Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Carmelo Anthony, Wild MNF & Who Wants To Coach USC?

Wednesday, September 15, 202117 takes

We recap a wild MNF game between the Raiders and Ravens. The Manning broadcast was very good ( - ). CFB talk, USC needs a new coach and an Ohio State bet has been made ( - ). Hot Seat/Cool Throne ( - ). Carmelo Anthony joins to talk about his new memoir, his HoF basketball career, Syracuse, the Knicks, Big Cat recruiting him to the Bulls and being left out of the Banana Boat ( - ). We finish with guys on chicks

Carmelo Anthony on the Knicks, Banana Boat, and Lakers Superteam

The vibes were immaculate in the studio as future Hall of Famer and American hero Carmelo Anthony joined Big Cat and PFT for over an hour. This wasn't your typical media tour stop; Mello was open, honest, and actually seemed to enjoy the chaos. Before getting to the legend, we had to break down a Monday Night Football game that had absolutely everything, including Derek Carr's questionable targeting strategy and the debut of the ManningCast.

Monday Night Meltdown

The Raiders and Ravens gave us a Week 1 masterpiece in Vegas. Big Cat noticed that while the Raiders came away with the win, Derek Carr seemed to have a very specific vision for the offense that didn't involve much variety.

Win
Sep 15, 2021
#25773
Big CatBig Cat

The Raiders' offense consists of Derek Carr force-feeding Darren Waller regardless of the situation

The offense was essentially Derek Carr trying to throw it into [Darren] Waller no matter what the situation a hundred times a game and just be like, all right, well, let's run this play. If anyone else is open, it doesn't matter. I'm going to Waller.

In this specific game (Week 1, 2021), Waller had 19 targets, which was nearly 35% of Carr's attempts, supporting the claim that they were force-feeding him.

On the other side, Lamar Jackson was spectacular but shaky. PFT pointed out that for all his highlight-reel plays, there's a recurring issue when the pocket collapses.

Win
Sep 15, 2021
#7128
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson is not secure with the ball when getting hit

There is something about Lamar Jackson... when he's getting hit, he's not the most secure guy with the ball.

Lamar Jackson has historically had high fumble numbers, leading the league in fumbles several times.

The ManningCast was the real winner of the night. Despite a shaky first quarter where Peyton was vibrating at a frequency only dogs could hear, the guys agreed it’s the future of sports broadcasting. Big Cat thinks Peyton has found his calling if he can just deal with the logistics.

Void
Sep 15, 2021
#7130
Big CatBig Cat

Peyton Manning would be a fantastic booth announcer if he committed to the travel

I do think Peyton Manning would be fantastic if he ever decided to actually commit to this and go into the booth.

While subjective, the Manningcast's massive success and Manning's natural charisma support this view.

The USC Vacancy and Ohio State Woes

USC finally fired Clay Helton, a move that was about two years overdue. The search is on for a replacement, and the criteria might be more aesthetic than most fans realize. PFT has a very specific theory on what the Trojans are looking for in their next leader.

Void
Sep 15, 2021
#25774
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

You have to be physically attractive to succeed as the head coach at USC

USC is definitely one of those jobs that... you have to be hot. That's what it really comes down to. You have to be relatively hot for a football coach... You just have to have that hotness about you.

Subjective aesthetic judgment of coaching hires.

Speaking of coaching seats, Urban Meyer is already under the microscope in Jacksonville. If things continue to look bleak for the Jags, a return to the college ranks might be too tempting to pass up.

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Urban Meyer will leave the Jaguars for USC if they start 2-7

If the Jaguars start – I'll even say if they start – 2-7, there's like a 50% chance that Urban Meyer leaves for USC. If it's like 0-6, yeah, I think it's pretty likely.

Urban Meyer was fired from the Jaguars later that season and did not take the USC job (Lincoln Riley did).

The guys also locked in a massive bet regarding Ohio State's season. Hank is convinced the Buckeyes are in for a historical slide, which led to a high-stakes wager involving PFT not being able to watch NFL football for an entire month if they fall apart.

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ohio State will lose four games this season

I wouldn't be surprised if [Ohio State] lose four games. Four games.

Ohio State finished the 2021 season with only two losses (Oregon and Michigan).

Carmelo Anthony in Studio

Mello's interview was an all-timer. He discussed his new memoir, *Where Tomorrows Aren't Promised*, and didn't shy away from the tough stuff. He touched on the heartbreak of the 2003 draft and how he almost ended up in Detroit. It's a move that would have changed the history of the league, and Mello knows he would have been the missing piece for those Pistons teams.

Void
Sep 15, 2021
#25776
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

The 2003-04 Pistons would have won the title even more easily if they had drafted me

I actually thought I was going to Detroit, man. And that was a loaded team. I just knew I was going to Detroit... They were a great team. And [I] would have complimented them perfectly because they were winning a title scoring 80 points. Could have used a guy like [me].

While hypothetical, many analysts agree that Carmelo would have extended the Pistons' championship window, though some argue he might have disrupted their chemistry.

We finally got the truth about the Banana Boat, too. It turns out Mello wasn't snubbed; he just had a better sense of style than to get on the yellow inflatable with LeBron, D-Wade, and CP3. Speaking of his friends, he gave his honest take on the current state of superteams and the impossibility of the solo carry in the modern NBA.

Win
Sep 15, 2021
#7141
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

It is now impossible for a single star to win an NBA title alone

Now it's like you try to do that now your ass would be out the league. Because it's impossible for anybody to do that... I don't want to say it's sad, but it is sad. Because it's impossible for you to try to go do it by yourself.

Every NBA champion in the modern era has featured multiple All-Stars or All-NBA players.

Now that he's joined forces with LeBron in LA, the hierarchy of the Lakers is the biggest question in basketball. Mello broke down the superhero dynamics between the King and AD with a perfect Justice League analogy.

Void
Sep 15, 2021
#7139
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

Anthony Davis can be Robin, but LeBron James can only be Batman

I think AD can be Robin... LeBron could try to be Robin, but that ain't who he is. He is Batman. You know, he Bruce Wayne. AD can be Robin. He can switch it up.

Subjective categorization of player roles and personalities.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Matt Nagy is firmly on the Hot Seat, not just for his play-calling, but for the way he's handling the Justin Fields situation. Big Cat is reaching a breaking point with his coach's refusal to play the future of the franchise.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Nagy has lost credibility with the Bears locker room by benching Justin Fields

I do think that we're getting close to the point where Matt Nagy is going to lose credibility with his team if he doesn't play Justin Fields. He's already lost it.

Nagy was fired at the end of the season, and internal reports later confirmed significant friction within the building regarding QB management.

PFT's brain is also on the hot seat as he tries to convince himself that a certain former Bears quarterback might be the savior for the Washington Football Team.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mitch Trubisky is better than Taylor Heinicke

I wouldn't hate Mitch Trubisky on the football team... He's better than Taylor Heinicke... He absolutely is.

Heinicke eventually led Washington to a 7-8 record as a starter that year, while Trubisky was a backup in Buffalo. Career-wise, both have been journeymen.

To wrap up the show, the guys went through a classic round of Guys on Chicks involving "dick microwaves" and the etiquette of watching your husband pee.

Stay Mello.

nflnbaraidersusc-footballknickslakers

More Takes

Win
Sep 15, 2021
#7132
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The idea of huge halftime adjustments is a media-fabricated myth

The idea that there's this big revelation and we change everything at halftime is just completely media fabricated. [Peyton Manning] is like, yeah, the players, by the time we get a drink of water, we're already going back out.

Multiple players and coaches (including Bill Belichick and Peyton Manning) have confirmed that halftime is too short for 're-drawing everything,' though small tweaks are made.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

USC is a top three job in college football

I think USC is a top job. Top three job maybe.

Subjective ranking, though Lincoln Riley's immediate move there suggests high market value.
Loss
Sep 15, 2021
#25775
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin will make it to the Big Ten championship game

I do think Wisconsin, after watching Notre Dame play Toledo, I think Wisconsin might be back... It would be so incredible if it was Ohio State versus Wisconsin in the Big Ten championship game.

Wisconsin finished the 2021 season 9-4 and did not reach the Big Ten Championship game (Iowa represented the West).
Void
Sep 15, 2021
#25777
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

Internal friction between players can ruin a team's championship chances regardless of talent

If you don't have chemistry with your teammates or on the team, I don't care how good you are, you're not going to win... If the point guard beefed with the big, that put the ring in jeopardy. And that's a true statement.

General sporting philosophy.
Win
Sep 15, 2021
#7140
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

The United States is still the best in the world at basketball

I knew we was going to win. We're the best in the world. I don't care what nobody say... They're only catching up to us because they're learning from us.

The US won gold in Tokyo (2021) and Paris (2024), supporting the claim of continued dominance.
Win
Sep 15, 2021
#25778
Carmelo AnthonyCarmelo Anthony

Damian Lillard needs to leave Portland if he wants to win an NBA ring

I understand what's going on with [Damian Lillard] and how he's thinking. Now, we all have these man-to-man conversations, and I tell them, look... whatever you feel like will get you to that, to a ring, then you have to make that happen. And it's not about being disrespectful... you handle your business and you go from there. And if it don't work, it don't work.

Lillard eventually requested a trade in 2023 and was moved to the Bucks, confirming Mello's insight that he would eventually feel he had to move on to pursue a ring.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers