Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

March Madness Recap, St Peters Head Coach Shaheen Holloway And We're Dead Men Walking

Monday, March 21, 202213 takes

March Madness recap, we're basically dead people podcasting. Wisconsin lost, Duke advanced, Arizona/TCU classic, Gonzaga/Memphis game of the tourney and tons more memories and moments from the first 4 days. (- ) Who's back of the week. (-) St Peters Head Coach Shaheen Holloway joins the show to talk about the story of the tournament, why his team is a bunch of dogs and more.(:14-) We wrap up with MLB and NFL talk. (-)

Coach Shaheen Holloway on St. Peter's Miracle Run and March Madness Recap

The first four days of the NCAA Tournament have officially melted everyone’s brains. Big Cat and PFT are recording with voices that sound like they’ve been gargling gravel, which is the only way to sound after seventy-two hours of straight hoops. Wisconsin is out, Coach K is still alive, and we have a fifteen-seed in the Sweet 16.

Big Cat is handling the Wisconsin loss surprisingly well, mostly because he knew the ceiling for this specific Badgers team wasn't exactly through the roof. It’s the kind of loss you get over in twenty minutes before the realization hits you on a plane ride three days later.

Void
Mar 21, 2022
#6836
Big CatBig Cat

Wisconsin's loss to Iowa State wasn't heartbreaking because they were a flawed team

Wisconsin was obviously, I don't think that they were going to win it all this year. They were a flawed team... it's not the most heartbreaking... because I knew I was realistic about this team. I knew they weren't like that crazy talented.

Subjective opinion on his own feelings as a fan.

While Wisconsin is heading home, Duke is moving on after a battle with Michigan State. Naturally, PFT has some theories about how the Blue Devils are still in the bracket, involving a secret cabal of legendary coaches and potentially some buried bodies.

Loss
Mar 21, 2022
#6837
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NCAA rigged the Duke vs. Michigan State game for Coach K

I think the fix was in. NCAA rigged. I think that Tom Izzo and Coach K... Coach K has three friends, one the sports information director at Duke that keeps all of the bodies buried in the right locations... Jim Boeheim... and Tom Izzo. They're like the Big Three.

While Duke won, there is no evidence of a rigging conspiracy involving Tom Izzo.

Despite the Duke victory, the real focus is on the bracket's biggest spoiler. St. Peter's is the story of the tournament, and while they have a date with Purdue next, the guys are already looking at the physical mismatch on the horizon. Big Cat sees a clear path for the Boilermakers, but PFT is letting his heart—and his wallet—steer the ship on this one.

Win
Mar 21, 2022
#6839
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm betting the St. Peter's money line against Purdue despite the physical mismatch

In the game against St. Peter's... there's no reason why I should bet St. Peter's against this team... with the physical mismatch... But I'm still gonna do it. Cause fuck it. Cause I ride. Sometimes you just gotta take the part of your brain that thinks that it's being smart and tell it to shut the fuck up.

PFT was right to trust his gut; St. Peter's beat Purdue 67-64.

The Legend of Douggie Dirt

St. Peter’s head coach Shaheen Holloway joined the show to discuss the Peacocks' historic run. Between the mustache of Doug Edert and the "Jersey Tough" attitude of the roster, this team has become the ultimate bracket buster. Coach Holloway isn't surprised by the success, mostly because his players have the kind of confidence that can't be taught.

Win
Mar 21, 2022
#6845
Shaheen HollowayShaheen Holloway

My St. Peter's players are not scared of anyone because they are from New York and New Jersey

The question was asked, how'd you guys handle that, Murray State's a very physical team... I said, come on man, I got guys from New York and New Jersey, like, this is what we do... I got some dudes in my locker room, man. I got dogs... my guys think they belong at Kentucky. So they think they belong at schools like that.

St. Peter's backed this up by beating Kentucky and eventually becoming the first 15-seed to reach the Elite Eight.

He talked about the grit required to play for him and how he’s built the program around local kids from the New York and New Jersey area who have chips on their shoulders. Even if the national media is shocked that they took down Kentucky, the guys in that locker room felt like they belonged on that floor the entire time.

One Shining Moments and Narratives

Jake Marsh joined to give his early locks for the One Shining Moment montage. While there are plenty of dunks and buzzer-beaters to choose from, one specific highlight from the Indiana game seems like a certainty for the final video.

Win
Mar 21, 2022
#6840
Jake MarshJake Marsh

The Indiana cheerleader who retrieved the stuck ball is a lock for the One Shining Moment montage

The Indiana cheerleader, also a lock. That one is the moment of the tournament.

The cheerleader moment did indeed make the official One Shining Moment montage.

Moving away from the mid-majors, the conversation turned to the heavy hitters. Gonzaga survived a massive scare from Memphis, and Big Cat is officially ready to buy all the stock in Chet Holmgren as a defensive force at the next level.

Win
Mar 21, 2022
#6841
Big CatBig Cat

Chet Holmgren is an elite rim protector and I'm a full-on believer in him

I thought he like his defense is already at a point where it's like, okay, this guy can be an elite rim protector. Cause he was playing guys who were 70 pounds heavier than him... I'm a Chet believer. I'm a full-on Chet believer. I like Chet.

Holmgren went on to be the #2 overall pick and has become one of the NBA's premier rim protectors.

On the flip side, some things never change. Tennessee and Rick Barnes had their usual March exit, proving once again that some narratives are simply facts of life.

Push
Mar 21, 2022
#6842
Big CatBig Cat

You just have to trust the narrative that Rick Barnes will always choke in the tournament

At some point you just have to trust the narrative. Like Fran McCaffery doesn't go to the Sweet 16. Rick Barnes is 25 and 25 all time in the tournament... I felt very bad for [Tennessee fans] because it was essentially like, we fell for this again.

Barnes did reach the Sweet 16 the following year (2023), somewhat pushing back on the narrative, though he remains a target for 'choker' claims.

NFL and MLB Chaos

While the tournament was raging, the rest of the sports world refused to stay quiet. The Browns pulled off the massive trade for Deshaun Watson, a move that Big Cat noted would never fly in other AFC North front offices.

Void
Mar 21, 2022
#27243
Big CatBig Cat

You would never see the Rooney family make a move for someone like Deshaun Watson

I all say is that you would never see the Rooneys make a move like this [trading for Deshaun Watson].

Subjective take on franchise philosophy.

Meanwhile, MLB free agency is moving at light speed. The Rangers are spending like crazy, but PFT isn't exactly sold on the long-term value of the massive contract they handed out to Corey Seager.

Loss
Mar 21, 2022
#27244
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Rangers signing Corey Seager to a 10-year deal is an F grade

Corey Seager from the Dodgers to the Rangers... F. I'll go with a D minus. Listen... that's an F yeah. That's 10 years.

Seager led the Rangers to a World Series title in 2023 and won World Series MVP, making this look like an A+ signing in hindsight.

If St. Peter's makes the Final Four, we might actually witness the first-ever podcast recorded entirely in sign language because no one will have a voice left.

march-madnesscollege-basketballnflst-petersmlb

More Takes

Win
Mar 21, 2022
#27242
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I want North Carolina to beat Duke in the Final Four

I want UNC to beat Duke in the Final Four... I'm just rooting for the most hilarious way possible for [Coach K] to get bounced.

This exact scenario happened: UNC beat Duke in the Final Four in Coach K's final game.
Loss
Mar 21, 2022
#6838
Big CatBig Cat

Purdue is on the doorstep of a Final Four with a clear path through St. Peter's

On paper you have to think you have a Jaden Ivey, who's a lottery pick. You have two guys in Williamson and Edey who were fucking monsters. You'd have to think Purdue 12-point favorites to get to the Elite Eight to be on the doorstep of a Final Four.

This take turned out spectacularly wrong as St. Peter's upset Purdue in the Sweet 16 to become the first 15-seed in the Elite Eight.
Void
Mar 21, 2022
#6843
Big CatBig Cat

Scott Drew's tweet about how hard it is to repeat is 'major loser energy'

Scott Drew tweeted it, which I feel like is just major loser energy. He tweeted a graphic... showing all the national champions... that either didn't qualify for the tournament after they won the title, or they didn't get very far... That's a weird thing to do. You let your fan base say that because it is hard to repeat.

The take is subjective, but Scott Drew did indeed tweet that graphic after Baylor's loss to UNC.
Win
Mar 21, 2022·Who's Back
#6844
Big CatBig Cat

Patty the Batty is going to be a massive star

Our colleague, Patty the Batty put on an electric show... Patty the Batty's going to be a star. I'm so excited. He choked out the guy in what, like three minutes... I just love Patty too because his haircut and just how he looks. And then he kicks your ass.

Pimblett became one of the most popular and recognizable names in the UFC shortly after.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers