Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Week 18, Fastest 2 Minutes, The Packers Are Dead, Jags Win The South, Who's Back And Billy Went To The Bottom Of The East River

Monday, January 9, 202321 takes

Week 18 and we recap every game starting with Fastest 2 Minutes (-:09). We taped the first half before Sunday Night Football so the Packers died halfway through the show. Jaguars 20, Titans 16 (-) Chiefs 31, Raiders 13 (-) Dolphins 11, Jets 6 (-) Bills 35, Patriots 23 (-) Bengals 27, Ravens 16 (-) Steelers 28, Browns 14 (-) Texans 32, Colts 31 (-) Vikings 29, Bears 13 (-) Panthers 10, Saints 7 (-) Falcons 30, Bucs 17 (-) Lions 20, Packers 16 (-) Seahawks 19, Rams 6 (-) Broncos 31, Chargers 28 (-) Eagles 22, Giants 16 (-) 49ers 38, Cardinals 13 (-) Commanders 26, Cowboys 6 (-) We finish with who's back of the week and we wrap up with Billy going to the bottom of the East River. (-)

Week 18 Recap: The Packers are Dead, Billy Hits the Bottom of the East River, and the Bears Land #1

Week 18 is officially in the books, and the regular season finale delivered exactly the kind of chaos we crave. The big story of the night was the Detroit Lions—who had absolutely nothing to play for—walking into Lambeau Field and putting the Green Bay Packers in the dirt. It was a beautiful, poetic end to the season for anyone who enjoys watching Aaron Rodgers walk off the field in frustration. Big Cat was practically glowing as he watched the Packers' playoff hopes vanish while he held the #1 overall pick in his pocket.

The Lions are Building Something

Dan Campbell has his squad playing with a level of grit that hasn't been seen in Detroit in a long time. They didn't just play spoiler; they looked like the better team. Jared Goff played mistake-free football in the cold, proving he can handle the elements, and Big Cat thinks the search for a new Lions QB should probably be on hold for a while.

Win
Jan 9, 2023
#12571
Big CatBig Cat

Jared Goff is the franchise quarterback for the Detroit Lions

Dan Campbell's building something and guess what? I think Jared Goff is his, the quarterback... he is fucking good.

Goff led the Lions to the NFC Championship game in 2023 and signed a $212 million extension in 2024, cementing him as the franchise guy.

While the Lions were celebrating, the Packers were unraveling. Between Quay Walker pushing a trainer and Rodgers throwing a back-breaking interception late, it was a total meltdown. PFT noticed the body language at the end of the game and thinks we might have just seen the last of #12 in a Green Bay uniform.

Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12570
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers has officially retired from football

I think he's retired. I think he's done. He didn't talk much after the game. They asked him for a jersey swap. He said no, hang on to this one. And then he walked into the hallway with Randall Cobb arm in arm.

Aaron Rodgers did not retire; he was traded to the New York Jets in April 2023.

Duval is Hosting a Playoff Game

The Jacksonville Jaguars completed an incredible mid-season turnaround by beating the Titans to win the AFC South. Doug Pederson has completely erased the stench of the Urban Meyer era, turning Trevor Lawrence into a franchise cornerstone in just one season. PFT is ready to give the man his hardware.

Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12564
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Doug Pederson should win NFL Coach of the Year

Doug Pederson is gonna get my coach of the year vote. Trevor Lawrence looks like he is like the next guy.

Brian Daboll won the 2022 NFL Coach of the Year award. Pederson finished third in the voting.

The contrast between Pederson and his predecessor couldn't be sharper. Seeing the Jags celebrate a division title just one year after being the laughingstock of the league makes the previous regime look even worse in hindsight.

Void
Jan 9, 2023
#21766
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer is the worst head coach in NFL history

I think this [the Jaguars winning with Doug Pederson] does cement Urban Meyer's [legacy] as maybe the worst coach, NFL coach of all time.

While subjective, Meyer's 2-11 record and numerous off-field scandals make him a consensus candidate for this title in NFL history.

The Bears are on the Clock

Thanks to the Houston Texans somehow winning a game they had every reason to lose, the Chicago Bears have secured the #1 overall pick for the first time since 1947. Lovie Smith went out a hero in Chicago by winning his final game in Houston, and while the Texans are left searching for a new head coach, Big Cat is ready to play some games with the rest of the league.

Win
Jan 9, 2023
#12573
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears should use a 'smokescreen' about drafting a QB to drive up the trade value of the #1 pick

I want everyone to know that what I'm about to say is smokescreen. Justin Fields might not be the guy. The Bears might draft a quarterback... You better trade and trade a lot for that number one pick.

The Bears did exactly this, maintaining leverage until trading the #1 pick to the Panthers for a massive package including DJ Moore.

Securing the top pick is a franchise-altering moment for the Bears, especially given their massive cap space heading into the offseason. Even if they don't take a quarterback, the leverage they now hold over QB-needy teams is immense.

Void
Jan 9, 2023
#12569
Big CatBig Cat

Having the #1 overall pick is the second-best outcome a team can have

I'd actually argue that the number one pick, if you can't win the Super Bowl, that's the second best spot to be in. Number one pick. Give the number one pick.

This is an inherently subjective philosophy of roster building.

Billy's Quest for Mammoth Bones

In what might be the most dangerous bit in the history of the show, Billy Football decided to spend his Saturday morning 74 feet below the surface of the East River. After hearing a rumor on Joe Rogan's podcast that mammoth bones were dumped there in the 1940s, Billy teamed up with Donnie Does and a professional dive crew to go treasure hunting.

Billy described the experience as being on another planet, dealing with insane currents and zero visibility while wearing a weighted lead vest. While he didn't find any actual mammoth tusks—and definitely didn't find the fake skeleton bone he tried to pass off on Twitter—he did survive the trip. PFT was genuinely concerned for Billy's life, especially considering Billy skipped the usual several-week certification process to just strap on a helmet and jump in.

Looking Ahead to Wild Card Weekend

The playoff matchups are set, and the guys are already eyeing the board. The Cowboys' embarrassing loss to the Commanders has everyone fading Dak Prescott, who has now thrown an interception in seven straight games. Big Cat has seen enough to know he doesn't trust the Cowboys when the lights are brightest.

Void
Jan 9, 2023
#12574
Big CatBig Cat

Dak Prescott stinks and I don't believe in him

Dak Prescott seven straight games with an interception. Yeah. He stinks. He's bad. I don't believe in him whatsoever. I'm sorry. I just don't.

This is a subjective opinion on player quality.

PFT is leaning hard into the Buccaneers for their matchup against Dallas, mostly because betting against Tom Brady in the playoffs against a struggling Cowboys team feels like a trap he's happy to walk into.

Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12575
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Buccaneers will beat the Cowboys in the Wild Card round

Tom Brady has never lost to the Cowboys... I'm gonna say [the spread is] a pick'em. I love the Bucks in this. Did you see the Cowboys today? Dog shit. Brady's never lost to that shit organization.

The Cowboys beat the Buccaneers 31-14 in the Wild Card round.

It was a fittingly weird end to a weird regular season. Between the Packers dying, the Bears winning by losing, and Billy nearly becoming a permanent resident of the East River, we're heading into the playoffs with max energy.

Don't forget to listen to Milwaukee radio tonight if you want to hear the sound of a fan base losing its mind.

nfl-week-18green-bay-packerschicago-bearsdetroit-lionsbilly-footballfastest-2-minutes

More Takes

Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12565
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Malik Willis is so bad he might be cut by the Titans next year

How bad is Malik Willis to not be getting to start? He's gotta be so bad that there's a good chance that they cut him next year. That he's not even on [the roster].

Malik Willis was not cut in 2023; he remained on the Titans' roster for another season before being traded to the Packers in 2024.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12566
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Derek Carr was born to be an Indianapolis Colt

Derek Carr just, he feels like a Colt. He feels like he was born to be an Indianapolis Colt.

Derek Carr signed with the New Orleans Saints on March 6, 2023.
Win
Jan 9, 2023
#21767
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Raiders should fire Josh McDaniels

Josh McDaniels, he's 11 and 28 as a head coach. If you take away [his] started six and oh... when they were cheating... Josh McDaniels, I, I would fire him.

The Raiders did eventually fire McDaniels on October 31, 2023.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12567
Big CatBig Cat

The Dolphins should fire Mike McDaniel to maintain their streak of making the playoffs only with first-year coaches

The Dolphins have made the playoffs three times in the last 20 years and all of them with first year head coaches. ... Why not just fire him? Fire him. Get somebody new in there, gets some new blood... wait, get back to the playoffs.

The Dolphins did not fire Mike McDaniel; they made the playoffs again under him in the 2023 season.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#21768
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Flacco should retire from the NFL

Joe Flacco, he should probably retire. ... he looks very uncomfortable playing football. Like he doesn't like to be doing it. ... I hope he goes off to his seven kids.

Flacco did not retire; he signed with the Browns in 2023, won Comeback Player of the Year, and led them to the playoffs.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#21769
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Lamar Jackson will play for the Ravens in the Wild Card round

I think [Lamar Jackson] is gonna play. My, if I were to guess I would say that he's gonna play. He was just trying to rest up before the end of the season.

Lamar Jackson did not play in the Wild Card game against the Bengals; Tyler Huntley started in his place.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#21770
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kenny Pickett is the franchise quarterback for the Steelers

Kenny Pickett looks way better now than he did at the start of the year. ... I think Pickett's gonna get better. ... I think he is [the guy].

Pickett was traded to the Philadelphia Eagles in March 2024 after failing to secure the starting job in Pittsburgh.
Void
Jan 9, 2023
#12568
Billy FootballBilly Football

Sam Ehlinger would succeed in a Kyle Shanahan offense

If [Sam Ehlinger] was in a Shanahan offense, I think he'd have a lot of success.

This is a hypothetical claim that cannot be proven or disproven as Ehlinger has not played for Shanahan.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#21771
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Houston Texans will attempt to hire Josh McCown as their next head coach

I think they're [the Texans] probably gonna try to hire, what's his name? Josh? Josh. Josh McCown. Yeah. This off season.

The Texans hired DeMeco Ryans as their head coach on January 31, 2023.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#21772
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Saints should interview Sean Payton to return as head coach

They [the Saints] should request an interview with Sean Payton. ... he never wanted to leave, I don't think. ... He would probably go back.

The Saints did not hire Payton back; they stuck with Dennis Allen, and Payton was traded to the Denver Broncos.
Win
Jan 9, 2023
#21774
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Geno Smith is going to earn a massive contract in free agency

Geno's gonna get a shitload of money. I hope it's not my team, but somebody's gonna pay Geno Smith. ... maybe the Jets.

Geno Smith signed a 3-year, $75 million contract extension with the Seahawks in March 2023.
Loss
Jan 9, 2023
#12572
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Sean McVay is taking a hiatus from coaching

I think that he's actually done... If you get into media, all of a sudden you're working around all other media people... He should have retired after last year.

Sean McVay decided to return to the Rams on January 13, 2023, and did not take a hiatus.
Win
Jan 9, 2023
#21773
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ Watt will likely become a broadcaster in retirement

I could see [JJ Watt] being a broadcaster. ... He could probably name his job.

JJ Watt joined CBS Sports as an NFL studio analyst in June 2023.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers