Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 8, Fastest 2 Minutes, Jets Finally Win, Broncos And Colts Dominate, Packers Are A Problem, Brian Kelly Fired And Who's Back Of The Week

Monday, October 27, 202522 takes

FL Week 8 and we start with the fastest 2 minutes (-). We then recap every game from Sunday Jets 39, Bengals 38 and we remember our friend Nick Mangold (-) Ravens 30, Bears 16 (-) Eagles 38, Giants 20 (-) Texans 26, 49ers 15 (-) Patriots 32, Browns 13 (-) Dolphins 34, Falcons 10 (-) Bills 40, Panthers 9 (-) Bucs 23, Saints 3 (-) Broncos 44, Cowboys 24 (-) Colts 38, Titans 14 (-) Packers 35, Steelers 25 (-) We finish with some World Series talk, who's back of the week and Brian Kelly fired at LSU (-)

NFL Week 8 Recap, Jets' Emotional Win, and the Brian Kelly Era Ends

Week 8 in the NFL was a day of double-digit blowouts, but it started with an emotional victory for the New York football Jets. In a game dedicated to the memory of the legendary Nick Mangold, the Jets pulled off a 39-38 thriller over the Bengals. Memes was understandably shaken up, both by the loss of a friend of the program and the shock of seeing his team actually win a game.

Big Cat was quick to credit the coaching staff for the turnaround, specifically pointing to the late-game guts of Aaron Glenn. Glenn showed he wasn't afraid to trust the analytics when it mattered most.

Win
Oct 27, 2025
#17033
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Glenn is an analytically sound 'math guy' head coach

Aaron Glenn first win as an NFL head coach also Math guy... he showed a couple games that he's a math guy. Yeah. The Bucks game. He went for two... He's an analytically sound, but it worked. He was down 14, late in the game in the fourth quarter. Scored a touchdown, went for two, then scored again. Won the game in regulation with an extra point certified math guy.

The math behind going for two when down 14 is a standard modern analytical play, which Aaron Glenn correctly executed to win.

While the Jets celebrated, the Bengals were left looking for answers after their defense allowed 500 yards of offense. PFT wasn't just disappointed; he was ready to call for a total teardown in Cincinnati.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21115
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bengals need to blow the whole team up and start over

The Bengals... their defense is so historically bad that they lose games like this. I don't know what else the answer is. They gotta blow the whole thing up.

This is a subjective opinion on team management that cannot be definitively proven correct or incorrect.

The Bears Graduate to Mediocrity

In Baltimore, the Bears' winning streak came to a screeching halt. Caleb Williams struggled to find a rhythm, looking frantic in the pocket and missing the intuition that defines elite quarterbacks. Big Cat isn't ready to jump off the Sears Tower yet, but he’s being realistic about where this team currently stands.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21116
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are not a good team yet; they have only graduated from being a bad team

Have I at all said that the Bears were a good team? I have not. I said they were working towards being a good team. They have graduated from being a bad team, but I've never called them a good team. And today is why, because I don't think they're a good team yet.

The quality of a team is inherently subjective, though their final record and playoff performance will provide context.

While Caleb’s "feel" for the game was a major talking point, Big Cat is leaning on the coaching staff to navigate the rookie through these growing pains. He’s placing all his chips on Ben Johnson to be the ultimate judge of Williams’ future.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21117
Big CatBig Cat

I have complete faith in Ben Johnson to determine if Caleb Williams is the right quarterback for the Bears

The calmness that I have is all because of Ben Johnson. I believe in Ben Johnson. That's where the calmness comes from. I believe in whatever Ben Johnson's plan is... He will decide if [Caleb Williams] is his guy or not.

This is a statement of personal belief and trust in a coach's evaluation process.

Trade Demands and Giant Realities

In Philadelphia, the Eagles handled the Giants with ease, but the drama was largely off the field. AJ Brown apparently spent his Saturday night scrubbing Jalen Hurts from his social media, leading PFT to take up a new cause.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#17039
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am officially demanding a trade on behalf of AJ Brown

I side with AJ Brown. Yeah, I do. I do. It sounds like AJ his only crime. He's just too nice of a guy and he won't, he won't demand a trade. So I'll demand it for him. I'm demanding a trade on behalf of AJ Brown. Aj I will speak for you.

This is a comedic performance/demand that does not reflect actual league movement or player intent.

Max, however, remained the voice of reason (or pessimism) for the Eagles. Despite the social media drama and the Kelly Green jerseys looking phenomenal, Max is certain AJ isn't going anywhere just because his feelings are hurt.

Win
Oct 27, 2025
#17041
MaxMax

AJ Brown will remain an Eagle for the entire season despite being unhappy

Yes. He'll be an eagle for this entire, he won't be happy about it, but he will be an eagle... Howie's not going to just eat the, eat the cap because he's upset. He's not going to make this team worse. Just to make AJ Brown's feelings not hurt.

AJ Brown remained with the Eagles for the entire 2025 season. He was not traded.

Across the field, the Giants are facing a grim reality after losing Camp Galbo to a season-ending injury. With the playoffs out of reach, PFT thinks the blue side of New York needs to shift its focus entirely.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21118
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants' season is now entirely about developing Jackson Dart

I think the Giants are in a position where this season is now fully about just developing Jackson Dart. I think that whatever magic they had... now it's just about making sure that [Jackson Dart] progresses, gets better, learns how to compete, and you can just put all your stock in that.

This is a subjective take on team priority following a season-ending injury to Malik Nabers.

Contenders and Pretenders

In the afternoon slate, the Colts and Broncos emerged as the biggest winners. The Colts looked like a well-oiled machine, with Jonathan Taylor playing like it’s 2006 and he’s wearing a Chargers jersey. Big Cat is officially ready to crown them the kings of the league.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#17046
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts are currently the best team in the NFL

The Colts are just the best team in the NFL. I don't really know what else to say. They are the best team in the NFL... it finally was like, you know what, this is not, this is not just a hot start. They're just really fucking good.

Power rankings are subjective, but claiming the Colts are better than established contenders is a bold stance.

Meanwhile, the Broncos dominated the Cowboys in a way that had Sean Payton smiling for once. Bo Nix threw four touchdowns, and the Broncos looked like a legitimate threat in the AFC, provided their star cornerback stays on the field.

Win
Oct 27, 2025
#21122
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos are genuine AFC Championship contenders if Patrick Surtain II stays healthy

I think the Broncos are every bit of a AFC champion contender in my mind. If their defense, especially [Patrick Surtain II] is healthy.

Big Cat said the Broncos were AFC Championship contenders if Patrick Surtain II stayed healthy. The Broncos went 14-3, earned the #1 seed, and made the AFC Championship Game (losing 10-7 to the Patriots). They were clearly legitimate AFC Championship contenders.

On the flip side, Big Cat has officially seen enough of the Atlanta Falcons. After a 34-10 shellacking at the hands of the visor-wearing Tua Tagovailoa and the Dolphins, the Falcons have been moved to the "do not trust" list.

Void
Oct 27, 2025
#17044
Big CatBig Cat

I am done taking the Falcons seriously as a team

I'm done with the Falcons hashtag done. I can't take them as serious team after this game. I'm sorry. I wanted to believe in them this year... you can't lose by 34 10 to the Miami Dolphins who are reeling... and then they come into your house and just bully you.

The Falcons were 4-4 at the time; their 'seriousness' as a contender is subjective based on their final record and playoff performance.

Who's Back and College Chaos

The biggest news of the night came from the college ranks, as Brian Kelly was fired at LSU following a sideline meltdown against Texas A&M. The guys marveled at the $54 million buyout, which adds to a historic run of buyouts negotiated by LSU's AD. While Kelly is a polarizing figure, Big Cat admitted he’d swallow his pride for the sake of his alma mater.

Void
Oct 27, 2025·Who's Back
#17049
Big CatBig Cat

I would be fine with Brian Kelly coaching the Wisconsin Badgers

Have, have you thought about a world where Brian Kelly is the coach of the Wisconsin Badgers? I'd be fine with it. He'd, he'd make us better than what we are right now. He, he gets good results... I am so sick of watching my team suck every Saturday that I will, I will have the guy that I probably hate most of any coach, coach my alma mater.

This is a statement of personal preference regarding hypothetical coaching hires.

We also saw the return of the NBA, featuring a debut from V.J. Edgecombe that had Max ready to plan a parade in Philadelphia. The Sixers rookie put up numbers that haven't been seen since the days of Wilt Chamberlain, providing a rare bright spot for Max's sports portfolio.

Win
Oct 27, 2025·Who's Back
#17051
MaxMax

V.J. Edgecombe's NBA debut was the best since Wilt Chamberlain

VJ Edgecombe. Absolute beast. That's how, that's how you rebuild right there... Best NBA debut since Wilt Chamberlain. Wow. It's crazy. It's a crazy stat. Most points in his NBA debut since Wilt Chamberlain... 34 [points] in a win over the Celtics.

The stat provided (34 points being the most since Wilt) is a verifiable fact claim within the context of the fictional/future game being discussed.

Just remember, if your head feels four times too big tomorrow, you probably just had two Rails at Tots.

nfl-week-8jetsbearsbrian-kellycoltsbroncosnba

More Takes

Loss
Oct 27, 2025
#17035
MemesMemes

The Jets will not lose another game for the rest of the season

Honestly. Yeah. I don't think they should lose another game for the rest of the [season].

The Jets finished 3-14. They lost many more games after this take was made at 1-7.
Void
Oct 27, 2025
#17037
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams lacks the necessary 'feel' for the game and panics under pressure

My biggest thing with [Caleb Williams] right now is that the feel for the game feels to be lacking. And it feels like there's a panic that's like, he doesn't see or feel the game. And it comes out when you see there was two really bad, intentional grounding penalties... the command of a game, the great quarterbacks, you see it, it's almost like a intuition where they're in control at all times. He just hasn't gotten that command down.

Williams' rookie processing speed and internal clock are subjective but supported by the statistical groundings in the game mentioned.
Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21119
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mac Jones does not look like the long-term answer at quarterback for the 49ers

Mac Jones does not look like the long-term answer. I feel like the soft benching might have gotten a little harder. I think that bench got hard today.

Whether he is the 'long-term answer' is subjective, though his tenure with the team will provide evidence.
Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21120
Big CatBig Cat

Dylan Gabriel is not the answer at quarterback for the Cleveland Browns

[Dylan Gabriel] is terrible. [Dylan Gabriel] is so bad. I don't know. He can't be the answer. I don't think so.

Subjective evaluation of a player's long-term viability for a franchise.
Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21121
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys should go for it on every fourth down because their defense is too bad to be on the field

The Cowboys defense is just so, so bad. I feel like [Brian Schottenheimer's] got to look in the mirror and say, 'Hey, our defense is so bad. Fuck it. We're gonna go for it on every fourth down.' Because... why would you ever put your defense back on the field? You have to just go for it on every fourth down and just become that team.

This is a hypothetical coaching strategy that is unlikely to be implemented literally, making it subjective.
Win
Oct 27, 2025
#17047
Big CatBig Cat

Jonathan Taylor should be in the NFL MVP discussion

Jonathan Taylor... should be the MVP... in the discussion at least. He's got 14 touchdowns through eight games. That's, that was the LT 2006 season when it was just every single Sunday.

14 touchdowns in 8 games is a historic pace that objectively puts a player in the MVP conversation.
Void
Oct 27, 2025
#21123
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Colts' offense makes the most sense out of any offense in the NFL

The Colts' offense, I think it makes the most sense out of any offense. When I'm watching them, I'm like, this all makes sense. They use Jonathan Taylor correctly... it's the most sense-making offense in the NFL.

This is an aesthetic/logical judgment of offensive design.
Loss
Oct 27, 2025
#21124
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am sticking with my take that the Steelers will win a playoff game this season

I'm not gonna overreact to anything. So I'm not, I'm not gonna back off of my take yet. Weird stuff happens. There's a lot of season left... I'm gonna trust old me.

PFT predicted the Steelers would win a playoff game in 2025. The Steelers made the playoffs as AFC North champions (10-7) but lost their Wild Card game to the Texans 30-6, extending their playoff losing streak to seven consecutive losses.
Loss
Oct 27, 2025
#17048
Big CatBig Cat

Tucker Kraft is the best tight end in the NFL

Tucker Kraft best tight end in the NFL. I would say let's just, let's just get fucking reckless. That was yeah. Was the last thing we watched and yeah. Did he have 143 yards and two touchdowns and looked absolutely explosive and unguardable? Why not just fucking say it and then next week Sam LaPorta has a great game? No.

Kraft is a rising star, but ranking him over Travis Kelce or George Kittle is objectively a 'hot take' overreaction to one game.
Loss
Oct 27, 2025·Who's Back
#17050
Big CatBig Cat

Lincoln Riley might be fired or leave USC soon

USC... I think Lincoln Riley might be out. I think there's guys that might leave the places they want to be, even though they're not doing bad. I think it's gonna be basically full on musical chairs.

Lincoln Riley was not fired and did not leave USC. He remains head coach entering 2026, though under pressure.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers