Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Andrew Luck In Studio, Brian Windhorst On The Shocking Luka Trade + Monday Reading Live From Super Bowl Week In Nola

Monday, February 3, 202515 takes

Welcome to Super Bowl Week aka Max Week. We talk about the shocking Luka trade to the Lakers and what the hell happened (-). National Sports podcast news from the weekend (-). Who’s back of the week including Rory, Rugby and Kanye West at the Grammy’s (-). Andrew Luck joins us in studio to talk about his career, Jim Harbaugh, being the GM of Stanford Football, his snap count, retirement and tons more (-). Brian Windhorst joins us to break down the Luka trade and just how insane it is (-). We then finish with a time capsule Monday Reading from last years Super Bowl (-).

Andrew Luck and Brian Windhorst on the Shocking Luka Trade

It is officially Max Week in New Orleans, but the sports world decided to set itself on fire right as Big Cat, PFT, and the crew landed for the Super Bowl. The NBA landscape shifted permanently on a Saturday night when the Dallas Mavericks decided to trade one of the five best players on the planet to the Los Angeles Lakers for Anthony Davis and change. Big Cat wasn't holding back on the historical weight of the move.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3824
Big CatBig Cat

The Luka Doncic trade is the most shocking in NBA history

It's not hyperbole to say this is probably the most shocking trade in NBA history. Just because [Doncic] is 25 years old. He's one of the top five players in the NBA. He just took his team to the finals and he gets traded to the Lakers with no bidding whatsoever.

PFT immediately started looking for the angle, suspecting that the reported "mystery teams" involved in the bidding were nothing more than a PR smokescreen to protect the Mavericks' front office from the immediate backlash of a lopsided deal.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3832
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Mystery Team in the Luka trade was likely invented just to make the Mavs GM feel better

There was a mystery team. I think it was added just to make [Nico Harrison] the Mavs GM feel a little better. But it seems like they did this deal... maybe you're in debt to the ownership of the Lakers. Maybe you need a favor from the Lakers at a later date.

To get the real story, the guys hit the Brian Windhorst bat phone. Windy, sounding like a man who hasn't slept since the notification popped, confirmed that the entire league is in a state of shock. He compared the trade to a "pocket sale" of a beachfront mansion where the Lakers didn't even have to pay market value. While the Lakers now have a succession plan for LeBron, the risk for Dallas is astronomical.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3826
Brian WindhorstBrian Windhorst

The Mavericks potentially made a catastrophic mistake trading Luka Doncic

I don't understand this, and I think this is potentially a catastrophic mistake. Nico Harrison has got some capital with the Mavs fans, but my God, if Luka turns into this... and the Lakers have another era and Luka has a statue outside Crypto.com and Luka puts up more banners, Nico Harrison will live in infamy.

The Return of the Captain

After seven years of waiting and almost joining a book club just to get him on the show, Andrew Luck finally sat down in HQ. He is exactly who we wanted him to be: a guy who nerds out over architecture, cement, and the perfect snap count. He opened up about the "God's gift" mentality required to play the position at a high level and why he knew he had to walk away when he did.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3827
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

A successful NFL quarterback must believe they are 'God's gift' to the game

When you go on the field as a quarterback, you cannot leave any room for doubt. I think one way of doing that is... you have to go out there thinking that you are God's gift to this thing. It's an intense level of confidence. I knew that I was aware also of how good I was at football... I was probably the best player.

Luck remains a massive fan of the game, even if he's now spending his time as the GM of Stanford. He broke down the technical side of the position, specifically why a quarterback's involvement in the ground game is the true barometer of a team's potential.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#23711
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

If an NFL quarterback cannot effectively operate and manage the run game, their team has a limited ceiling

I felt very fortunate I was taught how to play quarterback while I was there... if you can't operate a run game in the NFL, there's only so far your team's gonna go. I truly believe that.

This is a fundamental football philosophy from a top-tier player, though subjective in nature.

Despite the constant rumors from fans who can't let go, Luck made it clear that his retirement is final. The mental and physical toll of being 100% committed is something he's no longer willing to pay, and he wouldn't even consider a "break glass in case of emergency" Super Bowl call-up.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3834
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

I would decline an offer to play in the Super Bowl as a last-minute emergency replacement

[If asked to play in the Super Bowl without practicing for a whole season] No, thank you. Appreciate it. And I'll tell you why: that's cheap. You gotta go all season. You gotta practice. You gotta earn that. I'd be hyped for the Colts though, if they're there.

Who's Back and Breaking Moves

Before the big interviews, the guys hit on a wild weekend of news, including Coach Cal's return to Kentucky. Big Cat is firmly in the camp that the Big Blue Nation needs to let him have it when he steps back into Rupp Arena.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kentucky fans should absolutely boo Coach Calipari when he returns with Arkansas

Coach Cal going back to Kentucky... Drop his nuts on Kentucky. That sucked for Kentucky fans. You boo him. You can celebrate him when time has passed and he's not coaching in the SEC anymore. You boo him when he comes back right now.

This is a subjective opinion on fan behavior.

In the middle of the show, news broke that the San Antonio Spurs landed De'Aaron Fox, giving Victor Wembanyama the elite point guard he's been missing. Big Cat sees this as the move that finally makes the Spurs a problem in the West.

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Spurs trading for De'Aaron Fox is a massive win that allows Victor Wembanyama to play serious playoff basketball

Sacramento is finalizing a trade to send De'Aaron Fox to the San Antonio Spurs... That's great for the Spurs. I wanna see [Wembanyama] in some actual serious playoff time this year.

The Spurs did not make the 2024-25 NBA Playoffs after trading for De'Aaron Fox. They finished 34-48 (13th in the West). Wembanyama did not get 'serious playoff time' in the 2024-25 season. However, the Fox-Wemby pairing is paying dividends in the 2025-26 season.

For Who's Back, Hank is all-in on Rory McIlroy after his win at Pebble Beach. According to Hank, the drought is ending and the green jacket is essentially already tailored.

Win
Feb 3, 2025·Who's Back
#3830
HankHank

Rory McIlroy is officially back and this will be the year he finally turns it around to win the Masters

My Who's Back of the week is Rory McIlroy. He's smashing. He won the AT&T Pro-Am at Pebble Beach. This might be his year... he might turn it around. [Golf doesn't start until the Masters] This might be his year to win it.

Rory McIlroy did win the 2025 Masters, defeating Justin Rose in a sudden-death playoff. He completed the career Grand Slam and won his first green jacket, confirming this was indeed 'his year.'

Soccer Talk and Monday Reading

Luck and PFT bonded over their shared optimism for the US Men's National Team. With the 2026 World Cup on the horizon and a roster full of European-based talent, the belief is at an all-time high.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#23713
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The current USMNT roster is the most talented the United States has ever had heading into a World Cup

The roster that we have right now... going into this World Cup, that is the best roster that the US will have ever had at that point. Just looking at the players that play competitively overseas, that's as talented as we've ever been.

Subjective assessment of roster talent compared across eras.

Luck didn't just agree; he went full homer, predicting a trophy lift on home soil.

Open
Feb 3, 2025
#23712
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

The US Men's National Team will win the 2026 World Cup

[Are we going to win the World Cup?] You bet we are. Why not? I'm eternally optimistic as a US soccer fan... the World Cup's gonna be here and in Mexico and Canada. It's fun to root for America.

The 2026 World Cup has not happened yet.

We wrapped up with a special Time Capsule Monday Reading, revisiting the legendary story of Diana Russini's plane ride next to a "disgusting" Max. While Max defended his honor and his hygiene, he also tried to justify his upcoming vacation diet with some questionable logic.

Void
MaxMax

Skiing is a fitness vacation

[You're going on a diet a week before vacation?] Skiing is basically a fitness vacation. Yes.

While skiing is physically demanding, it is rarely categorized as a 'fitness vacation' by the PMT crew context.

If the rest of Max Week is half as chaotic as this Monday, we might not make it to Sunday.

nbaluka-doncicnflcoltssuper-bowllakers

More Takes

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3828
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

The decision to play quarterback at an NFL level is binary: 100% in or out

To go back to playing quarterback, you're either like all in or you're not. It's a, to me, in my mind, the schema of how you emotionally, physically, psychologically, spiritually invested in quarterback is binary. You either aren't or you are 100% in. And I had a point in my life where I was like, I am unwilling to hop to the 100% in so I can't do it.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3829
Andrew LuckAndrew Luck

Frank Gore is the 'teach tape' for how to be a pass-protecting running back

I got to play with Frank Gore, who's awesome by the way. No one knew pass protection better than Frank Gore. The dude got football... he is the teach tape on how to be a pass-protecting running back. And he is also the teach tape on how to be a gap scheme running back. The dude was unbelievable.

Void
Feb 3, 2025
#3825
Brian WindhorstBrian Windhorst

The Luka Doncic trade is one of the most shocking transactions in American sports history

It's one of the most shocking transactions in American sports history for the magnitude and the way it came out of the blue. I've never had my phone go crazy like this. I'm talking about players, head coaches, assistant coaches, executives, referees, agents, lawyers, workout guys, and they all had the exact same question: 'We don't understand what's going on.'


PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers