Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

2024 NBA Preview With Ryen Russillo, People Keep Complaining About The Dunk Contest + Lebron's 50/50 Retirement Tour

Monday, February 19, 202421 takes

Vacation episode on zoom. We talk dunk contest and how it will never be fixed so stop complaining about it. NBA All Star Weekend. Lebron being 50/50 on wanting a retirement tour. Golf is back (-). Who's back of the week including shorts and whales plus the waterdogs are playing for some fake championship (-). Ryen Russillo joins the show in person to talk about the NBA, his month abroad in Germany, where you would want to live in the world and tons more (-). We finish with lottery ball machine (-).

Ryen Russillo on NBA Contenders, Wembanyama, and His Month in Germany

Big Cat and PFT Commenter are checking in from vacation via Zoom, but they couldn't ignore the annual tradition of everyone being miserable about NBA All-Star Weekend. The Dunk Contest has become a lightning rod for complaints once again, but the reality might just be that the human body has reached its limit for creativity in the air.

Win
Feb 19, 2024
#19999
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dunk Contest is unfixable because we have already seen every possible dunk

There's really no way to fix the Dunk Contest. I think they've jumped over the biggest human they can find... maybe it's just that we've seen every cool Dunk and there's only so many cool dunks that you can do.

The 2024 dunk contest was widely panned as one of the worst ever, supporting the idea that it is stale.

Hank had a massive problem with the reigning champ, Mac McClung, taking home the hardware while technically being a G-Leaguer. For Hank, the 'NBA' part of the title should actually mean something, even if the dunks are technically better than what the stars are providing.

Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20000
HankHank

Mac McClung should be ineligible for the NBA Dunk Contest because he isn't an active NBA player

Mac McClung should be ineligible because he is not in the [NBA]... That is the NBA dunk contest, not the G League dunk contest. If you're going to do that, just bring people off the street.

Subjective opinion on exhibition eligibility rules.

The conversation shifted to LeBron James, who is currently playing a 50/50 game regarding a potential retirement tour. While he claims to be uncomfortable with the praise, Big Cat isn't buying the humble act for a second.

Open
Feb 19, 2024
#20002
Big CatBig Cat

Introvert LeBron James would choose a year-long retirement tour over winning his fifth NBA title

He says he's uncomfortable with praise. So you know, introvert LeBron James, we need to protect him... If you had true serum with LeBron right now... I think he might take the Retirement Tour [over a fifth title]. The fact that he's pretending that he will be reluctant in any way on this is the most ridiculous comment I've ever heard.

The choice is hypothetical and LeBron hasn't retired yet.

Before getting to the guest of honor, the guys touched on the chaos of college basketball and the absolute force that is Caitlin Clark. Beyond the logo threes, Big Cat is fully leaning into the drama she causes among the old-school talking heads.

Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20003
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially a Caitlin Clark superfan because she agitates people and creates constant debate

I think I'm gonna become a Caitlin Clark super fan because she makes people so, so angry. And I love it... I'm all for anyone who just agitates the world like she does... I'm in on Caitlin Clark all the way.

Big Cat consistently supported and discussed Clark through the end of the season and into the WNBA draft.

Ryen Russillo Joins the Program

Ryen Russillo joined the show in person to perform his annual duty of actually watching the NBA so we don't have to. The conversation immediately turned to the Clippers and James Harden. While the Clippers look like a legitimate problem for the rest of the West, Russillo isn't ready to tear up his old scouting reports just because Harden found a functional third-option role.

Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20009
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

James Harden winning a title as a third option doesn't invalidate a decade of criticism against him

Does it mean I was wrong about Harden for 10 years if he wins it this year? No... he's the third option now. So I'm still in the clear for a decade worth of takes... If somebody can play bad on purpose to get their way, like what are you gonna be like in a really tight spot in the playoffs?

The Clippers did not win the 2024 title, so the hypothetical was never tested.

Russillo broke down the tiers of the league, and while everyone is excited about the youth movements in Oklahoma City and Minnesota, history suggests those teams are still a few years away from holding a trophy.

Win
Feb 19, 2024
#23526
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The Phoenix Suns, Minnesota Timberwolves, and OKC Thunder are not true title contenders due to their lack of a proven shot-clock scorer or youth

I don't think they're gonna be sitting there with a trophy at the end of this whole thing... I'm not gonna trust [Minnesota's] offense late in the playoff series... History tells you the youth part of [OKC] would be an absurd aberration historically for them to win an NBA title.

None of these teams reached the Finals in 2024 (Suns out in 1st, Wolves/Thunder out later).

When it comes to the heavy hitters, Russillo is looking at the stars who can actually create a bucket when the play breaks down. He pointed to two specific guys who operate on a different level of basketball IQ than everyone else in the league.

Void
Feb 19, 2024
#23528
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Nikola Jokic and Luka Doncic are the only two players in the NBA who can guarantee a good shot on every possession

Jokic gives you the best chance on every possession of anybody in the league. He is a genius... I think Luka's number two where it's like if I needed a bucket I might pick him over Jokic because he can put it and drive a little bit better.

Subjective ranking of player value and skill.

As for the biggest story in the league, Victor Wembanyama has managed to exceed the most insane hype cycle in recent memory. Russillo noted that it isn't just the physical tools, but the mental makeup of a kid who seems destined to carry a franchise.

Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20013
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

Victor Wembanyama is already a massive success and will meet every expectation

He's incredible. Everything about him this year individually for him is a massive success... His personality just seems so genuine in that he's been mentally built to take on the responsibility that he's gonna have to take on for a franchise at a young age.

Wembanyama won Rookie of the Year unanimously and had one of the best rookie seasons in NBA history.

Life Advice and Beyond

Outside of the court, Russillo shared an incredible story about his time in Germany as a high schooler in a select choir. It involved a host family of volleyball giants, a nine-year-old javelin prodigy, and a cool older brother named Mark who saved the trip on a motorcycle.

To wrap things up, the group debated the merits of expanded playoffs and the 'participation trophy' feel of the current NBA and NFL postseasons.

Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20015
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

I hate expanded playoffs in any sport and prefer leaving teams out

I don't like that there's this many NFL teams in the playoffs. I think it's stupid. I'm big on—I know it's gonna shock you—I like leaving people out of things. I hate expanded anything.

This is an ideological preference on league structure.

We’ll see everyone back in the studio on Wednesday, hopefully with fewer Zoom lags and more lottery ball hits.

Enjoy the Ferraris and the boat life, Ryen.

nbalebron-jamescaitlin-clarkgolfclippersceltics

More Takes

Loss
Feb 19, 2024
#20001
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A G-League player who wins the NBA Dunk Contest should receive a two-week NBA contract

If you win the Dunk contest and you're on a G League team, you should get like a two week contract.

Mac McClung won in 2024 and did not receive an immediate NBA call-up following the event.
Push
Feb 19, 2024
#23524
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Caitlin Clark and Steph Curry should compete in a logo-three contest at a future All-Star Weekend

I think in a couple years we'll see Caitlin Clark against Steph Curry and they're gonna do like logo threes, like extra long three pointers. And that would be cool.

The NBA eventually announced a variation of this for the following year involving multiple participants including Clark.
Win
Feb 19, 2024
#23525
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will call Caleb Williams a dress-wearer if he is drafted by any team other than the Bears

But if any other team besides the Bears gets [Caleb Williams], he wore a dress. [If he goes to the Bears] it was like a new age suit that men wear.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The Bears did draft Caleb Williams, and PFT (a Bears fan) defended his fashion choices throughout the process.
Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20004
HankHank

Randy Moss is not a top 10 Patriot of all time

Randy Moss also, it's crazy to say, but like, I don't know that he's a top 10 patriot of all time. [Because he] didn't win a ring.

While subjective, most analysts consider Moss's 2007 season and overall impact top-tier, making this a very controversial take.
Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20005
Big CatBig Cat

Tiger Woods is officially over the hill

I think Tiger might be a little bit over the hill. I think it might have happened. I want him to be in these events 'cause it's fun when he is there. But it also is a bummer when he has to withdraw.

Tiger has struggled to finish tournaments or remain competitive at a high level throughout 2024.
Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20006
Big CatBig Cat

The rule that disqualified Jordan Spieth for an incorrect scorecard is the dumbest rule ever

That Jordan Spieth rule was the, it's the dumbest rule ever because it's not even his, it's his partner filling out the scorecard and he signs it. That's stupid.

The rule is widely criticized by fans and media but remains an active USGA/R&A rule.
Void
Feb 19, 2024·Who's Back
#20007
HankHank

Mark Zuckerberg is an animal and would defeat everyone on the PMT crew in a fight

Zuck is a beast... Zuck would take us down. I hate to say it but kind of an animal. He gets smoked and he... yeah.

Without a sanctioned fight, this remains speculative.
Void
Feb 19, 2024
#20010
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

LeBron James no longer does the little things like boxing out or transition defense

LeBron is the best player I've ever seen... But he doesn't do the little things that I think are really important in basketball anymore. He doesn't do those things anymore... you lose your guy boxing out all the time. You don't get back in transition. You lose guys on these baseline cuts.

Statistical analysis often supports that LeBron conserves energy on the defensive end during the regular season.
Void
Feb 19, 2024
#23527
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The NBA offensive explosion is caused by rules and officiating that make it impossible to play defense

I don't know what the defense is supposed to do anymore... The foul number isn't the really thing to look at. I think it's defenses are scared to death to even be in compromised positions because guys just fucking run into everybody now. You just adding it all up... the offensive player has never had this many advantages.

Inherently subjective analysis of league trends and rule applications.
Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20011
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The Boston Celtics are the NBA championship favorites if Kristaps Porzingis remains healthy

Boston... if Pingus is healthy, they have probably, they're probably still the favorite... Their one through rate is ridiculous.

The Celtics won the 2024 NBA Championship. Porzingis played in the Finals despite injury issues earlier in the playoffs.
Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20012
Ryen RussilloRyen Russillo

The heliocentric style of offense led by Luka Doncic is difficult to win with in the playoffs

The history of the heliocentric offenses are really bad in the playoffs. You basically had one NBA finals guy for a top 20 usage rate in the NBA history... It sucks watching somebody else have the ball all the time... whenever they shut off your drive in the playoffs, now I have to shoot.

Luka Doncic reached the NBA Finals in 2024 but lost to the more balanced Celtics, largely validating the 'team ball beats heliocentric ball' argument.
Win
Feb 19, 2024
#20014
Big CatBig Cat

Jared Goff is a winner and his success with the Lions proves I was right about him

I was right about Jared Goff... he take the Lions the NFC Championship game. He's a quiet leader... I'm very happy for you and your good friend Jared Goff.

Goff's continued high-level play and contract extension in 2024 further support Big Cat's position.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers