Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 5, Fastest 2 Minutes, Eagles Horrific Loss, The Worst Tie Ever, Bears Get Punk'd And A Seahawks/Niners Classic Plus Who's Back And MLB Playoffs

Monday, October 12, 202617 takes · Transcript ↓

Fastest 2 Minutes and then we talk every game on Sunday (-) Jaguars 19, Eagles 17 (-) Giants 27, Commanders 27 (-) Packers 31, Bears 7 (-) Patriots 45, Raiders 17 (-) Steelers 34, Colts 22 (-) Jets 17, Browns 12 (-) Bengals 31, Dolphins 24 (-) Vikings 23, Saints 13 (-) Texans 26, Titans 3 (-) Broncos 23, Chargers 17 (-) Lions 45, Cardinals 21 (-) 49ers 32, Seahawks 29 (-) Ravens 30, Falcons 23 (-) We then talk playoff baseball and who's back of the weekYou can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or Netflix. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/pardon-my-take

Week 5 delivered exactly the kind of football Sunday that makes the Sickos and Perverts proud: an Eagles collapse in London, a tie so poorly managed it felt fictional, the Bears getting pantsed in Green Bay, and Drake Maye turning into the quarterback Hank has been waiting for his entire life. Big Cat, PFT, Max, Memes, Zac, and Hank went game by game through the wreckage, with plenty of time left over to diagnose Ben Simmons' jump shot and the future of human-versus-robot combat.

Eagles Lose the Impossible Game

Max's Eagles had the Jaguars dead. They were underdogs, played good defense, survived a chaotic game, and kicked a field goal with eight seconds left to supposedly win it. Then Jake Elliott sent a line drive directly to Amir Abdullah, who returned it into Cam Little's range. No timeouts. Eight seconds. A perfect nightmare.

Big Cat pointed out that two games ending with field goals inside the final 10 seconds had happened in the entire Super Bowl era before this season. Now it has happened twice in 2026, because apparently the NFL's new official rule is that nobody is allowed to simply end a football game normally.

Win
Oct 12, 2026
#31622
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles blew a historic late-game situation

From 1970, the Super Bowl era, to 2026, it had never happened where there were two field goals under 10 seconds to end a game. It's now happened twice in the 2026 NFL season.

The claim is presented as a historical statistical fact in the episode; no contrary information is available in the transcript.

Max was not interested in calling it bad luck. He delivered a furious instructional video on the revolutionary concept of kicking the ball out of the end zone and trusting Jalen Carter and the defense to stop one desperate play.

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31623
MaxMax

The Eagles should have trusted their defense and kicked it out of the end zone

You just kick it out of bounds. You kick it into the end zone. All you have to do at that point is defend the sideline. Anything in play is game over. And the defense has been so fucking good all game. Why are you overthinking it? Just fucking do it. Put the ball in the fucking end zone and trust your fucking defense.

This is an evaluative coaching opinion that cannot be definitively judged.

The Eagles' second-half offense also remains a crime scene. Max described a team that looks like a real football team for two quarters, then turns into a peewee squad that has never seen a huddle before. Nick Sirianni will once again be at the podium explaining that he needs to look in the mirror, prompting PFT to suggest that Sirianni needs either a better mirror or fewer mirrors.

The Commanders Lose a Tie

Washington and the Giants produced the most Commanders ending imaginable. Jayden Daniels got to the Giants' 24-yard line in overtime with no timeouts, took his time, ran a play that looked like a fake handoff to nobody, dove at a defender, and then sat on the field while the clock continued to exist.

PFT split the blame 75/25 between Daniels and Dan Quinn, but admitted Quinn will probably be the one eating it. The larger problem was that Washington had already punted on fourth-and-five in overtime, a decision PFT labeled the most cowardly punt of the season. The Giants later fumbled away their own winning position, only for Washington to immediately return the favor by forgetting how clocks work.

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31624
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jayden Daniels deserves most of the blame for the tie-ending brain fart

On the last play, without us knowing everything, I'm gonna say 75% Jayden, 25% Dan Quinn. Now who's gonna end up eating shit for it? Probably Dan Quinn.

This is a subjective allocation of responsibility for a play.

The tie was so bad that PFT still thinks Washington can win the NFC East, mostly because the division is apparently being held together with duct tape and bad situational football.

Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31625
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders can still win the NFC East

Strictly from how we played today, taking away that very last-second brain fart, I think that we still could, because the division is ass.

The Commanders' final NFC East standing is not established in the transcript and must be determined after the season.

The Bears Get Punked in Green Bay

Big Cat's Bears went into Lambeau looking like the team that had spent the offseason feeling good about itself. The Packers looked like the team that had spent the offseason thinking about nothing except revenge. Jordan Love threw bombs, Christian Watson was everywhere, and Chicago was down 130-9 in the first quarter before anyone had time to emotionally prepare.

Tyson Bagent did not help. Big Cat was done trying to pretend the backup could make throws he simply cannot make, while also begging for Caleb Williams to get healthy. The Bears defense, meanwhile, got a firsthand demonstration of what happens when the opposing quarterback is capable of throwing the ball over the top.

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31626
Big CatBig Cat

Tyson Bagent is not an NFL quarterback

Tyson Bagent, not an NFL quarterback. I think we could be done with that.

Whether Bagent is an NFL-caliber player is partly evaluative; the stronger statement is not objectively resolvable from this episode alone.

The verdict was not that the Bears' season is over. It was that this particular game should be burned so thoroughly that nobody can ever find the tape again. The problem is that Atlanta is next, Caleb's status is uncertain, and the defense still has to prove it can survive a good offense without pretending Carson Wentz and Gino Smith are measuring sticks.

Drake Maye Is Very Much Back

Hank got his perfect Sunday. The Jets won, the Patriots destroyed the Raiders 45-17, and Drake Maye played the best game of his young career while the 2001 Patriots were honored in Foxborough. The deep ball was working, the protection held up, and the entire afternoon had the unmistakable feel of a franchise discovering that its quarterback might actually be good.

Hank called Maye perfect. PFT went even further, handing him the MVP label with the only reasonable qualifier: keep playing like this.

Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31627
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If Drake Maye keeps playing like this, he is the MVP

He was perfect. The deep ball was magical. Everything was great. He played awesome. I have absolutely zero criticism of Drake Maye this week. He looked like, if he plays like this, he is the MVP.

The 2026 NFL MVP outcome is not known from the episode and remains to be decided.

Big Cat did develop one new gambling doctrine from the game: Kirk Cousins is an indoor cat. Outdoor Kirk looked old, uncomfortable, and generally like he had just been informed that the thermostat was broken.

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31628
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins cannot be bet outdoors

I think we just can't bet Kirk Cousins outdoors anymore. I think he's an indoor cat.

This is a deliberately broad betting opinion rather than a precisely testable claim.

Jets Fever, Cam Ward Panic

Memes called the Jets' 17-12 win over Cleveland a historic victory, which is exactly the kind of sentence that becomes dangerous when it is said with a straight face. Aaron Glenn blitzed Deshaun Watson into the rain, David Bailey lived in the backfield, and Braylon Allen supplied the late touchdown that kept New York from doing what New York usually does in that spot.

Memes immediately put the Jets at 3-3 with control of the AFC East, while Hank made it clear that losing to New York would end the Patriots season psychologically and possibly require changing the name of the franchise. This is how rivalry week should feel, especially when one team is already discussing using the other team's every available orifice as part of the wager.

Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31630
MemesMemes

The Jets control their destiny in the division

If you win the game, you're three and three. The Patriots are three and three. You control your own destiny in the division.

The Jets' eventual AFC East position and whether the win becomes a turning point are unresolved.

The Titans, meanwhile, lost 26-3 to Houston and made Cam Ward look like a quarterback trapped inside a slow-motion loading screen. Big Cat is already looking toward the next draft for Tennessee's next answer, which is a fairly brutal conclusion after five games.

Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31631
Big CatBig Cat

The Titans should already be looking for another quarterback

I'm not saying not playing Cam Ward this year, but you have to look elsewhere. Next year might be, let's draft a quarterback.

Whether Tennessee drafts another quarterback and moves on from Ward cannot be determined until future roster decisions occur.

The 49ers Look Like the Team

San Francisco survived a turnover festival against Seattle and still came away 5-0. Mike Evans kept making enormous catches, Brock Purdy had enough help around him to avoid needing to be perfect, and the defense looked like it had decided the Seahawks were not allowed to have a clean drive.

PFT made the obvious but still spicy declaration: the 49ers are the best team in football. The roster argument is compelling. Quarterback, running back, receiver, tight end, left tackle, linebacker, coaching, and now Mike Evans looking like the biggest guy on the field every time the ball is in the air. The only real counterargument is the traditional San Francisco one: please stay healthy.

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31632
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 49ers are the best team in football

I think the 49ers are the best team in football.

The best team in football is a season-long evaluative judgment and cannot be definitively resolved until the season's results are complete.

Who's Back, and Who Is Fighting Robots?

Who's Back began with Hank discovering that Michael Brennan won in Japan and then immediately admitting he had stopped watching. It moved to the Celtics, where Hank finally allowed the possibility that Jalen Brown and Jayson Tatum might not be best friends after all. This was a significant development in Hank's long-running campaign to insist that everything with Boston is fine.

PFT then watched a few preseason clips and decided Ben Simmons' jump shot might be back. The evidence included a made free throw, which is exactly the sort of foundation on which a responsible basketball prediction should be built.

Big Cat's baseball segment covered the White Sox striking out 75 times in 45 innings and watching a surprisingly fun season end in the most painful possible way. Jose Ramirez hit a home run off what appeared to be his shoelace, while Big Cat argued that this entire competitive-but-not-quite-good-enough season was precisely the sort of thing Jerry Reinsdorf dreams about.

The show closed by considering a robot-versus-human fight league. PFT proposed equal human and robot representation on the governing board, then everyone watched a very large robot throw spinning elbows while asking the obvious question: why are we teaching the robots how to fight us?

The Eagles lost a game they had already won, the Commanders tied a game they had already won, and Max may soon be taking ownership of Memes' suspiciously tiny chair. Just another perfectly normal Monday at PMT.

nfl-week-5eaglesdrake-mayecommanders49ersmlb-playoffsben-simmons

More Takes

Void
Oct 12, 2026
#31638
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Dan Quinn made the cowardly punt of the season

Dan Quinn had the most cowardly punt of the NFL season so far, when he punted the ball away in overtime at fourth and five and gave the ball up.

Whether the punt was the correct decision is a subjective coaching evaluation.
Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31629
Big CatBig Cat

The Steelers will win nine or ten games and probably lose in the playoffs

The Steelers are just gonna do this. They're gonna go week to week. Their offense definitely has more pop than it did last year. Their defense probably isn't as good. Although their defense stood up strong in the red zone. And the Steelers are gonna win nine or 10 games and probably lose the playoff.

The Steelers' regular-season win total and playoff result are not yet resolved in the episode's season context.
Open
Oct 12, 2026
#31633
ZacZac

The Ravens could go unnecessarily far this season

This could be a catalyst for the Ravens. The Ravens could go unnecessarily far this season.

The Ravens' ultimate postseason result is unresolved at the time of the episode.
Void
Oct 12, 2026·Who's Back
#31634
HankHank

Jalen Brown and Jayson Tatum might hate each other

Jalen Brown and Jayson Tatum might hate each other. I thought they were, I really don't know anymore. It was a little odd.

The private relationship between Brown and Tatum cannot be definitively judged from a preseason interaction.
Open
Oct 12, 2026·Who's Back
#31635
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ben Simmons' jump shot might be back

I think the jump shot might be back. Dare I say maybe fixed.

Whether Simmons' shooting has genuinely returned requires meaningful regular-season evidence and is not resolved by the episode's clips.
Void
Oct 12, 2026·Who's Back
#31636
Big CatBig Cat

The White Sox were Jerry Reinsdorf's perfect wet dream

This is Jerry Reinsdorf's wet dream: to have a team that he doesn't have to spend money on be just competitive enough to give you hope that you could win the division, get some home playoff games, then next year be like, 'Hey, we're gonna do it.'

This is an interpretation of an owner's incentives and is inherently subjective.
Void
Oct 12, 2026·Who's Back
#31637
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Robot combat needs equal human and robot representation

If you're going to sanction it and you have to have a board, I feel like it needs to be equal parts represented by humans and robots on the board.

This is a comedic opinion about how a hypothetical robot combat governing body should be structured.

Transcript

Loading transcript…

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!