Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Former NHL Mutt Ryan Whitney And NFL Draft Scout Matt Miller

Friday, January 12, 201821 takes

Divisional Round is here and we go through all our picks and story lines for the best weekend in Football ( - ). Big Cat reveals a podcasting/diet secret ( - ). Former NHL Player Ryan Whitney joins the show to catch up on hockey, explain what the hell is going on with the Olympics, and bashes Basketball ( - ). NFL Draft Scout Matt Miller joins the show to talk about the new coaching hires, the biggest weaknesses in this weekend's games, and ranks the Quarterbacks in the 2018 Draft ( - ). Segments include Connect the Dots, Just Chill out Man for the former 49ers exec who wants to lube up Jimmy G, Dad to Dad for Lavar vs Lebron, the return of Spoilers, Thats enough internet for the day, and Jimbos.

Ryan Whitney on NHL's Marketing Failures and NFL Draft Scout Matt Miller

It is officially Fri-yay, and Big Cat is coming out of the gates hot with a massive claim about the upcoming weekend of football. While Wild Card weekend has its charms, the Divisional Round provides that perfect four-game slate before the field gets too thin.

Void
Jan 12, 2018
#2385
Big CatBig Cat

The divisional round is the best weekend of football

I would like to contend that the divisional round is the best weekend of football. Saturday and Sunday. It is a full weekend of football, and you're going to miss this. Actually, just one week when there are just two games left.

This is a subjective opinion on which weekend is the best to watch.

The weekend kicks off with a bird fight in Philly. The Eagles are the rare one-seed that nobody seems to respect, while the Falcons are suddenly everyone's favorite pick. Big Cat is leaning into the narrative, officially jumping back on the bandwagon of the team that broke everyone's hearts last February.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2386
Big CatBig Cat

The Falcons will win the NFC

I've been on the Falcon bandwagon. I am on their bandwagon of thinking that they could win the NFC. I said it a couple months ago. I am going down with the ship, so I'm taking the Falcons. I'm taking them all the way to the Super Bowl.

The Falcons lost to the Eagles in the Divisional Round (this very weekend), making this prediction incorrect.

Hank, ever the contrarian, is staying away from the Falcons hype and backing the home dog.

Win
Jan 12, 2018
#2387
HankHank

The Eagles will cover +2.5 against the Falcons

I like the Falcons too. But I'm going to take the Eagles. Hank's on the Eagles plus two and a half.

The Eagles won the game 15-10, easily covering the +2.5 spread.

The Patriot Way and Woke Theories

When it comes to the Titans heading to Foxboro, the conversation naturally shifts to the Dynasty. Despite the recent Seth Wickersham article suggesting internal turmoil, the guys aren't buying the demise of the Patriots. PFT has a particularly woke theory about where that "explosive" reporting actually came from.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2389
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick leaked the Seth Wickersham article himself to motivate the team

I'm very, very woke on this whole article thing because there's a reason it came out last week when they didn't have a game. I think Belichick might have been the source for some of the things just to try to get a little controversy going out there in the media, get people starting to doubt the Patriots because Belichick, he loves to play the 'we don't have any respect' card.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
There is no evidence Belichick was the source for the report; most sources pointed to internal friction within the Kraft/Belichick/Brady triad.

Hank is so confident in a New England blowout that he's suggesting listeners liquidate their assets to back Tom Brady.

Push
Jan 12, 2018
#2390
HankHank

The Patriots will beat the Titans by 30 points

Bet every single dollar you have on the Patriots. They're going to win by 30.

The Patriots won 35-14 (a 21-point margin). While a dominant win, it didn't reach the 30-point threshold.

Big Cat and PFT also get into a serious discussion about the Vikings and Saints. While the world is falling in love with New Orleans, Big Cat wants to remind everyone that Minnesota isn't just a feel-good story; they are a defensive juggernaut.

Win
Jan 12, 2018
#2391
Big CatBig Cat

The Vikings will beat the Saints in the Divisional Round

This to me is the game where everyone just forgets that the Vikings are really fucking good. I think the Vikings are really fucking good and people forget that. I'm taking the Vikings.

The Vikings won 29-24 in the 'Minneapolis Miracle'.

Ryan Whitney Explains the Olympic Mess

Friend of the program Ryan Whitney joins the show to talk puck, and he's not holding back on the state of international hockey. With the NHL staying home, the Olympic tournament feels like a shell of its former self. Whitney explains that between the owners' fears of injury and the NHL's marketing failures, the fans are the ones losing out.

Void
Jan 12, 2018
#2393
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Olympic hockey committee ruining the games by banning NHL players is a joke

It's a joke. You can't. The NHL asked if they could at least show the videos from the Olympics, which you can't do. They wanted the NHL logos on the board. They wouldn't do that. So at some point it's both sides, but it does suck for the game.

Subjective opinion on the quality of the tournament.

Without the best players in the world, Whitney expects a very specific country to walk away with the gold, simply because they have the best "amateurs" left on the board.

Win
Jan 12, 2018
#2395
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Russia is the heavy favorite to win Olympic Gold with no NHL players involved

Unfortunately, it's Russia. They're going to win and then they're going to take the flag out and they won't play an anthem. But it's going to be pretty crazy to see because they're loaded. They got all these guys over there that never, I mean, some of them couldn't play in the NHL because there's a chance of them could. They're playing in the KHL.

The Olympic Athletes from Russia won the gold medal in 2018.

When he's not trashing the Olympic committee, Whitney is keeping a close eye on the NHL season. He’s already planted his flag for who is lifting the Cup at the end of the year, and it’s bad news for the rest of the league.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2396
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Tampa Bay Lightning are the best team in the NHL and my Stanley Cup pick

Yeah, they were my Cup pick. I think I picked them when I came on your show, fellas. They're nasty. They have four legit superstars. Hedman, Stamkos, Kucherov, and their goalie, Vasilevskiy. They're the best team in the NHL, for sure.

The Lightning lost in the Eastern Conference Finals to the Capitals in 2018.

Matt Miller Scans the 2018 QB Class

Bleacher Report's Matt Miller stops by to talk about the new coaching hires and the upcoming draft. As a Bears fan, Big Cat is desperate for some hope regarding Matt Nagy. Miller delivers, painting a picture of a creative, leader-of-men type coach who is going to unlock Mitch Trubisky.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2400
Matt MillerMatt Miller

Bears fans should be excited about Matt Nagy and Mitch Trubisky

You should be so fucking excited just for what Mitch Trubisky's going to be able to do now. It is, like, it's really going to be, I think, a mixture of an old-school West Coast offense and a spread system. He's creative, he's smart. I think being a head coach, you have to be a really good leader. I think he's got that.

Trubisky never developed into a top-tier QB under Nagy, and Nagy was fired in 2021 after offensive regression and losing seasons.

The guys also force Miller to rank the 2018 Quarterback class. While names like Sam Darnold and Josh Allen have the hype, Miller is staying steady with the most polished thrower in the group.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2404
Matt MillerMatt Miller

Josh Rosen is the best quarterback in the 2018 Draft

I would take Josh Rosen first. There are holes in his game, of course, and his personality is going to rub some people wrong, but I think he's the most naturally gifted of the bunch.

Rosen was a massive bust, while Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson (from the same class) became superstars.

As for Josh Allen, Miller sees him as the ultimate boom-or-bust prospect. He has the size and the arm of a superstar, but the accuracy issues are a massive red flag that can't easily be coached away.

Win
Jan 12, 2018
#29050
Matt MillerMatt Miller

Josh Allen will either be great or awful in the NFL with no middle ground

He's either going to be great or he's going to be awful. I don't think there's any middle ground with him [Josh Allen].

Josh Allen became an elite, All-Pro level quarterback for the Bills, proving the 'great' side of the coin.

Segments and Final Takes

In a special Dad to Dad segment, the guys address the rumors that LeVar Ball might be the reason LeBron James stays away from the Lakers. PFT thinks LeVar is actually playing 4D chess to keep "Small Ballers" out of Los Angeles.

Loss
Jan 12, 2018·Dad To Dad
#2411
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

LeVar Ball is an deterrent for LeBron James going to the Lakers

This is a huge problem. Dad to dad, this is actually a great piece of news for LeVar Ball because I don't think LeVar Ball has time for a small baller like LeBron in L.A. LeVar wants to make sure that L.A. is a ball town. LeVar Ball actually might do the real outbreak thing and just hover in a helicopter above LAX and not let LeBron land in town.

Hot TakeBasketballHotSarcastic
LeBron James signed with the Lakers that summer (2018) despite LeVar Ball being there.

The episode wraps with some classic Jimbos, including a listener who accidentally watched The Sopranos on a loop in front of his mother-in-law. Big Cat and PFT also reveal that they have been wearing electronic ab-stimulators throughout the entire recording, officially making this the first-ever workout podcast.

If you see Big Cat with an eight-pack by Monday, you’ll know the pulsating stickers actually worked.

nfl-playoffsnhlnfl-draftbearslakersgambling

More Takes

Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2388
Big CatBig Cat

The Patriots will win the Super Bowl

Bill Belichick and Tom Brady are just going to fucking, you know, shit kick everyone in the playoffs this year. I think, honestly, I have to take the Pats. I'm going Pats.

The Patriots reached the Super Bowl but lost to the Eagles, making this incorrect.
Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2392
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Case Keenum is a Kurt Warner in the making thanks to Jeff Fisher's tutelage

I think Case Keenum has proven that he's actually just really good. He's just a good quarterback. He's a Kurt Warner in making. Thanks to Jeff Fisher and his tutelage, he has evolved into an elite quarterback.

Case Keenum had a magical 2017 season but regressed significantly after leaving the Vikings, never becoming a Hall of Famer like Kurt Warner. Also, Jeff Fisher's coaching is widely cited as the reason Keenum struggled in LA.
Void
Jan 12, 2018
#2398
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The NHL does a terrible job of marketing the league

I feel like the NHL just doesn't do a good job of marketing the league. It's so goofy. I don't understand it. You do stuff that really kind of confuses the casual fan. They haven't talked about [the All-Star Game] at all.

Subjective opinion on marketing effectiveness.
Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#29052
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Pittsburgh Penguins might miss the 2018 playoffs

That's how it looks right now [that the Penguins won't make the playoffs]. I refuse to believe it because even though they're in last or second to last in the division, they're only like five or six points out... But they look like they're in a bad place right now.

The Penguins turned their season around and made the playoffs as the 2nd seed in the Metropolitan Division.
Win
Jan 12, 2018
#2402
Matt MillerMatt Miller

Jalen Ramsey is the best cornerback in the NFL

I think right now Jalen Ramsey's the best corner in the NFL. I mean, Calais Campbell could probably be defensive player of the year. That defense is legit, right? Just watching them, they seem like one of the best defenses I've seen in the last five, six years.

Ramsey was indeed named First-team All-Pro in 2017, making this a very strong claim for that season.
Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#29051
Matt MillerMatt Miller

The Browns should sign Kirk Cousins and avoid drafting a rookie quarterback

I would try to sign Kirk Cousins and not draft any of them [the 2018 QBs]. I'd be terrified.

The Browns did not sign Cousins; they drafted Baker Mayfield #1 overall.
Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2405
Big CatBig Cat

Jake Fromm is better than any quarterback in the 2018 Draft class

I had a hot take. Jake Fromm is better than any of the quarterbacks that are in this year's draft.

Jake Fromm was absolutely not better than the 2018 class, which included MVP Lamar Jackson and star Josh Allen. Fromm barely stuck in the league.
Loss
Jan 12, 2018
#2407
Matt MillerMatt Miller

Tua Tagovailoa will win four or five Super Bowls

Oh, without a doubt. First ballot Hall of Fame for Tua. College and pro. I think you've got to put him up there, four or five [Super Bowls]. He's pretty damn good, though.

Tua is a solid NFL starter but has zero Super Bowls as of 2024, and 4-5 seems extremely unlikely.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers