Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Week 9, Fastest 2 Minutes, The Bears Are A Disaster, The Lions Are Unstoppable + Jason Kelce And Joel Embiid Stepped To The Haters

Monday, November 4, 202423 takes

NFL Week 9 and we start with fastest 2 minutes. We then recap every game from Sunday (-) Bills 30, Dolphins 27 (-) Falcons 27, Cowboys 21 (-) Ravens 41, Broncos 10 (-) Commanders 27, Giants 22 (-) Chargers 27, Browns 10 (-) Bengals 41, Raiders 24 (-) Panthers 23, Saints 22 (-) Titans 20, Patriots 17 (-) Cardinals, 29, Bears 9 (-) Lions 24, Packers 14 (-) Eagles 28, Jaguars 23 (-) Rams 26, Seahawks 20 (-) Vikings 21, Colts 13 (-) We finish with who's back of the week including Embiid and Kelce and Justice for Peanut the squirrel. (-).

NFL Week 9: Lions Reign Supreme, Bears Meltdown, and Philly Fights Back

Week 9 is in the books, and while the witching hour didn't quite deliver the chaos of last week, the landscape of the NFL is becoming crystal clear. The Detroit Lions went into the frozen tundra—which was actually just a very rainy Lambeau Field—and proved they are the class of the NFC. They didn't even need to play their best football to dismantle the Packers, benefiting from Jordan Love's penchant for back-breaking interceptions and a defense that simply punishes mistakes. Big Cat is officially ready to crown them.

Void
Nov 4, 2024
#16722
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions are currently the best team in the NFL

I'll say it, the Chiefs are undefeated, but I think the Lions is the best team in the NFL right now. If they were playing next week, I would take the Lions.

The Lions finished the regular season with the best record in the NFC (14-3) and were widely considered the best team alongside the Chiefs.

While the Lions are soaring, the Chicago Bears are currently a crime scene. Big Cat is dealing with four kidney stones, but he's adamant that watching the Bears lose to the Cardinals was the most painful part of his weekend. The team looks like it has completely quit on Matt Eberflus, who is now 0-18 on Sunday road games. It was a lifeless, garbage performance that has the city of Chicago calling for heads to roll immediately.

Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16717
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Eberflus is a loser and needs to be fired immediately

Matt Eberflus is a loser and he needs to be fired, which he won't be because the Bears will never fire a coach in the middle of the season... This team quit. It's an utter disaster. Lifeless garbage. He's never gotten on a plane on a Sunday been like, 'great win boys.' It's never happened.

Matt Eberflus was eventually fired on November 30, 2024.

The concern in Chicago has shifted from playoff hopes to the literal safety of their franchise savior. Caleb Williams was left in the game during garbage time and ended up hobbling around after a late hit. The offensive line surrendered pressure on nearly half of his dropbacks against a Cardinals defense that doesn't usually breathe on anyone.

Void
Nov 4, 2024
#26574
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are at serious risk of breaking Caleb Williams

You gotta worry about them breaking Caleb. It's now Defcon red. I'm convinced it's gonna happen now. He was scrambling, he shrugged and threw his arms up like, 'what the fuck am I supposed to do?' At that point you're like, this guy is teetering.

Subjective take on the developmental trajectory of a quarterback.

Over in Buffalo, the Bills continued their reign of terror over the Miami Dolphins. Tyler Bass redeemed himself with a monster 61-yard game-winner, but the story remains the ownership Josh Allen has over that entire franchise. Even on a day where they started slow, the outcome felt inevitable because, as Big Cat points out, the hierarchy in the AFC East hasn't changed.

Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16699
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen and the Bills are the Miami Dolphins' daddy

Josh Allen and Sean McDermott and the Buffalo Bills continue to be the Miami Dolphins Daddy. Sean McDermott's now 15 and 2 against the Dolphins.

Sean McDermott's record against the Dolphins is indeed 15-2 after this game.

With the Bills sitting at 7-2 and the rest of the division rotting, the conversation has naturally shifted to the MVP race. Lamar Jackson is the frontrunner, but Allen’s ability to drag this Bills roster to wins cannot be ignored.

Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#26570
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen should be in the MVP conversation

Josh Allen should definitely be in the MVP conversation. He should be very much in it. Lamar [Jackson] probably should win it again because he's been insane, but so is Josh. Josh has been really good too.

Josh Allen finished as a finalist but Lamar Jackson won the MVP award for the 2024 season.

In the late window, Max was on the verge of a full-blown meltdown during the Eagles' narrow win over the Jaguars. Nick Sirianni continued to make baffling in-game decisions, including a 57-yard field goal attempt that made zero sense mathematically. However, the Eagles' talent—specifically Saquon Barkley's physics-defying backward hurdle—overcame the coaching hurdles. Max is convinced this backfield has reached elite status.

Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16727
MaxMax

Saquon Barkley is on the Christian McCaffrey level

I think it's fair to say that [Saquon Barkley] is on the McCaffrey level of like, he's a running back that can actually make a difference in your offense. He's so good. If they're one-on-one in space, the defense can't do anything.

Barkley finished as an All-Pro and OPOY contender, proving he is in that top tier.

The Chargers also took care of business against a Jamis Winston-led Browns team that regressed to the mean. Jim Harbaugh has transformed the Chargers from a team that finds creative ways to lose into a fundamentally sound unit that simply out-toughs opponents. Big Cat is all-in on them being a factor come January.

Win
Nov 4, 2024
#26573
Big CatBig Cat

The Chargers will secure an AFC Wild Card spot

There's those two [wildcard] spots left. And I think the Chargers are one of those two spots. Out of those five teams [Chargers, Broncos, Colts, Bengals, Jets], I think the Chargers are one of the two best.

The Chargers finished the season 11-6 and qualified for the AFC playoffs.

We wrapped things up with a heavy Who's Back segment featuring the city of Philadelphia fighting back against the haters. Jason Kelce spiked a kid's phone after having a slur hurled at him regarding his brother, and Joel Embiid reportedly shoved a reporter who brought up his late brother in a column. The guys are standing firmly with the athletes on this one.

Void
Nov 4, 2024·Who's Back
#16730
Big CatBig Cat

Jason Kelce was in the right for smashing that kid's phone

Jason Kelce turned around, grabbed his phone, smashed it through the crust of the earth, awesome spike... I have no problem with that guy brought the F-word into it. He was very clearly harassing him. I stand with Jason Kelce.

Subjective opinion on a viral incident.
Void
Nov 4, 2024·Who's Back
#16733
Big CatBig Cat

Joel Embiid was justified in shoving the reporter

I am on Joel Embiid's side. This reporter Marcus Hayes wrote an article basically calling Joel Embiid... calling out his dead brother. You don't have to bring up Joel Embiid's family. Talk shit, get hit.

Subjective opinion on a player-media confrontation.

Between the NFL action and the return of college hoops, there’s almost too much to track, but at least we know Peanut the Squirrel is finally at peace away from the New York bureaucracy.

See you on Wednesday, hopefully with fewer kidney stones and more competence from the Bears.

nfl-week-9detroit-lionschicago-bearsphiladelphia-eaglesjason-kelcejoel-embiidnfl-recap

More Takes

Void
Nov 4, 2024
#16700
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Dolphins are the best two-win team in the NFL

I think the Dolphins are by far the best two win team in the NFL.

Subjective comparison between 2-win teams like the Browns, Titans, and Jaguars.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16701
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys are a bad football team with a lot of holes

The Cowboys are not good. They're not a good football team. They're not a playoff team. They have a lot of holes. They like building the entire offense out of just CD Lamb does not make any sense.

The Cowboys finished 6-11 and missed the playoffs, confirming they were not a good team in 2024.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#16702
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys should trade Micah Parsons

I actually think they should trade Micah Parsons. They never will. But that would be the smart move for Jerry Jones. So if you're like, if you signed Dak Prescott to a big deal and you're like, he's the quarterback, you need some draft picks. You need to start like getting depth around him.

The Cowboys did not trade Micah Parsons at the 2024 deadline.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#26571
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Broncos could make the playoffs

The Ravens are light years better than the Broncos right now, but I could see the Broncos making the playoffs. That could happen. I think their defense is good enough to keep 'em in it and in the conversation.

The Denver Broncos finished the 2024 season with a winning record and qualified for the AFC playoffs.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#16705
Big CatBig Cat

Derrick Henry is officially on 2,000-yard watch

Derrick Henry... reached a thousand yards. We're on 2,000 yard watch. He is 1052 yards on the season. We are officially on 2,000 yard watch for Derrick Henry.

Derrick Henry finished the 2024 season with 1,777 rushing yards, falling short of the 2,000-yard mark.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#16708
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders could reach the NFC Championship if they beat the Steelers and Eagles

If we somehow beat the Steelers and the Eagles... I could see us potentially getting to the NFC Championship game. And you wouldn't have a road game until the NFC Championship game.

The Commanders lost both games to the Steelers and Eagles following this take and were eliminated in the Wild Card round.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#26572
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Commanders will win 11 or 12 games this season

If I'm looking at the schedule right now, I think saying 11 or 12 wins is very, very possible. And I don't think I'm being delusional when I say that.

The Commanders finished the season 7-10, losing every game following this podcast.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16709
Big CatBig Cat

The Chargers have an identity and Jim Harbaugh is the reason

What Harbaugh does when you get a guy like Jim Harbaugh, he gives your team an identity. The Chargers have an identity. They play tough, hard football. And when you have an identity, you can win games.

The Chargers made the playoffs with an 11-6 record, largely credited to their improved toughness and defense under Harbaugh.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16711
Big CatBig Cat

Dennis Allen is one of the worst NFL head coaches of all time

Dennis Allen is the third worst NFL head coach of all time. He's now 26 and 52 as a head coach. And there's only two head coaches in history who have coached as many games as he has with a worse losing percentage. I don't know how he's still employed.

Dennis Allen was fired on November 4, 2024, with a 26-53 career record.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#16714
HankHank

The Patriots should draft Travis Hunter

I feel like you gotta take the best player in college football. Travis Hunter... you get two players for one with him. It's tremendous value. Defensively, that'd be unstoppable with Christian Gonzalez.

The Patriots did not draft Travis Hunter. He was selected 2nd overall by the Jacksonville Jaguars. The Patriots' 1st overall pick was Cam Ward, a quarterback.
Loss
Nov 4, 2024
#16719
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will eventually hire Lincoln Riley and it will be a disaster

You know who they're gonna get? They're gonna get stinking Riley. He's gonna bolt from USC and that's going to be a disaster. We're gonna, and he's gonna get Caleb Williams playing good football and that defense is gonna erode.

The Bears did not hire Lincoln Riley; Riley remained at USC and the Bears hired Thomas Brown as OC then searched for a new HC in the 2025 cycle.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#26575
Big CatBig Cat

The Cardinals are a good team and Jonathan Gannon is a good coach

Cardinals are good. I'm buying on the Cardinal stock. I mean, they credit to the Cardinals. I think they're a pretty good team. I made fun of Jonathan Gannon, but he's a good head coach.

The Cardinals won the NFC West in 2024, validating Big Cat's 'stock' purchase.
Win
Nov 4, 2024
#16725
MaxMax

If the Eagles beat the Cowboys and Commanders, they can beat the Lions

If we go two and oh these next two [Cowboys and Commanders], I'm thinking there's no reason we can't beat the Lions. We can beat the Lions.

The Eagles did go 2-0 against Dallas and Washington, becoming a top NFC contender.
Win
Nov 4, 2024·Who's Back
#26576
MaxMax

The 76ers will make the playoffs

They're gonna make the playoffs. Paul George is playing tonight. What are we gonna do five games into the season? They're gonna make the playoffs.

The 76ers eventually made the postseason via the play-in tournament.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers