Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Scott Van Pelt Live From Augusta, Rory Wins An Incredible Masters, NBA Playoffs Set, Who's Back And Monday Reading

Monday, April 14, 202518 takes

An all time Sunday at August leads us to Rory McIlroy's career grand slam. We talk about the incredible drama on Sunday and the up and down play from Rory that led us to his playoff against Justin Rose. Wrapping up other Master thoughts/storylines (-). NBA Playoffs are set and Lebron having his shirt off offended Isiah Thomas (-). Tennessee loses their quarterback and we NIL has gone sideways (-). Who's back of the week including Paddy the Baddy, Coach Gruden in Madison, and PFT's kidney stones (-). Scott Van Pelt joins us from Augusta to talk Masters, Rory getting the monkey off his back, the sights and sounds from an insane 4th round and an update on the Big Texas (-). We finish with a Monday reading and a conclusion to Jim Nantz's wallet toast card and lottery numbers (-).

Scott Van Pelt on Rory’s Career Slam, NBA Playoff Seeding, and Nico Iamaleava

Monday’s show opens with the unimaginable: the hater narrative is officially dead. Rory McIlroy has completed the Career Grand Slam with a Masters victory that was as chaotic as any round of golf in history. Big Cat and PFT admit that while they spent the weekend praying for a classic Rory collapse, watching him battle through doubles and bogies to beat Justin Rose in a playoff was the most entertaining outcome possible.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5649
Big CatBig Cat

I would rather have a set of guys I hate in golf than root for whoever wins

I would rather have a set of guys that I root for and a set of guys I hate than be like, I'm just rooting for whoever wins. And then when they win, I say, what a great story. Rory deserved it.

This is a subjective philosophy on how to enjoy sports.

Big Cat confesses that even as a hater, he had to tip his cap to the resilience Rory showed. From a double bogey on the first hole to the miraculous shot on 15, it wasn't a clean win, but it was a legendary one. PFT points out that the victory effectively breaks the show’s favorite bit because you can no longer call a guy a choker when he puts on the Green Jacket to join the most exclusive club in sports.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#26410
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rory McIlroy's Masters win extinguished the hater narrative forever

It's a much harder hate. Yeah. We had to retire it. That's what I'm sad about. We had to retire because Rory, no matter what he is now the sixth all time to have the career Grand slam... He beat all the haters. Including us.

The 'hater' narrative is a matter of fan opinion, though the Grand Slam is a historical fact.

Masters Fallout and the Leaderboard

While Rory was the story, the rest of the leaderboard provided plenty of fodder for the guys. Ludvig Åberg looked like he was ready to seize the moment before a disastrous finish, leading Big Cat to question if he would have survived the pressure of the final group.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#26409
Big CatBig Cat

Ludvig Åberg would have had an all-time meltdown if he had been in the final group during his final holes

If he had the lead outright and that's how he ended his round, people would be, let's say he was in the final group today and that's how he finished his round. When he was in contention to win. People would be talking about that as maybe the biggest meltdown outside that French guy [Jean van de Velde] at the open championship. Or Greg Norman.

This is a hypothetical comparison of collapses, which is subjective.

Then there’s Scottie Scheffler, who finished fourth despite not having his best stuff. Hank is already looking for the next person to root against now that Rory is off limits, and he’s setting his sights on the World No. 1. He thinks the narrative is shifting toward Scottie being a specialist rather than a dominant force across all four majors.

Loss
Apr 14, 2025
#5651
Big CatBig Cat

Scottie Scheffler is just a Masters merchant and hasn't proven he can dominate other majors

He's also gonna be the new narrative guy. He might just be a masters merchant. He's got, he's got a win in major that's not the masters... People compare to Tiger. These are his, you know, finishes and majors in his last 10 majors. It's not the greatest.

Scheffler has a PGA Championship (2024), so calling him a 'Masters merchant' is technically incorrect, though Big Cat is looking for the next hater narrative.

As for the LIV guys, the weekend was a bit of a reality check. Bryson DeChambeau faded after a hot start, and the rest of the LIV contingent failed to make a serious push on Sunday. Hank, formerly a LIV defender, seems to have finally reached his breaking point with the 54-hole circuit.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5652
HankHank

LIV golfers are no longer serious contenders at the Masters compared to PGA Tour players

I'm done with with thinking that, you know, the live guys can make it happen. The masters... as the years have gone on, yes. It's 'cause they Yes. They all have a ton of money. Yes. And they're all playing 54 holes... they're not pushed the same way.

This is a subjective evaluation of performance trends between tours.

NBA Playoff Seeding and the Play-In

The NBA regular season has finally concluded, and the bracket is set. Big Cat remains the world’s leading critic of the Play-In Tournament, viewing it as a tool for mediocre owners to trick their fans into thinking they’ve achieved something.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5653
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA Play-In tournament is a ploy for owners to convince fans they made the playoffs

I've said from the beginning it is a ploy for the Jerry Reinsdorf type owners to convince their fan base that they've made it to the playoffs when they have not. I hate the playing tournament... it sucks.

This is a subjective opinion on the NBA's business and competitive structure.

Meanwhile, Hank is riding high on the Bulls' chances despite a season of inconsistency. He’s convinced that the Cavaliers are the most vulnerable team in the East and that Chicago is actually trending toward a legitimate upset.

Loss
Apr 14, 2025
#5655
HankHank

The Bulls are trending upward and are a legitimate threat to beat the Cavaliers in a playoff series

Bulls are about to go on a run. Keep saying, I think they can beat the Cavs. It starts on Wednesday night... I'm not worried about the Cavs. I didn't say I want them to. I'm just saying like the bulls are trending. Cavs are overrated.

The Bulls lost to the Heat in the play-in and never faced the Cavs in the 2025 playoffs.

Chaos in Knoxville

College football took a wild turn on Saturday with news that Tennessee quarterback Nico Iamaleava was holding out from team activities over NIL money. Big Cat thinks the university made a power move by letting him walk into the portal rather than being held hostage by his representation.

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5663
Big CatBig Cat

Tennessee was smart to move on from Nico Iamaleava

What Tennessee did was actually smart. They came out and they said, we're moving on from Nico. Yeah. Before Nico had a chance to be like, I've entered the transfer portal. He wasn't good enough to get a million and a half raise.

Whether Tennessee was 'smart' to move on from Nico Iamaleava is subjective and depends on how both Iamaleava and Tennessee perform going forward.
Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5665
Big CatBig Cat

Nico Iamaleava is receiving bad career advice from his father/agent

I think he's getting bad advice from his, so his dad is his agent, which also complicates thing because when your dad is your agent... he doesn't have to act in good faith... I think it's shortsighted because Nico, if he had a really good year in Josh Heupel's offense could be a high draft pick.

Subjective opinion on management, though Nico's draft position will provide some evidence.

This latest drama with transfer portals and spring games has Big Cat convinced that the current model of college football is headed for a major structural change, specifically regarding how teams prepare in the offseason.

Open
Apr 14, 2025
#26411
Big CatBig Cat

College spring games will be phased out in the next few years due to NIL and transfer portal chaos

We're losing spring games. Spring games are gonna be, I bet you in a couple years there'll be no spring games.

This will be proven true or false based on the existence of CFB spring games in the late 2020s.

SVP Live From Augusta

Scott Van Pelt joins the show from the Augusta airport to provide the definitive perspective on Rory’s win. He describes the atmosphere as purely cathartic, noting that the relief on Rory’s face was far more apparent than the joy. SVP believes this win isn't just a career milestone; it’s a dam breaking that will lead to more hardware for McIlroy.

Open
Apr 14, 2025
#5673
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Now that he's won the Masters, Rory McIlroy could stack three or four more majors

This is the damn burst that now frees them up to be truly like, fuck it. I'm gonna go do like... he's got a ton of runway in front of him. He could stack three or four more of these.

This will be proven over the next several years of golf majors.

They also check in on the status of the Big Texas cinnamon roll, which has become a recurring tradition of disappointment for SVP at the airport. While he didn't find the roll initially, he did confirm that the feeling around the grounds was that everyone was witnessing history, even if Rory tried his best to make it difficult.

Who’s Back and Monday Reading

Who’s Back features Paddy the Baddy’s return to form and a very personal health update from PFT regarding his latest battle with kidney stones. After an ER visit that included a ball-themed ultrasound, PFT is convinced that his toughness is officially off the charts.

Void
Apr 14, 2025·Who's Back
#5667
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kidney stone pain is worse than childbirth

Also, the doctor again for the second time told me that this pain is worse than childbirth. Which I will not be saying to any women, but it's true... I've given birth to like 13 kidney stones. I'm as tough as Philip Rivers' wife.

This is a commonly debated anecdotal claim in medical circles but inherently subjective.

Finally, Monday Reading brings closure to the long-standing mystery of Jim Nantz’s toast. For years, the guys have obsessed over the idea of Nantz carrying a laminated card in his wallet showing a picture of how he likes his bread burnt. It turns out, Nantz is the ultimate prankster.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Jim Nantz's wallet toast card was actually a prank on a reporter

So the card is a prank, but he does like his Toast Nantz style... Nantz ordered his special brand of toast... I made sure the reporter saw the card and when he asked about it, I said, well that card has saved me a lot of hours.

The story from golf.com confirms it was an intentional gag by Nantz's assistant.

At the end of the day, Rory has his jacket, PFT has his health, and we still have eleven more years of Jim Nantz saying hello to friends.

mastersrory-mcilroynba-playoffstennessee-footballnilscottie-scheffler

More Takes

Void
Apr 14, 2025
#26408
Big CatBig Cat

I prefer Rory winning a Masters through a series of chokes and comebacks rather than a comfortable blowout

If Rory was gonna win the career Grand Slam, I wanted to see him push to the brink. So, and he almost went in the water at 11... the fact that Rory was pushed to the brink made me, even as a hater, I had to tip my cap. Like the career achievement... he choked and he unchoked and he choked. And then he got like, the shot of a lifetime on 15.

This is a personal preference on how he enjoys sports as a 'hater,' which is subjective.
Open
Apr 14, 2025
#5650
Big CatBig Cat

Rory McIlroy will go on a hot streak and get to 10 majors now that the monkey is off his back

I actually think Rory might go on a hot streak. Yeah. Because like, that was, that did feel like the monkey off your back Steve young moment... Rory might just rip off, you know, he might get to 10 majors.

Rory McIlroy currently has 4 majors (according to the simulation/transcript context of 2025). This will be testable as his career continues.
Void
Apr 14, 2025
#5661
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Stan Van Gundy is wrong about Knicks and Sixers fans being fairweather

I couldn't disagree more living in New York for whatever we did, six, seven years. Knicks fans love their team. They just fucking expect, they want them to be good... what Stan Van Gundy is describing. That's just fans.

This is a debate about the definition of 'fairweather' vs 'passionate'.
Void
Apr 14, 2025·Who's Back
#5669
Big CatBig Cat

Donald Trump reports his weight as 224 pounds specifically to troll the media and trigger a reaction

He's actually lost weight. He's 224... 6'3" 224. So that is that's RG3... I think that he does that now. Like at first I think he was lying about it. Now he lies about it because he knows that people are going to make fun of him for lying about it.

Trump's internal motivations are subjective and unknowable.
Win
Apr 14, 2025
#5671
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Rory McIlroy's Masters win was primarily 100% relief

It was almost all relief. And the thing that Andy North described to me... you feel so much more relief than joy... it was so obvious that sure there's joy in there... but clearly it was like, just thank God I did it.

Rory himself later admitted it was a burden, supporting this view.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers