Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

An ugly win provides a bigger confidence boost than a pretty close win

An ugly win is actually worth more than a pretty close win. Because if you can win ugly, that's like a confidence boost. Like, okay, we didn't have our stuff [but we still won].

Subjective sports psychology take.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Eli Manning is no longer a good quarterback

Eli Manning is not a good quarterback anymore... That means he was a good quarterback, two Super Bowl rings, Hall of Famer, all that stuff. He's not a good quarterback anymore, and I can't stand the offensive line talk because, yes, the offensive line is bad, but Eli Manning is the king of pressures coming, just turtle, and not look downfield.

Eli Manning's stats and eye test in 2018-2019 confirmed he was at the end of his career.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry Jones traded for Amari Cooper because he was drinking Johnny Walker Blue

I do not understand how the Dallas Cowboys gave up a first-round pick for Amari Cooper... Jerry Jones... the reason is Johnny Walker Blue.

While the logic is a joke, Amari Cooper actually performed very well for Dallas initially, making the first-round price tag more palatable than Big Cat predicted.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Marshawn Lynch is faking his injury because he doesn't want to play for Jon Gruden

Marshawn Lynch is out... He's out with an injured groin is the explanation they gave. I don't think that Marshawn Lynch is capable of having his groin injured... I think he doesn't like Jon Gruden. He doesn't want to play for Jon Gruden to do a car.

Lynch did have surgery for a core muscle injury and did not play again in 2018. He eventually left the Raiders after the season.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

2018 is the 'Year of the Blake' because Griffin and Bortles are back

Cool Throne, I have Blake. Blake's. Plural. Both of our Blake's. Blake Griffin, 50 Burger... and Blake Bortles, named starter. So we're back. It's been a big year for Blakes.

Both Blakes had temporary resurgences in late 2018, though Bortles would be benched again shortly after.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL teams should always go for two when down eight in the fourth quarter

The nerds had the correct theory here that you go for two when you're down eight in the fourth quarter, because essentially you have to score another touchdown no matter what. If you hit the first two, you can win the game with an extra point. I'm smarter than I was in the past.

Analytics now widely support going for 2 when down 8 to maximize the win probability in regulation.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Cody Kessler is a terrible quarterback

Cody Kessler that guy stinks throwing the ball over the place fumbling he recovered his fumble but still interceptions I get it you gotta maybe sit down the boat [Bortles] for a minute it was uh the engine needs a little tune up but good news the next game for the Jaguars is in London and Blake Bortles owns London.

Kessler finished his career with a 2-10 record as a starter and poor efficiency metrics.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

If Titanic 2 sinks, it would be the greatest moment ever

If the Titanic 2 could somehow sink, it would be the greatest moment ever... because you're an asshole for riding on the Titanic 2.

The Titanic II project has been perpetually delayed and has not yet sailed or sunk.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Hue Jackson is objectively a very bad football coach

From where I'm sitting, [Hue Jackson] is objectively a very bad football coach. Okay? And on top of that... He just blames everyone else when shit goes wrong.

Hue Jackson's winning percentage at the time was one of the worst in NFL history for a coach with his longevity.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Patriots are very beatable without Rob Gronkowski

I thought that I think [the Patriots] are very beatable, though, without Gronk.

The Patriots won the Super Bowl this season (Super Bowl LIII) despite Gronk being physically limited.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are suffering a quintessential Super Bowl hangover

No, they are a quintessential Super Bowl hangover. Because every game, they're up 17-0. They're like, oh, we got this... but it's these games that they think they've won and they just lose them.

The Eagles finished 9-7 and barely made the playoffs, a significant drop from their 13-3 championship season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Justin Tucker is worth a second-round pick

Justin Tucker is the one kicker that I think would actually probably be worth a first-round pick... I'll give you a second.

Subjective value, but Tucker is the most accurate kicker in history, making his value exceptionally high.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Taysom Hill is better at everything Tim Tebow does

[Sean Payton] puts Taysom Hill out there, and Taysom Hill is like Tim Tebow – except he's better at everything Tim Tebow does. He's a better pump protector. He's a better passer. He's a better runner.

Hill has had much more longevity and versatile success in the NFL than Tebow as a non-traditional weapon.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Vrabel hates ties more than he hates losses

Mike Vrabel, I figured him out. He just hates ties. He thinks ties are worse than losses... and the Titans lost at the goal line going for two.

Vrabel consistently played aggressively for wins throughout his career, famously avoiding ties when possible.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer can't get his team ready for inferior opponents

Urban Meyer's sad faces on the sideline because Ohio State lost a game that they should have won... people are saying, not me, people are saying, Urban Meyer, can he get his team ready for the inferior opponents? I don't know... but this is now becoming a trend for Urban Meyer.

Meyer finished 2018 with another Big Ten title but the loss to Purdue kept them out of the playoff, supporting the idea that one slip-up to a 'lesser' team was a pattern.
Void
HankHank

Boban Marjanovic is not of this world

My who's back is Boban... His clips of him playing are, I mean, I remember people talking about him last year, but this year it's like surreal. He's not of this world. It's like he's playing on a seven-foot hoop.

Hyperbolic but reflects Boban's historically high PER and physical uniqueness.
Void
Dave DameshekDave Dameshek

Antonio Brown is the best wide receiver since Randy Moss

Antonio Brown's the best receiver since Randy Moss. And Le'Veon Bell's the best running back in the game. And are they really never even going to get to a Super Bowl together?

Brown had a legendary run in Pittsburgh, though many would argue for Megatron or others. Brown never won a Super Bowl with the Steelers.
Win
Dave DameshekDave Dameshek

The Eagles lack a grinder running back to finish games

It's clear in the fourth quarter that's what [the Eagles] miss with not having Jay Ajayi or LeGarrette Blount. That's going to be a bad thing, and I don't know what the fix is out there on the open market for them to get that guy who can just grind the defense when you need him to.

The Eagles struggled to run consistently in 2018, finishing 28th in rushing yards per attempt.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Philip Rivers is the most underrated quarterback of our time

Phil Rivers is probably the most underrated quarterback of our time. He's for sure a Hall of Famer.

Rivers finished his career with elite passing numbers, though his Hall of Fame status is still debated by some due to lack of rings.
Loss
Dave DameshekDave Dameshek

Joey Bosa is a better long-term defensive player than TJ Watt

I assume Bosa's going to come back healthy. I would definitely take Bosa [over TJ Watt for the rest of their careers].

While both had great careers, TJ Watt won DPOY and became a perennial leader in sacks, likely surpassing Bosa's career arc.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

David Price's postseason demons won't be fully exercised until he wins in the World Series

I'm not ready to declare the demons exercised. The demons are warmed up. They're jazzercising right now. To be fully exercised, it has to be in the World Series.

David Price went on to win Game 2 and Game 5 of the 2018 World Series, earning the series-clinching win and effectively silencing critics.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bryce Harper sweepstakes is over for the Red Sox because of their current outfield chemistry

So can we put the Dunn chain on the Red Sox in terms of being in the Bryce Harper sweepstakes next year? Ooh, you don't want to mess up with that chemistry of a team that went to the World Series.

The Red Sox did not sign Bryce Harper; he signed with the Phillies in early 2019.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are officially good if they can beat the Patriots

If the Bears can beat the Patriots, then they're officially good. It's going to be a big test.

The Bears lost to the Patriots 38-31, but they finished 12-4 and won the division, proving they were indeed 'good' even in a loss.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jets did themselves a favor by missing out on Kirk Cousins

If you know anything about Kirk Cousins, you actually did yourself a favor by not getting him because you'd rather suck out loud than be kind of around average for four years.

Cousins led the Vikings to several winning seasons and a playoff win, while the Jets struggled with Sam Darnold and Zach Wilson for years. Subjectively, the Jets likely would have preferred Cousins' stability.
Void
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Only 12 NFL owners actually care about winning championships

I think there are legitimately 12 teams in the National Football League that are legitimately concerned about winning a Super Bowl... I think there are certain owners that are just in there to build equity... and every now and then catch the lightning.

This is an insider's professional opinion on institutional goals, which is inherently subjective but highly respected given his proximity to owners.
Win
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

The Dallas Cowboys will never win a championship until Jerry Jones stops being the General Manager

I've always said they'll never win until [Jerry Jones] is ready to actually relinquish control. I mean, it's one thing to appoint a guy, you know, head coach or whatever. It's an entirely different thing to empower that guy.

The Cowboys have not won a Super Bowl since 1995, and Jerry Jones remains the GM.
Win
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Aaron Rodgers acts like Compound W by covering up the Packers' warts

When you've got a quarterback like that—I always just say this about Peyton Manning... he's like Compound W, just spreading himself all over warts. The issue you get into is that I think you get this self-confidence that we're pretty good... they think they're a lot better than they really are.

The Packers went 6-9-1 and missed the playoffs in 2018, proving that Rodgers could no longer mask the team's deficiencies entirely that year.
Win
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

The NFL is tailoring the game to fantasy football fans by creating 'Points-a-Palooza'

We've created a generation of people who have watched football based on fantasy football... and the NFL is actually going, okay, you love fantasy football? Here it is. Here's fantasy football for you. People are digging it.

The 2018 season was one of the highest-scoring in NFL history, and rule changes have continued to favor offense and high-scoring games.
Win
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Case Keenum is missing wide-open targets because of bad footwork

He [Case Keenum] just hasn't been very good. He's missed a bunch of wide-open targets... part of it is your offensive line stinks, and so you speed up your footwork... and the ball just gets out of your hands. The timing of your footwork and the routes don't line up.

Keenum finished 2018 with 18 TDs and 15 INTs and was traded after the season, confirming he was not the long-term solution in Denver.
Void
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

Bill Belichick cannot truly understand the pressure of a 3rd and 12 from your own goal line because he never played

Bill Belichick has no idea what – he's the greatest football coach we've ever been around... He has no idea the ass pucker you get third down and 12 from your own six-yard line right in the shadow of your own end zone... I've been there. He can't.

This is a subjective claim about the nature of empathy and experience.
Void
Mark SchlerethMark Schlereth

You can only play with a back fracture in hockey and football

The only sports that you can play with a small back fracture are hockey and football... Injured is when you have to have surgery that holds you out. You have to play injured [in the NFL]. And more importantly, you have to play well injured.

This is a subjective claim about the threshold of pain and playability in different sports, though medially controversial.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will stop calling Kevin Durant a 'baby back bitch' if he signs with the New York Knicks

If he goes to the Knicks, I've got his baby back. We will take away the triple B if he goes to the Knicks. So here we go. Kevin Durant, when you put your pros and cons on a sheet this summer, Just put in the pro, pardon my take, will stop calling me a baby back bitch.

Durant did not sign with the Knicks; he signed with the Brooklyn Nets.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The G-League's $125k offer is a major threat to the NCAA

The G-League has come out and they have said that they are giving a $125,000 contract to players that could be eligible for the one and done and they want to skip college... This is trouble for the NCAA.

The G-League Ignite and other professional paths (Overtime Elite, NIL) eventually revolutionized college basketball and drastically changed the one-and-done landscape.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

America is sick of Aaron Rodgers winning games in predictable, dramatic fashion

He will win a game late, and he will do it in dramatic fashion, and he will drop dimes and all that. I'm sick of it. I think America is sick of it, to be honest, if I'm just going to speak for America here.

This is subjective, but Rodgers' style of late-game heroics continued to be a major NFL storyline for years, though 'America' was likely more entertained than sick of it.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Witten was hired by ESPN solely to mend the relationship between the network and NFL owners

Jason Witten is in place to mend the ESPN-NFL relationship, which makes sense... they put him in there, and it doesn't really matter if he's bad for the audience. It just matters that the rest of the owners and Roger Goodell likes him.

While Witten's hire was widely criticized for his lack of experience, the specific 'mending relationships' motive is a matter of corporate strategy that hasn't been officially confirmed but remains a strong industry theory.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL referees are being bullied by the internet into not calling the game by the rules

The refs are getting bullied by the blogosphere and the twittersphere into not calling the game by the rules. I would have liked to see [Clay Matthews] get penalized for that [hit on C.J. Beathard].

Whether refs are 'bullied' by social media is inherently subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

American cheese on a breakfast taco is the best type of cheese

American cheese on a breakfast taco is the best type of cheese. We need to, here's what we need to do. We need to start eating more breakfast tacos in America.

Culinary preferences are inherently a matter of opinion.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Josh Allen's ligaments were too weak to support his rocket arm

His arm was too strong that his ligaments couldn't support all the muscle... the good news is he doesn't need Tommy John surgery.

Josh Allen suffered an elbow injury but did not require surgery in 2018, which aligns with the latter part of the take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Boston sports fans don't feel joy when they win; they just enjoy that everyone else feels bad

I'm convinced that Boston fans, they don't feel joy when they win... One, it's relief. And two, it's that they feel good that everybody else feels bad. You guys are desensitized to winning all the time... You like everybody else being a loser.

The emotional state of a fan base is a matter of interpretation.
Void
Bill BurrBill Burr

The NFL is effectively becoming seven-on-seven flag football

Tom Brady threw for over 500 yards and lost the Super Bowl... I loved the doomsday defense, the steel curtain... Those guys, they just shut you the fuck down... and it's just all gone. I mean, the fucking guy, Tyreek Hill... runs across the middle of the field... nobody's going to hit him.

This is a widespread subjective opinion regarding the evolution of NFL rules and scoring trends.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Wisconsin Badgers season is officially over

The Badger season's over. They're a fucking dumpster fire. I'm done... don't ever think about getting sucked back into this Wisconsin season. They're chicken shit cowards and don't deserve your time or money.

The Badgers finished the season 8-5 and won the Pinstripe Bowl, so the season wasn't technically 'over', but they failed to meet high preseason expectations.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 2018 Chicago Bears are not a Super Bowl team

I also, if the Bears had won that game and gone 4-1 and then played the Patriots next week and had been like, someone would have written the, could this be a Super Bowl preview, which is stupid because the Bears are not a Super Bowl team, whatever.

The Bears finished 12-4 but lost in the Wild Card round (the Double Doink game), confirming they were not a Super Bowl team.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jon Gruden is starting to realize he is in over his head as the Raiders head coach

Right now, Jon Gruden's entering the phase of this job where he is starting to realize, hey, I might be in a little bit over my head. This isn't actually the year 1998.

Gruden's tenure with the Raiders was generally underwhelming, finishing with more losses than wins before his eventual resignation in 2021.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nathan Peterman is the Matt Schaub of our generation

Yeah, he's the Matt Schaub of our generation. It's great. I mean, every game is just so much more exciting when Nathan Peterman gets involved because you know what's going to happen. It's just a matter of time.

Subjective comparison between two quarterbacks famous for throwing interceptions at critical moments.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets might actually be good

The Jets might be good. 3-3. Todd Bowles, turn that squad around. Turn it around. Top 10. That's what he does. He's getting up there.

The Jets finished the 2018 season 4-12 and Todd Bowles was fired.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chiefs defense is so bad they can lose games even when scoring 40 points

The Chiefs' defense, though, if you score 40 points in the NFL and you lose, that's impressive. That's an impressive thing to do. Their defense is so, so bad.

The 2018 Chiefs defense finished near the bottom of the league in several categories, eventually costing them in the AFC Championship game against the Patriots.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Rob Gronkowski is the greatest tight end in the history of the game

Did you guys realize that Rob Gronkowski is actually the greatest tight end in the history of the game? Like, he actually is. It's kind of not even a debate.

While Kelce has since challenged the record books, Gronkowski remains widely considered the most complete/best tight end in history by many fans and analysts.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I am still buying Scott Frost as a good coach for Nebraska

Their quarterback got injured. I don't know. For whatever reason, I'm still buying Scott Frost.

Scott Frost never had a winning season at Nebraska and was fired in 2022 with a 16-31 record.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James is the new Steve Jobs

LeBron is the new Steve Jobs. From films and TV shows to educational institutions, A&R-ing via his IG... James is using his magnitude to invade industries and redirect the conversation.

Inherently subjective comparison between a basketball star and a tech visionary.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Giants should 'put Eli Manning down' like an old house cat

Eli Manning, he's more like an old house cat that just coughs up hairballs and shits himself all the time. Put it down. Put it down.

Eli Manning was benched for Daniel Jones the following season (2019) and retired shortly after, confirming he was at the end of the road.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers