Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Buffalo Bills do not want to see the Cincinnati Bengals in the playoffs

The Buffalo Bills, if they get the two seed, the last team they wanna see is the Cincinnati Bengals. Yeah. That's the only that like, you, you don't, 'cause that's the Bengals. The the crazy thing about the Bengals is they can't stop anyone. But if you get in a shootout with the Bengals, like anything can happen.

The Bengals eventually failed to make the playoffs in the 2024 season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Lamar Jackson will win the MVP because he has two standalone games left to influence the narrative, even if Josh Allen deserves it more

Lamar [Jackson] might win it just because he plays two standalone games. And that's all this award ends up coming down to... I think it should be Josh [Allen]. I'm just saying how these things work. He's got, Lamar's got two standalone games and Josh has zero.

Lamar Jackson did win the MVP, partially fueled by strong performances in these standalone games, making Big Cat's prediction about the winner correct.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Penix Jr. is the guy to finally unlock Bijan Robinson and Kyle Pitts

I think [Michael Penix Jr.] might be the guy to finally unlock Bijan [Robinson] and give us a proper... maybe Kyle Pitts just needs a left-handed quarterback.

While Penix showed promise, the Falcons' offensive output remained inconsistent under the new QB during the final weeks.
Loss
HankHank

I am pumped for a Mike Vrabel and Josh McDaniels coaching duo in New England

Vrabel McDaniels... that's the combo. [Josh] McDaniels had Mac Jones in the Pro Bowl... give me Vrabel and McDaniels and I am pumped.

This coaching combination did not happen in New England.
Win
Jon GrudenJon Gruden

Losing David Montgomery ruins the identity of the Detroit Lions' team

When you lose [David] Montgomery, you lose part of the identity of your team. So I do know that deep down when Coach [Dan] Campbell gets in his car, he ain't feeling real nicey. Yeah. It's tough.

Montgomery missed significant time and the Lions' run game and overall efficiency took a noticeable dip during his absence.
Void
Jon GrudenJon Gruden

The NFL should adopt the college pass interference rule

I would make [pass interference] the college rule, honestly, because some of these, some of these past interference calls are impacting a game. Just one play there... I don't think there's a common thread in what is and what isn't past interference.

This is a subjective opinion on rule changes and cannot be proven right or wrong.
Loss
Jon GrudenJon Gruden

The Philadelphia Eagles are the favorites in the NFC

I think Philly's probably the favorite. Yeah. You gotta put Philly in there... Philadelphia Eagle defense man, Vic Fangio's got a couple rookies in the secondary... They're good man.

The Eagles were favored by many but lost in the NFC Championship to the Lions.
Win
Jon GrudenJon Gruden

Bucky Irving is a combination of Warrick Dunn and Napoleon Kaufman

The emergence of this Bucky Irving... I mean he's a combination of Warrick Dunn, Napoleon Kaufman, Charlie Garner, he is a badass man. This guy's a hell of a back.

Irving finished a strong rookie campaign as one of the most efficient backs in the league, largely validating the comparison.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears organization will never change because it's built on bad fundamentals and rotting from the top down

Nothing is going to change with this organization. It will always be this way. They will always be based on bad fundamentals and hoping to get lucky from time to time and nothing done the right way... the foundation of the house has been decaying and rotting for a very, very long time.

This is a subjective opinion on organizational culture.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears should fire Ryan Poles and Kevin Warren and start fresh

They should fire Ryan Poles and Kevin Warren and start completely fresh. They won't do that. They'll either keep Ryan Poles and Kevin Warren, fire Ryan Poles. Keep Kevin Warren. And it's just gonna be a mess. And nothing's ever gonna change.

The Bears fired coach Matt Eberflus mid-season, but as of the episode date, the front office remains intact. This is a subjective assessment of the organizational health.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially retiring from ever getting 10/10 excited for the Bears until the ownership changes

I'm officially retiring from ever getting to a 10 outta 10 excitement for the Chicago Bears until something changes... anything, ownership probably... I will not let myself get a 10 outta 10 excited. That doesn't mean I'm not gonna root really hard for them and want them to do well. I'm not going to get, let myself get 10 outta 10 excited ever again until it's proven on the field that something has changed.

This is a personal emotional commitment by Big Cat about his Bears fandom. It cannot be objectively verified.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Kevin O'Connell is the NFL Coach of the Year

Vikings are great. Vikings keep rolling. Vikings are Kevin O'Connell's just, he's Coach of the year, in my opinion. He's, I mean, think about what he's done... Sam Darnold, who's been thrown to the trash pile a few different times. He's made him playing at elite level.

Kevin O'Connell won the 2024 AP NFL Coach of the Year award, leading the Vikings to a 14-3 record with Sam Darnold at QB. Big Cat's call was correct.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Vikings must keep Sam Darnold because he is playing at an elite level that justifies a big contract

I still think you gotta keep Sam, I think you have to keep Sam... how much better could Sam Darnold be playing right now than he already is? He's worth that money. I wouldn't take that chance [on McCarthy].

PFT Commenter said the Vikings must keep Sam Darnold because he was playing at an elite level. The Vikings let Darnold leave in free agency without even franchise tagging him, opting to go with J.J. McCarthy instead. Darnold signed with the Seahawks.
Push
HankHank

The rumored Conor McGregor vs. Logan Paul boxing match will be a 'shitty money grab' that sucks

Conor McGregor tweeted that the rumors of about with Rio are false. I'm in preliminary agreements... to face Logan Paul in a boxing exhibition in India... It's probably gonna suck. I'm sick of it. This might be, so they fight someone who's actually like at the top of their game.

The McGregor vs Logan Paul fight was nixed by the UFC and did not happen. It was indeed a 'money grab' attempt that fell through, though it never took place so we can't judge if it 'sucked.'
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ultimate Dick Kicking is a better combat sport than Power Slap

We got a new combat sport that we have to start paying attention to guys, it's better than Power Slap. It's better than arm wrestling. It's the ultimate dick kicking championship. Two guys just stand across from each other and kick each other in the dicks until one guy gives up.

The 'better' combat sport is entirely subjective and intended as a joke.
Void
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

College football players should be required to sign contracts and form a union

I think these players at this point, they need to sign contracts. I think we need a CBA, I think we need to form some kind of player's union... we somehow need to get that national view to partner with the players union. Create a CBA where you're held accountable. Okay, we're gonna agree on NIL here are the rules we're gonna agree on... and then we obey the contract on both sides.

This is a policy proposal for the future of college athletics, which is currently undergoing significant legal and structural changes.
Win
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

Ohio State's offensive line is a massive concern that could lead to an upset loss against Tennessee

If you really watched the Michigan game, when they lost the center from Alabama, Seth McLaughlin, when he went down with that Achilles, I think that offensive line is a serious question mark going up against Tennessee's strength, which is their defensive front.

Tennessee won 27-24, and the OSU offensive line struggled significantly in the loss.
Void
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

The Dr Pepper tuition challenge is 'embarrassing' and should be moved back 10 yards to ban chest passes

I'm with you. That, that, you know, everybody, it is almost like pop a shot. They're just firing that thing away. Right. And it, it doesn't take any ability at all. Right. So I think that, I think you're onto something. I think you move it back at least another 10 yards... to take away that, the chest pass.

This is a humorous critique of a promotional segment.
Open
Paul Walter HauserPaul Walter Hauser

I will play the role of Chris Farley with such love that I won't let his fans down

I love Chris so much that I'm incapable of letting Chris, and I mean, I, I can't, I'm not incapable of letting his fans down... I love Chris so much that I'm not worried about keeping his memory alive in a, in an authentic and loving way. I know I'm going to do that... some people are just supposed to play certain people.

The movie's reception will ultimately determine if the fans feel 'let down'.
Void
Paul Walter HauserPaul Walter Hauser

Aaron Rodgers' best days are definitely behind him

And I think, you know, Rogers the best days are probably behind. But I loved watching him... Not everyone can stay. So you can be talented but not have the sharp or crispness that you once had. And it doesn't mean you're not good. It just means you're a 42-year-old quarterback.

This is a common observation based on Rodgers' 2024 stats and age.
Void
Paul Walter HauserPaul Walter Hauser

I want to still be doing WrestleMania and getting put through tables when I'm 60 years old

I hope I'm still showing up at WrestleMania and someone's putting me through a table... my hope is that when I'm 60... someone's putting me through a table. I don't think [the competitive spirit] will happen to you [leave you].

This is a personal goal/outlook for his future.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes will be totally fine despite his high ankle sprain

Do we believe it? Do we think it matters? Because he, I feel like this happens to him once a year and he ends up being totally fine and everyone's like, oh man, he's banged up, but it'll be fine.

Mahomes did not miss time and the Chiefs continued their run to the Super Bowl.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Jameis Winston's time as the starting quarterback in Cleveland is over

The bigger story is it might be over for Jamis [Winston] in Cleveland... When you get benched for DTR, it's bad. He was on, I'll say this, if you watch this game, the Chief's defensive line was on fire and Jamis had no time.

Winston actually started the final three games of the season for Cleveland despite being benched in this specific game.
Void
MemesMemes

I'm back in on Aaron Rodgers

I'm back in on Rogers... I'm back in on Aaron Rogers. I'm definitely... I'm back in on Aaron Rogers if that means we get to keep Devonte Adams.

Subjective personal stance as a fan.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Mac Jones might be the cockiest bad quarterback of all time

I think Mac Jones might be the cockiest bad quarterback of all time... he is legitimately cocky for how bad he is... he's got the cockiness of 'My dad will sue you.'

Subjective opinion on player personality/performance.
Loss
MemesMemes

The Jets should hire a new GM first, then a coach, and use Aaron Rodgers as a bridge to Jameis Winston

Hire GM. GM first... Hire coach. Hire coach... Aaron Rogers Bridge... Bridge to Jamis. Jamis could be on the team too. Give it another go next year. Then quarterback the next year.

The Jets did not follow this plan, as they pursued different coaching and GM candidates and Jameis Winston remained under contract/focus elsewhere.
Void
HankHank

Jerod Mayo feels like a puppet for Robert Kraft

I've always kind of said [Mayo] feels like a puppet for Craft... today they were cutting to the booth and the Lip readers, they had Jonathan Craft taking notes and you could clearly read his lips being like, 'the play calling is terrible'... that's not a good sign.

This is a subjective characterization of a coaching relationship.
Void
HankHank

Travis Hunter is better as a cornerback than as a wide receiver

I think [Hunter] is better as a corner. I would have, I don't know. He's better as a corner. He's better as a corner. Yeah. Him and Christian Gonzalez... that'd be the Patriot missile No Fly zone.

Positional superiority is a matter of opinion and will be debated throughout Hunter's NFL career.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mike Evans is one of the greatest receivers of all time

Respect. Mike Evans is one of the greatest receivers of all time. He had 159 yards, two touchdowns... he's gotta average 83.7 yards in his final three games to reach a thousand yards for the 11th straight season. And that's all 11 years of his career.

Evans did reach the 1,000-yard mark for the 11th straight season, solidifying his HOF case.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Broncos are the best story in the NFL right now

The Broncos are one of the best stories in the NFL right now... they just secured their first winning season since 2016 and have a playoff probability north of 90%. They're the best story right now in the NFL.

Subjective evaluation of team narratives.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Colts need to move on from GM Chris Ballard

Chris Ballard... feels like he's had a job for way too long and it just doesn't feel like the Colts are ever going. They're never, they're always like right around that middle ground, but they're never going forward... It might be time.

The Colts did not move on from Chris Ballard; he remained the General Manager following the 2024 season.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles are the best team in the NFC

I'll say it. Eagles is the best team in the NFC after today. They are... they're the best team in the NFC as of right now.

The Eagles finished with a high seed but the Lions ultimately earned the #1 seed and represented the NFC in the Super Bowl.
Loss
MaxMax

Anything less than winning a Super Bowl is a disappointment for the Eagles

A hundred percent. A hundred percent. Anything less than a soupy is a disappointment... Winning a soupy. Gotta win a soupy. Winning a soupy gotta win. It must win.

The Eagles did not win the Super Bowl in 2024, making the season a 'disappointment' by this standard.
Void
HankHank

LeBron James' absence was extremely odd and under-reported

He left the Lakers a few days ago... there was, you know, internet rumors circulating that he was maybe getting arrested. That he was disappearing... it was weird the way it was, you know, he left and with LeBron and the media, they, you know, will talk about him nonstop and it kind of got swept under the rug.

Subjective take on media coverage and personal speculation.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Analytics and the three-point shot have made the NBA tough to watch

It's analytics. I blame analytics... That too. Three point shot. That too. Dunk should be three... Imagine if they made dunks threes. Everyone was just trying to fucking yam on each other constantly. That would be sick.

Subjective opinion on game quality.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Paying Brock Purdy $60 million per year would be insane

The projections that I'm reading right now... a report 60 a year. That's insane. You can't pay Brock Purdy 60 a year... he's a good quarterback, he's not in the level of make everyone better quarterback.

Brock Purdy signed a 5-year, $265 million extension ($53M/year average) with the 49ers in May 2025. While Big Cat said $60M/year was insane, Purdy got $53M/year which is in the same ballpark. The 49ers did pay him a massive deal, suggesting the market valued Purdy highly despite Big Cat's skepticism.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Brock Purdy looked stupid and shitty against the Rams

I think he had a very bad game tonight. Like he looks, he looked stupid and shitty tonight. That's my analysis. That last throw was so bad. It was stupid and shitty in one throw. It was dumb to throw it and it was a bad pass.

Purdy did throw a crucial interception and the 49ers offense struggled significantly in that game.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The San Francisco 49ers are officially dead for the 2024 season

The Niners are dead. It's over reset everything. It's over... less than 1% chance [to make the playoffs].

The 49ers finished the season with a losing record and missed the playoffs.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants are currently the worst team in the NFL without Dexter Lawrence

I'll say this, without Dexter Lawrence, I think [the Giants] might be the worst team. I think they would take the key. So it'd be between the Giants, the Raiders, and the Titans.

This is subjective but grounded in the Giants' poor performance and the analytical value of Lawrence.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bill Belichick's main recruiting pitch at UNC will be a direct, simplified path to the NFL

There is a compelling case for Bill Belichick shows up to your living room and says, Hey, I can get you in the NFL... I'm not gonna sit here and pretend that you need an education... I'm just gonna get you to the NFL.

The effectiveness of this pitch will be seen over several recruiting cycles, but it is currently a theoretical opinion.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Lions defense struggles against running quarterbacks

This is the week that the lions all their defensive injuries... This is an elite elite offense. And Aaron Glenn, I know this from experience because Justin Fields used to play well against Lions. Aaron Glenn's defenses don't do well against running quarterbacks. He refuses to do a spy.

Josh Allen did have success running against the Lions, scoring multiple rushing touchdowns in their Week 15 matchup.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Bills vs. Lions is a potential Super Bowl preview

Possible Super Bowl preview. This would be my dream Super Bowl matchup in terms of fans... in New Orleans. Holy shit. Would it rock just like partying with Lions and Bills fans all week.

The Super Bowl was Eagles vs. Chiefs, not Bills vs. Lions. Neither the Bills nor Lions made the Super Bowl.
Void
NF
Nick Foles

The Chicago Bears are stuck in an unhealthy cycle of hiring coaches on their 'last leg' who then draft and ruin rookie quarterbacks

They're sort of in this cycle that it is just not a healthy cycle... their coaching staff at the end of their like their prove-it year, they draft a quarterback in the first round... The rookie quarterback gets one year with the coaching staff and then they've just been fired. And then that rookie quarterback... has to deal with that again. It's not a great cycle.

The historical pattern (Fox/Trubisky, Nagy/Fields, Eberflus/Williams) supports this analysis of organizational dysfunction.
Void
NF
Nick Foles

Andy Reid is the greatest coach because he knows the pulse of his team and refuses to listen to outside input

I always go to the example of Andy Reid. I think Andy Reid's the greatest... Big Red's gonna make the best decision. Like you might think like you have said something that's really gonna impact and change the way he thought. He knows what's best for the pulse of his team and he's gonna take you that direction.

This is a subjective assessment of coaching greatness from a player who played for him.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Meta Quest 3 is significantly better than the Apple Vision Pro

I got the Apple Vision Pro like seven months ago. What a waste of fucking money that was. That was probably the the biggest waste of money I've ever had in my entire life... picked up the Meta Quest 3. That thing rocks... this kicks the shit out of the Apple Vision Pro.

This is a subjective consumer opinion.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McCarthy needs to stop watching replays of his team's mistakes on the Jumbotron during games

I have a suggestion from Mike McCarthy... Something bad happens, you know, something bad has just happened in the game. As head coach, he forces himself to watch the replay of that bad thing over and over and just sit in that pain. Yeah, Mike, you gotta stop doing that. You gotta stop subjecting yourself to just trauma repeatedly over and over again.

This is a subjective observation of coaching behavior.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Simpsons characters are significantly better in 2D than 3D

I did watch the first half of The Simpsons broadcast last night, and I don't know why it took me so long to remember this. The Simpsons are a million times better in 2D. The Simpsons in 3D. Not that fun.

Artistic preference is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The 'In the Hunt' graphics for the NFC are currently patronizing to bad teams

Everyone from the Saints on down, Saints, Cowboys, Bears, Panthers. Just just be like, Hey, I know technically not [eliminated], but dude, get a fucking grip. You're brain dead if you're actually thinking this.

The teams mentioned (Saints, Cowboys, Bears, Panthers) all eventually missed the playoffs in the 2024 season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The extreme delusional negativity of Philly fans is a sign the Eagles are ready for a Super Bowl run

I saw this video and I was like, this could not sum up the Philadelphia Eagles fan base more and I wouldn't have it any other way... I actually think that this might be a sign that the Eagles are ready to go on a Super Bowl run because they're what, 11 and two and they've won nine games in a row. Everything's going well. They now have players talking about players. Old players talking about old players.

This is a subjective take on team chemistry and fan psychology.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I would vote for Ashton Jeanty to win the Heisman Trophy

If I had a vote today after the votes were in, I'd probably vote [Ashton Jeanty].

Travis Hunter won the 2024 Heisman Trophy, making this vote 'incorrect' in terms of backing the winner.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers