Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Void
HankHank

Basketball broadcasts should use the baseline rolling camera angle more frequently.

More basketball games should have the camera that they have on the baseline that rolls with the action. I only see that during the Final Four National Championship.

Inherently subjective preference on sports broadcasting aesthetics.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Texas Tech is officially a basketball school as long as Chris Beard is the coach.

I now officially consider you [Texas Tech] a basketball school as long as Chris Beard stays there.

Chris Beard eventually left for Texas, and Texas Tech has remained a competitive basketball program, though Beard was the catalyst for their peak.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Instant replay should have a shot clock to keep the game moving

We should just have a shot clock on the replays because that would be thrilling. If the ref only has a certain amount of time... if they can't find the replay fast enough, guess what? Tough shit.

This is a policy recommendation for sports broadcasting and officiating.
Void
HankHank

Jimmy Kimmel is no longer a 'guy's guy' because he thinks 'One Shining Moment' is bad

That's when Jimmy stopped being a guy's guy. [When he said] that one shining moment lived out its one shining moment 15 years ago... that it's not cool anymore.

The quality of a song and a person's status as a 'guy's guy' are subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Masters deserves all the hype it gets and cannot be overhyped

You can't overhype the Masters. Take your microphone off. That's a bad take. The Masters deserve all the hype.

The level of 'hype' an event deserves is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Reed's Masters menu looks like what a 14-year-old thinks an adult dinner is.

This menu really is like what a 14 year old would think an adult's menu looks like. He basically was forced to be like well I like steak and and I don't really like anything else. I like macaroni and cheese. I'm surprised chicken fingers weren't on here.

This is a subjective opinion on Patrick Reed's culinary taste.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Tiramisu is an overrated dessert

The dessert is weird. It's tiramisu. Tiramisu is overrated, by the way.

Taste in dessert is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The player who signs second between Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving will be viewed as the follower, not the leader.

Durant and Irving are debating on who will sign first. Why is that important? The player that is signed second is viewed as the follower, not the leader. Oh, my God. This league.

Durant and Irving ended up signing with the Nets together; the leader/follower narrative persisted regardless of timing.
Win
Chris LongChris Long

The double dribble by Virginia against Auburn was a clear foul that should be called 90% of the time.

I'm telling you, they missed the double dribble. I mean, that's clear. But... that play that went to the review, everybody that just two days ago was saying, we need to get every call inside two minutes right is all of a sudden anti-replay.

Broad consensus among officials and rules experts was that it was a missed double-dribble.
Void
Chris LongChris Long

Instant replay has been positive for the NFL and fans generally don't mind the pace of play issues.

I think replay has been good for football... Honestly, I don't know how we'd get through games nowadays without it. I think people mostly don't even notice that it's slowing the game down at all. I think we're mostly glad we have it.

Public opinion on NFL replay remains highly divided, making this an inherently subjective take.
Void
Chris LongChris Long

Being a sports fan is way harder than being a professional player

It's totally different as a fan. It's almost more nerve-wracking. You just feel so hopeless... As a fan, I am just, man, I, uh, I'm, I'm a basket case... being a fan is way harder than being a player.

The psychological difficulty of being a fan vs. a player is subjective.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Skip Bayless won by getting the Virginia Cavaliers to talk about him after the title game

Anytime a championship team talks about an analyst, a troll analyst, they won. Mission accomplished. No matter who it is, no matter what it is that's giving Stephen A. Smith attention, Stephen A. is basking in it.

The goal of these analysts is engagement and relevance, which Ty Jerome provided by mentioning them in his post-game press conference.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers isn't a malicious teammate, just passive-aggressive

I don't think that Aaron Rodgers is as bad as the article might have made him out to be. I don't think he is a maliciously bad teammate. I think he is very passive-aggressive and will cut someone off probably pretty quickly.

The internal personality traits of a player are subjective and debated among former teammates.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Auburn's loss to Virginia is the worst possible way to lose a Final Four game

Auburn, I would say that might be the worst possible way to lose a Final Four game of all time... hitting three free throws in that situation, that's the shit you do in your backyard, and you miss two out of three, and you're like, all right, redo. He was money on all three. And Auburn, I would say that might be the worst possible way to lose a Final Four game of all time.

While subjective, it remains one of the most debated and heartbreaking finishes in Final Four history.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kyle Guy is making a strong case for the Jim Nance Tie Player of the Year

He is making a hard case for the Jim Nance tie player of the year. I think if it's not Kyle Guy, I think even if UVA loses the national championship, Jim Nance is going to find a way to get him that tie.

Jim Nance did not give Kyle Guy his tie; he gave it to Jarrett Culver after the championship game.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

You can't play the 'sliding doors' game with officiating mistakes in a loss

Auburn has a terrible loss but at the end of the day it's like that's kind of how it goes. Like you can't play sliding doors, you can't be like, well this call should have gone another way and it would have changed everything.

This is a philosophical opinion about sports fandom and logic.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins is an average quarterback who doesn't motivate anyone

Kirk Cousins also gave the pregame speech which is perfectly Kirk Cousins. It was, it didn't motivate a single person and I honestly don't think like Michigan State like didn't lose the game as much as Texas Tech was just so fucking good.

Michigan State did lose the game following the speech, and Cousins' reputation as a mid-tier starter persisted for years.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Paul Pierce is making himself look overrated by actively claiming he's better than Dwyane Wade

Paul Pierce made the ultimate error where Paul Pierce is the perfect guy that if he just kind of stays under the radar, everyone will say, hey, you know who's better than people give him credit for? Paul Pierce. But when he says he's like actively says he's better than someone, people will roast him... now you've done the reverse. And everyone's like, Paul Pierce was overrated.

This prediction about public perception proved true, as Pierce was widely mocked for years following the 'better than Wade' and 'wheelchair game' discussions.
Win
Shawn MarionShawn Marion

The NBL is a legitimate professional league and its players could hold their own in the NBA

Don't slack on the NBL. I think them guys are professionals... there are some guys that can go out there and probably hold their own in the NBA with no problems at all.

The NBL has produced multiple NBA stars like LaMelo Ball and Josh Giddey since this interview.
Void
Shawn MarionShawn Marion

The 2006 Suns were better than the 2007 team that everyone thinks should have won the title

Everybody speculates thinking [2007] was the year we should have won the championship... I don't. [The year before that] was better... I was physically, mentally drained because I was going from Sam Cassell to Elden Brand and Chris Kaman. From Kobe to Lamar to Ron Artest... Then I had to go against Dirk. My body was shut. I was tired. I was dead tired.

This is a former player's personal assessment of his own team's strength and fatigue levels.
Void
Shawn MarionShawn Marion

Dirk Nowitzki was actually a great defender during the Mavericks' 2011 championship run

Dirk was actually a great defender for us in the championship run. People like, you know, I ain't, but like I said, it's not all about individual defense, but team defense. He was amazing.

This is a tactical evaluation by a teammate.
Void
Shawn MarionShawn Marion

LeBron James isn't a bad teammate, but he does show his teammates up too much on the court

He's not a bad teammate... but I'm just going to be real candid and honest, though. I think he shows his teammates up a little bit too much on the court. You know, and, you know, that's just part of him.

Subjective assessment of leadership style.
Void
Shawn MarionShawn Marion

LeBron James shows his teammates up too much on the court

I think he shows his teammates up a little bit too much on the court. You know, and, you know, that's just part of him. I mean, you know, he kind of feel like he earned that. And I mean, that's him... but that's one of the things I don't like he does.

This is a subjective observation from a former teammate.
Void
The MizThe Miz

The 2018 Evolution event was the best WWE pay-per-view of the year

This year we had our first ever all women's pay-per-view Evolution, which I think stands as the best pay-per-view we've had all year... it blew the roof off the place.

Subjective opinion on wrestling match quality.
Void
The MizThe Miz

The Undertaker is the most intimidating person in the world

Undertaker is the most intimidating person. There is nothing more intimidating. When he steps in that ring, it's just magical. He's literally a dead man walking.

This is a subjective opinion from a peer in the industry.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Referees and umpires are more entertaining when they stand up for themselves

I like umps that stand up for themselves. I think that we've done umps a disservice recently... I like it when they stand up for themselves, when they have a thing like Country Joe West. It's kind of fun knowing that there's a guy out there who's absolutely not what people paid to watch that thinks that he's what people paid to watch.

Subjective appreciation of entertainment value in sports officiating.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

I am officially panicking about the Cubs in the first week of April

I've already taken the panic button out of my closet for the Cubs. It's April. I know. I don't care... If I have to watch Yu Darvish pitch more fucking walks and Jason Hayward hit into more double plays, I will smash the fuck out of that panic button.

The 2019 Cubs missed the playoffs, finishing 84-78, suggesting the early panic was somewhat warranted.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The AAF was a Fire Fest run by people with no plan

It is hilarious to just imagine Bill Polian as being Billy McFarland. Like, drinking like rock stars, fucking like porn stars speech. I guarantee you Bill has said that at some point... Instead of cocaine and tequila on a private island, it was like tortilla chips and a nice beer, just hanging out watching tape.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
The comparison is satirical, but the league's collapse was a factual disaster.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Lying to your doctor is a universal human experience despite being dangerous

Doctors are the one profession that we should not lie to, but we lie to them the most. All the time... whenever you have to fill out a form, whenever anyone has to ask you, like, hey, give us the honest truth about your health. Yeah, I don't really want to do that.

While not a scientific fact, it's a widely acknowledged social phenomenon.
Void
George KittleGeorge Kittle

There are many number one tight ends in the NFL, but Rob Gronkowski and Tony Gonzalez are the standard

Man, I think there's a lot of number one tight ends right now... I'm going to keep going now. It's working for me so far... [Who's the best?] Gronk and Tony [Gonzalez].

Consensus top tight ends mentioned.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The AAF died exactly like the XFL did

This is what we warned you about. This is exactly what happened with the XFL. It just died. And we all got excited. And then it died.

The AAF did indeed collapse mid-season in 2019, much like the original 2001 XFL (though XFL finished one season).
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Alliance of American Football failed because they didn't have an 'L' for League in their name

That was the biggest, actually, problem, is they didn't have an L. Yeah. And you know what? Two vowels at the start of your league? Yes. Listen, these are things that we could have solved.

The league did indeed fail, though the name was likely not the primary cause.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The AAF was like the cold pizza served at the end of a wedding when the party is already over

I think it was actually the cold pizza that they buy like 50 pizzas at the end of a wedding when the music stops and everyone's sweaty and drunk... That's what the AAF was. The party was over.

Subjective comparison of the league's cultural relevance.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Gar Foreman and John Paxson are the idiots in the room now that Ernie Grunfeld is fired

Gar Foreman and John Paxson because now they are the idiots in the room. So it's like you never want to be the last to leave a party. They are the dum-dums. And you could always say, well, it's not Ernie Grunfeld. Well, guess what? Now Ernie Grunfeld's gone, so you are on the hot seat.

GarPax were eventually removed/reassigned by the Bulls in 2020 following years of fan protest.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears won the Jay Cutler trade

I think we can all look back and say that was a great success. I think the Bears won that trade. I remember vividly... thinking the Bears are probably going to win two Super Bowls from Jay Cutler.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
Cutler holds most Bears passing records, but never reached the Super Bowl as predicted. Most analysts consider the trade a mixed bag rather than a clear 'win'.
Void
Christian LaettnerChristian Laettner

Upperclassmen leadership is the difference in the NCAA tournament

Sometimes you run across a Michigan State team that's as physical and have maybe a little more junior and senior leadership than we had. And that makes a huge difference in the tournament if you have some upperclassmen that give you some experience.

This is a classic basketball philosophy, particularly relevant in the one-and-done era.
Void
Christian LaettnerChristian Laettner

The one-and-done era has watered down both college and NBA basketball

And it's watered down the game a little bit. And then everyone leaving early for the NBA, I think, waters down the NBA a little bit. But it's hard to stop kids from pursuing their dream.

A widely debated structural opinion about basketball talent pipelines.
Win
Christian LaettnerChristian Laettner

Magic Johnson and Larry Bird were the first guards to have guard skills at 6'9"

Larry Bird and Magic Johnson were the first guys I ever saw six nine six ten bringing the ball up having guard skills so to be on a team with them was just awesome.

Historically accurate observation of the evolution of the 'point forward' and skilled big man.
Void
Christian LaettnerChristian Laettner

There is no such thing as a clutch gene

Is the clutch gene real? No, not real at all.

Inherently subjective/unverifiable biological claim.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL draft hats are just a way for Roger Goodell to sell more junk

This is what Roger Goodell is really, really good at, and that's just finding a one-off occasion and then selling a bunch of shit on top of it. So they designed all 32 teams brand-new hats.

The business model of the NFL clearly supports this, though 'junk' is subjective.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL released draft hats just to flex on the dying AAF

Basically, they put a big piece of cheese out in the middle of the floor... Snap. You're talking about the NFL in the middle of April. This is the nail in the coffin for the AAF. It's a flex.

The AAF died for financial reasons, though the NFL's dominance is undeniable.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The New York Giants draft hat looks like it has a barbed wire tattoo

The Giants one looks like it's got a barbed wire tattoo around the entire hat, which is very appropriate for the fan base.

Subjective roast of apparel design.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson was the college basketball season and his departure leaves a hole in the Final Four.

I'm going to miss Zion a lot because he was so much fun to watch this season. He was the college basketball season, and he leaves like a hole in all of our hearts for the Final Four. Zion was the only one who, like, wanted it, I felt like, a lot of times during this Duke run.

Subjective appreciation of a player's impact.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Kentucky would destroy Auburn if the game were played on an NBA court instead of a college court.

[Kentucky] has too many NBA caliber players and it doesn't translate to college ball. Kentucky would destroy Auburn on an NBA court... That's actually very, very true.

This is a hypothetical claim that can't be proven, though Kentucky did have more NBA talent (Herro, Washington, Johnson) than Auburn.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I doubt the Gonzaga basketball program will ever be able to get over the hump and win a national championship.

I doubt that that [Gonzaga] program will ever get over that hump. It's just they've got that stink on them now. And it's tough to wash it out.

As of 2024, Gonzaga has still not won a national title, though they reached the championship game again in 2021.
Void
Mark TitusMark Titus

Coach K and John Calipari are more focused on building their brands than winning basketball games.

Cal and Coach K are not playing the same game as everyone else. They're not trying to win basketball games. They're trying to win their brand. They're trying to build their brands and keep the machine just churning. And they don't want anyone to notice.

This is a subjective interpretation of coaching philosophies and program management.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Zion Williamson is 'one bad weekend away' from being fat.

Zion Williamson, the best way to describe him is, as a bigger guy myself, he's one bad weekend away from being fat. Like, if I go one weekend where I just eat like shit, drink like shit, don't sleep very well, I'll come in Monday morning and everyone will be like, whoa, dude, what happened to you? And it can happen that fast.

History has shown that Zion's weight and conditioning have been consistent issues throughout his early NBA career.
Void
Mark TitusMark Titus

The gap between Zion Williamson and the second-best player in college basketball is the largest I have ever seen.

I can't remember a time in my life where the gap between the best player in college basketball and the second best player was so big as it was this year.

Widely accepted at the time given Zion's historic PER and physical dominance, though talent gaps are subjective.
Win
Mark TitusMark Titus

Auburn is a nightmare matchup for Virginia because they play fast and shoot a high volume of threes.

Auburn is a nightmare matchup for Virginia in the sense that they play fast and shoot a ton of threes... That's always been Virginia's kryptonite, is teams that just bomb threes on them. So, I don't know. Auburn might be all right.

Correct; Auburn pushed Virginia to the absolute limit in a 63-62 game that was decided by a controversial foul on a three-pointer at the buzzer.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

I am going to miss watching LeBron James in the first round of the NBA playoffs.

Everyone out there, please remind us how much fun it's been to talk about LeBron this year because I will have a moment in the first round of the playoffs where I'll be like, I kind of wish LeBron was here.

Subjective viewer sentiment, though the Lakers did indeed miss the playoffs.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers