Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Win
Peter SchragerPeter Schrager

Brandon Aiyuk and John Lynch's personal friendship will lead to a deal with the Niners

His agent's a guy named Ryan Williams... Ryan Williams and John Lynch are like lifelong buddies... John Lynch was at the wedding... at the end of the day, if those are the two people who are running the business operation in this situation, like they'll find a way to get Aiyuk dressed and with the Niners.

Aiyuk eventually signed a long-term extension with the 49ers on August 29, 2024, staying with the team as Schrager predicted.

More from this episode

View episode
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Kucher is a douchebag for refusing to finish his round on Sunday

Matt Kucher. What a dish. Dickhead. What a douchebag... picks up his ball and leaves and says it's too dark. And came back on Monday to finish half a hole. When everyone else had finished... Douchebag move by him.

Inherently subjective but reflected the general consensus of the sports media at the time.
Loss
HankHank

Matt Kucher was actually taking a stand for faster play by refusing to finish on Sunday

I did see a golf journalist who had a thread breaking down why he might have been doing it... the group in front of 'em was playing super, super slow all day... Kucher was basically standing up for the guy who lost a lead... maybe he was just trying to set an example of like, the guy should have been playing faster in front of them.

Kucher later apologized for the 'mess' he created, suggesting the 'protest' defense wasn't his primary intent.
Loss
Aug 14, 2024
#17291
MaxMax

JJ McCarthy will be back in two months from his meniscus injury but it will linger

[JJ McCarthy] could be back. He'll probably be back in like two months and then it'll linger for a little bit longer... And it'll come back like within the next couple years. Like there'll always be the worry of, you know, the meniscus to, it could tear again. It probably will tear again.

McCarthy underwent a full repair and was ruled out for the entire 2024 season, making the 'two months' timeline incorrect.

More from Peter Schrager

View profile
Loss
Peter SchragerPeter Schrager

The Giants completely changed their negative reputation in just three days of the NFL Draft

The Giants have had the roughest reputational year that a team can imagine... And in the matter of three days, Joe Shane and Brian [Daboll] have completely changed a conversation around this team where like every Giants fan is like back on board and they're like, let's go.

The Giants struggled significantly in the 2025 season despite the draft praise, failing to change their reputation for long.
Loss
Peter SchragerPeter Schrager

The Falcons cannot keep Kirk Cousins as a backup with his current salary following the Michael Penix Jr. pick

I can't imagine the Falcons week one paying Kirk Cousins that salary and having Michael Penix be the starter... if you're the Falcons, you can't have that guy with that salary as much as they say it... that guy can't be on the ri, he's a great teammate in the whole thing and he showed up to Spring Camp, but you can't be paying him that number to be a backup.

Cousins remained the starter for the majority of the 2024/25 season while on that salary.
Loss
Peter SchragerPeter Schrager

Xavier Restrepo will be the #3 receiver for the Titans and record 60 catches as an undrafted rookie

I watched a lot of Miami. I don't understand [how he didn't get drafted]... That guy makes a play every single time they throw it to him... Isaiah [Xavier] Restrepo is gonna be like the number three receiver and he'll have 60 catches and he'll be a great NFL player.

Restrepo did not reach 60 catches as a rookie for the Titans.