Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Preview With Pete Prisco, Michael Irvin, Mt Rushmore Duel + Listener Takes On The 2025 Season

Wednesday, September 3, 202516 takes

NFL is almost here and we do our predictions for the season, worst case scenarios for all of our teams, MVP, SB, least improved and more (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including is President Trump dead or alive (-)? Mt Rushmore duel to end the Rushmore season plus punishment (-). Pete Prisco joins the show to preview the entire league division by division and an incredible NFC South preview plus his Super Bowl picks (-). Michael Irvin joins the show to talk about the new Cowboys documentary, the wild 90’s, partying after the season and more (-). We finish with listener submitted takes ahead of the 2025 season (-).

NFL Preview with Pete Prisco and Michael Irvin, Plus Mount Rushmore Duel

Football is officially back tomorrow, and the energy in the studio is high. Big Cat and PFT are buzzing for the NFL kickoff, but first, the cast had to look in the mirror and face their deepest fears for their respective teams. Hank is somehow still convinced the Patriots are a juggernaut in disguise, while Big Cat is terrified of a world where Chicago's savior isn't actually the savior.

Open
Sep 3, 2025
#21351
Big CatBig Cat

My worst-case scenario for the Bears is Caleb Williams being 'absolute dog shit'

I think we all know my worst case scenario, it's that Caleb [Williams] is dog shit... It's essentially that everyone is good around Caleb and Caleb is just absolute dog shit. That would be worst case scenario by far.

The season hasn't started yet as of the episode date.

PFT's anxiety is more physical. He’s spent the entire offseason watching Jaden Daniels highlights while simultaneously clutching his own knees in prayer.

Void
Sep 3, 2025
#21352
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

My worst-case scenario for the Commanders is Jayden Daniels suffering a major knee injury

My worst case scenario because it does, I think about this every Sunday. Is Jayden Daniels' knee exploding? Oh, I think I think about it way too much every time he gets hit. I think about it.

Subjective fear/scenario; cannot be 'correct' unless it actually happens.

MVP and Super Bowl Predictions

Before getting to the guests, it was time to put the reputations on the line with season picks. While Big Cat is looking at a Cincinnati resurgence, Hank has fully drank the Green Bay Kool-Aid, much to Big Cat’s chagrin.

Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15960
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Burrow will win NFL MVP

I'm taking Joe Burrow this year. Joe Burrow's my pick.

Joe Burrow did not win 2025 MVP. Bengals went 6-11. Stafford won.
Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15961
HankHank

Jordan Love will win NFL MVP

I'm taking Jordan Love. I think the Packers are gonna be filthy.

Jordan Love did not win 2025 MVP. Stafford won. Packers went 9-8-1.

When it came to the big game, Big Cat is finally ready to believe that the table-jumpers in Buffalo are going to get their ring.

Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15962
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills will win the Super Bowl

The Bills is who I think is gonna win the Super Bowl.

The Bills lost to the Broncos in the Divisional Round. Seahawks won the Super Bowl.

Pete Prisco’s Deep Dive

Our good friend Pete Prisco joined the show for his annual division-by-division breakdown. Prisco wasn't holding back on his favorite targets, including the Dolphins (who he thinks might be a disaster) and the Raiders' defensive roster.

Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15967
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Raiders will only win five games because their defense lacks talent

Yeah, they [the Raiders] might win five games... When I look at their defense, there's not a lot of talent on it... I worry about the defense. I do think they'll be pretty good on offense... but I worry about the defense.

Pete Prisco predicted the Raiders would win five games. The Raiders finished 3-14, winning only 3 games — even fewer than the predicted five. While the spirit (Raiders being bad) was correct, the specific number was wrong.

Prisco also provided some spicy quarterback movement predictions, suggesting that the Giants might pull the plug on the Daniel Jones era much sooner than people think.

Win
Sep 3, 2025
#21354
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Jaxson Dart will start for the Giants before Dylan Gabriel starts for the Browns

I think [Jaxson] Dart's gonna come in [for the Giants] before Dylan Gabriel comes in in Cleveland. Yes I do.

Pete Prisco predicted Jaxson Dart would start for the Giants before Dylan Gabriel started for the Browns. Dart made his first NFL start in Week 4 (vs. Chargers, Sept 28, 2025), while Gabriel made his first start in Week 5 (vs. Vikings in London, Oct 5, 2025). Dart started one week before Gabriel.

As the resident "Tape Watcher," Prisco found himself aligned with Big Cat on the Bills' dominance, noting that their schedule is essentially a red carpet to the postseason.

Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15965
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Bills will win 13 or 14 games and have a very favorable schedule

I think the bills run away with it. And if you look at the Bill's schedule, the bill's schedule is as favorable as any first place team has ever had... I they have to look to me of a 13 win team. I really believe that. Maybe 14.

The Bills went 12-5, not 13 or 14 wins. They also failed to win the AFC East (Patriots won it at 14-3) and were eliminated in the Divisional Round.

The Playmaker on the 90s Cowboys

Michael Irvin joined the show to discuss the new Netflix documentary on the Cowboys' dynasty. It was a trip down memory lane that included stories about the infamous "White House," recruiting Deion Sanders, and the internal politics between Jerry Jones and Jimmy Johnson. Irvin didn't mince words about what that team could have been if the egos had stayed in check.

Void
Sep 3, 2025
#15975
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

The 90s Cowboys would have won five straight Super Bowls if Jimmy Johnson stayed

We often talk about we would've could've won five straight, [with Jimmy Johnson] but it didn't happen that way.

Counterfactual history that cannot be proven.

He also gave some perspective on the current Cowboys, specifically the addition of George Pickens and why he thinks the talent on the roster isn't the issue—it's the "collective will" of the locker room.

Void
Sep 3, 2025
#21356
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

The Cowboys family dynamic, not just skill, is what's missing for a Super Bowl run

They've always had the skill. It's just I need the collective will. Those three years we went 12 and 5, we had a good enough team... They had the skill, it was just not the collective will when we got to the playoffs. Hopefully that comes together.

Subjective analysis of team chemistry.

Mount Rushmore Season Finale

The show concluded with the high-stakes Mount Rushmore Duel between Team PFT/Hank and Team Max/Memes. With the punishment on the line—a full week of dark spray tans, frosted tips, and puca shell necklaces—the categories ranged from people you'd switch lives with to the best inventions in human history. Memes trying to claim "legalized prostitution" as a top-tier law was a vintage PMT moment that left everyone questioning his search history.

It’s time to stop talking and start watching; see you all on Friday for the first Recap of the season.

nfl-previewsuper-bowl-picksdallas-cowboysmount-rushmorenfl-mvp

More Takes

Win
Sep 3, 2025
#15959
HankHank

The Patriots' best-case scenario is 12 wins and an AFC Championship appearance

Best case, 12 wins, win the division. [Make] the AFC Championship. I don't want to get crazy.

The Patriots went 14-3, won the AFC, and reached the Super Bowl, exceeding the best-case of 12 wins and AFC Championship.
Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#21353
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Buccaneers are legitimate Super Bowl contenders in the NFC

Bucks. More bucks. I think they're one of the teams that could push for the Super Bowl in the NFC. I love the Bucks. I think the make everybody's back on offense... They're gonna be the team to beat in that division.

Pete Prisco called the Buccaneers a Super Bowl contender who would be the team to beat in their division. The Bucs finished 8-9 and lost the NFC South to the Panthers on tiebreakers. They did not make the playoffs.
Void
Sep 3, 2025
#15973
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Travis Kelce is more name than game at this stage of his career

Kelsey, the football player isn't the same as he used to be. Let's be real... he's more name than game than he is been in the past.

Subjective assessment of a player's performance level.
Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15971
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Bills will defeat the Packers in the Super Bowl

Green Bay over Philly [in the NFC Championship]... and Buffalo over Green Bay [in the Super Bowl]. There's gonna be a party like they've never felt in Buffalo.

Pete Prisco predicted the Bills would beat the Packers in the Super Bowl. Neither team made it to the Super Bowl. The Bills lost to the Broncos in the Divisional Round 33-30. The Packers lost to the Bears in the Wild Card 31-27. The actual Super Bowl was Seahawks 29, Patriots 13.
Open
Sep 3, 2025
#21355
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

CJ Stroud will be the 'Least Improved Player' of the year due to offensive line issues

CJ Stroud. I don't think it's gonna be his own doing either. I think that line, I think that line's a problem. And once the line's a problem, it really speeds up the quarterback and it becomes a problem for him too.

Pending 2025 season stats and performance compared to 2024.
Void
Sep 3, 2025
#15977
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

George Pickens will be a phenomenal talent for the Cowboys playing with Dak Prescott

Phenomenal talent [George Pickens]... imagine what he must feel like Right now with a Dak Prescott at quarterback. Yeah.

Subjective evaluation of fit/talent.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers