Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 1, Fastest 2 Minutes, Recap Of Every Game + Football Guy Of The Week

Monday, September 9, 201928 takes

Football is back and we're trying out something new. No guest on Monday's in the fall. We start with the Fastest 2 minutes then get into a recap of every Sunday Game with overreactions and weird tangents (2:2 8 - ). Antonio Brown is a Patriot and Mike Tomlin deserves an apology ( - ). Who's back of the week ( - ) Football Guy of the Week. The debut of our newest segment "Do Your Pod" and Stay Classy Philly for fighting Sixers player Mike Scott ( - )

NFL Week 1 Overreactions, AB to the Pats, and Mike Tomlin's Apology

Football is officially back, and Big Cat and PFT Commenter are hitting the ground running with a new Monday format: all football, all the time. No guests, just pure overreactions and the return of the Fastest 2 Minutes. The energy is high because Week 1 is the one time of year where our brains convinced us that whatever happened on Sunday is exactly how the next four months will play out.

The Browns Stink (For Now)

The most anticipated debut in Cleveland history ended in a total disaster. Between Greg Robinson getting ejected for kicking a guy in the face and Baker Mayfield throwing three picks, the hype train hit a brick wall. Big Cat noted that while everyone was focused on Odell's watch and Freddie Kitchens' play-calling, the offensive line looked like a sieve. On the flip side, the Titans looked like a team nobody wants to play, specifically because their head coach seems to thrive when the world ignores them.

Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#29698
Big CatBig Cat

I believe the Browns and Baker Mayfield will be fine despite their Week 1 loss

I actually do believe the Browns are going to be fine... As a Baker [Mayfield] guy, he's going to fix it. He's fine.

The 2019 Browns finished a disappointing 6-10 and Freddie Kitchens was fired after one season.

Lamar Jackson and the 50-Burger

Lamar Jackson silenced the "he's a wide receiver" crowd by hanging a 59-10 loss on the Dolphins. While Lamar looked like an MVP candidate, the Dolphins looked like they might be the worst team in NFL history. PFT is still holding onto his preseason optimism for Miami, even if the rest of the world thinks they're tanking for Tua.

Win
Sep 9, 2019
#10305
Big CatBig Cat

Whenever Mike Vrabel is underestimated, bet on him

I am now making a new rule. Whenever Mike Vrabel is underestimated, bet on him. I feel like this happens every single time the Titans, we're like, the Titans stink, their offense is boring, and Marcus Mariota isn't the guy. They did it last year when they played the Patriots.

Vrabel consistently outperformed expectations as an underdog throughout his Titans tenure, including a deep playoff run later this season (2019).

In the same division, the Vikings dismantled the Falcons by barely asking their quarterback to participate. It turns out the recipe for success in Minnesota involves keeping the ball out of Kirk Cousins' hands as much as possible.

Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29699
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson might just be a statue quarterback who carves teams up from the pocket

The concern at this point is can [Lamar Jackson] do enough with his legs? Is he fast enough? Is he a good enough running quarterback? Or is he just like one of those statue guys that goes back there and carves you up?

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Lamar Jackson won the MVP in 2019, proving he could dominate both with his legs and his arm.

Nick Foles and the Minshew Era

The Jacksonville Jaguars' season took a massive hit when Nick Foles went down with a broken clavicle in the first quarter. While Gardner Minshew and his legendary mustache stepped in and played surprisingly well, Big Cat thinks the Jags need to look toward the Meadowlands for a veteran replacement to save their season.

Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29691
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Rosen will be remembered for having the worst career situations possible

I think [Josh Rosen] will, when his career is done, will look back and be like, that guy had the worst situations possible.

Rosen's career was defined by poor supporting casts and early coaching changes in Arizona and Miami, followed by several years as a journeyman backup.

Around the League in 60 Minutes

The guys touched on every single game, including the Bengals' close loss to the Seahawks. Zach Taylor’s debut showed some promise, especially with John Ross finally looking like a real NFL player, but PFT isn't ready to buy into the long-term success of the new-look Cincinnati staff.

Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#10306
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dolphins will still win seven games this season despite losing by 49 points in Week 1

The Dolphins can still get seven [wins]. I'm not done with this take yet... Patriots at Dolphins, Dolphins always manage to win a game against the Patriots... [Ryan Fitzpatrick] has so many revenge games built into every schedule... two wins against the Bills, two wins against the Jets for the revenge games.

The Dolphins finished the season 5-11.

Meanwhile, Dak Prescott looked like he deserves every penny of the massive contract he hasn't signed yet. He carved up the Giants' secondary, but Big Cat suggests Jerry Jones might want to keep the pen in his pocket for a little while longer to keep Dak motivated.

Void
Sep 9, 2019
#29692
Big CatBig Cat

The Falcons are the most frustrating team in NFL history to watch and bet on

I fucking hate the Falcons... They're the most frustrating team I've ever watched, ever bet on. I bet on them pretty much every single week... and they fucking suck, and they do the same thing every time.

While 'most frustrating' is subjective, the Falcons' tendency for late-game collapses and underperforming their talent roster (Ryan, Jones, Ridley) is a widely held view among fans and bettors.

Antonio Brown is a Patriot

The biggest story of the weekend happened off the field. After a week of frostbitten feet, helmet grievances, and calling his GM a cracker, Antonio Brown forced his way out of Oakland and straight into the waiting arms of Bill Belichick. Hank is already planning the parade route, but the most shocking realization of the whole saga is that Mike Tomlin might actually be a genius for keeping AB sane for nine years.

Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#10309
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Zach Taylor will coach the Bengals for six years and never make the playoffs

Here's my overreaction is that Zach Taylor is going to be the Bengals coach for the next six years and never make the playoffs. I feel like he's going to go 8-8.

Zach Taylor led the Bengals to the Super Bowl in his third season (2021), proving this prediction completely wrong.

With Josh Gordon looking healthy and AB joining the fold, Hank is back to his usual levels of insufferable Patriots confidence. He’s already calling for a nearly perfect season, assuming the league's most volatile receiving corps stays on the field.

Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#10308
Big CatBig Cat

The Jaguars should trade for Eli Manning following Nick Foles' injury

Nick Foles broke his clavicle... I'm going to say a name for who the Jaguars should look to trade for. Eli Manning. Let's get it going. Let's get him back with [Tom] Coughlin. Get the band back together. The defense is good enough. All you need is Eli to win nine games.

The trade never happened; the Jaguars moved forward with Gardner Minshew.

College Football and Stay Classy Philly

LSU looks like a powerhouse with an actual passing offense, which feels like a glitch in the matrix. Big Cat scouted Trevor Lawrence in person at Clemson and confirmed he is, in fact, good at football. However, the same cannot be said for the state of affairs in Austin, where PFT has some concerns about the visual aesthetic of the Longhorns' home turf.

Push
Sep 9, 2019
#29701
Big CatBig Cat

The Seahawks will miss Doug Baldwin significantly more than they realize

The Seahawks are going to miss Doug Baldwin so much more than they realized... it felt like every time they needed a big play, it was like, wait, where's Doug Baldwin?

The Seahawks offense remained top-10 in scoring in 2019 as Tyler Lockett and DK Metcalf stepped up, making the loss of Baldwin less impactful than feared.

Finally, we check in on Philadelphia, where Sixers player Mike Scott got into a physical altercation with Eagles fans at a tailgate. Nothing says Week 1 in the NFL quite like fighting your own city's professional athletes next to a casket.

It’s a long season, but based on Week 1, we're all going to be dead by October.

nflantonio-brownbrownspatriotsoverreactionscollege-football

More Takes

Void
Sep 9, 2019
#10307
Big CatBig Cat

The key to Kirk Cousins' success is not letting him play quarterback

They figured out the key to Kirk Cousins. Don't let him actually play quarterback. He only threw 10 passes. Less is more with him... Actually, the key for Kirk Cousins is to make sure that the quarterback doesn't play quarterback.

The Vikings' offense was significantly better when leaning on Dalvin Cook and the run game in 2019, though Cousins still had high-volume games.
Void
Sep 9, 2019
#29700
Big CatBig Cat

Christian McCaffrey is talented enough to be a professional in every single sport

I don't know this for a fact, but I'm pretty sure Christian McCaffrey could be pro in every single sport. He's that type of guy.

While McCaffrey is an elite athlete, the claim that he could be a pro in *every* sport is inherently subjective hyperbole.
Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29702
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Eli Manning is officially a corpse

Eli Manning is a corpse. That's my eye test.

Manning was benched after Week 2 and retired at the end of the season.
Void
Sep 9, 2019
#10310
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys shouldn't sign Dak Prescott to an extension right now while he's playing for a contract

Dak Prescott's going to make a shitload of money. And I actually think if you're Jerry Jones, don't sign him right now because he's playing for a contract.

Dak had a career year in 2019, throwing for nearly 5,000 yards while playing on his rookie deal, supporting the 'motivation' theory.
Void
Sep 9, 2019
#10311
HankHank

If a general manager misses the playoffs two years in a row, they should be fired immediately

If you're not going to make the playoffs two years in a row... You're only as good as this year, though, and they're not going to make the playoffs... If you can't make it two years in a row, you've got to go.

This is a subjective organizational philosophy.
Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#29693
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyler Murray has a 75% chance of being a bust

So three quarters of bad Kyler, one and a half of good Kyler. So 75% he's a bust. [Big Cat] 75% chance Kyler Murray's a bust right now.

Hot TakeFootballFireSarcastic
Kyler Murray won OROY in 2019 and became a multi-time Pro Bowler, definitively not a bust.
Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#29703
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

There is a 75% chance that Kyler Murray is a bust

Three quarters of bad Kyler, one and a half of good Kyler. So 75% he's a bust. 75% chance Kyler Murray's a bust right now.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Murray won Offensive Rookie of the Year in 2019 and became a multi-time Pro Bowler.
Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29704
Big CatBig Cat

TJ Hawkinson is going to be an awesome NFL player

TJ Hawkinson, by the way, is awesome... it looks like he's going to be awesome. There's something to build on there.

Hawkinson became a multi-time Pro Bowler and one of the better tight ends in the league.
Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29694
Big CatBig Cat

Jameis Winston is addicted to turnovers and cannot be fixed

Jameis Winston fucking stinks. That guy stinks. He is addicted to turnovers... How do you fix a guy who, one in every five passes, he says, 'Ooh, I haven't thrown it dangerously close to the other team in a while. Let me do that.'

Winston became the first player to throw for 30 TDs and 30 INTs in the same season (2019), essentially proving the 'addiction' and lack of fixability at that stage.
Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#29695
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots are going to win the Super Bowl again

I mean, the Patriots are going to win the Super Bowl again. [PFT Commenter] Yeah. That was an ass kick.

The Patriots lost to the Titans in the Wild Card round; the Kansas City Chiefs won the Super Bowl.
Loss
Sep 9, 2019
#29705
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots are going to win the Super Bowl again

I mean, the Patriots are going to win the Super Bowl again. [PFT] Yeah. That was an ass kick. Listen, the Patriots, they're wagon.

The Patriots lost in the Wild Card round to the Tennessee Titans.
Loss
HankHank

Antonio Brown and Josh Gordon will both play every game for the Patriots this season

Antonio Brown, Josh Gordon, do both of them play 16 games? [Big Cat] Antonio Brown obviously didn't play tonight, so 15 in his case. [Hank] Yes.

Antonio Brown was released after one game. Josh Gordon played 6 games for the Patriots before being placed on IR and waived.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots will finish the season 18-1

18-1 is my official preseason prediction... I think they're going to lose a random regular season game, and that'll be it... They're not going to lose in the playoffs.

The Patriots finished 12-4 in the regular season and lost in the Wild Card round to the Titans.
Void
Sep 9, 2019
#10312
Big CatBig Cat

We owe Mike Tomlin an apology for how he handled Antonio Brown

In all of this, in all the Antonio Brown madness and the Raiders and all that stuff, I think we owe Mike Tomlin an apology. I think he actually dealt with Antonio Brown the way that you have to deal with a receiver that talented.

This is a subjective moral/professional judgment on coaching performance.
Void
Sep 9, 2019
#29696
Big CatBig Cat

The life lesson of Antonio Brown is that talented people can get away with anything

If you're extremely talented at something, you can probably get away with more than everyone else. That's a tough lesson... If you are extremely valuable and exceptionally talented at your given work, you probably can get away with shit.

This is a philosophical observation about celebrity and professional sports leverage.
Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29697
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Burrow will win the Heisman Trophy

Joe Burrow, MVP. Heisman. [PFT Commenter] Probably heard of him. Joe Burrow looks like a Heisman guy. This year, he looks fucking amazing.

Joe Burrow won the 2019 Heisman Trophy in a landslide after one of the greatest seasons in college football history.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Texas is officially 'not back' because their field looks like baby diarrhea

Somebody pointed out that the color situation on the broadcast cameras change at Texas depending on what network is running the game... It changes depending on how back Texas is... I was like, they're not back because that field looks like baby diarrhea. Officially not back.

OpinionCFBMediumSarcastic
Texas finished the 2019 season 8-5, which most fans did not consider 'back' to their former glory.
Win
Sep 9, 2019
#29706
Big CatBig Cat

Trevor Lawrence will be a good NFL quarterback

I scouted in person. Go Tigers. I think Trevor Lawrence is going to be a good quarterback.

Lawrence became the #1 overall pick and a Pro Bowl quarterback for the Jaguars.
Void
Sep 9, 2019·Who's Back
#29707
HankHank

Rafa Nadal is the GOAT of tennis

Rafa's the GOAT. He won the U.S. Open, which means he now has five major titles since his 30th birthday, the most by any person.

The tennis GOAT debate is inherently subjective and varies as Grand Slam totals shift.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers