Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Draft With Todd McShay, NBA/NHL First Round Is Underway, Ryan Garcia May Save Boxing And Mr Pear Win A Single Pick Challenge

Monday, April 22, 202422 takes

The NBA and NHL playoffs are here and we talk about every game from the weekend. Timberwolves next up (-). Is Embiid made of glass (-)? The Lakers/Nuggets play the same game over and over (-). Big Cat has some words for Jerry Reinsdorf (-). Celtics are a wagon and the Mavs tricks us all (-). The Bruins own the Leafs and we debut our Period of the week (-). Who's back of the week including Ryan Garcia's electric weekend, rap beef, and John Sterling's brand new TV (-). Todd McShay joins the show to get us ready for the NFL Draft this week, where the draft starts, what he's hearing about picks after Caleb Williams at 1, who he loves that no one is talking about and a bonus fun fact about Mel Kiper having no cell phone and 5 landlines (-). We finish with Mr Pear trying to pick one single winner one time (-).

Todd McShay on NFL Draft, NBA/NHL Playoff Overreactions, and Ryan Garcia

The greatest two weeks of the sports calendar are officially here. Between the NBA and NHL playoffs starting and the NFL Draft just days away, there is zero chance anyone is getting any actual work done. Big Cat and PFT are in full overreaction mode after a weekend of Game 1s, and the vibes are already at an all-time high.

NBA Playoff Overreactions

The weekend started with a defensive rock fight between the Cavs and Magic that felt like it was filmed in the 90s. While Cleveland took the first game, PFT isn't convinced it'll be a short series.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#26817
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Cavaliers will win their series against the Magic, but it will likely go to six or seven games

I think this is gonna be one of those series that the Cavs are gonna win. I think they'll win both at home then the magic will win a couple at their home. ... That'll go six or seven.

The Cavaliers won the series in seven games, and the first four games followed the exact home-win pattern PFT predicted.

Big Cat was quick to remind everyone that despite the win, the Cavaliers' owner still hasn't proven he can win without the King.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4973
Big CatBig Cat

The Cleveland Cavaliers have never won a playoff series without LeBron James

Fun fact, little fun fact. The Cleveland Cavaliers, Dan Gilbert has never won a playoff series without LeBron James.

This was correct at the time of the episode. The Cavs had not won a series without LeBron since 1993, which predates Dan Gilbert's ownership (2005).

Meanwhile, in the West, Anthony Edwards officially took the torch by talking trash directly to Kevin Durant’s face. The Timberwolves looked more physical and hungrier, leading Big Cat to call the series early.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#26818
Big CatBig Cat

The Timberwolves will sweep the Suns

T wove in four. Whoever wins game one is four.

The Timberwolves actually did sweep the Suns 4-0.

PFT has even higher hopes for a certain team in Los Angeles, though he admits it might just be a bit to mess with Hank.

Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4971
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Los Angeles Clippers are going to win the Western Conference

The Los Angeles Clippers are going to win the West. Ooh. Not that they're gonna compete. That they're gonna compete. Hey, I, I said that mostly just to get Hank's hopes up because Hank is grasping at all the straws.

The Clippers lost in the first round of the playoffs to the Mavericks.

The LeBron Stamina Problem and Sixers Drama

The Lakers and Nuggets gave us exactly what they always give us: a Lakers lead that vanishes the moment Nikola Jokić decides the game is over. LeBron James looked incredible early, but the fourth quarter told a different story.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4979
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James lacks the stamina to play at an elite level for four quarters

LeBron is doing at 39. He does not have the stamina to do it for four quarters. Like you saw it, he scored I think maybe two or four points in garbage time with like the under a minute left in the fourth quarter. He runs out of gas and no one else... the other guys have to do stuff and they're not able to.

LeBron's stats consistently dipped in fourth quarters throughout the 2024 series against Denver.

Hank is already predicting the ultimate LeBron exit strategy if the Lakers fall into a deeper hole.

Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#26819
HankHank

LeBron James will not finish the series against the Nuggets because he will fake an injury

If The Lakers get blown on next game, LeBron will not finish a series. So, oh he'll, he'll pull an injury. They, he did it Saturday night. ... I said it out loud. I was like, LeBron's gonna, this is fake injury territory.

LeBron James played every game of the series, which the Lakers lost 4-1.

Over in the East, the Knicks and Sixers played a classic Garden game. Joel Embiid’s health is once again the only story that matters for Philly, and Hank isn't buying the tough guy act.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4977
HankHank

Joel Embiid is made of glass

I don't want to, I don't wanna be a hater, but it's like... the playoffs, if you make it to the finals, it's a long run. Like how many games do you think [Embiid] has in him? ... I don't want Embiid to get hurt. I can just look at data and history and acknowledge that he's made of glass.

Embiid played 6 games in the 2024 playoffs but clearly struggled with injuries throughout.

Despite the Game 1 loss and the injury scares, Max is staying loyal to his squad and expects a comeback.

Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4978
MaxMax

The Sixers will win their series against the Knicks

Sixers are gonna win the series. Oh plus I think it was plus two 50... I'm already really invested so I don't think that I have to do any bets.

The Knicks defeated the Sixers in 6 games.

Jerry Reinsdorf's Masterclass in Mediocrity

After the Bulls were eliminated in the play-in, Big Cat spent some time "seeing red" and unloading on the state of the organization. He laid the blame squarely at the feet of owner Jerry Reinsdorf, who seems perfectly content with a team that never truly competes.

Void
Apr 22, 2024
#4980
Big CatBig Cat

Jerry Reinsdorf is the worst owner in the NBA

The Chicago Bulls are a joke of an organization. Jerry Reinsdorf is one of the worst owners, if not the worst in the NBA. He's a fucking clown... the Chicago Bulls have made the playoffs two times in the last nine seasons. Two times they've back to back nine 10 game champions and that's it.

Subjective ranking of owners, though the Bulls' lack of success is factual.

Todd McShay Preps for Draft Week

Todd McShay joins the show to provide the final word on the draft. He’s been grinding the tape and making calls, and he’s convinced that Caleb Williams is walking into the best possible situation for a rookie quarterback.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4983
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Caleb Williams entering the Chicago Bears is the best situation for a #1 pick in a long time

Caleb comes in and you've got DJ Moore, Keenan Allen, Deandre Swift... this is as good as situation as we've seen in a long time. ... You have to go back a while to say which quarterback was in this good of a situation that Caleb Williams is entering into as the number one overall pick in the draft.

The offensive weapons surrounding Caleb Williams (Moore, Allen, Odunze) are statistically much better than typical #1 pick environments.

When it comes to the rest of the quarterback class, Todd doesn't think the Jayden Daniels vs. Drake May debate is actually a debate inside NFL buildings.

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4984
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Jayden Daniels is clearly the #2 quarterback in the draft over Drake May

There isn't one person I've spoken to that believes that Drake May should be drafted number two over Jaden Daniels. ... That first tier has has been for for teams has always been kind of Caleb and Jaden. And then the second tier is Drake.

Jayden Daniels was indeed drafted 2nd overall by the Commanders, and Drake May 3rd by the Patriots.

Todd also floated some fascinating scenarios for the rest of the top ten, including a potential rise for an interior defensive lineman and a perfect landing spot for JJ McCarthy.

Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4985
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Byron Murphy could be a surprise top 10 pick and the first defensive player drafted

The more people I've talked to in the league, the more I get the sense that Byron Murphy defensive tackle from from Texas could be, and, and, and I, I don't wanna say it's most likely, but if there's gonna be a surprise in the top 10, it's Byron Murphy.

Byron Murphy II was drafted 16th overall by the Seahawks. Laiatu Latu (15th) was the first defensive player drafted.
Void
Apr 22, 2024
#4986
Todd McShayTodd McShay

JJ McCarthy will have the best rookie season of any quarterback if he lands in Minnesota

JJ McCarthy could have the best rookie year of all the quarterbacks if he lands in Minnesota, that that's the most desirable spot for these rookie quarterbacks.

McCarthy suffered a season-ending meniscus injury in the preseason and will not play his rookie season.

Who’s Back and Mr. Pear

Who's Back featured a wild recap of the Ryan Garcia vs. Devin Haney fight. Garcia spent the last month acting completely insane on social media, only to go out and dominate Haney. Big Cat thinks we’re looking at a new era for the sport.

Void
Apr 22, 2024·Who's Back
#4982
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Garcia is the new face of boxing

Garcia was awesome and he, he might be the new face of boxing 'cause he is, he's crazy. He's like the perfect amount of crazy fun to watch. Was throwing bombs... he's something else.

Subjective, but Garcia's subsequent PED controversy and erratic behavior have polarized his 'face of boxing' status.

PFT also found a way to spin the Capitals' Game 1 loss into a victory using some very specific math.

Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4981
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Capitals technically won Game 1 against the Rangers if you ignore three specific minutes of play

If you take out like three minutes in the second period, we actually tied this game. One. One. ... If you take out that 10 seconds and the two and a half minutes in the second period, the caps actually won. This game won nothing... and it turns out that we technically kind of actually won that game.

Hot TakeHockeyScorchingSarcastic
The Capitals literally lost the game 4-1 and were swept in the series.

Finally, the show ended with Mr. Pear attempting to pick a winner for the first time in his miserable turtle career. He's currently Owen-Two and fading fast, but the guys are giving him one more shot before he becomes a soup candidate.

Just remember: if the turtle says Sixers, bet the house on the Knicks.

nfl-draftnba-playoffsstanley-cupboxingchicago-bears

More Takes

Win
Apr 22, 2024
#4976
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Anthony Edwards is now a legitimate NBA superstar

Anthony Edwards is is a legit superstar Now. [Durant] he he couldn't do anything about it. Yeah. He was like, yeah, you're right. You're kind of, you're kind of dunking on me right now.

Edwards led the Timberwolves to the Western Conference Finals in 2024, cementing his superstar status.
Void
Apr 22, 2024
#26822
Big CatBig Cat

James Harden is only elite in the playoffs when he has significant rest between games

James Harden, when he has rest, basically every game one, he's awesome. ... Guy likes rest when he gets his rest. Yeah. ... So just remember James Harden when he has rest. Bet him.

Harden had 28 points and 8 assists in Game 1 after rest, but struggled later in the series with shorter turnarounds.
Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4988
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Ladd McConkey will be a first-round draft pick

Ladd McConkey from Georgia is, is so dynamic in terms of his route running ability... I'm gonna say he's going in the first round.

Ladd McConkey was drafted in the second round, pick #34 overall.
Win
Apr 22, 2024
#26820
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Michael Penix Jr. will be a first-round draft pick despite concerns about his durability

I think Michael Penix is gonna go in the first round. ... He's the best pure passer in this class. ... But it's the lack of mobility in the pocket and then the durability. ... I worry about him holding up. ... You're starting to hear somewhere in the, in the first, I've, I've even heard rumors, maybe the Raiders at 13. I think Michael Penix goes in the first round.

Michael Penix Jr. was drafted #8 overall by the Atlanta Falcons.
Loss
Apr 22, 2024
#4987
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Bo Nix is a second-round talent and will not be drafted in the first round

Bo Nix, everyone puts him at 12 to the [Broncos] ... But Bo Nix, if he doesn't go 12 to Denver is a second round pick according to everybody. ... I think round two is where you'll see Bo Nix.

Bo Nix was drafted #12 overall by the Denver Broncos.
Win
Apr 22, 2024
#26823
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Nate Wiggins is ready to start immediately in the NFL and is an elite cornerback talent

Nate Wiggins [from] Clemson... burner. ... He could play off coverage press coverage. He played zone and man. I think that that Nate Wiggins is gonna wind up being a really good cornerback. ... I think he's ready to start right away.

Nate Wiggins had a strong rookie season for the Ravens in 2024. He started, recorded 33 tackles, 13 passes defended, allowed no touchdowns in coverage during the regular season, and had a 47.8% completion rate when targeted with a 66.7 passer rating allowed. He ranked top-5 in lowest opposing passer rating among qualifying corners.
Win
Apr 22, 2024
#26821
Todd McShayTodd McShay

Jonathan Brooks will be the first running back selected in the NFL Draft

Jonathan Brooks should be the first running back off the board coming out of Texas. I think there's gonna be a bunch of guys in the third, fourth, fifth round range.

Jonathan Brooks was the first running back drafted, going #46 overall to the Panthers.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers