game five when the Yankees had a complete and utter meltdown.

The Yankees committed several high-profile errors in Game 5, including dropping fly balls and failing to cover bases, directly leading to their loss.

Beyond the fundamentals, the guys discuss the "new" identity of the Dodgers. With Shohei Ohtani and a roster full of All-Stars, they’ve officially stepped into the role the Yankees used to occupy: the big-spending empire that everyone loves to hate.

Win
Nov 1, 2024
#24911
Big CatBig Cat

The Dodgers are the new Yankees because they keep adding the best players to an already elite roster

The Dodgers are the new Yankees. That was the, that was the big thing. Like the the Dodgers. The Dodgers already had a super team and they're like, you know what we're gonna do? We're gonna add Shohei [Ohtani]. That's what the Yankees used to do. Yeah. So like that's, that's the Dodgers are the new Yankees and they, and they played fundamental Ball better than anyone else. They were the best team by far.

The Dodgers did indeed sign Ohtani to a massive deal after years of high spending, and they defeated the Yankees in the 2024 World Series.

Week 9 Picks and Preview

As the NFL hits the halfway point, the board is heating up. Big Cat is eyeing a focused Baltimore team looking to bounce back from a shocking loss to the Browns. While the Broncos have been a great story, the spread suggests the Ravens are ready to remind everyone who the heavyweight is in the AFC.

Win
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#5758
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens will beat the Broncos in a focused effort following their loss to the Browns

I think the Ravens are gonna be very focused. Broncos riding high and you see that nine point spread and you're like, oof, that's easy. It's a lot of points. Broncos are, are five and three. How are they nine point underdogs. I agree with you. Like I said, if the Ravens had won last week, I would probably be leaning heavy to the Broncos.

The Ravens defeated the Broncos 41-10 on November 3, 2024.

In the AFC East, the Bills continue to hold a psychological edge over the Dolphins. PFT is expecting Josh Allen to use his legs early and often in Buffalo, continuing his streak of dominance against Tua and company.

Loss
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#24913
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Josh Allen will score a rushing touchdown and have a big day on the ground against the Dolphins

I think Josh Allen's gonna have a big day with his feet too. Yeah. I think he's gonna just, he's gonna take off, he's gonna run some people over. Josh Allen touchdown this weekend.

In the Week 9 win over Miami, Josh Allen had 0 rushing yards and 0 rushing touchdowns.

Meanwhile, in Dallas, the wheels are officially falling off. The guys look at the Cowboys' lack of a run game and the general lack of explosiveness in an offense that used to be a juggernaut. Big Cat points to the lack of production from the backfield as a primary reason for their struggles.

Win
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#24912
Big CatBig Cat

Ezekiel Elliott is completely washed up

Zeke is completely washed by the way. Zeke is completely washed. He's the only running back with 30 Carries who has yet to break or miss a tackle according to Sports Info Solutions.

Elliott struggled significantly in 2024, seeing his role diminish and eventually being made inactive for various games.

Julian Edelman on "Dudes" and the Lions

Julian Edelman joins the show to talk about his new podcast, *Dudes on Dudes*, and to break down the current state of the league. Edelman offers a fascinating look at the Lions, noting that while they are elite, the loss of Aidan Hutchinson changes their ceiling in the postseason. He’s also looking for Dan Campbell to start coaching like a favorite rather than an underdog.

Void
Nov 1, 2024
#5761
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Dan Campbell needs to evolve and stop taking unnecessary risks like fake punts

I love Dan Campbell, but he needs to evolve his play color. His, his, his coaching style. He, he, he can't act like he's a the hunter anymore. He's being hunted. You know, you, you're the good team. Your culture's in place. We don't have to run a fake punt in the opening drive... when you, me, everyone in the goddamn stadium knew it was gonna be a fake fucking punt.

Subjective coaching critique.

Edelman also shares some love for Matthew Stafford, calling him one of the most gifted throwers the game has ever seen. He argues that Stafford's longevity and talent should have him in the Hall of Fame conversation immediately upon retirement.

Open
Nov 1, 2024
#5762
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Matthew Stafford is a first-ballot Hall of Famer

I think he's a first battle hall of famer, man. He's a stud... I feel like he's like a Aaron [Rodgers] and [Mahomes] hybrid where like he gets that pop that, that Aaron got. But he also has been changing arm angles and doing No looks back in Detroit 10, 15 years ago.

Stafford is not yet eligible; this will be determined after his retirement.

Bruce Arians on Quarterback Grittiness

Coach Bruce Arians stopped by the studio to talk about his storied career and what he sees in the current crop of young signal-callers. Arians, who has coached everyone from Peyton Manning to Tom Brady, gives a glowing review of Andrew Luck, calling him the most complete prospect he ever encountered.

Void
Nov 1, 2024
#5766
Bruce AriansBruce Arians

Andrew Luck is the ultimate quarterback prospect, possessing every top-tier trait

If I was gonna build all of [the QBs I've coached] into one, it'd be Andrew Luck. 'cause he had everything that they all had, you know, he had a photographic memory. He was as athletic stuff was off the charts, same as Cam Newton's. His, his recall was like Ben and Tom. His preparation was like Ben and Tom and Ben, Tom and Peyton.

Subjective ranking from a coach who worked with all of them.

He also weighed in on the struggles of young QBs like Anthony Richardson. Arians emphasizes that while athleticism is a plus, the NFL eventually requires you to win from the pocket, something Richardson is still trying to prove he can do consistently.

Win
Nov 1, 2024
#5765
Bruce AriansBruce Arians

Anthony Richardson is currently more of an athlete than a quarterback because he lacks consistency in the pocket

Anthony's stats didn't match. His ability and, and all, all ability doesn't make a quarterback. Now. You gotta be, you gotta win two minute, third down. I don't give a shit how fast you run. How high you jump... if you can't show me that you can do that in college, that to me, you're not a quarterback, you're an athlete... And he didn't exactly tear people up in college. You know, it was just combine superstar.

Arians' critique of Richardson's college production and pro readiness matches his current benching for Joe Flacco.

Before letting him go, Arians shared the incredible story of coaching an entire season with a torn Achilles because he didn't want to spend eight months in a boot. That is the definition of no risk, no biscuit.

Just remember to set your clocks forward next week, or backward, or whatever it is that makes the football start earlier.

nflmlbjetsdodgersworld-seriespatriotsbuccaneers

More Takes

Loss
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#5759
HankHank

The Commanders will lose their Week 9 matchup against the Giants

It would be very funny if, and I feel like the commanders are gonna lose this game. Yeah. Really. So Giants are gonna be, you're in your hungry dog thinking about it. Yeah. Wow. I honestly, I think the Giants are a good bet this week.

The Commanders beat the Giants 27-22 on November 3, 2024.
Loss
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#24914
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants are a good bet to beat the Commanders in Week 9

I honestly, I think the Giants are a good bet this week. If I'm being completely neutral on this and knowing my franchise and knowing how the giants typically play against us. It, it's, it's a good bet.

The Commanders beat the Giants 27-22.
Win
Nov 1, 2024·Picks
#5760
HankHank

The Lions will defeat the Packers by at least 10 points

I'm excited about this game. I think the lions are gonna roll. 10 plus. Like a, A stomping.

The Lions beat the Packers 24-14 on November 3, 2024, exactly a 10-point victory.
Void
Nov 1, 2024
#24915
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Lions are not currently the best team in the NFL because of the Aidan Hutchinson injury

I don't think they're the best team in the NFL... The Hutchinson's injury though does concern me. Like against bad football teams, you don't need a pass rush... but I'm concerned of those games when they have to play against a Lamar Jackson may be in a Super Bowl or you know, a Brock Purdy or, or or a a Jordan Love... can they stop 'em in the red? They need to get a three points in the red area. They can't give up a touchdown. Can they stop 'em in the red area? I don't think so right now.

Subjective power ranking, though the Lions continued to dominate even without Hutchinson for several weeks.
Void
Nov 1, 2024
#24916
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The 49ers lack mental toughness and play like they've already won a Super Bowl

San Francisco's kind of disappointed Me too though, honestly... they act like they've already won the Super Bowl, like the way they play and stuff. To me, they need a little more mental toughness. There's always a a story out there. Someone's hurt, someone's shot, someone's this, someone's that... How can you focus on the games? We don't, we don't focus on anything but what's going on outside the game.

The 49ers struggled with late-game collapses and consistency throughout the 2024 season, lending credence to the idea of a mental or cultural lapse.
Loss
Nov 1, 2024
#24917
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

The Steelers resemble the Legion of Boom era Seahawks teams

Pittsburgh's sneaky man... that team right now reminds me and gives me like, not, I'm not saying they are, but it's like those legion of being boom, super Bowl teams. Russ Wilson throws a teardrop here, deep ball there. He's got an explosive receiver to get a good run game and play really good defensive special teams. Like that's how they won in Seattle.

While the Steelers defense was elite, they did not reach the historical level of the Legion of Boom, nor did they win the Super Bowl in 2024.
Loss
Nov 1, 2024
#5763
Julian EdelmanJulian Edelman

Bill Belichick will definitely return to coaching in the NFL

Hell yeah. [Is he going to coach again?] He's definitely gonna coach again... I do think he, he, he loves football and he wants to coach man. I think this could be all part of his, his master trick of trying to get back in and show that he's like young and cool... if I was a gambling man, I think he'd be a, he, he, he [will coach].

Bill Belichick did not return to coach in the NFL. He took the head coaching job at the University of North Carolina instead, surprising many by going to the college level rather than returning to the NFL.
Win
Nov 1, 2024
#5764
Bruce AriansBruce Arians

Bryce Young has the talent to succeed in the NFL given the right offensive system

I saw Bryce win the national championship with, with maybe better players than he is playing with now... he can do it. He's shown he can do it in the right system. His stature scared me... there weren't any braces. There weren't any Johnny Manzes at that size and stature that made it in the NFL.

Bryce Young had his best NFL season in 2025 with 3,011 yards, 23 TDs, and led the Panthers to an 8-9 division title and playoff berth, showing the talent Arians described when given the right system under Dave Canales.
Void
Nov 1, 2024
#24919
Bruce AriansBruce Arians

Lamar Jackson was a more accurate passer coming out of college than Michael Vick

Lamar can spin it coming outta college. It was a little bit raw, but when I look at him and Michael Vick, I thought he spun it more accurately than Mike did coming out. Now Mike got better Lamar's Lamar's there now.

Lamar's passing statistics and MVP awards generally support the idea that he became a more polished passer than Vick, though college comparison is subjective.
Void
Nov 1, 2024
#24918
Bruce AriansBruce Arians

Brock Purdy is not just a system quarterback

I don't think [Brock Purdy] is a system quarterback, but not necessarily could he play in other offenses that push it way down the field. He's in the perfect thing with Kyle [Shanahan]... It's a great marriage.

Subjective debate about the definition of a 'system quarterback.'

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers