Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Writer Michael Silver, Jayden Daniels Is Incredible, The Jags Are Dead, College Football Talk + Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, September 25, 202416 takes

Jayden Daniels is incredible and we talk Monday Night Football and PFT’s experience in Cincy (-). The Bills are humming and Trevor Lawrence is broken (-). College Football talk and Travis Hunter should be the Heisman winner (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including a shift to team Raiola and Joe Mazzulla misses Hank (-). NFL Writer Michael Silver joins the show to talk football, his new book about the Shanahan coaching tree “The Why Is Everything”, crazy Dennis Rodman stories and tons more (-). We finish with Guys on Chicks (-).

Michael Silver on the Shanahan Tree, Jayden Daniels' Masterclass, and Jags in Hell

PFT returned from Cincinnati a changed man after witnessing Jayden Daniels put on an absolute clinic on Monday Night Football. The energy in the studio was electric as the guys broke down a game where neither team punted or turned the ball over, a statistical anomaly that hasn't been seen in decades. While the Bengals moved to a terrifying 0-3, the story was entirely about the rookie quarterback in D.C. who looked like he’d been playing in the league for ten years.

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#4618
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels' Monday night performance was the best game I've ever seen a quarterback play for the Commanders

What I saw last night made me feel emotions that I have not felt in my cold dead football heart in decades... what really got me excited about Jayden was how he handled like third downs, fourth downs. He was cool. He was directing guys around. He was calm in the pocket... I think that's the best game I've ever seen a quarterback play for my team.

Daniels finished with a 91.3% completion rate, the highest for a rookie in NFL history, supporting the claim that it was a historic performance.

PFT was so high on the performance that he was ready to crown Jayden the king of the division and potentially the sport. Even Max, a noted Eagles homer, had to concede that the Commanders finally have a guy, especially considering the financial flexibility of a rookie deal compared to the massive bag Jalen Hurts just secured.

Push
Sep 25, 2024
#24303
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels is already the best quarterback in the NFC East and potentially the entire NFL.

But yeah, he's, I mean, I, I don't know. It's one game. But he's the best quarterback in that division. Maybe even in the entire league.

While Daniels had an incredible rookie season, being the best in the 'entire league' remains a hyperbolic claim against players like Mahomes.
Win
Sep 25, 2024
#24308
MaxMax

I would take Jayden Daniels over Jalen Hurts due to the rookie contract, and I wish Daniels were not in the NFC East.

I wish Jayden Daniels was not in the NFC East... he looks very good... [I would take] any rookie on a rookie contract [over Jalen Hurts].

Daniels won Offensive Rookie of the Year, validating the 'rookie contract value' sentiment for 2024.

The fallout for the Bengals is much grimmer. Big Cat noted that the historical odds for an 0-3 team making the playoffs are essentially nonexistent, and the defense looks like a sieve that might be beyond repair. Beyond the X's and O's, there is a clear aesthetic issue in Cincinnati that needs immediate attention.

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#4619
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals are in deep trouble after starting 0-3 with a defense that can't be fixed

I do think the Bengals are in trouble... only six of the 225 teams that started 0 and 3 in the Super Bowl era have made the playoffs... I don't know where the fixes are on defense. The only fix I have for the Bengals is Joe Burrow has to change his hair color. You can't be 0 and 3 with those frosted tips.

The Bengals did not make the playoffs in 2024.
Void
Sep 25, 2024
#24307
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Joe Burrow must change his hair color and get rid of the frosted tips because you cannot lose games with that look.

The only fix I have for the Bengals is Joe Burrow has to change his hair color. You can't be 0-3 with those, with that hair... get rid of the frosted tips Joe... you gotta cut your hair... you can't lose with Frosted Tips.

Burrow eventually cut the hair and the Bengals' play improved, though the correlation is superstitious.

The Jags Are Broken and Josh Allen is Toying with People

While the Commanders were ascending, the Jaguars were descending into a deep, dark abyss. Trevor Lawrence looked completely lost, at one point performing a "spin to nowhere" that had the guys questioning if the franchise quarterback might actually be a bust. It’s a complete disaster for Doug Pederson, especially after owner Shad Khan hyped this as the best roster the team has ever had.

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#24309
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trevor Lawrence might actually stink, and his regression is being overshadowed by Jayden Daniels' success.

Yeah, he might stink. And I think Shad Khan said before the season, this is the best team that the Jaguars have ever assembled. So to me that does not sound good for Doug Pederson... He just spun into his own guy [spin to nowhere].

Lawrence and the Jaguars struggled throughout the 2024 season, confirming the sentiment of regression.

On the flip side, Josh Allen played a perfect half of football and sat on the bench for the rest of the night. Big Cat wasn't hesitant to remind everyone where Allen stands in the hierarchy of the league, even if he doesn't have the rings of Mahomes.

Void
Sep 25, 2024
#4621
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is the second-best quarterback in the NFL

Josh Allen is what a franchise quarterback looks like. And we've said it a million times. Just because he's not Patrick Mahomes doesn't mean he's [not] the second—he is the second best quarterback in the NFL.

Subjective ranking of quarterbacks.

College Football and the Heisman Debate

Transitioning to the college game, the focus turned to Colorado and the absolute insanity of Travis Hunter. He played nearly every single snap of their double-overtime thriller, forcing a fumble at the goal line to win the game after already putting up massive numbers at receiver. Big Cat and PFT are officially leading the charge to get him the trophy he deserves, regardless of the "Deion fatigue" felt by the rest of the media.

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#4623
Big CatBig Cat

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman winner because he is the best football player in the country

Travis Hunter should be the Heisman. And maybe it's because I bet on him pre-season, but Travis Hunter should be the Heisman... if you actually voted for Heisman how it should be voted—best player, not how every award now gets voted on... Travis Hunter should be your Heisman Trophy winner because he is the best football player in college football.

Travis Hunter won the 2024 Heisman Trophy, as Big Cat predicted. Hunter won as a two-way player for Colorado.

Michael Silver on NFL Revolutions

NFL writer Michael Silver joined the show to discuss his new book, *The Why Is Everything*, which traces the history of the Shanahan coaching tree. Silver provided incredible behind-the-scenes stories from the 2012 Washington staff that featured Kyle Shanahan, Sean McVay, Matt LaFleur, and Mike McDaniel. He also pulled back the curtain on how Mike Shanahan still influences the 49ers today.

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#4624
Michael SilverMichael Silver

Mike Shanahan uses a virtual system called 'Shana-Cam' to watch all 49ers meetings and film, though calling him a 'shadow GM' is an exaggeration.

There is something at 49ers headquarters referred to as the 'Shana-Cam', where Mike Shanahan needs to watch meetings and practice ASAP virtually... Some people think he's the shadow gm. I think that's an exaggeration. But this is incredible.

The existence of the 'Shana-Cam' is a specific fact claim reported by a high-level journalist; the 'shadow GM' status is subjective and debunked by the source here.

Beyond the coaching X's and O's, Silver touched on the business side of the league. He didn't hold back on his assessment of how certain historic franchises are run, specifically pointing out that the organization in Chicago hasn't exactly kept pace with modern marketing or revenue generation.

Void
Sep 25, 2024
#4625
Michael SilverMichael Silver

The Chicago Bears are the most under-marketed entity in American commerce

I don't believe that there is a more under-marketed entity in American commerce than the Chicago Bears... in this city... it's a football town... and with the Bears, you know, in '85 and like that was, it was just, it engulfed everything. And they've been living off it since.

Subjective business/marketing opinion.

Silver finished the interview with some legendary stories about Dennis Rodman, Madonna, and Jeff Fisher, proving that the old-school era of NFL reporting was a lot more wild than the sanitized version we often see today. It was a perfect blend of football history and the kind of degenerate storytelling that makes PMT what it is.

If Joe Burrow doesn't cut those frosted tips before Sunday, the Bengals season is officially buried.

nfljayden-danielscommandersjaguarscollege-footballbearsmichael-silver

More Takes

Win
Sep 25, 2024
#24304
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams is going to be a great quarterback, and those calling him a bust after three weeks are just nitpicking.

I am undeterred with Caleb Williams. I think Caleb Williams is great. I think he's going to be great. I know people wanna fucking nitpick and say LOL Bears week three, three weeks of the season, he's a bust. That's fine. They could do that. Me, when I go back, when I put my head on my pillow at night, I'm like, Caleb Williams is fucking awesome.

Caleb Williams had an excellent 2025 season under new coach Ben Johnson, throwing for a franchise-record 3,942 yards with a 27-7 TD-INT ratio, leading the Bears to the NFC North title and a playoff win. Big Cat was right that Williams would be great despite early-career nitpicking.
Open
Sep 25, 2024
#4620
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels will win a Super Bowl in the next five years

I did fire off a tweet at like 3:00 AM as I was, I got back from the casino... and I said that I think [Jayden Daniels] is gonna win a Super Bowl in the next five years. Whoa. And I think he is. Maybe even two.

The outcome is pending as the 5-year window spans through 2029.
Win
Sep 25, 2024
#4622
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bills losing Stefon Diggs was addition by subtraction

It probably is addition by subtraction, losing Diggs. Oh, definitely. And Gabe Davis... it feels like this. Josh [Allen] is like star. He's turned a brand new page clean slate for this team. So he doesn't have any of that excess baggage that he used to have.

The Bills' offense remained highly efficient in 2024 without Diggs, often performing better than with him the previous year.
Win
Sep 25, 2024
#24306
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Alabama will defeat Georgia this weekend.

Georgia Bama. I like Bama... You're taking Bama, Georgia. Okay.

Alabama defeated Georgia 41-34 on September 28, 2024.
Void
MaxMax

Fox's Big Noon Kickoff is 'bullshit' because it ruins the atmosphere of Penn State's White Out games.

That's Fox's fault. Big 10. Fucking Big 10 kickoff is big Noon kickoff is bullshit... it's like a really big thing in college football... they burn your whiteouts on, on Lame Games.

The sentiment that morning kickoffs diminish the White Out atmosphere is inherently subjective to fans.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The alleged celebrity lists associated with the Diddy investigation will never be made public.

The list never come out. They never come out. They tell you that there's a list and it's a distraction so that you can come up with your old, your own like fan fiction like lore universe that you make up... The lists never do [come out].

Celebrity names were indeed made public during the Diddy trial in 2025. During jury selection, a list of 190+ celebrities was read aloud, and numerous A-listers were named during trial proceedings. A jury ultimately acquitted Diddy of sex-trafficking charges in July 2025. PFT's prediction that 'the list never comes out' was wrong.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers