Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Week 17 NFL Recap, Fastest 2 Minutes, The Jets & Commanders Eliminated, Packers Stay Alive & College Football Playoffs

Monday, January 2, 202318 takes

Week 17 we start with the fastest 2 minutes then recap every game from Sunday. (-) Bucs/Panthers (-) Patriots/Dolphins (-) Commanders/Browns (- ) Giants/Colts (-) Saints/Colts (-) Chiefs/Broncos (-) Lions/Bears (-) Jaguars/Texans (-) Falcons/Cardinals (-) Chargers/Rams (-) Niners/Raiders (-) Seahawks/Jets (v -) Packers/Vikings (- ) Ravens/Steelers (-) We then talk College Football Playoffs who's back and football guys of the week. (-)

Week 17 NFL Recap: Commanders & Jets Eliminated, Packers Alive, and CFP Chaos

Week 17 arrived with the usual mix of playoff heartbreak and pure, unadulterated chaos. Big Cat and PFT Commenter kicked things off with the fastest two minutes before diving into a Sunday that effectively ended the seasons for several teams represented in the room. The biggest story out of the gate was Tom Brady and the Buccaneers officially clinching the NFC South. While the team has been a tough watch all year, the deep ball connection with Mike Evans finally looked like the vintage version fans have been waiting for.

Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#24779
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2022 Buccaneers are flawed but have learned the lessons they need for a playoff run

It looks like the Bucks have actually looked at what's made them flawed and then realized there are certain things that we can do good. Let's lean into those things... as if it turns out that still throwing deep balls to Mike Evans works.

The Bucs lost their first playoff game 31-14 to the Cowboys, so the 'lessons learned' didn't lead to a run.

Evans turned in a massive performance with three touchdowns, prompting Big Cat to remind everyone that the receiver's resume is starting to look elite. Beyond just the stats, the longevity and consistency have put him in very rare air.

Void
Jan 2, 2023
#19794
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Evans is a Hall of Famer

Mike Evans is a hall of famer. Yeah. Which is crazy cuz it's, it doesn't, it feel like he's had a very good career, but then when you stop and you look at it, you're like, holy shit. He's, he's got 81 touchdowns in his career. If he gets to a hundred, he'll be top 10 all time in touchdowns. Everyone in the top 15 is in the Hall of Fame. Every single year he's been in the NFL nine years. Every year he's gotten over a thousand yards and he's not even 30 yet.

Evans extended his streak to 10 consecutive seasons in 2023 and is widely considered a future Hall of Famer, though his career is still active.

As the Bucs look toward the postseason, PFT Commenter is already envisioning a first-round matchup against a familiar foe. Given the history of the matchup, the guys are already predicting some major fallout in Dallas if things go the way they expect.

Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#19796
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Buccaneers will beat the Cowboys in the first round and cause Mike McCarthy to get fired

It's gonna be Bucks Cowboys first round. Cowboys are going to lose somehow to Tom Brady who's never lost to the Cowboys before. McCarthy fired. Sean Payton head coach of the Dallas Cowboys.

The Cowboys actually defeated the Buccaneers 31-14 in the wild card round, and Mike McCarthy remained the head coach. Sean Payton was eventually traded to the Broncos.

Meanwhile, the vibes in the room were decidedly split. While Max was panicking over the Eagles' second straight loss without Jalen Hurts, Hank was doing his best to troll everyone by claiming the Cowboys are destined for the top spot in the conference. Big Cat isn't ready to crown Dallas just yet, especially with the way the Eagles' absence has proven just how valuable their QB really is.

Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#19799
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts should be the MVP because of how badly the Eagles struggled without him

Jalen [Hurts] should be the MVP because of what we've seen from Gardner Minshew. Give him the MVP because the debate is always, if you took this guy off the team, what would they look like? Well now we know: 13 and 1, 0 and 2.

Patrick Mahomes won the 2022 MVP; Hurts finished second.
Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#19795
HankHank

The Cowboys are getting the one seed in the NFC

Cowboys are getting the one. Yeah, you've been talking about this cuz you just, your anger for Philadelphia just never leaves your brain. No, I just in today and you're like, Cowboys getting one. Cowboys getting one.

The Eagles won the NFC East and secured the No. 1 seed after beating the Giants in Week 18. The Cowboys finished as the No. 5 seed.

Speaking of the NFC East, the Commanders officially saw their season go up in smoke after a disastrous performance from Carson Wentz. Between Ron Rivera seemingly not knowing the elimination scenarios and Wentz’s inability to move the ball, it was a dark day for PFT Commenter. The future for Wentz looks increasingly bleak, with the guys questioning if he’ll even be on a roster when next season kicks off.

Win
Jan 2, 2023
#24782
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Carson Wentz might be out of the NFL entirely in a year or two

I actually think that there's a chance he might not be on a team next year... who's going to actually say we're starting the season [with him]. The best chance he has is the Colts and he burned that bridge already.

Wentz was released by the Commanders and remained a free agent until signing with the Rams as a backup in November 2023.

On the brighter side of the division, the New York Giants officially ended the 'boat curse' and secured their first playoff berth since 2016. Big Cat was quick to give all the flowers to Brian Daboll for turning a roster that looked dead in the water into a legitimate postseason threat.

Win
Jan 2, 2023
#19798
Big CatBig Cat

Brian Daboll is the NFL Coach of the Year

Brian Dayle is Coach of the Year. He's getting my official vote. I have a lot, lot of backup votes. I think he's coached the year. The New York Giants, excuse me, are in the playoff for the first time since 2016. The boat curse has officially been erased. This team is pretty much the same team as it was last year, except the coach is different and he's gotten so much out of these guys.

Brian Daboll won the AP NFL Coach of the Year award for the 2022 season.

In the AFC, the Jets were officially eliminated following a lackluster performance against the Seahawks. Billy Football tried to deflect the blame toward the local media, even suggesting a documentary series to investigate why quarterbacks can't succeed in New York. On the other side of that game, the Seahawks stayed alive, but they'll need help to keep the Packers out of the dance.

Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#24785
Big CatBig Cat

The 2022 Packers will win their play-in game against the Lions and make the playoffs

The Packers are in a true win and get in situation week 18 at Home Against the Lions... I don't know how [Rodgers] keeps doing this, how he keeps getting away with it... fuck, they're playing decent football right now.

The Lions beat the Packers 20-16, eliminating them from the playoffs.

Finally, the guys spent some time reflecting on what might have been the greatest day of college football in history. The semifinals delivered two games that were actually competitive for a change, with TCU pulling off a massive upset and Georgia surviving a thriller against Ohio State. Big Cat is fully bought into the Horned Frogs as they head toward the title game.

Void
Jan 2, 2023
#24778
Big CatBig Cat

The college football playoff semifinals were the best in history

The best college football playoffs we've ever seen. Semi-finals. I like how people were tweeting, like is it a hot take to say these are the best semi-finals we've ever seen? No, they usually always suck. And those were two incredible games.

The games were objectively some of the highest-scoring and closest in CFP history to that point.
Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#19802
Big CatBig Cat

TCU has 'Team of Destiny' vibes and can win the National Championship

I don't count them out in this game against Georgia. They are fucking, whatever it is, they just, the hypno toed. I don't know what it is. They're just good. I'm gonna bet on 'em. Yeah. I'm, there's some, they do seem like Team of Destiny vibes. They've all, they've got like Tiger Blood, they don't die. Never.

TCU was crushed by Georgia 65-7 in the National Championship game, one of the most lopsided games in history.

The episode wrapped up with Who’s Back and the official start of Jumpsuit January, where PFT Commenter and Big Cat promised to transform the show into a "hard body podcast" by the time the Super Bowl rolls around.

Loss
Jan 2, 2023·Who's Back
#24786
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The PMT podcast will be 'sexy as shit' and have Super Bowl abs by February 2023

This podcast, it's gonna be fucking sexy as shit. Yeah. By the end of January we're getting Super Bowl abs. I'm going Buns of Anarchy... All are welcome to join Buns of Anarchy.

PredictionLifeMediumSarcastic
The hosts generally did not achieve 'Super Bowl abs', though they did various fitness bits.

Hank still hasn't won the lottery ball, and at this point, it feels like the universe might be actively preventing it.

nflcollege-football-playofftom-bradycarson-wentzgreen-bay-packersnew-york-giants

More Takes

Win
Jan 2, 2023
#24780
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I will jump off the top of the building if the Eagles are underdogs against the Giants in Week 18

If the line comes out, if the, I'll be your life off. If the Eagles are underdogs, I will, I will go up to the top of this building and jump off.

The Eagles opened as 14-point favorites, so PFT was correct and did not have to jump.
Loss
Jan 2, 2023
#24781
Big CatBig Cat

Tom Brady will not retire after the 2022 season

I don't think there's any chance he's retiring. I think this type of game where he won the NFC South, going back to the playoffs through the bombs... That's like when you golf and on the 18th hole you just crush a drive. Man, that was fun.

Tom Brady announced his retirement on February 1, 2023.
Void
Jan 2, 2023
#19797
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ron Rivera should be fired if he truly didn't know the Commanders' playoff elimination scenario

Ron Rivera apparently didn't know that if the Packers beat the Vikings later on in the day, that that would eliminate us from the playoffs. And that's why he chose to start Carson Wentz. I if that's true, it's one of two things. Either, either Ron Rivera is trying to get fired by saying he didn't know that or he should be fired if he didn't know that.

Rivera remained the coach for another year before being fired after the 2023 season. His lack of awareness of the playoff scenario was widely mocked.
Win
Jan 2, 2023
#19800
Big CatBig Cat

It is 'winner talk' for a fan to want their team to lose for a better draft pick

If you're friends with someone who's a Bears fan, if you have a family member's Bears fan who thinks that they should somehow try to win week 18, you need to tell 'em to shut the fuck up. This is not loser talk. No, no, no. It's actually winner talk to try to actually set up your franchise to be in the best possible position to get the most possible picks going forward.

The Bears lost in Week 18 and secured the #1 overall pick, which they traded to the Panthers for a massive haul (including the pick that became Caleb Williams).
Win
Jan 2, 2023
#24783
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The 2022 Jaguars will smoke the Titans in Week 18 and make the playoffs

I think they're gonna smoke the Titans. Yeah, I think that's gonna, we're gonna be jagging off in the playoffs. Yeah. Duval. Fill up the pool. Everyone put your jeans on. We're going swimming.

The Jaguars beat the Titans 20-16 to win the AFC South and make the playoffs.
Win
Jan 2, 2023
#24784
Big CatBig Cat

The 49ers should have drafted Brock Purdy earlier

Frank the tank did bemoan that the Dolphins should have drafted... sorry, Brock Purdy. I do think that that will be a real take that people will say, well they should have drafted Brock Purdy, Mr. Irrelevant.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Purdy's continued success led to many legitimate 're-draft' articles, making this a prescient observation of media trends.
Void
Jan 2, 2023
#19801
Billy FootballBilly Football

The New York media is the primary reason why Jets quarterbacks fail

I'm really trying to figure out, what is the reason why quarterbacks are having real problems succeeding in the New York Jets organization. I really do think it's the New York media that makes the jets bad. It would be funny to figure out what exactly is going on. I might do like a docu-series, like try to figure out what the hell's going on.

While the NY media is famously harsh, most analysts attribute the Jets' failures to poor drafting and coaching. This remains a highly subjective and debated 'fan' theory.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers