Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is the second-best quarterback in the NFL

Josh Allen is what a franchise quarterback looks like. And we've said it a million times. Just because he's not Patrick Mahomes doesn't mean he's [not] the second—he is the second best quarterback in the NFL.

Subjective ranking of quarterbacks.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bills losing Stefon Diggs was addition by subtraction

It probably is addition by subtraction, losing Diggs. Oh, definitely. And Gabe Davis... it feels like this. Josh [Allen] is like star. He's turned a brand new page clean slate for this team. So he doesn't have any of that excess baggage that he used to have.

The Bills' offense remained highly efficient in 2024 without Diggs, often performing better than with him the previous year.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman winner because he is the best football player in the country

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman. And maybe it's because I bet on him pre-season, but Travis Hunter should be the Heisman... if you actually voted for Heisman how it should be voted—best player, not how every award now gets voted on... Travis Hunter should be your Heisman Trophy winner because he is the best football player in college football.

Travis Hunter won the 2024 Heisman Trophy, as Big Cat predicted. Hunter won as a two-way player for Colorado.
Void
MaxMax

Fox's Big Noon Kickoff is 'bullshit' because it ruins the atmosphere of Penn State's White Out games.

That's Fox's fault. Big 10. Fucking Big 10 kickoff is big Noon kickoff is bullshit... it's like a really big thing in college football... they burn your whiteouts on, on Lame Games.

The sentiment that morning kickoffs diminish the White Out atmosphere is inherently subjective to fans.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The alleged celebrity lists associated with the Diddy investigation will never be made public.

The list never come out. They never come out. They tell you that there's a list and it's a distraction so that you can come up with your old, your own like fan fiction like lore universe that you make up... The lists never do [come out].

Celebrity names were indeed made public during the Diddy trial in 2025. During jury selection, a list of 190+ celebrities was read aloud, and numerous A-listers were named during trial proceedings. A jury ultimately acquitted Diddy of sex-trafficking charges in July 2025. PFT's prediction that 'the list never comes out' was wrong.
Void
Michael SilverMichael Silver

The Chicago Bears are the most under-marketed entity in American commerce

I don't believe that there is a more under-marketed entity in American commerce than the Chicago Bears... in this city... it's a football town... and with the Bears, you know, in '85 and like that was, it was just, it engulfed everything. And they've been living off it since.

Subjective business/marketing opinion.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The start of the 2024 season proves that coaching matters more than anything else in the NFL

The big picture for me before we get into all the games is Sam Darnold's three and oh, Geno Smith's three and oh... this start of the 2024 season has just been a red blinking light of coaching matters a lot.

The season-long success of Sam Darnold and Jared Goff, contrasted with the struggles of highly-drafted QBs in poor systems, generally supported this theme throughout 2024.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kevin O'Connell is one of the best coaches in the NFL

Minnesota might have one of the best coaches in the league. Yes. And I would also put McVay's performance this week right up there too.

O'Connell led the Vikings to a surprisingly successful season and is widely regarded as a top-tier offensive mind.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nick Sirianni does not deserve to be let off the hook for his poor coaching despite the Eagles' win

I'm hoping that Max doesn't let [Sirianni] off the hook. Yeah. He doesn't deserve to be left off the hook. They won the game and they were the better team in this game... That was a horrible display of coaching from him today.

Subjective opinion on coaching performance.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings' defense is officially for real

The Vikings are just good. Brian Flores, that defense was everywhere... back to back week, you know, week one, obviously the Giants are kind of a mess... but the 49ers and the Texans are two teams that have Super Bowl aspirations... and Brian Flores basically put 'em in his back pocket.

The Vikings defense remained a top-tier unit throughout the first half of the 2024 season, validating the take.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

I'm not worried about Caleb Williams; I'm worried about the Bears' coaching staff ruining him

Nothing has changed about my opinion about Caleb Williams other than the fact maybe everyone was right that Matt Eberflus is a fucking moron... Caleb Williams is not my worry at all. I know people were going to say he is a bust and all that shit. He's not my worry. I swear to God, I'm not worried at all. I'm worried about the coaching staff just like ruining him in a way that makes me worried.

The Bears eventually fired Shane Waldron mid-season, validating Big Cat's concern about the coaching, though Caleb Williams' overall performance remained a subject of debate.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Anthony Richardson's poor decision-making suggests he might not be 'the guy' for the Colts

I've seen a lot of bad quarterback play in my day. That [interception] should be a play that you should file away as one that's like, is he the guy? Probably not.

Richardson's struggles led to a mid-season benching in 2024, though his long-term status remains debated.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Malik Nabors is the frontrunner for Offensive Rookie of the Year

Malik Nabors is really, really, he's awesome. He's right now Rookie of the Year.

Jayden Daniels ultimately won Offensive Rookie of the Year, though Nabors remained one of the top candidates.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers cannot bench Justin Fields for Russell Wilson as long as they are winning

It feels like he's [Fields] kind of rounding into form to being a winning quarterback... I personaly would not [bench him]... you cannot bench a three and oh quarterback... You gotta wait until something bad happens and like he has a bad game and then maybe make a switch.

Mike Tomlin eventually did bench a winning Justin Fields for Russell Wilson in Week 7, and the team improved, proving Big Cat's 'you cannot' rule wrong in this specific instance.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Starting Justin Herbert with a high ankle sprain against the Steelers was a mistake

I don't know why they started Justin Herbert in this game... I feel like that was maybe a mistake... I thought maybe just sit him out, try to win that game with Taylor Heinicke... because this is gonna linger now.

Herbert did struggle with mobility and eventually aggravated injuries, though he avoided a season-ending setback.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers' defensive formula can beat 90% of the NFL

They [Steelers] have a formula that I feel like can beat 90% of the NFL. Just don't turn the ball over. Run the football when you need to... get some nice like 10, 12 play drives put together.

The Steelers started 8-2, proving they could beat most of the league with this style.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Matt LaFleur is the current NFL Coach of the Year through three weeks

Matt LaFleur is the coach of the year through three weeks. It's insane... two wins without Jordan Love.

LaFleur remained a top candidate for COY throughout the season, leading the Packers to the playoffs with a young roster.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams' win over the 49ers was a coaching masterpiece by Sean McVay

I just felt it going in, the Rams kitchen sink. Sean McVay is such a good head coach. They are down so many guys, they're gonna find a way... that was a coaching masterpiece by Sean McVay.

Subjective opinion on coaching performance.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Matthew Stafford is a Hall of Famer

Matthew Stafford, Hall of Famer. Matthew Stafford has 99 total wins in his career... almost half of Matthew Stafford's wins have needed Matthew Stafford to have a game winning drive. He's an absolute baller when it comes down to late game situations.

This remains a subjective debate, but Stafford's career stats and Super Bowl ring make it a very strong case.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

David Montgomery and Jahmyr Gibbs are the best running back tandem in the NFL

Lions also got back to basics of just pounding the rock... I'd say best running back tandem in the NFL.

Subjective ranking of backfields.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am dangerously close to buying in on the Seahawks as a legitimate team

I am getting very close to buying in on the Seahawks... Mike Macdonald seems to be a very good head coach in three games. I am dangerously close to believing in the Seahawks.

Subjective valuation of team quality.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cowboys' defense officially stinks

Do the Cowboys stink? They might. I think their defense stinks.

The Cowboys defense struggled significantly throughout the 2024 season, losing several key players to injury and ranking poorly in most metrics.
Win
HankHank

The Patriots' offensive line is currently worse than the Bears'

[The Patriots] looked horrible. Their offensive line like looked worse than the Bears. [Jacoby Brissett] never had more than one second to throw. They missed a ton of tackles on defense.

While both units were bottom-tier, the Patriots' line was statistically among the worst in terms of pressure rate allowed throughout the 2024 season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shohei Ohtani is the best baseball player of all time

I'd say that this, he is the best baseball player of all time. Whether or not he'll have the best career of all time is kind of up for grabs. But we've never seen anybody that's doing what he's doing.

This is inherently subjective, though Ohtani's 2024 season and dual-threat history make him a consensus top-tier candidate for the 'best ever' title.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

NFL offenses are struggling because they are taking the bait on two-high safety looks

Everyone's blaming the two high safeties. And I actually read an article... essentially deep passes still work, but offenses are taking the bait with the two high safeties and just they're running the ball into light boxes and it's just not, it's not as effective... stop taking the bait.

The 'two-high' shell was a dominant talking point in 2024. Offensive production did eventually tick up as teams adapted, though passing yards remained historically low for much of the year.
Win
MaxMax

Bryce Huff is a terrible player

I have a guy that you guys can get, he was first in pressure rate in 2022 and third in rate in 2023. And you can have him, do you want him... Oh no, he sucks.

Huff struggled significantly in the first half of the 2024 season, validating early concerns, though 'sucks' is a harsh subjective term for a pro edge rusher.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You should never have a quarterback wearing number 19

Skylar Thompson wearing number 19 is terrible. That's a bad quarterback name number. It's Johnny Unitas and nothing else. You can't, yeah. Number 19... it's a just warning sign that this is a very backup quarterback.

This is a subjective aesthetic opinion about uniform numbers.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Week 3 is a must-win game for the Ravens

It's a must win. I'm declaring it's a must win for the Ravens. If they lose, I think only one team since the expansion has made the playoffs after starting 0-3. I like the Ravens just because of purely sense of urgency.

The Ravens beat the Cowboys 28-25, so they avoided the 0-3 hole.
Void
Anthony "Spice" AdamsAnthony "Spice" Adams

A football team's true identity is revealed by the 'second quarter' of the season (Weeks 5-8)

I think by the second quarter you should know like, this is the first quarter, first four days... I think by the second quarter, man, you should know the type of team you got. You should know if you a running team, if you're a play action team, or if you're on defense and you, you, you are a defense that stopped the run.

This is a standard veteran football philosophy that is generally accepted in coaching circles.
Void
Anthony "Spice" AdamsAnthony "Spice" Adams

The hip-drop tackle ban is difficult to enforce because players just react in the heat of the moment

The whole thing is to get him down... You're not saying, oh let me do this illegal tackle so that I could tear his ACL or break his ankle... You don't have time to gauge like, oh, it's my helmet going to come in contact with his helmet... You just go and you just react. I think all of this stuff... nobody really thinking about what the defense gotta go through.

While the rule exists, enforcement has been sporadic and controversial, mirroring Spice's point about the difficulty of live-action compliance.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The narrative that the NFC South is the worst division in football is officially over

I believe that we officially have to end the narrative that the NFC South is the worst division in football because they have the two and Oh Saints, the one and one Falcons, the two and oh bucks. They're a good division now.

By season's end, the NFC South actually remained one of the weaker divisions statistically, though it was improved from the previous year.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles should have run the ball twice on their final offensive possession

Running the football there... I'll even get crazy here. Ready? Ready for this Max. I think you run it twice and you get a first down because you're the Philadelphia Eagles and no one can stop when you run it with your biggest offensive line in football.

While speculative, the Eagles are known for the 'Tush Push' and have a dominant run game. Running the ball would have burned at least 40 more seconds off the clock, making the Falcons' final drive much more difficult.
Void
MaxMax

The Eagles defensive line is horrible

I took notes... D-line. Mega bad. [Bryce Huff] is horrible. Like horrendously bad. Like he shouldn't be.

Subjective assessment of defensive line quality, though Bryce Huff's early stats in Philly supported this at the time.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2024 Falcons have changed the perspective of the entire franchise

If you're a Falcons fan, this felt like it was a pretty big moment for the franchise. This is, it may have changed your entire perspective on football. Yeah. Because this is, it was the reverse Falcons thing. The Eagles turned into the Falcons.

The Falcons did indeed win the game with a very low win probability, making it a historic turnaround for a franchise known for blowing leads.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Bryce Young's tenure has officially established the floor for how short a quarterback can be

It unfortunately probably puts the limit on height. Now he's officially the floor. We've reached it. We pushed it with Russell Wilson... then Kyler Murray, I think Bryce Young is now the floor of how short you can be as a quarterback.

The next draft cycles will prove if teams shy away from sub-6 foot quarterbacks due to Bryce Young's career path.
Win
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Georgia is still a playoff team, but they aren't as dominant in the trenches as years past

I think they're holding Carson Beck back a little bit... that offensive line's not what I thought they were gonna be. So they can't just push people around and mash people and they're really not that kind of a group on defense. Now what they do have are freak show monsters on defense that can get you off the edge... but it's just not gonna look as dominant or clean as it has in years past.

Georgia struggled in several SEC games and lost to Alabama and Ole Miss, confirming they were not the untouchable juggernaut of previous seasons.
Win
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Ole Miss vs. Georgia is the most important game for the Rebels' playoff path

I think the Ole Miss game [vs Georgia] probably the most important game there... I don't think 10 and two just guarantees that you're in the playoff with those schedules and if Georgia were to go down to say an Alabama or Texas not near as big of a deal. But I think you can go a little bit further in eliminating Ole Miss with maybe a 10 and two similar record if you're Georgia.

Ole Miss beat Georgia 28-10 on Nov 9, 2024. This win effectively solidified their playoff resume and proved to be their most significant victory of the year.
Win
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Tennessee's Dylan Sampson is a lightning rod and an explosive play waiting to happen

The difference right now, Dylan Sampson, it's not Nico [Iamaleava], it's not the receivers. This kid is a lightning rod at tailback explosive play waiting to happen and he presses the line of scrimmage... this kid is big time.

Sampson went on to have a record-breaking season for Tennessee, confirming Cole's high appraisal.
Void
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Urban Meyer's coaching style would not work in modern college football

I have a ton of respect for Urban, but I don't think his style of coaching is overly conducive with today's college football. He's a grinder. Yeah, absolutely... That's a small portion of why Saban walked away. Like he couldn't coach the guys the way that he wanted to anymore, the way the guys probably need to be coached. But you now you have an out... Rick Trickett... referenced me as the dumbest motherfucker... every single day. You can't do that anymore.

This is a subjective assessment of coaching culture, though Saban's retirement and the failure of other 'old school' coaches in the portal era lend it credibility.
Win
Cole CubelicCole Cubelic

Texas is a bigger matchup problem for the SEC than any SEC team is for Texas

I don't from a matchup perspective, PFT I don't really know if there's a ton that I look at and just say like from a matchup perspective, like that's, that's rough... I think they're more of a matchup problem for anybody else than anybody else is for them because of how versatile they are offensively the motions they use the formations.

Texas proved to be a dominant force, reaching the SEC Championship game and the CFP, with their only regular season loss coming to Georgia.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

This victory over the Lions might be Todd Bowles' signature win as the Buccaneers head coach

The Bucs, you called it the gutsy one of the week. I think this might be Todd Bowles' signature win. He won a playoff game, but I'm gonna give Todd Bowles his signature win this week. This is signature win for Todd Bowles. We've all been waiting for one.

While Bowles won a playoff game previously, this Week 2 victory was a major statement win against an NFC favorite.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Buccaneers are currently the number one team in my NFL power rankings

The Bucs have now beaten two outstanding teams. I think I have the Bucs number one in my power rankings right now. Commanders and the Lions.

The Bucs finished 9-8 and won their division, but they were certainly not the #1 team in the league by season's end.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Saints are the best team in the NFL through the first two weeks

If we were just going off of two weeks, are the Saints the best team in the NFL? Yes, they are. I think that they are the best team in the NFL. If you go off two weeks, cumulative scores are 91 to 20.

The Saints cooled off significantly after Week 2, losing seven straight games shortly after this take.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The entire NFC South is a lot better than we expected it to be

I think that the entire NFC South is a lot better than we thought it was gonna be. The Saints have looked unstoppable in two [weeks].

The division was more competitive than in 2023, with three teams (Bucs, Falcons, Saints) finishing with 9 or 8 wins, though only one made the playoffs.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Brian Daboll cost the Giants the game by failing to carry a backup kicker

Brian Daboll, what the fuck are you doing? They could have brought up another kicker. It felt like Brian Daboll cost his team the game here by not having a kicker.

The Giants lost by 3 points and missed an extra point/didn't attempt field goals due to Gano's injury, making this a widely accepted factual criticism.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots should transition to Drake May sooner rather than later

I think you should start Drake May. Why maybe not this week on a Thursday, but if you want to push the ball downfield and give your team chances like that, it should be Drake May. That's my point. If it's tank, then Jacoby Brissett's perfect.

Drake May eventually took over in Week 6 and showed significant promise, validating the idea that he provided a higher ceiling for the offense.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brian Flores is a great defensive coordinator but not a good head coach

The Vikings defense kind of ate you up a little bit. Brian Flores, he's a good defensive coach. Not a good head coach. Good defensive coach. I think that might be a mark of a great defensive coordinator, if you hate quarterbacks that much.

Flores was a polarizing head coach in Miami (24-25 record). His success as Vikings DC supports the 'elite coordinator' part of the claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Anthony Richardson is not currently good at quarterbacking

Anthony Richardson is just not that good at quarterbacking right now. He had two very, very bad interceptions. Missing guys. I just don't see it what other people see. Kale Williams was really good in college. Anthony Richardson wasn't. So that's where I'm like, I don't know.

Richardson was eventually benched for Joe Flacco later in the 2024 season before being reinstated, confirming his struggles with the fundamentals of the position.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jaguars are officially a bad football team

Are the Browns good or the Jaguars bad? I think, I think Jags bad. Miles Garrett was making Trevor live in hell today.

The Jaguars finished 6-11 and were one of the most disappointing teams of the 2024 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals are not in trouble despite starting the season 0-2

I was like very walked away from that game saying the Bengals that I thought the Bengals might be in trouble. I was teetering on that with the wrist and everything. I do not think the Bengals are in trouble. They just couldn't beat the Chiefs because the Chiefs just are inevitable.

The Bengals finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs, marking a disappointing season where they were indeed in trouble.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers