Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

The Bills Offense Can't Be Stopped, NFL Week 2 Picks And Preview, Golfer Chris Gotterup In Studio Ahead Of The President's Cup Plus Fyre Fest

Friday, September 18, 202615 takes · Transcript ↓

The Bills open their new stadium and drop the hammer on the Lions Defense with a perfect performance on Offense. Josh Allen is playing football on easy mode (-). NFL Week 2 Picks and Preview for every game, we uncover a new film guy who may be the smartest film guy ever, Chargers must win, Bengals/Texans and more (-). We then give out a TD picks and over unders plus spreads (-). Chris Gotterup joins us in studio to talk golf, football, the upcoming Presidents Cup here in Chicago and tons more (-). We then finish with Fyre Fest of the weekYou can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or Netflix. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/pardon-my-take

Josh Allen opened Buffalo's new stadium by treating the Lions defense like a warm-up drill, and Big Cat immediately admitted that the show may not be glazing him enough. The flicks, the runs, the effortless deep balls, the ability to carry Aidan Hutchinson around like a backpack: Allen looked like he had unlocked the easy difficulty setting.

Void
Sep 18, 2026
#31428
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is playing quarterback on easy mode

We're a Josh Allen podcast. People sometimes get upset about how much we glaze him. I don't think we glaze him enough because he's playing quarterback on easy mode. It looks like that for him. The flick of the wrist, the runs, everything—it all looks like the game is slowed down for him. He's in just total control of the game.

Subjective assessment of Josh Allen's play and dominance.

The Bills' offense was so overwhelming that the show briefly revisited the most painful alternate-history question in Buffalo sports: how many Super Bowls would the Bills have won if kickers didn't exist? PFT's answer was "like three or four," which is both completely unprovable and exactly the kind of thing that can derail a Friday football podcast for ten minutes.

Void
Sep 18, 2026
#31429
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bills could have three or four Super Bowls without kickers

You can make the argument that the Buffalo Bills would have like three or four Super Bowls if kickers weren't a thing in football. You can make the argument that the Patriots might not have had the start of that dynasty if it wasn't for kickers.

The claim is a counterfactual and cannot be definitively verified.

Week Two Overreaction Season

Week 2 is where everyone finds out whether Week 1 was information or just a very elaborate hallucination. Big Cat brought a 70% trend involving teams that failed to cover in Week 1 and are underdogs in Week 2. The list included the Lions, Falcons, Titans, Browns, Dolphins, and Colts, meaning the trend is useful but requires you to hold your nose while betting it.

Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31440
Big CatBig Cat

Week 1 underdogs that failed to cover are a 70% ATS trend in Week 2

Teams that failed to cover the spread in Week 1 and enter Week 2 as underdogs have gone 26-11-2 against the spread since 2014. Seventy percent.

The stated 26-11-2 record and 70% rate can be checked against historical NFL results.

The Steelers-Patriots preview featured Hank's return to graph talk, Drake Maye's allegedly unlucky interceptions, and PFT's discovery that Matt Stafford has enjoyed two straight years of suspiciously excellent turnover luck. Then the show spent several minutes watching NFL Tape Watch clips of open Patriots receivers while Hank tried to figure out why everyone was suddenly obsessed with a man named Glen. The reveal that PFT had edited the clips to remove one defensive player was a perfect little office prank, especially because Hank had confidently counted the remaining eleven.

The gambling slate kept producing material. Memes believes rain can make the Jets a real football team against the Packers, while PFT dared Jalen Hurts to beat Tennessee from the pocket after Jeffrey Simmons said the Eagles quarterback should be forced to play quarterback. PFT's proposed response was not subtle: 300 yards, three touchdowns, and a message.

Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31432
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jalen Hurts will answer the Titans by beating them as a passer

I actually think Jalen Hurts is good enough as a quarterback that when somebody dares him to do that, he could say, 'Fuck you, I will beat you as a quarterback.' And then stay in the pocket and throw for like 300 yards and three touchdowns.

Hurts' passing production against Tennessee will determine this prediction.

PFT also made the Jaguars the most powerful small-market team in America, at least conditionally. A win in Denver would put Jacksonville behind only the Jets in his power rankings, which is a sentence that would have sounded like a cry for help two weeks earlier. He also crowned Seattle No. 1 after remembering that the Seahawks beat New England while playing much of the game with ten defenders on the field.

Void
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31433
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jaguars would be the second-best team in football if they win in Denver

If they win this game in Denver, I would put them maybe second in the power rankings behind the Jets.

The Jaguars' win and their resulting standing in PFT's power rankings are the relevant conditions; the ranking itself is subjective.

The afternoon slate brought the discovery of Jack Strand, a Division II quarterback from the jump-rope capital of Wisconsin who may or may not be about to take over the Falcons. The available film consisted of what appeared to be four plays on a loop, but that did not stop Max from becoming a Strand believer. "Let's get stranded" was repeated enough times to qualify as a new segment.

Hank, meanwhile, finally stopped pretending he didn't have a Hungry Dog. His early candidates included the Commanders, Bengals, Vikings, Giants, Jets, and Falcons, which is less a locked-in pick than a man opening every refrigerator in the house and claiming he is still deciding what to eat. He did, however, make one actual prediction about Washington and Dallas.

Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31441
HankHank

The Commanders will roll over the Cowboys

I think the Commanders are gonna roll this game. The Eagles are good and the Commanders almost beat them. The Commanders are gonna beat the Cowboys.

The Commanders-Cowboys result and margin will determine this prediction.

Chris Gotterup Wants America To Win

Chris Gotterup joined the show ahead of the Presidents Cup at Medinah and instantly fit the PMT ecosystem: New Jersey lacrosse and golf, Oklahoma wind, a 320-yard drive, and absolutely no interest in pretending that his tournament whiff was anything other than a spectacular whiff.

Gotterup talked about the weird pressure of alternate shot, the rule he shares with partners that nobody is allowed to say "sorry," and how much worse it feels to hit a bad shot when somebody else's family is watching. He also explained why Oklahoma produces golfers: it is windy every single day, and the wind finds out immediately whether your swing is real.

Open
Sep 18, 2026
#31436
CG
Chris Gotterup

The United States cannot lose the Presidents Cup

You cannot lose it. It can't be my first team and then lose, and then no, then I'm done forever.

The 2026 Presidents Cup result will determine whether the U.S. team loses.

He was refreshingly direct about the PGA Tour's pace of play, too. Thursday and Friday rounds are too slow, and if someone is having a bad round, they should at least have the decency to play quickly. That is a take every golfer has had while standing behind a group that is treating a 12-foot putt like a NASA launch.

Void
Sep 18, 2026
#31437
CG
Chris Gotterup

Thursday and Friday rounds on the PGA Tour are too slow

Overall pace of play's too slow. I'm—Thursday and Friday are the worst. Especially if you're having a bad round, at least play fast.

Pace-of-play judgments are partly subjective, though tournament timing data could support them.

The interview eventually reached Jim Irsay, who once challenged Gotterup and JB Holmes to a $100,000 golf match, took them to a Colts game, showed them an indoor ice rink, and apparently kept Elton John's Live Aid piano in his living room. This is the correct way to be a billionaire: envelopes of cash, an ice rink, and a house that sounds like it was designed by a seven-year-old with unlimited money.

Fyre Fest Of The Week

PFT's Fyre Fest began with Blake the dog's recurring ear infections and ended with PFT accidentally taking his Adderall at approximately 1 a.m. after mistaking Blake's barking for his alarm. He then spent an hour organizing the home screens on his iPhone while unknowingly chemically preparing for Wake Up Barstool. Hank correctly pointed out that nobody calls it a desktop. PFT refused to accept this terminology correction because the sleep deprivation had already won.

Big Cat and Max also began preparing for a potential six-day sports war involving Wisconsin-Penn State, the Bears, the Eagles, the Phillies, and the Cubs. Their friendship will be tested by baseball series, football loyalties, and possibly the kind of tattoo bets that begin as a joke and end with somebody explaining a terrible piece of ink to a doctor.

Big Cat's other Fyre Fest was assistant Dom's full-uniform Cleveland fandom, complete with a catcher's mitt and the emotional stability of a baseball fan who changes sports the moment one game goes badly. The final cyber-security crisis came from Zac, whose laptop had moved from Islamic prayer ads to Russian apartment timeshares. The office's weakest link may have accidentally created a new international market for PMT.

One thing is certain: if the Commanders' glass-roof stadium melts Jayden Daniels, Mud will have asked the only question that matters.

nfl-week-2josh-allenbillspresidents-cupchris-gotterupgolffyre-fest

More Takes

Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31430
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears will beat the Vikings, but they won't score 59 again

I think the Bears are gonna win. I do not think they're gonna score 59 points. I do think they're gonna win.

The Bears-Vikings result and Chicago's point total will determine this prediction.
Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31431
MemesMemes

Rain gives the Jets a real chance against Green Bay

Packers are a really good team. But I think the rain helps the Jets. If it was perfect conditions, Jets would probably lose. But it's gonna be rainy as shit too.

The Jets-Packers result and game conditions will determine whether the weather-based prediction holds.
Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31439
Big CatBig Cat

The AI whistleblower panic is a coordinated industry play

The whistleblower was an op. All these companies are running out of money and they don't actually have any utilization yet. They've taken all this investment in, so they basically had a whistleblower come out and be like, 'It's gonna kill us all.' Get the government involved, regulate the AI, the AI companies can be like, 'Hey, it's not our fault. We didn't actually produce any profits.' The government shut us down.

This is a speculative claim about the motives and coordination of AI companies that cannot be established from the episode.
Void
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31434
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Seahawks deserve to be No. 1 in the power rankings

I think the Seahawks are absolutely—they deserve to be number one in the power rankings. They are. They're an awesome team. Great defense.

Power rankings are subjective and cannot be definitively judged.
Void
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31442
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Fred Warner is the player football fans need to respect more

Fred Warner, he is now, I think he's number one on my list of guys that we need to respect more.

Whether Fred Warner is the league's most under-respected player is subjective.
Open
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31435
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Antonio Williams is a Rookie of the Year candidate

I love Antonio Williams, by the way. Antonio Williams. Great rookie wide receiver. I put in a bet on him to win Rookie of the Year too. He had a pretty good game last week, but he was always open and he's gonna be a fun player to watch.

The 2026 NFL season award outcome will determine this prediction.
Void
Sep 18, 2026·Picks
#31438
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts were more devastated by Andrew Luck's retirement than any franchise by a player retirement

How badly do Colts fans just want to wipe your whole house, get clean, just start fresh? You guys have been doing basically the exact same thing every year since Andrew Luck retired, and it's just—no team franchise ever been devastated by a retirement more than this.

The claim that no franchise was more affected is a subjective historical comparison.

Transcript

Loading transcript…

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!