Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 5, Fastest 2 Minutes, The Cowboys Got Whomped, Lions Are For Real And Tons More

Monday, October 9, 202325 takes

Week 5 in the NFL We start with Fastest 2 Minutes. We then get into every game from Sunday (-) Niners 42, Cowboys 10 (-) Jaguars 25, Bills 20 (-) Steelers 17, Ravens 10 (-) Colts 23, Titans 16 (-) Lions 42, Panthers 24 (-) Saints 34, Patriots 0 (-) Falcons 21, Texans 19 (- Dolphins 31, Giants 16 (-) Eagles 23, Rams 14 (-) Bengals 34, Cardinals 20 (-) Jets 31, Broncos 21 (-) Chiefs 27, Vikings 20 (-) We finish with who's back of the week and some playoff baseball talk. (-)

Week 5 Recap: Cowboys Get Whomped, Lions Are For Real, and the Patriots Hit Rock Bottom

Week 5 is in the books, and it felt like the Sunday where the pretenders finally got exposed. Taping in the middle of Surviving Barstool meant things were a bit chaotic in the New York office, but nothing was more chaotic than watching Dak Prescott and the Cowboys get absolutely dismantled by the 49ers in prime time. It was a measuring stick game, and as PFT Commenter pointed out, the stick was mostly being used to kick the Cowboys' asses.

The NFC Hierarchy is Set

While the Cowboys were getting exposed, the 49ers solidified themselves as the clear class of the league. George Kittle had three touchdowns, and the Brock Purdy discourse has reached a point where his play is simply undeniable. Big Cat made it clear that if you aren't on the Purdy train by now, you're just not watching the football games.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19646
Big CatBig Cat

Brock Purdy is 100% a top 10 quarterback

Brock Purdy is 100% a top 10 quarterback. If you disagree, you aren't watching the games. Brock Purdy is just good. He's just very good.

Purdy finished the season as a Pro Bowler, led the league in passer rating, and was an MVP finalist. He is widely considered a top 10 QB by metrics and most analysts.

Purdy looks like a franchise guy, and his efficiency has the Niners looking like the early favorites to take it all. PFT isn't just calling them contenders; he thinks they're the best team in the world right now.

Push
Oct 9, 2023
#19645
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 49ers would win the Super Bowl if it were played today

The 49ers. Congratulations. The 49ers. They won the Week five Super Bowl. If the Super Bowl were played today, I say that the 49ers would win easily.

The 49ers were the #1 seed and reached the Super Bowl, though they eventually lost to the Chiefs in overtime. At this specific point in the season, they were arguably the best team.

Beyond San Francisco, the hierarchy in the NFC is becoming very exclusive. The guys agreed that there is a massive gap between the elite tier and the rest of the conference.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19647
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles, 49ers, and Lions are the only three really good teams in the NFC

I feel like today was a day that we found out there are three really, really good teams in the NFC and then there's everyone else. I'm referring to the Philadelphia Eagles, the San Francisco 49ers and the Detroit Lions.

These three teams were indeed the top three seeds in the NFC and the last three NFC teams standing in the playoffs.

London Calling and Grounding the Bills

The Jaguars continued their residency in London by knocking off the Bills, who looked like they were running on three hours of sleep and a dream. Buffalo's decision to fly out so late in the week backfired spectacularly as they sleepwalked through the first half. Big Cat was baffled by the travel logistics, noting that the Bills basically gave the game away before it even started.

Void
Oct 9, 2023
#25535
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills threw away the Jaguars game because of their terrible travel schedule to London.

The Bill's schedule to go to London... made no sense. ... They actually looked like they were sleepwalking in the first half. ... The Bills basically threw this game away with how they travel.

Subjective claim about the cause of a loss, though the Bills did start very slowly in that game.

PFT, ever the innovator, suggested a more medical approach to international travel for future teams looking to avoid the "sleepyhead" Josh Allen performance.

Loss
Oct 9, 2023
#19649
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL teams should fly to London earlier and use medically induced comas to acclimate

What should happen is the moment you get a chance, like maybe that Monday... you put your guys in medically induced coma, knocked them out, put them onto London time, get their body naturally acclimated, fly them over while they're all knocked out. And then you get there, you practice through the week. You use a copious amount of drugs to put them asleep at night and wake them up in the morning.

This is a medical impossibility and highly illegal, though the Bills did play 'sleepy' as he noted.

AFC North Grittiness and the Best Backup

Steelers-Ravens was exactly what we expected: ugly, violent, and full of drops. The Ravens wide receivers seemed to have hands made of stone, dropping multiple touchdowns that would have put the game away. Meanwhile, Jalen Warren continues to look like the most explosive player in the Steelers' backfield, leading to PFT calling for a change in the depth chart.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19650
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jalen Warren should be getting Najee Harris's touches for the Steelers

Jalen Warren should get Najee Harris' touches. He's so good. So much better than Najee Harris. Anybody with eyes can see Jalen Warren carry the ball and be like, this guy has 10 times the burst Najee has.

Warren continued to outproduce Najee in efficiency (5.3 vs 4.1 YPC) throughout the season, leading to a much more even split by season's end.

Over in Indy, Gardner Minshew continues to be the ultimate safety net. With Anthony Richardson going down again, Minshew stepped in and navigated a seven-minute fourth-quarter drive to bury the Titans. Big Cat is officially calling him the premier insurance policy in the NFL.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#25536
Big CatBig Cat

Gardner Minshew is the best backup quarterback in the NFL.

Gardner Minshew is the best backup in the league. ... He has now had to come in what, three times this year. And the Colts are three and two.

Minshew went on to start most of the season for Indy, nearly leading them to the playoffs and making the Pro Bowl as an alternate.

Rock Bottom in Foxborough

Hank is officially in the darkness. The Patriots were shut out 34-0 at home by the Saints, marking the worst two-week stretch in Bill Belichick's legendary career. Mac Jones has more pick-sixes at Gillette Stadium than Tom Brady, and the offense hasn't scored in ten quarters. Hank is ready to burn it all down and start over with a very specific centerpiece.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19652
HankHank

The Patriots should rebuild around the lighthouse and fire Bill Belichick and Mac Jones

The lighthouse is all we got. That's really the only, like, I think you rebuild around the lighthouse. Get rid of Belichick, get rid of Mac Jones and just build around the lighthouse. Build an entire team around the lighthouse.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
The Patriots did eventually move on from both Mac Jones and Bill Belichick after the season.

As the Patriots' season spirals, PFT floated a conspiracy theory that Belichick might be sabotaging the roster on his way out the door, possibly looking toward a homecoming in Nashville with the Titans.

Loss
Oct 9, 2023
#19653
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill Belichick is ruining the Patriots on purpose to make them easier to beat when he joins a new team

I think he's ruining the Patriots because he's gonna go somewhere else and then he'll make the Patriots easier to beat when he's at the next location. Vrabel to the Patriots Belichick to the Titans... Vanderbilt is where my dad coached Nashville is where I was born... It's coming home.

Belichick did leave the Patriots, but he did not join the Titans; he remained a free agent and media personality for the 2024 season.

Quick Hits and Overly Direct Takes

The Lions are no longer a feel-good story; they are a legitimate powerhouse. Even without Amon-Ra St. Brown and Jahmyr Gibbs, they hung 42 on the Panthers. PFT is convinced this roster is one of the most complete in football.

Win
Oct 9, 2023
#25537
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Lions have one of the best rosters in the NFL and are almost a 'great' team.

If you look objectively at their roster right now, they're one of the best rosters in the NFL. ... Lions are almost a great team.

The Lions backed this up by winning the NFC North and reaching the NFC Championship game.

In Denver, the Nathaniel Hackett revenge game was a success, as the Jets took down Sean Payton’s Broncos. Big Cat couldn't help but point out that Hackett actually managed to make Zach Wilson look more competent than Payton has made Russell Wilson look all year.

Void
Oct 9, 2023
#25540
Big CatBig Cat

Nathaniel Hackett did a better job coaching Zach Wilson than Sean Peyton did coaching Russell Wilson.

Nathaniel Hackett coached Zach Wilson and made him look better than Sean Peyton coached Russell Wilson and made him look. That's just a fact.

Subjective comparison of two struggling QBs, though Zach Wilson did outplay Russ in the head-to-head matchup.

To wrap things up, the crew delivered some Overly Direct Takes, including a bold ranking for the Niners' signal-caller and a grim prediction for the NFL's most famous new couple.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brock Purdy is a top five quarterback in the NFL

My overly direct take... Brock Purdy this year is a top five quarterback in the NFL. I like it. Top five. I think he's number five in the NFL right now... If he gets to a Super Bowl, I'm gonna say it. Brock Purdy might be elite.

Purdy finished the 2023 season 4th in MVP voting, arguably making him a top 5 QB for that specific season by consensus voting.
Loss
HankHank

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift are going to break up soon

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift... we're gonna break up. Allegedly. She's gotta go back out on tour. Travis has got some rehabbing to do with the injury...

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift remained in a high-profile relationship throughout 2023 and 2024.

At least we still have the bank and the Phillies to keep Max screaming until his eyes well up with tears of joy.

nflcowboys49erslionspatriotsbillssteelers

More Takes

Push
Oct 9, 2023
#19648
HankHank

The Cowboys will get smoked if they make it past the divisional round of the playoffs

This team [Cowboys] might make it to the divisional round of the playoffs. They're gonna get smoked if they make it any, anywhere past that. And you can't feel any differently.

The Cowboys actually lost in the Wild Card round to the Packers, so they didn't even make it to the divisional round where Hank thought they might get 'smoked'.
Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19651
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Panthers will get their first win of the season at home against the Falcons.

They might win that one [against the Falcons]. I think they might win that one. Yeah. ... There's gonna be, they're gonna beat the Falcons at home.

The Panthers defeated the Falcons 9-7 at home on December 17, 2023.
Loss
Oct 9, 2023
#25538
Big CatBig Cat

I still believe Bryce Young is going to be a good NFL quarterback despite his early struggles.

I still think Bryce Young's gonna be good... I just watched him so much in college and I'm like, he can't be that bad and he's playing on a bad team, so I'm just gonna keep holding out hope.

Young continued to struggle throughout his rookie year and was benched early in his second season (2024) after a poor start.
Win
Oct 9, 2023
#25539
HankHank

I wouldn't be surprised if Bill Belichick wants to leave the Patriots.

I think Belichick, whatever he wants to do... I wouldn't be surprised if he is like, 'I need to get the fuck outta here.'

Belichick and the Patriots mutually agreed to part ways following the conclusion of the 2023 season.
Void
Oct 9, 2023
#19654
Big CatBig Cat

CJ Stroud needs to throw a reckless triple-coverage interception to be a true gunslinger

I'd like him to just throw a ball that, you know, there's no chance it's gonna be completed... he needs to throw a reckless interception. Like triple coverage. Just trying to do it all in arm strength.

Stroud eventually threw his first interception the following week against the Saints. He maintained an elite TD-to-INT ratio throughout the season.
Win
Oct 9, 2023
#19655
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

It is 'loser shit' to ban the Brotherly Shove just because defenses can't stop it

The NFL actually might stop it... which is it's, that's loser shit right there. Listen, I'm saying this as a Commanders fan, as a division rival, it's loser shit to ban the brotherly shove because just 'cause you can't stop it doesn't mean that they shouldn't be able to do it.

The NFL ultimately decided not to ban the play for the 2024 season, agreeing with the sentiment that it is a legal football play.
Void
Oct 9, 2023
#19656
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Zach Wilson is the third-best quarterback in the AFC East

I think objectively speaking, you can say that Zach Wilson is the third best quarterback in the AFC East. Big difference. Russell Wilson stinks and what we said, he looked okay the first four games, but he had to play a real defense for once.

By season's end, both Jones and Wilson were benched. Most metrics would place Tua Tagovailoa and Josh Allen 1-2, leaving the 3-spot for a debate between the benched Wilson and Jones.
Loss
Oct 9, 2023
#19657
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Justin Ross could be the next breakout star for the Chiefs' wide receiver corps

Justin Ross had a great catch today. Incredible catch. He is. They're gonna unlock him at some point this year. You saw one great catch from him. He's a massive target... Justin Ross could be the next guy up for the Chiefs wide receiver corps.

Ross never truly 'broke out' in 2023, finishing with only 6 receptions for 53 yards on the season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers are going to kick the shit out of the Raiders on Monday night

My overly direct take is Monday Night Football. I hate betting on this team, but I think the Packers are gonna kick the shit outta the Raiders.

The Raiders won the game 17-13.
Loss
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Mac Jones will be benched by Halloween

My overly direct take... is that Mac Jones will be benched before Halloween. Just benched. For Bailey Zappy maybe.

Mac Jones started through Week 12 and was not officially replaced by Bailey Zappe as the full-time starter until late November.
Loss
Oct 9, 2023·Who's Back
#19662
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Colorado Avalanche will win the Stanley Cup

I've got the B's avalanche. I'll go with you on the Avalanche Hank. I've got back to back. [Vegas] I've got the avalanche.

The Florida Panthers eventually won the Stanley Cup. The Avalanche were eliminated in the second round.
Win
Oct 9, 2023·Who's Back
#25541
Big CatBig Cat

Miami's loss to Georgia Tech is the literal worst loss of all time.

Miami maybe the worst loss of all time. The literal worst loss of all time. Mario Cristobal with 35 seconds left, ran the ball instead of kneeing the ball. ... Incomprehensible.

Widely considered one of the worst coaching blunders in college football history because kneeling would have 100% guaranteed a victory.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers