Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Booger McFarland, MNF Recap, Playoff Baseball Is Here, College Football + FAQ’s

Wednesday, October 2, 202422 takes

Playoff baseball is here and the Mets may be a team of destiny. Tigers win with their hoss Tarik Skubal, Orioles bad luck continues and we find a new website to grade fan experiences (-). RIP Dikembe Mutombo and Pete Rose (-). Monday Night Football had two very different games and the Lions looked awesome while the Dolphins are a bummer (-). We talk College Football (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne (-). Booger McFarland joins the show to talk ball, quarterback play, building a culture in football and more (-). We then finish with listener submitted FAQ’s (-).

Booger McFarland on NFL Contenders, CFB Chaos, and Championship Picks

The vibes are shifting across the sports landscape. Playoff baseball is officially here, and the New York Mets have transformed from a punchline into a legitimate problem for the rest of the league. After a wild doubleheader split with the Braves, the OMG era is in full swing, and Big Cat is starting to see the signs of something special brewing in Queens.

Win
Oct 2, 2024
#14787
Big CatBig Cat

The New York Mets might be a team of destiny

The New York Mets might be a team of destiny. They have the omg that they're running around the rallying cry they have... the Mets might be a team of destiny.

The Mets made a deep postseason run to the NLCS, defying expectations after a poor start to the season, confirming the 'destiny' narrative for most of October.

This newfound Mets magic has sent shockwaves all the way to Philadelphia. Max, usually the most delusional Phillies fan on the planet, has been completely broken by the thought of facing Francisco Lindor and company in October. He’s already waving the white flag before a single pitch has been thrown in the NLDS.

Win
Oct 2, 2024
#14788
MaxMax

I have zero confidence in the Phillies beating the Mets in the NLDS

I wanted nothing more than to play any team but the Mets going into yesterday and like the way everything has gone in the past two days, it's like I have zero confidence in that series.

Max's lack of confidence was justified as the Mets defeated the Phillies in the NLDS 3-1.

While the Mets are riding a wave of emotion, the Detroit Tigers are leaning on a true hoss in Tarik Skubal. Big Cat recounted a legendary story from the NFL Draft where an anonymous fan handed him an envelope with nothing but a Skubal Cy Young betting tip inside. It’s looking like the most profitable piece of mail in history.

Win
Oct 2, 2024
#14789
Big CatBig Cat

Tarik Skubal will win the Cy Young

Tarik Skubal, who's a Cy Young, shout out... he's gonna win it. I bet it instantly... he's gonna win the Cy Young. He was an absolute beast.

Tarik Skubal won the 2024 American League Cy Young Award unanimously.

Monday Night Football and the QB Renaissance

Monday Night Football gave us two very different flavors of ball. The Lions and Seahawks put on an absolute clinic in Detroit. Jared Goff was perfect, literally, and the Ben Johnson offense looked like it was being played on a video game console. Despite the loss, PFT isn't ready to sell his stock in Seattle just yet.

Push
Oct 2, 2024
#14791
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Seattle Seahawks are actually a good team despite their loss to the Lions

I think the Seahawks are not bad. I think on the contrary. I think the Seahawks are good. They had the most first downs in NFL history in a loss last night.

The Seahawks finished with a winning record but were inconsistent throughout the season, missing the playoffs in a tough NFC West.

On the other side of the doubleheader, the Dolphins and Titans played a game that felt like a federal crime. Mike McDaniel’s offense is completely stalled without Tua, and the questions about his leadership are starting to get loud. Big Cat is genuinely concerned that the "cool coach" routine only works when you aren't scoring zero touchdowns at home.

Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14792
Big CatBig Cat

I am nervous Mike McDaniel might lose the Dolphins locker room

Is Mike McDaniel coaching for his job? I mean, his job is to coach... I am nervous about the locker room for McDaniel. It's a fair criticism.

The Dolphins struggled significantly without Tua but remained competitive once he returned, and McDaniel was not fired.

Booger McFarland Joins the Show

Friend of the program Booger McFarland dropped by to talk shop, and he didn't hold back on the current state of the NFL. The big story is Washington, where Jayden Daniels has PFT feeling things he hasn't felt since 2012. Booger confirmed that the hype is real and the Commanders might actually be the class of their division.

Push
Oct 2, 2024
#14797
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Washington Commanders are currently the best team in the NFC East

The Washington Commanders look like the best team in the NFC East right now. Dallas can't get out of their own way... and the Giants are the Giants. Jayden Daniels looks to be not just the best rookie quarterback, he's among the top 15 quarterbacks in football.

The Commanders had a strong season and remained in the playoff hunt, but the Eagles eventually reclaimed the top spot in the division standings.

We also touched on the Sam Darnold revival in Minnesota. Booger used a pretty vivid rehab analogy to describe Darnold’s journey from seeing ghosts in New York to becoming a surgical point guard for Kevin O'Connell. It turns out that getting away from bad coaching is the best medicine for a former top pick.

Win
Oct 2, 2024
#14799
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Sam Darnold's success in Minnesota is here to stay

What I've seen from Sam Darnold makes me believe that I think it's here to stay as long as that pairing [with Kevin O'Connell] is there... he's seen the light.

Darnold led the Vikings to a successful playoff berth and played well for the duration of the 2024 season.

Booger also gave us his definitive picks for the business end of the season. He’s buying high on the Lions’ roster and thinks Dan Campbell finally hoists the Lombardi Trophy in New Orleans.

Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14802
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Detroit Lions will win the Super Bowl over the Baltimore Ravens

Super Bowl. I'm going to go Detroit versus Baltimore... I think Detroit wins it all this year.

The Lions did not win the Super Bowl. They lost in the Divisional Round 31-45 to the Commanders. The Super Bowl was Eagles vs. Chiefs.

College Football and the Heisman Race

Alabama’s win over Georgia was the game of the year, and it sparked a massive debate about whether Kirby Smart simply cannot handle the Crimson Tide. Booger argued that it's a culture issue, noting that Georgia is essentially a "carbon copy" of the Saban-era Tide, and the original usually wins out.

In the Heisman race, the guys are unified. Travis Hunter is doing things that shouldn't be possible in the modern era of the sport. PFT thinks the "best player" award should actually go to the best player for once.

Win
Oct 2, 2024
#14794
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Travis Hunter is the best college football player I've ever seen

He is the best football player in the country... Travis Hunter. Travis Hunter deserves the respect. He might be the best college football player I've ever seen.

While subjective, Hunter's historic season earned him the Heisman Trophy, validating PFT's extreme praise.

To wrap things up, the guys discussed the "walls" at Barstool reporting that Christian McCaffrey’s Achilles issues might be more than just a temporary setback. If the walls are right, the NFC West is wide open for the taking.

Don't let your car die in the middle of a Chicago highway this week.

nflcollege-footballmlb-playoffsdetroit-lionswashington-commandersmets

More Takes

Void
Oct 2, 2024
#24924
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Small ball wins in the baseball postseason

Small ball. Mike Socialism. Yeah, bring it back. It's great. Pete Rose would be disgusted by the Baltimore Orioles. Yeah. Swing down at the ball line drives ground balls. Those can be hits. Pop flies can't.

Whether small ball specifically wins more than power in the modern era is subjective and statistically debated, but it's a staple of PFT's sports philosophy.
Void
Oct 2, 2024
#14790
Big CatBig Cat

Pete Rose should be in the Hall of Fame

I'm a believer that he [Pete Rose] should be in the Hall of Fame because I think the Hall of Fame should have everyone in it... Tell the whole story of baseball steroids, guys. Pete Rose, everything. He should have been in the Hall of Fame.

This is a subjective opinion on how a Hall of Fame should be curated.
Win
Oct 2, 2024
#24925
Big CatBig Cat

Geno Smith looks totally in control of the Seahawks offense

I was watching that game being like, [Geno Smith] looks like totally in control. And it's crazy how much better he looks than the Geno we've known.

Geno Smith's performance can be evaluated through season-long stats and game tape; he remained a top-tier passer for much of 2024.
Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14793
Big CatBig Cat

The Baltimore Ravens can win the Super Bowl this year

I believe in the Ravens potentially winning a Super Bowl this year. I actually think they absolutely could.

The Ravens lost to the Bills 25-27 in the Divisional Round and did not win the Super Bowl.
Void
Oct 2, 2024
#24926
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Travis Hunter is the biggest cheat code in college football

He might be the best college football player I've ever seen. I'll take it one further. PFT, let's play a quick game. What dumb thing did Hugh Freeze say this week?

Hunter's status as 'the best ever seen' is subjective, but he was undeniably the 2024 Paul Hornung Award winner and a top Heisman finalist.
Loss
HankHank

The 'walls' at Barstool Sports say Christian McCaffrey might retire

The walls at Barstool Sports have been saying... Christopher McCaffrey might retire. Double Achilles tendonitis is not good... he's definitely not gonna play this season.

McCaffrey did not retire in 2024 and returned to play, though the 'walls' rumor about the severity was somewhat accurate regarding his time missed.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Adam Schefter will become the Ultimate Insider covering both NFL and NBA

Adam Schefter could be a candidate to replace Woj... In this scenario, Schefter would cover both the NFL and NBA as what a source called the Ultimate Insider... there's nothing you can do when someone says, Hey, you wanna be the ultimate insider?

ESPN eventually hired Shams Charania to replace Woj as the lead NBA insider, not Schefter.
Push
Oct 2, 2024
#14798
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The 49ers can win the division but cannot win the Super Bowl without Christian McCaffrey

They can win the division without McCaffrey. They can't win a Super Bowl without him.

The 49ers went 6-11 in 2024, missing the playoffs entirely. McCaffrey was injured for most of the season. They did not win the NFC West (the Rams did at 10-7) and they certainly couldn't win a Super Bowl. Booger was right that they couldn't win a Super Bowl without CMC, but wrong that they could win the division — they couldn't even make the playoffs.
Void
Oct 2, 2024
#14800
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

College kickers miss big kicks because they are mentally weak

My theory is this, is that football players... develop mental toughness. Kickers don't do that. Kickers... are not mentally tough. And so when you get in those pressure moments, they haven't been mentally hardened... I just think kickers are mentally weak man.

This is a subjective assessment of a position group's psychology.
Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14801
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Jalen Milroe will be a first-round pick in the NFL Draft

Don't be surprised if he's [Jalen Milroe] a first round pick at quarterback. If you would've said that a year ago... people would've said you're crazy.

Jalen Milroe was not a first-round pick. He was selected by the Seattle Seahawks in the 3rd round with the #92 overall pick.
Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14803
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

Texas and Alabama will play in the College Football National Championship

College Football national championship game. I'm going to go Texas versus Alabama.

Alabama suffered multiple regular season losses and did not reach the championship game. Texas made the playoff.
Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#14804
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

The Philadelphia Phillies will defeat the New York Yankees in the World Series

World Series? I think the Philadelphia Phillies are the best team... Philly's over Yankees.

The Phillies were eliminated in the NLDS by the Mets. The Yankees reached the World Series but lost to the Dodgers.
Loss
Oct 2, 2024
#24927
Booger McFarlandBooger McFarland

UConn will win their third straight College Basketball National Championship

College basketball. It'll be a three-peat, UConn baby.

UConn did not three-peat in men's basketball. UConn was not among the Final Four teams in 2025. The tournament was won by Florida.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers