Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Gilbert Arenas, Knicks Up 2-0, Thunder And Wolves Tie The Series, The Pope Is American, Playoff Hockey And Fyre Fest With Some Bonus Mystery Guests

Friday, May 9, 202519 takes

We start with Thursday night games and it turns out Steph Curry is very important to the Warriors as the Wolves tie the series(-). We talk playoff hockey and the Capitals catch phrase that has some people confused(-). The Pope is American and from Chicago and its another win for USA(-). George Pickens on the Cowboys is a match made in heaven(-). We then kick it back to studio with Hank and talk Celtics Knicks after another 20 point blown lead by the Celtics and a special guest joins us via zoom to rattle Hank more(-). The Thunder are back on track after destroying the Nuggets Wednesday night(-). Gilbert Arenas joins the show to talk playoff basketball, his new documentary out on Netflix, his career, card games and the time he walked in on Lamar Odom having sex(-). We finish with fyre fest and Max joins us from Hawaii to make one of the worst arguments in show history(-).

Gilbert Arenas on Knicks-Celtics, Mamba Mentality, and the Pope’s White Sox Fandom

The NBA playoffs are in full swing and the energy in the studio is reaching a fever pitch, mostly because Hank is slowly losing his mind as the Celtics continue to choke away 20-point leads. Big Cat and PFT opened the show breaking down the Warriors' struggles without their North Star. It turns out that when Steph Curry isn't on the floor to hit circus shots, the Warriors' offense looks like a JV team trying to solve a Rubik's cube.

Win
May 9, 2025
#3194
Big CatBig Cat

The Warriors will not win their series against the Timberwolves without Steph Curry

The Warriors just couldn't, they didn't have enough offense. And, and the wolves, like even with Anthony Edwards... I'll just say it. The Warriors will not win this series without Steph.

The Timberwolves ultimately won this series 4-2 in the 2025 playoffs as Curry's injury was too much to overcome.

PFT thinks the desperation might lead to some questionable medical decisions in the Bay Area.

Void
May 9, 2025
#3195
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Steph Curry will try to return to the playoffs sooner than he should

I think that Steph is actually gonna come back sooner that we think that he is. I wouldn't be shocked if he tried to play in their next game because he knows... this feels like the last dance type thing that we're trying to do right now. I think he's gonna try to come back maybe too soon.

Without specific details about the injury timeline and Curry's exact return date during the 2025 playoffs, this cannot be precisely verified. The Warriors made it to the second round before losing to the Timberwolves.

The Bing Bong of It All

The Knicks are currently up 2-0 on the Celtics, and the vibes in New York are immaculate. To twist the knife into Hank even further, our good friend Jerry O'Connell called in wearing the "Broke Back" hat to celebrate Jalen Brunson’s dominance. While Hank tried to argue that the Celtics are still the better team despite, you know, losing every game so far, PFT reminded everyone that this specific New York roster was constructed for this exact moment.

Win
May 9, 2025
#20642
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Knicks are built specifically to beat the Celtics

I've said for the last like three, four months, this Knicks team is built to beat the Celtics.

The Knicks did beat the Celtics in the 2025 playoffs, winning the series 4-2 in the second round with a dominant 119-81 win in Game 6. The claim that the Knicks were built to beat the Celtics proved accurate.

Hank is currently insisting that a 4-2 series win for Boston is still "easy," which is the kind of delusional cope that makes this show great.

Loss
May 9, 2025
#3200
HankHank

The Celtics will still win their series against the Knicks easily

I do think the Celtics are gonna win this series easily... 4-2 is pretty easy. When you're looking back on the history books, 4-2 is pretty easy. That's easily.

The Knicks defeated the Celtics in 6 games in the second round of the 2025 NBA Playoffs, after Jayson Tatum suffered an Achilles tendon rupture. The Celtics did not win this series.

Chicago’s New Holy Father

In a historic turn of events, the Catholic Church has appointed its first American Pope, and he’s a White Sox fan from Chicago. Big Cat was quick to point out the irony of the Vatican finding a successor before his beloved Bears could find a competent signal-caller.

Win
May 9, 2025
#20641
Big CatBig Cat

Chicago getting a Pope before the Bears get a 4,000-yard passer is an all-time statistic

The joke of the day was the Catholic church got, or Chicago got a Pope before the Bears got a 4,000 yard passer. That was pretty funny.

The Bears are the only NFL franchise to never have a 4,000-yard passer; an American Pope from Chicago is indeed a more recent historical development.

Speaking of the NFL, the guys broke down the George Pickens trade to the Cowboys. Big Cat issued a stern warning to Jerry Jones about buying whatever Mike Tomlin is selling, while PFT worried about the locker room chemistry in Dallas.

Void
May 9, 2025
#3197
Big CatBig Cat

Never trade for a wide receiver from Mike Tomlin

Never trade for wide receiver from Mike Tomlin because Mike Tomlin is trading his wide receiver for a reason. And that means that Mike Tomlin is done with his wide receiver and he doesn't want him anymore. And you can go back. Deontay Johnson, chase Claypool, Antonio Brown... Mike Tomlin when he's like, I'm done with the, with, with, with the wide receiver. That's, it's over, it's damaged goods.

A general principle about trading for Steelers WRs. Subjective coaching observation.
Void
May 9, 2025
#3198
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

George Pickens will go insane if CeeDee Lamb dominates the targets

If CD Lamb starts getting the lion's share of the targets and Pickens isn't involved in the game plan, he is going to blow his head off. He is gonna go fucking insane even by George Pickens standards because he always wants the ball... even when he is getting the ball a decent amount, he still flips out.

Cannot verify whether George Pickens had behavioral issues related to CeeDee Lamb's target share on the Steelers in 2025. CeeDee Lamb was actually traded to Dallas for Micah Parsons, not to the Steelers.

To top off the NFL talk, Big Cat dropped a massive prediction regarding a certain darkness-retreat-loving quarterback and his eventual landing spot in the AFC North.

Loss
May 9, 2025
#3199
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers will sign with the Steelers on May 15th

They're waiting. Aaron Rogers is a quarterback for the Pittsburgh Steelers... he's just waiting for the schedule to come out. Then he will sign with the Steelers and make it official... I think we're gonna get Aaron Rogers on the Steelers on May 15th.

Did Aaron Rodgers sign with the Steelers on May 15, 2025? No, he is on the Jets.

Gilbert Arenas Joins the Show

Agent Zero himself, Gilbert Arenas, joined the program to talk about his new Netflix documentary and his thoughts on the current NBA landscape. Gil didn't hold back on the Celtics' obsession with the three-point line, specifically calling out Derrick White for forgetting his role on the floor.

Void
May 9, 2025
#20648
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Derrick White needs to stop shooting so many three-pointers and focus on defense

Derrick White raising his hand like, wait, wait, wait, wait. Hold on guy, you got paid for defense, play defense. Right? You're not gonna be chucking 10 threes up. And that's what end up happening in this new analytic where they're trying to fill all these three point quotas.

Subjective opinion on roster roles and player usage.

He also gave Jalen Brunson the ultimate praise, comparing his late-game heroics to the original Mamba Mentality. The conversation shifted to all-time rankings, where Gil doubled down on his controversial Nikola Jokic takes while simultaneously placing him in the pantheon of great centers.

Void
May 9, 2025
#20644
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Jalen Brunson is the closest player to the real 'Mamba Mentality' in the NBA

He's the closest thing we have to Mamba mentality, the real Mamba mentality... That killer mentality that wants to take over the world. That's what Brunson has in the last five minutes.

Subjective comparison of competitive drive and clutch performance.
Void
May 9, 2025
#3201
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Nikola Jokic is the worst three-time MVP in the last 40 years

If he wins the next one, he'll be the worst three time MVP in the last 40 years. Right. Because it was like... those five were in that timeframe as Magic, Bird, Jordan, LeBron, and Jokic at that time. He's gonna rank fifth.

Subjective ranking of NBA legends.
Open
May 9, 2025
#20646
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Nikola Jokic will retire as one of the two best centers to ever play the game

When he's done, you have to argue he's top one, two best centers ever. The only person who is gonna be standing tall over him is Kareem [Abdul-Jabbar].

Subjective legacy prediction based on current career trajectory.

Fyre Fest and Hawaii Max

Max called in from Hawaii to deliver what might be the worst take in the history of the show. Sitting on a beach watching turtles, Max tried to convince the room that Jason Tatum is actually a bigger playoff fraud than Joel Embiid. The logic was thin, the stats were cherry-picked, and the delivery was hindered by a six-hour time difference.

Void
May 9, 2025·Fyre Fest
#3203
MaxMax

Jayson Tatum has officially replaced Joel Embiid as the worst playoff superstar in the Eastern Conference

I guess that a super embarrassing that Jason Tatum has now taken the crown of the worst playoff performer in the Eastern Conference... Joel Embiid for a long time was known as the worst Eastern Conference superstar to play in the playoffs. And Jason Tatum simply has worst playoff stats than Joel Embiid. And that's a fact.

Subjective comparison of two stars' playoff reputations.
Void
May 9, 2025·Fyre Fest
#20649
MaxMax

Jayson Tatum was carried to his championship and would be a loser on any other organization

Jason Tatum would also be a loser if he wasn't playing for the Celtics... He played horribly in that championship and was carried by the rest of his team.

Subjective evaluation of championship contribution and hypothetical career outcomes.

Hank finished the show by detailing a truly horrific experience on a Southwest flight that involved a lack of barf bags and some very unfortunate projectile vomiting. It’s been a bad week for Henry Lockwood, but a great week for the rest of us.

At least the Pope is a White Sox fan.

nba-playoffsknickscelticssteph-currygilbert-arenaschicago-bears

More Takes

Loss
May 9, 2025
#3196
Big CatBig Cat

The Dallas Stars are going to win the Stanley Cup

The Stars took the first game of the series on the road and it feels like the stars are gonna win the cup. I don't know, maybe that's the stupid thing to say, but it feels like they're really fucking good.

The Dallas Stars lost to the Edmonton Oilers in 5 games in the Western Conference Final. The Florida Panthers won the 2025 Stanley Cup.
Void
May 9, 2025
#20643
Big CatBig Cat

The Thunder are 'up' in their series against the Nuggets despite being tied 1-1

I still think it's gonna be a very good series. But this was the thunder we all expected as the one seed... I think the Thunder's up in the series one-to-one.

Momentum is subjective, but based on their blowout win in Game 2, Big Cat argues the Thunder have the advantage.
Win
May 9, 2025
#20647
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

I beat Deshaun Stevenson in a three-point contest while shooting with only one hand

Deshaun Stevenson started, you know, talking. So I said, bro, I'll beat you with one hand... and I beat him with the one hand.

This is a well-documented event in NBA history that Gilbert has consistently claimed and others have confirmed.
Void
May 9, 2025
#20645
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Nikola Jokic is a better player than Bill Russell

[Big Cat] Is Jokic better than Bill Russell? [Gilbert Arenas] Yeah.

Subjective all-time ranking debate.
Open
May 9, 2025
#3202
Gilbert ArenasGilbert Arenas

Luka Doncic will be the MVP next year if he loses 30 pounds

If Luka can get down to about 230, 225, I I, I really believe he's gonna be MVP next year.

Depends on Luka's 2025-2026 performance and conditioning.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers