Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 2, Fastest 2 Minutes, The Bears Suck Again, The Giants/Cowboys Game Of The Day, Chiefs In Trouble? + Who's Back Of The Week

Monday, September 15, 202511 takes

Were back for Week 2 of the NFL and we start with Fastest 2 Minutes. (-) We then recap every game from Sunday Lions 52, Bears 21 (-) Bengals 31, Jaguars 27 (-) Cowboys 40, Giants 37 (-) 49ers 26, Saints 21 (-) Bills 30, Jets 10 (-) Seahawks 31, Steelers 17 (-) Patriots 33, Dolphins 27 (-) Rams 33, Titans 19 (- ) Ravens 41, Browns 17 (-) Colts 29, Broncos 28 (- ) Cardinals 27, Panthers 22 (-) Eagles 20, Chiefs 17 (-) Falcons 22, Vikings 6 (-) We then finish with who's back of the week. (-).

NFL Week 2: Bears Stink, Chiefs Slide, and the Pinky Bet Returns

Week 2 in the NFL provided exactly the kind of chaos that makes us love and hate this league in equal measure. We had Fastest 2 Minutes, a slate of games that refused to end on time, and some serious soul-searching for a few franchises that thought they were ready for the big time.

Before the guys even got into the games, the shadow of the Pinky Bet loomed large. With the Chiefs and potentially the Texans sitting at 0-2, Big Cat is already feeling the phantom pains of a future surgery.

Open
Sep 15, 2025
#14928
Big CatBig Cat

I'm eventually going to lose the tip of my pinky on a bet

I'm probably gonna lose a pinky. Eventually. I'm gonna lose a pinky. We're gonna do this show for the next 40 years. I'm gonna do this bet every year for some year. I'm gonna lose the pinky.

This is an ongoing lifetime prediction for his career.

The Chicago Bears are Who We Thought They Were

Lions 52, Bears 21. It was an absolute bloodbath in Detroit. Jared Goff looked like a surgical machine, throwing five touchdowns and nearly helping the Lions score a point per play. Meanwhile, the Bears look like they’ve managed to get worse in the fourth year of a supposed rebuild. Big Cat didn't hold back on Ryan Polls, pointing out that top draft picks like Colson Loveland and Luther Burden were essentially non-existent.

Win
Sep 15, 2025
#14929
Big CatBig Cat

Ryan Polls' rebuild of the Chicago Bears is a complete joke

The main culprit is Ryan Polls because we are now in year four of a rebuild... it's absolutely abysmal. Year four of a rebuilding they're somehow worse. Ryan Polls has not had a single Pro Bowler drafted. That's pretty crazy.

The Bears' poor performance and the stats cited (3-17 vs NFC North) are verifiable facts within the show's 2025 timeline.

While Caleb Williams wasn't the *main* problem, the defense giving up nearly 700 yards in five quarters is a joke. PFT tried to find a silver lining with Rome Odunze, but the vibes in Chicago are officially at rock bottom.

Cowboys/Giants Thriller and Kickers as MVPs

In a game that featured 41 points in the fourth quarter alone, Dak Prescott moved to 14 straight wins against the Giants. Russell Wilson nearly set a career high in passing yards, but the real story was Brandon Aubrey. The man makes 60-yarders look like chip shots, leading PFT to make a bold claim about his hypothetical draft stock.

Void
Sep 15, 2025
#14930
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brandon Aubrey could be a first or second-round draft pick if re-drafted

If he entered the NFL draft next year, if somehow he got reclassified back and he wasn't in the NFL and was eligible to be drafted, there would be a team that would take him in the second round. I'm saying he is so much better than any other kicker in the NFL.

Kickers almost never go in the early rounds, making this highly debatable but Aubrey's talent is real.

The AFC North and the Quarterback Question

In Pittsburgh, the Seahawks defense smothered Aaron Rodgers. It was a bizarre game highlighted by Caleb Johnson literally walking away from a live ball on a kickoff, essentially gifting Seattle a touchdown. Between the injuries and the stagnant offense, PFT is starting to think the Steelers have a specific comfort zone.

Void
Sep 15, 2025
#14932
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Steelers are better when they have a shitty quarterback

I think the Steelers are better when they have a shitty quarterback... I think that they're better when their defense knows that they have to be like impregnable.

It's a psychological theory that can't be objectively proven but fits Mike Tomlin's historic patterns.

Big Cat is even more pessimistic about the future in Pittsburgh, looking at Rodgers' inability to push the ball downfield as a sign that the end might be here.

Win
Sep 15, 2025
#14931
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers might be washed

I think they can just give it a little time 'cause I think Aaron Rodgers might not be good anymore. Under pressure, he was a disaster... He might be over.

Aaron Rodgers showed signs of decline in 2025 with the Steelers: 2,370 yards, 20 TDs, 7 INTs in 12 starts. He himself said 2025 would likely be his final season. He was not the elite Rodgers of old.

Crisis in Miami and the 0-2 Club

Things are getting ugly for Mike McDaniel. A players-only meeting after Week 1 followed by a communication breakdown in a loss to the Patriots has the seat feeling extremely hot. Big Cat is already putting a timeline on a potential firing.

Loss
Sep 15, 2025
#21399
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McDaniel will be the first NFL head coach fired this season

It feels like it's going to be our first head coach fired this season... the heat on his seat is volcanic at this point because they had a players only meeting after week one.

Big Cat predicted Mike McDaniel would be the first NFL head coach fired in 2025. The first coach fired during the 2025 season was Brian Callahan of the Titans (October 13, after a 1-5 start). The second was Brian Daboll of the Giants (at 2-8). McDaniel was fired after the season ended (January 8, 2026).
Open
Sep 15, 2025
#14933
Big CatBig Cat

If the Dolphins start 0-5, Mike McDaniel will be fired

I'll make the prediction. If the Dolphins start 0-5, he will be fired. 'cause they play the Bills. They're gonna lose to the Bills in Buffalo. Thursday Night Football. Then they play the Jets... then they play the Panthers. If they lose to the Jets and the Panthers... he's done.

Depends on the Dolphins' record and whether McDaniel is retained after a potential 0-5 start.

Then there are the Chiefs. Patrick Mahomes and Andy Reed are 0-2 for the first time in forever, losing a rock fight to the Eagles. The offense looks broken, and even Travis Kelce’s improved athleticism couldn't save them from a disastrous mistake late in the game. Zac thinks we might be witnessing the end of an era.

Push
Sep 15, 2025
#14938
ZacZac

The Chiefs' Mahomes and Andy Reid dynasty is finished

I just think the dynasty's over. I think Andy Reid and Mahomes dynasty's finished... usually when they pan the camera to Andy Reid, he's got a certain amount of girth... but this time it almost looks a little hollow. It looks a little empty.

The Chiefs did not return to the Super Bowl after losing LIX and have not been serious title contenders the last two seasons. The dynasty may indeed be over, though Mahomes is only 29.

Big Cat is desperately rooting for a Texans loss on Monday night just so he doesn't have to put his pinky on the line for the Mahomes dynasty, even if the Texans are the only 0-2 team that actually looks like a contender.

Void
Sep 15, 2025
#21396
Big CatBig Cat

The Houston Texans are the only Owen-two team with legitimate Super Bowl aspirations

I was looking at the Owen two teams and the only argument for a team that had legitimate Super Bowl aspirations would be the Houston Texans. Every other team that is Owen two was a dog shit team.

Subjective assessment of team quality and expectations at a specific point in time.

Transitive Property and Who's Back

To wrap things up, the guys looked at the Falcons' dominant defensive performance over the Vikings. It turns out the Packers might be the most terrifying team in the NFC North based on how everyone else is playing.

Open
Sep 15, 2025
#21398
Big CatBig Cat

The Green Bay Packers might be really good this year

The Packers might be really, really fucking good... the transitive property game, watching the Falcons demolish the Vikings makes me think the Bears are even worse than I thought... and the Packers, unfortunately, are really, really, really good.

Requires seeing the full season outcome for the Packers.

We also got a look at the Falcons' long-con regarding their quarterback room, with PFT theorizing that Kirk Cousins was nothing more than a very expensive distraction.

Void
Sep 15, 2025
#21397
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons signed Kirk Cousins as a smoke screen to draft Michael Penix Jr.

I think that the Falcons when they, they probably signed Kirk Cousins and said, Hey, this is a smoke screen. No one's gonna think that we're gonna draft Michael Penix. So a fall to us. So let's just pay this guy a hundred million dollars. So we get our guy and it worked.

It's an interpretation of the Falcons' front office strategy which cannot be definitively proven true or false.

Who's Back of the Week featured the return of boxing, Ken Rosenthal's terrifying death stare on the sidelines, and our new best friends at Twisted Tea.

At least we still have 15 weeks of this to figure out who actually sucks.

nflbearslionschiefseaglesfastest-2-minutespinky-bet

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers