Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Push
HankHank

I'd much rather the Celtics play the Bulls in the first round because it's a free win

I mean the Heat obviously have had success against us. No Jimmy Butler... but still it's like, you just don't mess with [the Heat]. Forget about the Heat. Don't mess with it. If you play the Bulls, it's much better... I just want the free win.

The Heat beat the Bulls in the play-in for the 8-seed, so the Celtics played the Heat. The Celtics won the series 4-1, proving that even the Heat weren't a major threat.
Win
HankHank

JJ McCarthy is my 5th ranked QB because he's a game-managing system quarterback

JJ McCarthy... is the bottom... He doesn't throw, he didn't see any long balls or all the long balls are wide open. Short throw. Short throws... he's seen the, he, he was a game manager. System quarterback.

JJ McCarthy was drafted 10th overall by the Vikings, lower than the big 3 and Penix, which aligns with Hank's ranking (5th among the top group).
Loss
HankHank

Drake Maye looks short on film and the ball looks heavy in his hands

Drake Maye... This was the biggest, the biggest deterrent and, and the thing that I see happening the most, the ball seems very heavy in his hands... It just seems like it takes him a long time to get the ball up and out... [He] looked short in the film that I was watching.

Drake Maye is 6'4'', which is tall for a QB, and his arm strength is considered elite by actual scouts, making the 'heavy ball' take highly subjective and likely incorrect.
Void
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

Most people tap out in Jiu-Jitsu because of the fear of being in the submission, not because it actually hurts yet

Most people tap before it actually, like before the submission actually hurts, right? It's like the fear of being in the submission is when you tap. And so like that can be applicable to handling championship expectations or success.

This is a subjective observation about psychology and competition.
Win
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

The more successful you are, the closer you are to losing

The closer you are to winning, the closer you are to losing. Right? So like, you saw it at UFC 300... most people can't handle the fact that you think you beat your opponent, but now you still have to fight them.

This is a philosophical principle that Mazzulla successfully applied to lead the Celtics to a championship shortly after this interview.
Void
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

You can't allow the best player on the opposing team to take a practice shot after the whistle because it's insulting and helps them find rhythm

I don't understand how you could give your opponent any opportunity to feel good about themselves on your half of the turf... I don't think there's anything more insulting than allowing your opponent to do that... What if that one kind of gets the, gets him the rhythm that he needs to make one?

Whether it actually affects rhythm is debatable, but the Celtics did have an historically efficient season.
Void
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

I refuse to walk through revolving doors because you are a sitting duck if they get stuck

I won't walk through revolving doors. Because like one of them gets stuck, then you're just a sitting duck. Avoid them. Get stuck, you're, you're screwed.

This is a personal lifestyle choice based on his worldview.
Void
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

I never sit with my back to the door in restaurants so I can always have a vantage point

I never sit with my back to the door like you in a restaurant. I never sit with my back to the door. You always gotta sit to where You can have a vantage point of like, everything that's going on around you.

This is a personal habit rooted in safety/strategic thinking and cannot be objectively proven correct or incorrect.
Void
Joe MazzullaJoe Mazzulla

The Ninja Turtles are the Mount Rushmore of Italians

I think the Ninja Turtles are probably up there [on the Mount Rushmore of Italians]... Rafael's more my personality. Michelangelo is my son's favorite, so I flock to him.

Purely subjective and comedic.
Win
Michael MaloneMichael Malone

Victor Wembanyama is the future of the NBA and has no weaknesses

Yes, you're watching Wembanyama and you're saying, wow, this guy is a future of the NBA... Wendy's ability to be a playmaker. His passing ability, he was making all his teammates better... he's gonna get stronger, but I, I don't see any weaknesses in his game.

Wembanyama unanimously won Rookie of the Year and finished 2nd in DPOY voting, largely validating this take.
Push
Michael MaloneMichael Malone

The Oklahoma City Thunder aren't too young to win a title

I don't buy into the hole, they're too young to win it. Last year people thought, well, we've never won a championship. They can't win a finals... They have the talent, they have the coaching, and I think these Western conference playoffs are just gonna be so fun to watch.

The Thunder won their first-round series but lost in the second round to the Mavericks, showing they were capable of winning playoff games but not yet a title.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Pelicans would have beaten the Lakers if Zion Williamson had stayed in the game

I think the Pelicans win that game if Zion stays in the game. They had, Brandon Ingram wasn't good... and Zion was like, I'm putting the whole team on my back. And he almost beat the Lakers by himself.

The game was tied 95-95 with 3:13 left when Zion exited; the Lakers eventually won 110-106. While unprovable, it is a widely held 'what if'.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Chicago Sky are going to play 'bully ball' with Kamilla Cardoso and Angel Reese

Angel Reese and [Kamilla] Cardoso... in the last year, the two of them have shot five total three pointers. Bully ball. Just rebound. We're going just bully ball. Everyone's shooting the three, we're just gonna fucking pack the paint and just have some beasts down there.

The Sky indeed led the WNBA in rebounding for much of the season, specifically offensive rebounds, driven by Reese and Cardoso.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I will no longer praise the food at Guaranteed Rate Field because Jerry Reinsdorf is a bad owner

I'm no longer gonna say that [the food is good] because that's what Jerry Reinsdorf wants you to say... It doesn't matter what happens on the field. We got great food, we got great beer... I can no longer say that I'm gonna stand with White Sox fans. I will no longer plug the fact that going to a game there is actually fun.

This is a subjective personal pledge based on team performance and ownership quality.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Alex Caruso should get the final open spot on the Team USA Olympic roster

It's gotta be Caruso. Gotta be Caruso. Needs to be Caruso for sure. We gotta get Caruso on this team.

Kawhi Leonard was initially given the final spot, and Derrick White replaced him. Caruso was not selected.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Blake Griffin is a first-ballot Hall of Famer

I think it's a no brainer. I think it's first ballot.

This will be determined when Griffin becomes eligible for the Hall of Fame in 2027.
Void
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Kyrie Irving is the most talented basketball player in the NBA

I think he's the most talented basketball player in the NBA, maybe still. It's a weird thing to say because there's so many talented guys, but the things he does at his stature... he probably has like three of the top five things craziest things I've seen in practice of all time.

This is an expert opinion from a peer that cannot be definitively proven or disproven.
Win
Blake GriffinBlake Griffin

Joe Mazzulla's authenticity is why he will be a great coach for a long time

I think that's one of the most important things about head coaches is the authenticity. Like guys can sniff through it immediately... that's just who he's, so I think that's why he's, he's gonna be a great coach for a long time.

Mazzulla led the Celtics to the 2024 NBA Championship shortly after this interview, validating the 'great coach' take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Verne Lundquist should do a 'ManningCast' style broadcast for the Masters starting next year

Verne needs to do like a ManningCast thing next year at the Masters where it's just Verne sitting in his living room... with that big smile on his face.

This is a subjective opinion about media formatting.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Golfers should be allowed to use any club they want, regardless of size

My take is that you should be allowed to use whatever club you want. Yeah. Ever. Like all the time. Doesn't matter how big it is. Gets blow in the hole. You should, you should be allowed to cheat at golf with the clubs that you use. You, you obviously have to take your own shots. But if they're your clubs, they're in your bag. Just get the ball in the hole.

The USGA and R&A have strict rules on equipment conformity that are unlikely to change.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UFC overtime should consist of a five-foot octagon where fighters punch each other until someone wins

That should be overtime in all the UFCs just stand, they they shrink the octagon. Yeah. and just like five feet in diameter, just stand in there and punch each other until somebody wins.

This is a satirical suggestion for a rule change.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Nestor Cortes' fake pitch is awesome because of how much it bothers baseball traditionalists

I'm Now on Cortez's side. All right. I Now think it's an awesome pitch. I didn't [know] it made people that mad. So, I mean, there's no way this is actually like a strategy that could like [work]... I Now think it's an awesome pitch. If it makes people mad, that rules.

The value of the pitch is subjective, based on its ability to annoy traditionalists.
Loss
HankHank

The Patriots should draft Marvin Harrison Jr. instead of a quarterback

I'm still down for Marvin Harrison Jr. No one... [Bailey] Zappe's there. Yeah. There's plenty of fine quarterbacks out there. You have a franchise wide receiver who's a stud and can actually make things happen with a perfectly fine Jacoby Brissett.

The Patriots drafted QB Drake Maye at #3 overall, rejecting Hank's preferred strategy.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Mark Pope will succeed at Kentucky because nostalgia is a powerful drug

Kentucky basketball and Mark Pope. Yeah. I I'm with you. I think I'm be, I'm a believer in Mark Pope now. Nostalgia is a very powerful drug. Like I would just, if I were a Kentucky fan right now, I'd just be looking at pictures of Mark Pope and Rick Pitino and be like, this is, this is, we're going back. Sometimes you gotta go back.

Pope's success will be determined by future seasons at Kentucky.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Scottie Scheffler's dominance is sustainable because he has no vices and a strong perspective on life

The genius of Scottie is he's like, 'I'm real good with whatever this is and I'm not trying to change any of it.' ... Presuming he stays healthy, I think he'll just keep just obliterating people... he just doesn't seem to have vices or things that that could get in the way of any of it.

Scheffler's continued success suggests this perspective is accurate, though it remains subjective.
Void
Scott Van PeltScott Van Pelt

Fans do not care about the LIV vs. PGA Tour drama anymore and the game just needs to be unified

No one gives a shit about this LIV stuff at this point. Golf just needs to get back together... I think everyone kind of just understands that it's better when everyone plays. It's fun to see [Rahm] and Brooks and Bryson and Cam Smith... you wanna see 'em all play together 'cause that means the best in the world are together.

This is a subjective assessment of fan sentiment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NBA should allow the top four seeds to draft their first-round opponents

The NBA should do two new things the NBA should do. They should do a draft of who the top four seeds get to pick who they get to play in the first round. And also there should just be an automatic Weby makes the Playoffs clause.

The NBA has not implemented a draft system for playoff opponents.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

OJ Simpson was a significantly better football player than he was a person

Say what you will about OJ. But he was a way, way better football player than person. Absolutely. Not even close. Like 2000 yards in 14 games.

The take is subjective, but accurately reflects Simpson's Hall of Fame career versus his legal history.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Will Compton is a better person than he was a football player

The perfect Will Compton is a better person than he was a football player. Oh, a hundred percent. Yeah. It's easy. Yeah. That's easy.

This is a subjective comparison of character vs. athletic skill.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Skinny jeans are a joke and it is impossible to look tough while wearing them

I think that certain fads out there, certain trends are just set up as a joke by the industry to see what these suckers will pay for and start wearing. I think the entire skinny jeans movement was like that. You can't, in my opinion, you can't look tough wearing skinny jeans.

This is a purely subjective fashion opinion.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Making 25 bets a day is not that crazy for a serious gambler

25 bets a day is not that crazy. I wanna say that a lot of people were shaming that listen during this college football Saturday. It's not that crazy gamble responsibly.

'Crazy' is a subjective descriptor of gambling habits.
Loss
HankHank

I think Shohei Ohtani was gambling

I think he was gambling. [Big Cat: You do, do you think Shohei was gambling?] Yeah.

Federal investigators eventually charged Ippei Mizuhara and cleared Ohtani of any knowledge or involvement in the gambling.
Win
Jake MarshJake Marsh

It is crazy to accuse Shohei Ohtani of gambling without a full investigation clearing him first

I think a lot of people are accusing that. I think they just want the chaos. But I think that's crazy to accuse unless like they did a full investigation and he's clear.

Shohei Ohtani was eventually cleared by the federal investigation, making Jake's cautious approach look correct in hindsight.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Scott Drew claiming God called him to stay in Waco is a red flag given the history of religious leaders in that area

I just wanna remind people of the last guy that said God is commanding them to live in Waco, Texas. And how that turned out. Not great.

This is a historical reference used for comedic effect.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

Mark Pope is a better fit for Kentucky than Calipari because he can actually coach basketball, even if he doesn't recruit as well

One of the complaints that Kentucky fans have had for the last four or five years is like, we get the recruits but we don't have coaching. Mark Pope can coach. So you get the coaching now.

The success of Mark Pope vs Calipari will be determined over the next few seasons.
Void
Kirk MinihaneKirk Minihane

Max Homa needs to be more of an asshole to win major championships

I do like [Max Homa], but I think he has that Rory disease... He wants to be liked too much. He's a very nice guy. But I want him to be more of an asshole because I think assholes win these things.

Subjective opinion on personality traits and their link to winning.
Void
Kirk MinihaneKirk Minihane

Scottie Scheffler is a bore despite being a historically great golfer

The Scottie Scheffler of it all just looms and he's such a bore. I understand he's a wonderful player, but he's so boring.

Boringness is a subjective trait.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The golf talent pool is so deep now because of the 'Tiger Woods generation' that we will never see a dominant superstar like him again

I don't think we'll ever see a golfer that good again because... now we're watching the products of the Tiger Woods youth generation. The talent pool's too big now.

This is a historical and sociological theory about sports evolution.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I have officially transitioned into a 'spill guy' who spills on his clothes once a week

I had a great run as a guy who didn't spill on himself... I am now a spill guy. Happens probably once a week. Chips in queso have become the devil. I just end up with a spill no matter what.

Personal admission of a lifestyle change.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UConn just completed the most dominant postseason run of any team in history

The most dominant stretch in postseason play of any team ever. The best, the best run of any team ever. I think we could say like UConn dominate everybody. The games were not particularly exciting. UConn, they, I think they're the best second half team in the entire tournament by a vast margin.

UConn won all 6 games by 13+ points for the second straight year, a historic level of point-differential dominance.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Hurley's press conference after losing to Villanova in 2020 will go down as one of the coolest, most badass clips of all time

Danny Hurley's press conference after the Villanova lost in 2020 might go down as one of the coolest, most badass Clips of all time when he said, get us now, 'cause we're coming and you're not gonna get us later.

The clip is widely regarded as iconic in college basketball history now that UConn has achieved this dominance.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Dan Hurley is the new face of college basketball

[Dan Hurley] shows his emotion and he's not a fucking robot and he's the new face of college basketball.

Winning back-to-back titles and the media attention he commands makes this a widely accepted take.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If UConn wins a third title in a row, they will officially be 'bad for basketball' like their women's team was

What happens if UConn wins a third in a row? ... At that point they become UConn women's team. Yeah. They're bad for basketball 10 years ago. They're bad for basketball.

UConn did not win a third in a row, so the condition was never met.
Push
MaxMax

UConn will struggle next year because they return almost nobody

It also is crazy that everyone just keeps talking like UConn like three, they literally return nobody... Samson Johnson's a junior... Caravan's a sophomore... Caravan's is the only one I was wrong on.

While UConn lost several players to the NBA, they returned key pieces like Karaban and brought in talent, but they did not win a third title.
Void
HankHank

The solar eclipse was overrated

So my Hot Seat is us. We're still in the third dimension. I was kind of looking forward to it. So that was, it was gonna be cool throne, but I kind of was hoping we were in the hot fourth dimension. So, well, eclipse sucked, overrated eclipse.

Subjective opinion on a public event.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Masters app is the greatest piece of technology ever invented

My cool Throne is the Masters app... I redownload the Master's app. Have to, it's a tradition unlike any other. And when you log into the, the first time, it just feels, it's such a great way to come down from the NCAA tournament being over... the greatest piece of technology ever invented. Yep. And you open it up and you're like, everything's going to be okay. 'Cause the Masters app's here and it's comforting and it's perfect.

Hyperbolic opinion, though the app is frequently cited as best-in-class in sports tech reviews.
Win
Max HomaMax Homa

My great golf is good enough to win a major

I know for a fact my great golf's good enough. It just needs to come out the right week. So let's just hope it's this week. It's a big difference. It's a little bit more calming knowing that like, it doesn't need to be perfect. It just needs to be good.

Homa finished T3 in the 2024 Masters, proving his 'great golf' can indeed compete for a major.
Void
Brooks KoepkaBrooks Koepka

The best way to play golf is to simply not think about anything

Three of your 10 lessons, were just don't think... that's honestly Fellas. That's the best way to be. It's like, I just kept on scrolling and I was like, wait, we're not, oh, just a reminder. But don't you think that if you're telling everyone to not think about anything now they're thinking about not thinking about anything, which is perfect. That's right where I want 'em.

A subjective coaching philosophy from a multiple-time major winner.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I would not leave the Masters if I were winning, even for the birth of my first child

If I was winning the Masters, I would not leave. First kid. I agree with you. First kid. First kid. I would first kid if I was winning the Masters. If I was winning the Masters, I would not leave.

Personal stance on a hypothetical situation.
Void
TrentTrent

Walking nine holes is the best way to experience golf

If you find a course and you find like a, a slot of time where You can walk, it's amazing. I sound kinda like the old like romanticism of golf guy... recently, within the last couple years I would walk nine holes, never 18. I'm gonna die out there if I walk. But if I walk nine holes, it's fucking beautiful. Yeah. Because in a cart you almost aren't looking at the scenery around you.

Subjective preference for playing golf.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers