The Texans had already kicked the Colts into next week by the time the microphones turned on, which meant Big Cat got to confidently recap a game nobody in the room had watched yet. That was only the beginning of an episode built around shaky information, strong opinions, and the annual PMT tradition of pretending a terrible NFL slate might secretly become incredible.
MLB Owners Get Put On Trial
The baseball lockout conversation immediately became an ownership courtroom. Big Cat wants a salary floor to force teams like the Pirates, Rockies, and A's to stop treating payroll like an optional subscription, but he cannot get behind a salary cap that limits what players can earn. PFT took it a step further: before owners ask players to accept a cap, they should open every book connected to the team, including the money flowing through places like Wrigleyville.
MLB needs a salary floor, but not a salary cap
I think you need a salary floor because I hate these owners who don't spend money. They need to be taking a task, like you have to start putting a competitive product on there. So I am all in favor of a salary floor. You can't have a salary floor without a salary cap, and I'm not in favor of capping how much a guy can earn. Therein lies my problem.
Owners should open their books before players accept a salary cap
If the owners want to be honest about it and show us the money that they're making, not just on the team, but in Chicago, they own Wrigleyville, that entire everything associated with the team. How is baseball going directly into your pocket? If you want to show us that there actually is a revenue issue, then yeah, we have to have a conversation. But until they release an audited full transaction of everything they make money off of related to the baseball team, there's no way that the players should take them for their word that they're losing money.
The proposed solution of flipping a coin every year between a salary cap and no rules was, naturally, described as “ironclad.” Max was the only person in the room willing to think through the obvious consequences, which is why the idea should probably be adopted immediately.
Week 11 Is Slop, But It Is Our Slop
There was no attempt to oversell the schedule. Six teams were on bye, several games carried cartoonishly large spreads, and the show had to talk itself into the idea that Saints-Bears could be compelling. Big Cat landed on the stakes for Chicago: losing to New Orleans or Miami would be season-ruining, especially with the rest of the schedule packed with NFC North teams and Super Bowl-level opponents.
The Bears cannot lose to the Saints or Dolphins
You cannot lose to the Saints or the Dolphins. That would actually be season devastating. Season ruining.
PFT also took one look at the Cowboys hiring their defensive coordinator's old boss to help fix the defense and concluded that Dallas had invented a new kind of organizational dysfunction. The official position: the move will not make anything better, except perhaps proving that the defense cannot possibly get worse.
The Cowboys' defensive shakeup will not make the defense better
This is just an ultimate cocking of your own defensive. I don't think it's gonna get better. The answer is no. I don't think that this is going to improve anything except for the fact that maybe it just can't be worse.
The picks contained the usual amount of dangerous confidence, including Big Cat's belief that Fernando Mendoza only needs a few wins to run away with Rookie of the Year and PFT planting his flag on JJ McCarthy. Even the Hungry Dog was struggling to find a meal in a slate this ugly.
The Aikman Warning Shot
The Troy Aikman-Joe Buck situation got the full conspiracy-board treatment. Aikman joking about Joe wanting a one-man booth was not treated as a joke. Big Cat and PFT saw it as a warning shot, with the next escalation potentially happening live during a broadcast. The dream scenario is Troy going fully rogue on Monday Night Football and turning a bad matchup into appointment television.
Troy Aikman is trying to force a change to the Monday Night Football booth
This feels like Troy's trying to force something to happen. I think something might happen. This is a warning shot. Next time it's on the air. Next time it's during the broadcast.
Kyle Long Brings Actual Football Knowledge
Kyle Long joined from Chicago and immediately explained what it is like to work the NFL Today desk with James Brown, Bill Cowher, Nate Burleson, and Russell Wilson. He can choose his own game audio from a sunken TV in the desk, which is the closest television has come to recreating the PMT gambling cave. Kyle also admitted that making TV is harder to sleep for than playing football, mostly because Saturday night in New York is full of invitations when all he wants is a quiet hotel room and a Sweetgreen wrap.
The football portion was excellent. Kyle sees the Bears and Jaguars as mirror images, believes Chicago can compete with anyone, and explained why Jeffrey Simmons-style interior pressure changes an entire defense. A defensive tackle who wrecks the pocket can ruin an offense without ever making the final tackle, which is a much better sales pitch than simply saying “he is built like an action figure,” even though Kyle also said that.
The Bears can beat any team in the NFL
I'm just excited, though, to compete because I do think they can compete with any team in the NFL. I think they're right there.
Jeffrey Simmons is the best interior defensive lineman in football
You bring Jeffrey Simmons into the equation and the best interior defensive line in football.
The conversation then moved to the Vikings' blitz package. Kyle's answer was refreshingly simple: stop trying to outsmart Brian Flores and run directly at him with eight enormous people until the dam breaks.
The Vikings' blitz can be beaten by running straight at it
Why don't we just run the fucking ball right at them? It takes a while to work, but if you watch the second half of that Bills game, they were in 13 personnel. They said, 'Oh, you've got a tricky scheme.' Well, I've got eight big suckers who are ready to go downhill at you for four quarters. Eventually that dam breaks.
Kyle was equally forceful on the rest of the league. He called the Jaguars a real team rather than a fraud, argued that Josh Downs changes the Chiefs on third down, and picked Drew Lock over Sam Darnold in Seattle until Lock proves he cannot do the job. He also credited the Bengals' offensive line with changing the entire feel of Cincinnati's season after Joe Burrow spent years getting hit like he owed somebody money.
Drew Lock should keep starting over Sam Darnold
Keep that sucker Drew Lock out there until proven otherwise. Sam Darnold, you win a Super Bowl, you have success, but your warts are still your warts, and turnovers cannot happen, particularly in the playoffs.
The Bengals' offensive line has finally changed the team's ceiling
The attitude in that Cincinnati offensive line room is different. For so many years we saw Joe Burrow just getting beat up. He's got a group now. And that defense, they're good enough. When you're scoring that many points, you can pin your ears back as a defensive front. That's a fun brand of football to play.
GTA 6 Has Already Claimed Zac
The GTA 6 conversation revealed that Zac is not merely playing the game. He is working out in the game, eating a protein bar in the game, fixing drywall in the game, and doom-scrolling Instagram on the in-game phone. The proposed PMT roleplay server quickly became an economic theory seminar where people pay real money for fake jobs at fake Verizon stores. Kyle volunteered to be a lifeguard in Vice City, which feels like a future lawsuit waiting to happen.
Fiona, The Hat, And The Fyre Fest
The mood took a hard turn when the news came through that Fiona the hippo had died after eating a child's knit hat. Big Cat had spent the earlier part of the day dismissing the hat as an opponent Fiona could easily handle, so the regret was immediate and spectacular. Hank responded by putting the entire state of Ohio's parenting class on trial.
The show eventually decided the Cincinnati Zoo was cursed, Fiona would want the Bengals to win the Super Bowl, and nobody should ever wear a hat near a zoo again. A fitting memorial, in its own way.
The actual Fyre Fest involved Hank spilling an entire glass of wine onto Kayla's dinner at the Fur Ball after placing it on the treacherous seam of a folding table. The dining room closed before she could get another plate, so Hank promised an Uber Eats gift card that apparently required several business days to arrive. This is why tables need to be regulated.
Glenn Audits Connor McDavid
The episode closed with Glenn Tape Watch, where Glenny Balls expanded into hockey analysis and accused the NHL of improperly awarding Connor McDavid two assists. His evidence was “by my count,” which is exactly the level of statistical rigor the sport has been missing.
Between the salary-cap coin flip, Mr. Rocket, the haunted apartment, and a hockey audit conducted from first principles, this was less a podcast than a very long group chat that somehow had Kyle Long in it. The hat won, Fiona lost, and the takes remain undefeated.

