Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
Big CatBig Cat

The dog show needs more controversy to become a mainstream interest.

I actually think this is exactly what Westminster needs. More controversies will get us to a point where dog shows become mainstream... we need to get some kind of maybe put it up to a fan vote.

The effect of scandal on the popularity of a niche hobby is a matter of opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins needs to stop tweeting or only tweet about charity

Kirk Cousins has reached a point where he cannot tweet anymore... He is very, very earnest and genuine. He can't tweet. He cannot tweet anymore... The only thing Kirk Cousins should be tweeting is about charity. Go charity route or delete your account.

Subjective opinion on brand management.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

An NFL starting quarterback is the apex predator of the sports world

If you have the choice of being an NFL quarterback or an outfielder, maybe an outfielder for the Oakland A's, it's not really a choice. And it's like you're it's the national brand of being a national hero versus being maybe at your absolute peak... starting quarterbacks in the NFL are the top, they're apex predators in the sports world.

This is a subjective assessment of cultural status between sports.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Quarterback draft stock only ever goes up as the NFL Draft approaches

Wherever [a quarterback] is going to be drafted today, he will be drafted higher once the draft comes. Because every quarterback just keeps going up and up and up.

This is a generally observed phenomenon in NFL draft cycles, though occasionally prospects like Will Levis or Aaron Rodgers have seen slides on draft night.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NFL quarterbacks lose value like used cars after their first year but regain it after starting for two seasons

The thing about NFL quarterbacks that are drafted in the first round, they immediately lose value. They're like a used car once you take them off the lot. So Josh Rosen lost a lot of value this year... but then once you're a starting quarterback for two years or more, then you gain value.

This accurately reflects how NFL teams value draft assets vs. proven (or struggling) young veterans, as seen with Josh Rosen being traded for only a 2nd round pick.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

NBA dads are correct that traveling is no longer called in the league

My cool throne is dads. Because we're all in agreement now that traveling is no longer called in the NBA. So, dads, you were right. They don't call it anymore. It was a gather step, bro. No, it was five steps... There were three gather steps, and then there were two more steps.

While exaggerated for comedy, the 'gather step' rules and lack of traveling calls were a massive point of contention in 2019 NBA discourse.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Blake Bortles and the Jaguars effectively ruined the Steelers franchise

We're all in agreement, though, that Blake Bortles and the Jaguars broke the Steelers last year, right? Absolutely ruined that franchise.

While the loss was a turning point, the Steelers' issues were multifaceted. However, the 'Days of Our Steelers' era did follow that defeat closely.
Void
Rick WeyrichRick Weyrich

Poodles are often favored in dog shows because their glamour catches judges' eyes better than low-key breeds

The glamorous dog catches [the judge's] eye... the Dalmatian, I think it's overlooked because of there's so many glamorous dogs in the non-sporting group and two of them are poodles.

This is an industry observation from a professional judge, which is inherently subjective but highly authoritative.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

There are no bad dogs in the world, only bad owners

All dogs are good. It's only owners that are dickheads. True. No bad dogs, only bad owners. That's a fact.

This is a philosophical stance on animal behavior that cannot be scientifically proven or disproven.
Void
HM
Howie Mandel

Getting hit in the nuts is the ultimate comedic punchline that no comedian can top

I think that's the ultimate punchline... No, I think getting hit in the nuts is... I have no jealousy as a comedian [of the guy who gets kicked in the balls].

The quality of comedy is subjective, but the 'guy getting hit in the groin' is a foundational trope of physical comedy.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The AAF outrating the NBA proves America loves football over everything else

We [the AAF] outrated the NBA game, the primetime NBA game, showing that America loves football over everything else, which we already know and we agree with.

The AAF debut on CBS did indeed outrate the NBA's primetime game that weekend, drawing 2.9 million viewers.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The AAF should schedule their season to end exactly when March Madness begins

What would be great is if they did the schedule... when you get to February, you can play the remainder of your season so that the Super Bowl of the AAF ends right before March Madness begins. Because I'm just being totally honest... there are certain points in the year of sports that I just won't choose a minor league football team... over what I usually watch.

The AAF folded mid-season in April 2019, never completing its first year or reaching a Super Bowl. Future spring leagues like the UFL have struggled with this exact scheduling conflict.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Tom Brady is a prisoner of his own success because of his extreme superstitions

Tom Brady's success is so successful and won so many Super Bowls, how many little things like this do you think he does in a day-to-day basis where he's like, well, it's helped me get to where I'm at? He's basically stuck in the most superstitious life of all time... He's permanently stuck upside down because he keeps winning Super Bowls... He's a prisoner of his own success.

Brady's superstitions and rigid lifestyle are well-documented (TB12 method, etc.).
Void
Big CatBig Cat

'Abducted in Plain Sight' is the most jaw-dropping documentary I've ever watched

Whatever you're doing right now, drop everything and watch Abducted in Plain Sight because it is—let's just say it's the most jaw-dropping documentary I've ever watched. Not like a good—it wasn't one of those documentaries where you come across being like, man, I'm really thinking about it. It was awesome. I just said what the fuck probably about 15 times.

Subjective opinion on a documentary's impact.
Win
JJ WattJJ Watt

Deshaun Watson is a much better pocket passer than people realize

I think he's a good pocket passer. I think that that's one thing that people, when you think of [Deshaun Watson], you immediately think of a guy that can move around and get away from pressure, but he is good in the pocket.

Watson's career stats prior to his suspension showed high efficiency from the pocket.
Void
JJ WattJJ Watt

Core work is the most important thing for an athlete because everything connects to it

Tons and tons of core work to make sure that my core is locked in... Core is important. It's extremely important. It's the most important. That's what they say. Everything attaches to your core.

This is a fundamental principle of kinesiology and physical training, though 'most important' is a matter of athletic philosophy.
Void
JJ WattJJ Watt

Being a professional athlete in America ruins your ability to be a fan because you know how the business works

American sports, I know how free agency works. I know how these backdoor conversations, I know how all the inner workings of it, and it kind of screws you up as a fan because it's hard to get fully into a team because you know how it all goes in the back end. So I'm watching [Premier League]... I don't know what the hell these transfer fees are... So I just blindly am a fan.

This is an experiential opinion from a high-level professional that cannot be proven or disproven.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Premier League is the most appeasing thing to watch in the morning because the green pitch lulls you like the Masters

The Premier League, part of the reason why people like watching it... it's very appeasing in the morning on a Saturday or Sunday. The pitch is so green, and it just kind of lulls you. It's like almost watching the Masters. It is a very nice, easy way to start the day.

Purely subjective aesthetic preference.
Loss
HankHank

The Celtics should trade whatever it takes to get Anthony Davis in his prime

If you can get a player like Anthony Davis in his prime, you do whatever it takes to get him. It's the exact same thing as the Khalil Mack situation. ...In the offseason, they're probably going to trade their entire team for Anthony Davis.

The Celtics did not trade for Anthony Davis; he was traded to the Lakers in June 2019. The 'Mack situation' comparison failed because Danny Ainge refused to meet the Pelicans' asking price.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL was within its rights to prevent Bob Costas from bashing the league during a broadcast

Of course the NFL was like, hey, Bob, you can't say that on one of our fucking broadcasts, dude. Roger Goodell does a lot of stuff to silence a lot of people... but this one, it's like, why would you be allowed to bash the league that's paying your salary right now? During a game, you really can't do that.

This is a subjective take on media ethics and business relations.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bob Costas is the first-ballot Hall of Famer of smelling his own farts

Listen, I like Bob Costas because he's got a big game voice and we grew up with Bob Costas, but he is number one in the Smell Your Own Farts Hall of Fame. He farts in his hand and cups it and puts it right to his nose.

This is a hyperbolic metaphor for narcissism or pretentiousness and cannot be factually evaluated.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Workers who cross picket lines as scabs should form their own union

I had this idea on Saturday to make a union of scabs. So scabs should unionize... scabs are the guys that come in and they take [picket-liners'] jobs and they'll go ahead and they'll work for lower pay... But the scabs themselves should unionize. It's like they should get together and demand better treatment.

OpinionLifeHotSubjectiveSarcastic
A union for scabs would defeat the purpose of being a scab, making it a satirical concept rather than a verifiable claim.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James screwed over the Lakers by trying to tamper for Anthony Davis

LeBron screwed the Lakers. LeBron screwed the Lakers... This was like the most blatant act of tampering of all time... And now everyone hates him on the Lakers. And it's hilarious.

The 2018-19 Lakers were indeed in turmoil after the trade deadline, missing the playoffs despite having LeBron. The chemistry was widely reported as toxic.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Pelicans' refusal to trade Anthony Davis was a battle of owners reasserting power over players

The ownership decided this is where it stops. This is where it all stops. It was a battle of millionaires versus people of wealth. And the people of wealth said, you know what? We care more about football than we do about the NBA.

The Pelicans did indeed hold firm, eventually trading him in the offseason for a massive haul (including Lonzo, Ingram, and picks), proving that waiting worked.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Pelicans were smart to wait on the Anthony Davis trade to see the draft pick order and negotiate with the Celtics

The Pelicans did the smart thing, and they were just waiting to see who has what pick in the draft. And also, they can negotiate with the Celtics now, too. It was a smart move by the Pelicans [to] wait and see where all the picks land, see if the Celtics want to offer a better offer and not just trade Anthony Davis because he wants to be traded.

The Pelicans eventually traded Davis to the Lakers in the summer for a massive haul including Brandon Ingram, Lonzo Ball, Josh Hart, and three first-round picks, which was widely seen as a better return than the mid-season offers.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Sixers are 'all in' on winning a championship this year

The Sixers are all in. They traded Markelle Fultz. They traded for Tobias Harris. They're all in. They're trying to win a championship this year.

The 2019 Sixers were arguably the most talented team in the East, losing on the Kawhi Leonard buzzer-beater in Game 7 of the ECF. They were objectively 'all in'.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

San Antonio and Memphis are the best barbecue cities in the AAF

I think overall I have the best barbecue situation, San Antonio and Memphis [in the AAF].

City-based barbecue quality is entirely a matter of regional preference.
Void
Peter BergPeter Berg

You should stop saying 'Thank you for your service' to veterans and just talk to them normally

If you can think of probably anything to say, and you guys are smart, witty, clever guys, I would always suggest say something other than thank you for your service to a vet... maybe just like, how's it going? Hey, you're a human being. I'd like to talk with you.

This is a subjective social take, but it aligns with Berg's firsthand experience and common feedback from the veteran community.
Void
Peter BergPeter Berg

Roger Goodell has a difficult job and is deserving of respect

I've known Roger for a long time... The job is a job, you know, and he's caught up in a complex tsunami of drama and players and egos and obviously complicated owners... I'm a fan of Rodgers. I don't think he gets everything right all the time, but I think if either of us, three of us had that job, we'd probably be vilified.

The difficulty of the job and Berg's personal fandom are subjective, though Goodell's survival and the league's financial growth support the argument.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Roger Goodell's wife is awesome for using burner accounts to defend him

The one thing I'll say nice about Roger Goodell, he has to be doing something right to have such a ride-or-die wife. His wife is awesome, and she put those burner accounts together to defend him. She's a cool chick.

This is a subjective opinion on personality and loyalty.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin Durant creates the mercurial media narrative he hates by getting mad at reasonable questions

Kevin Durant is like this mercurial guy who's always mad at the media. And then you get mad at that narrative, which you created. Don't get so upset because then it creates a whole – Kevin Durant is like this mercurial guy who's always mad at the media. And then you get mad at that narrative, which you created. So it's just a constant dog chasing its tail.

This is a psychological interpretation of a public figure's behavior and remains subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I support a three-batter minimum for MLB relief pitchers

Three batter minimum, love it... I actually think they should go further with that. I think they should have a, if you come in on an inning, you have to finish the inning. Just watch guys get fucking torched.

The three-batter minimum rule was officially implemented by MLB starting in the 2020 season.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A ground rule double in baseball should count as a home run

I also think that a ground rule double should be a home run. Not the weird one where it gets stuck in the ivy, but just if it bounces over, I think that should count as a home run.

The rule has not been changed; it remains a ground-rule double.
Win
HankHank

I wanted the Patriots to win another Super Bowl now because Tom Brady's window is closing

I would say the Patriots just because Brady's window is closing. So the more he can get in before he retires, the better.

Brady did eventually retire several years later, having won one more ring with Tampa Bay after this.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Brad Calipari's presence on the sideline is a psychological advantage for Kentucky

I truly do think [Brad Calipari] is a plus for Kentucky... when you show up and you have to play Kentucky, you're already in an uphill battle because they're a good team. And then you see this guy just mean mugging you with his half black half blue jean jacket... it just adds to the whole mystique of Kentucky basketball.

This is a purely subjective opinion about psychological impact on a basketball team.
Void
Mark TitusMark Titus

The Pac-12 is just soft because the weather is too perfect

The Pac-12 is just soft. Their only hope is to like import kids from the East coast... who wants to go to UCLA and like be in a gym all day, every day and work on your game? No, that's not why you go to UCLA.

While subjective, the Pac-12's performance in basketball continued to decline relative to other major conferences until its eventual dissolution.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

The Big 12's dominance by Kansas is driven by their home court advantage, not the quality of the team this year

I don't think Kansas wins the Big 12 every year. I think Kansas fans win the Big 12 every year... Phog Allen Fieldhouse wins the Big 12 for Kansas every year. It's impossible to win in there, and so they go into every Big 12 season knowing that they're getting nine free wins. Their team sucks this year. If they had to play in Baylor's arena every single night, they're not winning the Big 12.

Kansas actually failed to win the Big 12 regular season title in 2019, ending their 14-year streak, which largely validates Titus's claim that this team was different.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

On The Bachelor, the person calling someone 'emotional' is usually the bully and vice-versa

I feel like the emotional one is actually the bully, and the bully is actually the emotional one... it's one of those I'm rubber or you call the other person what you really are. [You project it].

Subjective analysis of reality TV character dynamics.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Super Bowl 53 was the worst Super Bowl I've ever watched

That was the worst Super Bowl. I think we can all agree the worst Super Bowl we've ever watched. [It] just wasn't well played. Like, it was compelling because it was close late... but it just was gross.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Super Bowl 48 was a worse game than Super Bowl 53

I would say the worst Super Bowl that I've ever watched is probably the Denver-Seahawks Super Bowl. But that was just because it was a blowout from the very start.

Subjective ranking of game quality.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Vic Fangio is a good hire for the Broncos

I really think that Fangio is a good hire for the Broncos. Oh, yeah, absolutely. We haven't really talked about it that much.

Fangio struggled as a head coach in Denver, going 19-30 over three seasons before being fired.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

A team with a fullback is the key to winning in the modern NFL because they zag when others zig

It's no coincidence that a team with a fullback is the reigning world champion because they zag when everybody else zigs. I'm serious.

The Patriots' 2018 success was heavily tied to their heavy personnel and power running game, supporting the idea that their 'zigging' worked.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Super Bowl 53 was Bill Belichick's best coaching job ever

I actually think this is probably his best coaching job. Because they're probably not the most talented Super Bowl team he's had, but they ran man basically all year, and then they ran zone in the Super Bowl and just fucked up Sean McVay.

This is a subjective opinion, but widely shared by analysts regarding the defensive masterclass Belichick put on in SB 53.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

If Roger Goodell had a brain, he would stop helping Dave Portnoy by arresting him

Arresting Dave at the game was such an all-time moment... no one plays into our hands better than the NFL. They're so dumb... thank you, Roger Goodell, for continually helping us.

The arrest provided Barstool with viral content that far outweighed the cost of ejection, confirming Big Cat's point about it being a marketing win.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Raiders playing in a baseball stadium again in 2019 will be cool because of the wind and potential McCovey Cove punts

Oakland Raiders playing in baseball stadiums [is back]. You will get to see the Raiders play on dirt and grass for another year... it would be great if a punt or a field goal went into the bay... look out for wind. It's going to be windy there.

The Raiders actually ended up staying at the Oakland Coliseum for 2019 after the SF deal fell through, making the premise incorrect.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Saints fans are justified in being salty for months because the Rams only scored three points

If you're a Saints fan... that is the worst possible outcome to get over the loss... you have to sit there and say Drew Brees would not score three points in the Super Bowl. You have permission for me to continue all your salty behavior for another three months.

Saints fans did indeed remain salty for the entire offseason, and many football analysts agreed New Orleans would have been more competitive.
Win
Willie ColonWillie Colon

Marijuana is a better recovery tool for NFL players than opioids or Ambien

I didn't like taking Ambien. I didn't like opioids. I didn't like none of that stuff. The only thing that got me to level out and get some sleep, and because my knees were shot, was [marijuana].

The NFL eventually loosened its marijuana policy in subsequent CBAs, acknowledging its role in pain management.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rob Ryan joining the Redskins as linebackers coach is huge for the defense

Rob Ryan has been hired as the linebackers coach for the Washington Redskins... we got Rob and Jim Tomsula testing the defense... this is huge news.

The 2019 Redskins defense remained poor, ranking 27th in points allowed, so the 'huge' impact was mostly entertainment value.
Void
Dan PatrickDan Patrick

Some great coordinators are simply not meant to be head coaches

There are certain guys who were just assistant coaches... Just because you're good at being a defensive coordinator doesn't mean you can be a head coach... certain guys are meant to be a head coach, certain guys are not.

History generally supports this as many elite coordinators fail as HCs, but it remains a subjective evaluation of individuals.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA purposefully tried to cuck the NFL during Super Bowl week

I saw somebody tweet something out like, I've scored the first four days of Super Bowl week as 10-8, 10-9, 10-8, 10-9 in favor of the NBA... This is our week, NBA. You sons of bitches, NBA. You did it again.

The NBA frequently dominates the news cycle with trades during Super Bowl week, specifically the Porzingis trade in 2019.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers