Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Brackets Are Here, Jon Rothstein, PMT Death Match + Justin Fields Traded To The Steelers

Monday, March 18, 202415 takes

The brackets are finally here and someone on the selection committee has it out for our show with JMU, Wisconsin, Duke and Vermont all being in the same quadrant. We break down our favorite matchups, storylines and who got snubbed (-). Who's back of the week including Scottie Scheffler, the Titanic, and Joe Lunardi sleeping on the job (-). Jon Rothstein joins us to break down his bracket region by region, storylines, and whether or not hes going to lose more friends during March (-). We finish with a recap of the Justin Fields trade and his time in Chicago plus Jake gives his thoughts on the bracket (-).

Jon Rothstein on Brackets, Justin Fields Traded, and the PMT Death Match

March Madness is finally here, and the selection committee has proven they are listening to the show, just for all the wrong reasons. Big Cat and PFT were stunned to find out that Wisconsin and James Madison are facing off in the first round, essentially forcing a civil war in the PMT office. It’s not just the Dukes against the Badgers, either. The committee decided to go full pervert by stacking the quadrant with Vermont and Duke, pitting Jake and Hank against each other in a potential second-round matchup.

Void
Mar 18, 2024
#26677
Big CatBig Cat

The 2024 NCAA Tournament committee is a bunch of sick perverts

Someone in that committee is a real sick pervert... The Pardon My Take region. It wasn't just that they had to put me versus PFT Wisconsin versus James Madison in the first round. They also put Vermont and Duke in the same quadrant.

This is a subjective opinion about the committee's motivations.

The seeding across the board felt like a fever dream. While the Mountain West got six teams in, Big Cat and PFT were incensed that the Big East was largely ignored, leaving teams like St. John’s and Providence out in the cold. But nothing compared to the collective disgust at seeing a certain slow-playing ACC team make the cut.

Win
Mar 18, 2024
#15707
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

UVA getting into the NCAA tournament is a disgusting decision

The sickest thing they did was put UVA in. Yeah, that's disgusting. UVA. So you should be ashamed of yourself.

Virginia played in the First Four and lost 67-42 to Colorado State in a game widely mocked for being uncompetitive, validating the 'disgusting' take for many fans.

Big Cat spent time mourning the bubble teams while looking for this year’s Cinderella. While everyone is looking for that classic 12-5 upset, the guys are eyeing some specific teams that play with the kind of reckless abandon that wins over the casual viewer.

Loss
Mar 18, 2024
#26679
Big CatBig Cat

Samford will be the 2024 NCAA Tournament's 'America's Sweetheart' team

Samford's playing Kansas 13-4. Kansas has been trending downwards... Samford plays so fast they chuck and like that's the type of team that everyone falls in love with. Just a bunch of like, undersized guys who hit threes and played a crazy pace.

Samford lost a controversial close game to Kansas in the first round and did not become a national sensation.

Before the tournament even tips, the guys had to air their grievances with the process itself. Big Cat and PFT remain convinced that the "experts" in the room are overcomplicating a job that most people on Twitter could handle with a few six-packs and a spreadsheet.

Void
Mar 18, 2024
#15708
Big CatBig Cat

Selection committees are bullshit and fans could do a better job

I'm convinced that all of these committees can be the job of the committees can be done better by like 75% of the fans... Just anyone who's been paying attention. I, I know for a fact I know college basketball guys who are way more informed about college basketball and who's good and who's bad than this stupid committee.

This is a subjective opinion about the competency of a governing body.

Jon Rothstein’s Region Breakdown

Jon Rothstein joined the show to do what he does best: live, breathe, and sleep college hoops (though he won't sleep until May). As per tradition, he named all the regions, starting with the "Region of Gladiators" in the East and ending with the "Region of Tension" in the Midwest. Rothstein is high on the defending champs, even with a brutal path.

Win
Mar 18, 2024
#15711
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

UConn will repeat as National Champions

I've got Yukon out of the region of Gladiators... I like Yukon over Purdue, Clingan against Edey, a Battle of the Titans in the title game, and Yukon led by Dan Hurley... becoming the first back-to-back national champion since Florida in 2006 and 2007.

UConn did indeed win the 2024 National Championship, beating Purdue in the final.

Rothstein also went through his bracket with surgical precision, identifying which double-digit seeds actually have the stones to make a run. While he usually sticks to the script, he’s seeing a specific bid-stealer making life miserable for a high seed early on.

Win
Mar 18, 2024
#15712
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Duquesne will upset BYU in the first round

My upset in this region is Duquesne beating BYU in an 11-6. I think we have to remember this and you guys get this. BYU for the most part was a team that was recruited to play in the West Coast Conference. And now you have a team in Duquesne who just won the Atlantic 10.

Duquesne (11 seed) defeated BYU (6 seed) 71-67 on March 21, 2024.

Who's Back and the Justin Fields Trade

During Who’s Back, the guys took aim at Joe Lunardi, who apparently decided to clock out early on the most important night of his year. Big Cat was specifically offended by the bracketologist’s desire to get to "golf season" while the rest of us are just getting started.

Void
Mar 18, 2024·Who's Back
#15709
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Lunardi hates his job and should be replaced by Steve Kornacki

Joe Lunardi has to work three weeks a year and he said goodnight at 10:57 during conference championship week on Friday night when there was like six games left. What is up with this guy?... What he needs to realize is that with one snap of the fingers that freak Steve Kornacki could step into his job and do it better.

Whether Lunardi hates his job is subjective, but he remains the primary face of bracketology for ESPN.

Finally, the show pivoted to the NFL news that rocked Chicago. Justin Fields is officially headed to the Steelers for a late-round pick. Big Cat, ever the balanced Bears fan, shared his bittersweet feelings on the move. He’s happy the team did right by Justin by sending him to a stable organization, but he can’t help but feel like the franchise failed their former first-round pick from day one.

Void
Mar 18, 2024
#15713
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears organization failed Justin Fields

The Bears failed Justin Fields, it sucks that this is the way it ended. They set him up in a really bad spot in the fact that they drafted him with a coach that was already on the hot seat... Year two, the team was actively tanking... Year three, they were basically like, be so good Justin Fields that we will keep you go out and do it with an OC that doesn't really know how to use you.

This is a subjective evaluation of organizational management.

Despite the sadness of seeing Fields go, Big Cat is fully bought into the Caleb Williams era. He pointed out that unlike Justin, who was thrown into a dumpster fire, the next quarterback is walking into a situation that is actually built for a human being to succeed in.

Void
Mar 18, 2024
#15714
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams is set up better than any number one overall pick in NFL history

I think the Caleb Williams might be set up better than any number one pick ever. And I know that sounds crazy because it's still the Bears... He now has a legitimate number one, he now has a legitimate number two in Keenan Allen. He has a top 10 tight end in Cole Kmet. He's got a running game... this is finally you've set up your future franchise quarterback to walk into a situation that he can succeed in.

While subjective, the Bears' 2024 roster (adding Keenan Allen and D'Andre Swift to a 7-10 team) is statistically one of the best supporting casts ever provided to a #1 overall QB.

Even with Russell Wilson currently sitting atop the depth chart in Pittsburgh, the guys are betting on Justin’s talent eventually winning out. It’s a clean slate for everyone involved, except for the Steelers’ wide receivers who will now have to deal with Russ's "Dangerwich" energy every single day.

Push
Mar 18, 2024
#15715
Big CatBig Cat

Justin Fields will eventually beat out Russell Wilson for the Steelers starting job

I hope Justin Fields beats him [Russell Wilson] out. I think he's better than Russell Wilson right now... Once you watch Justin Fields versus Russ, it's gonna be apparent.

Russell Wilson was the official starter, but an injury to Wilson allowed Fields to start the first 6 games of the 2024 season. Wilson eventually took over mid-season when healthy.

Good luck to everyone's brackets, except for the perverts on the committee.

march-madnessjustin-fieldsnfl-tradescollege-basketballstella-blue

More Takes

Loss
Mar 18, 2024
#26678
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

James Madison will reach the Sweet 16

I have the JMU Dukes, I have James Madison winning two games.

James Madison beat Wisconsin in the first round but lost to Duke in the second round, failing to reach the Sweet 16.
Void
Mar 18, 2024
#15710
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

I wake up every day believing I have accomplished nothing

The only way I know how to live life is to go through every life, each and every day. Like I've accomplished nothing. And the way in life to accomplish everything is to wake up each and every day believing that you accomplish nothing.

Subjective life philosophy.
Void
Mar 18, 2024
#26680
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears were right to trade Justin Fields to prioritize Caleb Williams

I thought that they had to trade him. And I'm happy that he was traded just because Caleb Williams is the future. And you couldn't have done the Justin Fields Caleb Williams thing at the same time. And if you had kept him, maybe you could have gotten more for him when quarterbacks get injured. But that would've been a disaster for Caleb Williams.

This is a subjective organizational strategy opinion.
Loss
Mar 18, 2024
#26681
Jake MarshJake Marsh

Charleston will upset Alabama in the first round

I have Charleston over Alabama and Vermont over Duke. Ah. And deep runs. I have Drake in the Elite Eight and I have Florida in the Elite Eight.

Alabama beat Charleston 109-96 in the first round.
Loss
Mar 18, 2024
#15716
Jake MarshJake Marsh

North Carolina will win the 2024 National Championship

I had North Carolina winning the championship. Congratulations to the Howard/Wagner winner on beating UNC because that will be my trend of my champion being out day one.

North Carolina did not win; they lost in the Sweet 16 to Alabama. Jake was wrong about the winner, but he avoided the 'day one' curse as they won their first two games.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers