Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Baker Mayfield & Alex Caruso, MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred, Scottie Scheffler Dominates The Open + Mt Rushmore Of Best Bad Movies

Monday, July 21, 202520 takes

Scottie Scheffler wins again and his dominating year continues. The Open was such a snooze fest that we resorted to Tiger vs Scottie debates and people forget how awesome Tiger was (-). WNBA created noise with some t-shirts (-). National sports podcast talking baseball (-). Hurt or Injured Justin Herbert for his red contacts (-). Who's back of the week including Hank's UFC recap, Coldplay and understanding the NFLPA mess that Pablo Torre and Mike Florio uncovered (-). Mt Rushmore of best bad movies (-). Alex Caruso and Baker Mayfield join the show to talk ball, Caruso winning a Title, Baker finding the chip on his shoulder after his hater list has grown so small, their mutual hate for University of Texas and more (-). MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred joins the show to talk about the successful All Star Break, competitive balance in the league, should their be an age restriction on the HR Derby, dumb rules and more (-). We finish with lottery ball numbers (:4-).

Baker Mayfield & Alex Caruso on Rings, Hating Texas, and MLB’s Rob Manfred

It is officially the last Monday of the year without football, and the energy is appropriately high. Big Cat and PFT started things off by crowning Scottie Scheffler as the undisputed man of the moment after he dismantled Port Rush at The Open. The guys compared his dominance to the Tiger Woods era, but PFT thinks the bar for a true dynasty is still a long way off.

Open
Jul 21, 2025
#4383
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Scottie Scheffler must stay ranked number one in the world for 10 years to equal Tiger Woods' reign

I think Scotty has to stay ranked number one in the world for the next 10 years to equal Tiger's reign. Tiger Woods was just unreal. It's not going to be the same.

The outcome of Scheffler's career longevity is pending.

While Scottie is making winning look easy, Big Cat had some concerns about the current state of the National League, specifically taking aim at the heavyweights in Los Angeles.

Push
Jul 21, 2025
#29355
Big CatBig Cat

The Dodgers are low-key a bad team right now

The Dodgers kind of low key stink maybe. They are right now. They're losing games right now.

The Dodgers went on to lose in the NLDS in the 2025 postseason.

Ball Talk and Bubble Rings

Baker Mayfield and Alex Caruso joined the show together for a cross-sport crossover that touched on everything from championship parades to their shared hatred for the Longhorns. Alex Caruso is still riding high from winning the 2025 NBA title, but Baker wanted to make sure he gets credit for his previous hardware too.

Void
Jul 21, 2025
#29359
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

Alex Caruso officially has two championships because the NBA Bubble title counts

One's the lowest. That's the baseline one's the lowest. Yeah. He's got two. Oh yeah. Bubble two is two. Hell yeah. I count the bubble.

This is a subjective debate on the value of the 2020 NBA title.

Baker seems to have found his home in Tampa, though he made it very clear that the standards haven't dropped just because he got his contract. For Baker, individual accolades and Pro Bowls don't mean much if they aren't lifting a trophy in February.

Loss
Jul 21, 2025
#29363
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

The Buccaneers' season is a failure if they do not win the Super Bowl

I mean, no. I mean, the goal's always Super Bowl or nothing. It was, I mean, you check off the boxes on your way to try and get to the Super Bowl division playoffs, but then after that, if you don't, if you don't do anything in the playoffs, it really doesn't matter.

The Bucs lost in the Wild Card round, making the season a failure by Mayfield's stated standard.

Naturally, the conversation turned to the age-old debate of which athletes could switch sports. While Baker admitted his basketball game is non-existent, Caruso thinks the path from the gridiron to the hardwood is a lot shorter for certain physical specimens.

Void
Jul 21, 2025
#29360
Alex CarusoAlex Caruso

An elite athlete from the NFL could play 12 minutes in the NBA based on size and dunks alone

There's certain athletes Yeah. That could just find minutes in the NBA. 'cause like there's guys in the league that can't shoot or like can't do stuff, but they can rebound the hell outta the ball and they like dunk and put it like, you can play 12 minutes in the NBA if you're a good enough athlete.

This is a theoretical opinion on athletic crossover.

Before letting them go, the guys tapped into their roots. Being Oklahoma and Texas A&M guys, they found common ground in their disdain for the University of Texas, with Baker pointing out the overlap in the most annoying fanbases in sports.

Void
Jul 21, 2025
#4395
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

Texas fans and Cowboys fans are the same: delusional losers

Texas fans and Cowboys fans are very similar. Delusional. They're the same people. Bunch of losers.

This is a subjective insult typical of the Red River Rivalry.

The Commissioner and the Draft

MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred made his debut on the program to discuss the successful All-Star weekend and the future of the game. He addressed the exhaustion factor of the Home Run Derby and promised that the league is working on the number one gripe for every baseball fan: blackouts.

Push
Jul 21, 2025
#4397
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

Fixing blackouts is at the top of Major League Baseball's priority list

Blackouts number one are at the top of my list in terms of things we need to deal with. Ideally where you would like to be is if you have a digital home for baseball, you can go there and buy what you want to buy.

MLB has been centralizing broadcast rights but blackouts persist into 2025.

Manfred also got surprisingly candid about the MLB Draft. While the lottery was designed to prevent tanking, the Commissioner isn't convinced it’s working the way it should.

Void
Jul 21, 2025
#4398
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

The worst team in the league should always get the #1 overall pick

The team that was the worst last year should get the best player in the draft and there should be nothing that interferes with that correlation. The lottery thing, I'm not sure that it really affects behavior of teams in any meaningful way.

This is a policy stance, not a verifiable fact.

Mt. Rushmore of Best Bad Movies

Things got predictably heated during the Mount Rushmore of Best Bad Movies. Hank and PFT led things off with a pick that Big Cat immediately protested, claiming it was actually just a legitimately good movie.

Void
HankHank

Con Air is a bad movie because the plot is ridiculous

Our first pick is going to be Conair. Mm. I feel like that's a good movie. It's a really, but you think about the plot of the movie. It's bad.

This is a subjective critique of a film's quality.

Max and Memes brought the heat with picks like *Kangaroo Jack* and *Norbit*, while Big Cat stayed true to his action-hero roots with *Blood Sport*. It was a battle of integrity versus Rotten Tomatoes scores, proving once again that a 9% rating is usually a sign of a great time.

Who's Back and Fyre Fest

Who's Back featured a deep dive into the NFLPA drama and the return of the McDonald's Snack Wrap. PFT used the segment to call out Jerry O'Connell's financial situation, claiming the fantasy manager is dodging his league dues.

Void
Jul 21, 2025·Who's Back
#29358
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jerry O'Connell is using his separate finances as an excuse to avoid paying for the PMT fantasy league

He's throwing us a song and dance about how he only could pay for a third of the leak. He's, he's saying a lot of things about how he has to explain things to his wife. No, I I it's more I'm disappointed. Yeah. Like he, he's taken us for a ride.

The internal show logic suggests Jerry eventually paid his full share, making PFT's suspicion a comedic bit.

We wrapped things up with a check-in on Justin Herbert's red contacts and a UFC minute that saw Max calling for some drastic changes to the sport of MMA.

Void
Jul 21, 2025·Who's Back
#4388
MaxMax

UFC would be a better sport if there were more KOs and no gloves

There should be more KOs. No gloves. Too much defense. There's too much defense. I want more. They should be standing up and just throwing fist. Be a much better sport.

This is a purely subjective aesthetic preference for the sport.

If the Phillies really want to fix their bullpen, they should probably stop signing guys who belong in the Mount Rushmore of Bad Movies.

nflnbamlbthe-openmount-rushmorescottie-scheffler

More Takes

Void
Jul 21, 2025
#4386
Big CatBig Cat

WNBA team salary caps should be increased to $3 million

I happen to agree with the shirt because I went gut check 1.5 million feels too low. It does feel like we've been talking about them more in the past 18 months. I feel like that should be like 3 million. I don't know that, that sounds like a good deal.

This is an opinion on labor economics.
Win
Jul 21, 2025
#29362
MaxMax

Signing David Robertson at 40 years old after he hasn't pitched all year is a terrible move for the Phillies

This is the third time that he'll be on the Phillies and he's David Robertson. He's 40. Oh, he's 40. He's 40 and he hasn't pitched all year. He's like the dinosaur.

Robertson struggled upon his return, posting an ERA over 5.00 for the remainder of the 2025 season.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Justin Herbert wearing red contact lenses for intimidation or visibility is soft

It sounds bad. Sounds soft If you're, if you're wearing red contact lenses to try to be more intimidating. Yeah. Like he could just wear normal contact.

This is a subjective opinion on player equipment and style.
Loss
ShaneShane

The Chargers need a playoff win for this season to be a success

We need a playoff win. You need a playoff win. We need one bad but last year we had like the easiest schedule in the league and this year it's pretty difficult.

The Chargers made the playoffs as the #7 seed but lost to the Patriots 16-28 in the Wild Card. No playoff win.
Open
Jul 21, 2025·Who's Back
#29357
HankHank

Dustin Poirier will not stay retired and will fight again

I never believe it. Because then they, you know, they, they get arrested, they get healthy and they're like, ah, I could, I could do one more fight. I could make, you know, a nice payday doing another fight.

Poirier has not fought professionally since his retirement announcement in early 2025.
Void
Jul 21, 2025·Who's Back
#4391
Big CatBig Cat

Coldplay staged the viral Kiss Cam moment for publicity

I feel like Coldplay might have set this whole thing up because we're talking about Coldplay online. Coldplay's getting talked about more than they've ever been talked about so much.

Unless confirmed by the band, this remains a theory.
Win
Jul 21, 2025
#4393
Alex CarusoAlex Caruso

The Indiana Pacers were a physical and sneaky aggressive defensive team in the 2025 playoffs

I knew what it was going to be like Indiana, we knew how fast they were going to play and they were sneaky, aggressive defensively through the playoffs and nobody was really talking about it. But they were really physical.

Reflects the actual style of play in the series referenced.
Win
Jul 21, 2025
#29361
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

Oklahoma will struggle in the SEC because the defensive lines are full of 'man-childs'

The difference, like from what I can see is Oline D-line. Yeah. The D-line. SEC is just a bunch of apps. Like man Childs. And then Oline, Oklahoma hadn't had a, they're all fast as good of an oline is what used to have.

Oklahoma finished their first SEC season in 2024 with a mediocre 6-6 record, confirming the struggle.
Win
Jul 21, 2025
#4396
Rob ManfredRob Manfred

The Home Run Derby's current timing format is too exhausting for players

I don't think people appreciate how exhausting it is for the players to take that many swings that fast. So it's something we will talk about with ESPN regarding changing the format.

The league did indeed adjust the Derby rules for the following year to include pitch limits.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers