Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Doug Pederson In Studio, Week 5 Picks And Preview, Playoff Baseball, Big Cat Won The 50/50 And An All Time Fyre Fest

Friday, October 3, 202519 takes

Sports are so back. We talk Thursday Night Football and a great win for the Niners and Mac Jones (-). Playoff Baseball and the Yankees, Tigers, Dodgers and Cubs advance (-). Big Cat fulfilled a lifetime goal of winning the 50/50 raffle and recaps an all time week at Wrigley (-). Week 5 Picks and Preview including a very mean Brian Flores quote, blind resumes with a twist and PFT gets Hank with an okie doke (-). Jerry OConnell's fantasy minute and our best bets (-). SB Champion Doug Pederson joins the show to talk football, winning the Super Bowl, Quarterback play, being a backup, Philly Special, Ice Cream and tons more (-). We finish with Fyre Fest of the week and all time Zac story plus a very special lottery ball (-).

Doug Pederson on the Philly Special, Week 5 Picks, and Big Cat Wins the 50/50

Sports are officially so back. Big Cat is radiating the glow of a man who has finally conquered his white whale, and no, it wasn’t a bet on a 7-point underdog. After 13 years of religious participation, Big Cat hit the 50/50 raffle at Wrigley Field during the Cubs' playoff win. The pot was over $100k, meaning he walked away with $54k, and in the most ethical move possible, he’s donating the winnings to the Lost Boys charity in Chicago. Memes, however, is taking it less well, considering he was recently fired from his Madden Jets rebuild and still hasn't hit a lottery ball.

Playoff Baseball and Yankee Pinstripes

Playoff baseball is in full swing, and the guys are already making sweeping declarations about legacy. After Cam Schlittler’s dominant performance for the Yankees, the conversation turned to whether the regular season stars have actually earned their stripes yet. Big Cat and PFT aren't giving out pinstripes for free, especially not to the guys who haven't delivered a ring to the Bronx.

Win
Oct 3, 2025
#6687
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Judge will never be a true Yankee unless he wins a World Series

Aaron Judge has to win. He has to. Aaron Judge will not, he will not ever be a true Yankee... [he] has to win a World Series or else. Not a true Yankee. Probably not even. I'll take him out of the Hall of Fame. I won't vote for him.

The Yankees eventually won the World Series in 2026, officially ending this debate for Big Cat.

While the Yankees are moving on, the Guardians' incredible season came to a screeching halt. After climbing back from a double-digit deficit in the division, losing the series to the Tigers felt like a reset button on the entire narrative of their year.

Void
Oct 3, 2025
#6688
Big CatBig Cat

The Tigers' series win erased the memory of the Guardians' historic 15.5-game comeback

Did the Tigers just erase that entire 15 and a half game comeback? I unfortunately think yes... when you lose then to the Tigers in three games, that's brutal. You caught them to then get the right to lose to them at home. You kept them alive to allow them to embarrass you.

Inherently subjective take on how fans remember a season.

PFT also has a logistical fix for the MLB postseason to ensure the best possible vibes for the remainder of October. It involves leaning into the specific architecture and atmospheres of Wrigley and the Bank.

Void
Oct 3, 2025
#6689
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cubs should always play afternoon playoff games and the Phillies should always play night games

I have a take about the Cubs games. I think the playoffs, whenever possible the Cubs should play afternoon games. And the Phillies should play night games... Because Wrigley Field looks awesome. Especially like in the sunset... the stadium is perfect for Twilight. And then Philly, the SEC environment... it works at the bank.

Subjective aesthetic preference.

Week 5 Picks and Preview

Moving to the NFL, the Week 5 slate is getting messy. Between London games and backup quarterbacks, the guys are finding value in the sludge. PFT opened the segment with a legendary "Okie Doke" on Hank regarding Drake Maye’s upcoming start against the Bills. While he sounded like he was praising the Patriots' rookie, he was actually setting a trap based on the level of competition.

Loss
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6685
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drake Maye will beat a winning team for the first time this week (Okie Doke)

I think this is the week that that Drake Maye finally beats a team that's above .500. I think he's done a great job getting to this place... he's put in the prep. This is the week where Drake Maye beats a winning team.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
The Patriots lost to the Bills 24-21, and the joke was that the Bills were the first team with a winning record they faced.

Hank, of course, is ready for a high-scoring affair in Buffalo. He’s leaning into the optimism that usually precedes a double-digit loss, hoping for a shootout rather than a defensive slog.

Push
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6702
HankHank

The Patriots vs. Bills game will be a shootout

I'm excited. I'm really excited. I think this game is gonna be a shootout. I think it's gonna, you know, Patriots are gonna have to get a little bit lucky, but it's gonna be a good test... One score. Yeah... I love the Patriots team total over, I love the regular over.

The final score was 27-24, which is a one-score game, but not necessarily a 'shootout' by modern NFL standards (Over/Under was 49.5, total was 51).

Down in the NFC, the Eagles are 4-0 but Max is already hearing the footsteps. PFT didn't miss the chance to stir the pot, questioning if a winning record necessarily equals a good football team when the eye test is failing.

Void
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6693
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2024 Eagles are the worst 20-1 team in NFL history

Is this Eagle's team the worst 20 and one team in their last 21 games of all time... every, literally every negative thing that I've said about the Eagles this year has come from a place of extreme jealousy and also trying to stir Max up... I think the Eagles, yeah, they're the worst.

Purely subjective hot take designed to frustrate an Eagles fan.

Doug Pederson in Studio

Super Bowl-winning head coach Doug Pederson stopped by to talk about his time away from the game and his legendary run in Philly. He went deep into the mechanics of the "Philly Special," revealing that Nick Foles was actually the one who suggested it during a timeout, and the rest of the coaching staff couldn't even hear the conversation. Doug also gave some great insight into the psychology of benching a franchise guy like Carson Wentz.

Void
Oct 3, 2025
#6706
Doug PedersonDoug Pederson

Changing the quarterback is the only way to send a real message to an underperforming team

You change your quarterback. Now you're sending a message to everybody. Like, whoa, we need to, we need to pick this thing up. And it wasn't anything against Carson Wentz, it was just the fact that we as a whole team, we weren't coaching and playing very well. I needed to do something to spark the team.

Subjective coaching philosophy.

He also touched on the life of a backup, a role he knows well from his days behind Brett Favre. He explained that while the world sees it as an easy paycheck, the mental strain of staying ready without the reps is immense.

Void
Oct 3, 2025
#6709
Doug PedersonDoug Pederson

Being a backup quarterback is the hardest role to prepare for in football

It's probably the hardest position on the football team that still has to prepare like a starter, but is not playing... you're sitting there watching... and I never did this in Green Bay... but if that starter goes out with injury, I've gotta put the helmet on and go play. I don't want you to play like the starter. I want you to play like you.

Subjective professional opinion from an expert.

To wrap up, the guys hit Fyre Fest of the week where Zac shared a truly incredible story about a restock fee on a pair of Levi’s that led to a four-course dinner consisting primarily of ice cream and Raising Cane's.

Jack finally hit the lottery ball for the first time in show history, leaving Memes as the only person in the building who hasn't seen the thing happen.

nflmlb-playoffsphiladelphia-eagleschicago-cubssports-betting

More Takes

Void
Oct 3, 2025
#6686
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers would have a Super Bowl by now if they had drafted Mac Jones instead of Trey Lance

If the 49ers draft Mac Jones like was rumored instead of Trey Lance, so many things are different. The 49ers probably win a Super Bowl. Mac Jones is one of the highest paid QBs in football. And we never find out just how good Brock Purdy is.

This is an unprovable hypothetical, though Mac Jones did find success later in his career with the 49ers in this specific timeline.
Void
Oct 3, 2025
#23882
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mac Jones should stay sidelined with his injury to maximize his free-agent value as a backup

[Mac Jones] should really lean in to the leg injury. Yes. And be like, 'I'm too sore. Please sit me out.' I'm due to make millions of dollars on the open market. At the very least as a, as a great backup.

Subjective career strategy advice.
Void
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6691
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shedeur Sanders is 'behind the eight ball' if Rex Ryan is getting in his head

If Rex Ryan is in your head, Rex Ryan talks on TV... He has nothing to do with the NFL right now... If Rex Ryan is taking up any space at all in your head to the point where you're gonna react to that in a press conference, I feel like you're already a little bit behind the eight ball.

Subjective evaluation of a player's mindset.
Void
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#23883
Big CatBig Cat

Brian Flores was being 'very mean' by comparing Dylan Gabriel's thought process to Tua Tagovailoa's

That is so mean of Brian Flores to say, 'I see Tua'—the guy I fucking almost ended his career by just hating him and bullying him as I was his head coach—in Dylan Gabriel. Brian Flores hated Tua to the point where Tua said that he had to go to therapy for two years to fix his confidence.

Subjective interpretation of coach's intent.
Win
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6692
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Browns will cover the +4.5 spread against the Vikings in London

I like the Browns to keep it within a field goal... the Browns defense obviously is elite top three defense in the NFL. The Vikings are going to blitz the fuck out of Dylan Gabriel. They're gonna confuse him. It's gonna be a lowest scoring game.

The Vikings beat the Browns 13-10, meaning the Browns covered the +4.5 spread.
Win
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#23884
Big CatBig Cat

The Saints will beat the Giants because Malik Nabers is out

I actually like the Saints in this game... I do think they can win this game just 'cause it's the Giants and a rookie king and no Malik Nabers. Which obviously sucks.

The Saints beat the Giants 24-6 on October 5th.
Void
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6696
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jalen Hurts is the new Joe Flacco

I think he's, he's become the new Joe Flacco where he won a Super Bowl, but everyone's trying to fight. Is Jalen Hurts Elite sound off in the comments?

Subjective comparison of two quarterbacks' public perceptions.
Win
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#23885
Big CatBig Cat

The Ravens vs. Texans game is a 'loser leaves town' match for the playoff race

This is a true loser leaves town. 'Cause one and four is zero [chance].

Big Cat called the Ravens vs. Texans Week 5 game a 'loser leaves town' match, saying 1-4 would mean zero chance at the playoffs. The Ravens lost and fell to 1-4. They finished 8-9 and missed the playoffs. The Texans won, went to 2-3, and made the playoffs at 12-5. The loser (Ravens) was indeed effectively eliminated.
Void
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#23886
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cardinals have the worst body language in the NFL

They're the worst body language team in the NFL by far. And they're, I think, leading the way. Kyler Murray, bad body language. Marvin Harrison, Jr. bad body language. Especially on Thursday night... they go to the sidelines and they don't talk to each other.

Inherently subjective observation of team chemistry.
Win
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6698
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Marvin Harrison Jr. will break his first career tackle this week against the Titans

I am on, on tackle breaking watch this week. I think this is the week that Marvin Harrison Jr. breaks his first tackle... Kyler Murray, bad body language. Marvin Harrison, Jr. bad body language... after Sunday... people are gonna start to have that conversation.

Marvin Harrison Jr. was credited with two broken tackles in the game against Tennessee.
Loss
Oct 3, 2025·Picks
#6700
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will win 'decisively' against the Chargers

This is a must win decisively game. I think that, I think we can win this game decisively. Commanders minus six and a half. Yeah. You should take that. I'm in, I'm in on it. I trust in Dan Quinn. Dan's gonna get it figured out.

The Chargers beat the Commanders 31-14.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers