Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Conference Tourney Week W/ John Fanta, NFL Free Agency W/ Pete Prisco Plus Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, March 13, 202422 takes

NFL Free Agency is moving quickly and everyone's getting a new running back. We talk Kirk Cousins in Atlanta and more (-). JMU is in the tourney plus Hot Seat/Cool Throne and Aaron Rodgers possibly being the Vice President (-). John Fanta joins us to break down Conference tourney week, how he got his start in media, Cooley Bowl 3, and who he likes to win the national championship (-). Pete Prisco joins us to talk winners and losers from free agency, what the Bears will do with Justin Fields, overpay of running backs and should guys be allowed to cry during football games (-). We finish with guys on chicks (-).

John Fanta on March Madness, Pete Prisco on NFL Free Agency, and VP Rodgers

NFL Free Agency is in full swing, and Big Cat and PFT Commenter are processing the chaos of running backs finally getting paid and the quarterback carousel spinning out of control. While the Bears have been active, the cloud of the #1 overall pick remains the biggest story in Chicago. Big Cat is already dreading the hypothetical scenario where the front office tries to play it safe by keeping their current starter while bringing in the new franchise savior.

Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14399
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears should not draft Caleb Williams and keep Justin Fields simultaneously

I am very much opposed to that. But that feels like what a potential situation to get the most value outta Justin Fields. It still makes no sense. The city of Chicago can't handle having those two guys on the same roster. It would not be good, let alone the locker room.

The Bears eventually traded Justin Fields to the Steelers before the draft, avoiding this scenario.

Speaking of quarterbacks, Kirk Cousins secured another massive bag, this time in Atlanta. Big Cat couldn't help but marvel at the pure business acumen of a man who has mastered the leverage game better than anyone in league history.

Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14395
Big CatBig Cat

Kirk Cousins is the GOAT of maximizing NFL contracts and free agency earnings

Incredible. I mean like whatever you wanna say about Kirk Cousins a quarterback. He has played every single thing right when it comes to free agency and the teams he picked. He's probably gonna eclipse 400 million over the course of his career. It's crazy.

Cousins did sign a massive deal with the Falcons (180M, 100M guaranteed) in 2024, continuing his streak of huge contracts.

March Madness with John Fanta

John Fanta joined the show with his signature high-energy delivery to break down everything happening in the Big East and across the country. While the Big East Tournament at Madison Square Garden is his home turf, he has his eyes on UConn as the undisputed team to beat this month.

Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14408
John FantaJohn Fanta

UConn is the clear front runner for the National Championship

In my eyes [Connecticut] is the best team in the country. They're the front runner for the national championship and they should be. The three losses are at Kansas, to Seton Hall [when Clingan got hurt], and then Creighton had another worldly shooting performance.

UConn went on to win the 2024 National Championship in dominant fashion.

Fanta also discussed the pressure on blue bloods and the potential for new faces to dominate the tournament. He highlighted Tennessee as a legitimate threat to win it all, largely because they finally have an offensive weapon that changes their postseason ceiling.

Push
Mar 13, 2024
#25286
John FantaJohn Fanta

Tennessee is a safer Final Four bet than Kentucky because of Dalton Knecht

I would take Tennessee before I took Kentucky... now they've got a guy who can be a Doug McDermott Jimmer Fredette type guy in [Dalton] Knecht. Rick Barnes has crumbled offensively [in the past], now you're not gonna crumble 'cause you know who you're going to.

Tennessee reached the Elite Eight in 2024, their best finish under Rick Barnes, validating the idea that this team was different, though they fell one game short of the Final Four.

Beyond the power conferences, Fanta went to bat for the mid-majors that the committee usually tries to overlook. He’s fully prepared to see a specific Ivy League squad cause chaos in the first round again.

Loss
Mar 13, 2024
#14413
John FantaJohn Fanta

Princeton will win a first-round game if they make the tournament

The winner of the Ivy League tournament is gonna be among my top mid-majors. I hope if Princeton makes it again, just take 'em in the first round. They're gonna win a first-round game. That team is back.

Princeton lost in the Ivy League tournament and did not make the NCAA tournament field.

NFL Free Agency Breakdown with Pete Prisco

Our good friend Pete Prisco stopped by to grade the early moves of free agency and provide his trademark "tape-based" scouting. Prisco was immediately skeptical of the hype surrounding certain draft prospects, specifically calling out the collective groupthink that happens in NFL war rooms during the spring.

Open
Mar 13, 2024
#14415
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

JJ McCarthy is not a first-round talent and is being 'forced up' by the media

I don't love JJ McCarthy. I don't see it. I just don't see it. I'd take him in a second round. I think the league is guilty of... the draft cult. One says it, so two says it... All of a sudden they all convinced themselves that he should be a high first round pick. And that's how mistakes get made.

McCarthy was drafted 10th overall by the Vikings, but his long-term success as a 'first round talent' is pending.

Prisco also weighed in on the Caleb Williams era beginning in Chicago. While Big Cat is ready to embrace the change, Prisco remains stuck on the USC quarterback’s emotional display after a loss last season, leading to a classic PMT debate about the appropriate times for a man to let it out.

Void
Mar 13, 2024
#14416
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Men should never cry after losing a football game

I just don't think you should ever cry after losing a football game. If there was a death in the family or something that week, I apologize, but if there was not, you were crying over the football game... bad luck. There's no way you cry after a loss.

This is an entirely subjective personal/cultural standard.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne and Aaron Rodgers for VP

Hot Seat/Cool Throne featured a massive scoop regarding the Jets' signal caller. PFT reported on the burgeoning rumors that RFK Jr. is seriously considering Aaron Rodgers as a running mate, a story that Big Cat initially thought was a joke but soon realized was the perfect final boss for Jets fans' misery.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers might run for Vice President with RFK Jr.

Aaron Rodgers might run for Vice President... He's being considered and is considering the opportunity right now. Mr. Kennedy confirmed on Tuesday that the two men [Rodgers and Jesse Ventura] were at the top of his list.

Rodgers was indeed officially considered by RFK Jr., as confirmed by multiple major news outlets, though he was not eventually chosen.

Hank landed on the Cool Throne for his premature victory lap regarding Chicago weather. After surviving just one winter, he's convinced the city’s reputation for brutal cold is a myth, much to the chagrin of every lifelong Midwesterner listening.

Void
HankHank

I am not scared of Chicago winters after my first year living there

I just, I don't know. It, it's been incredible. There's been four bad days and two of them had playoff football on. I lived in Massachusetts, New Hampshire. Those are way worse. I'm not scared of the winter here. That's my point.

While Hank didn't experience a 'real' Chicago winter in 2024, his lack of fear is a personal feeling.

The show wrapped up with Guys on Chicks, featuring a listener's boyfriend who is apparently so dedicated to the "silent piss" that he's completely sacrificed his accuracy.

Good luck to everyone's bladders and brackets this week.

nfl-free-agencymarch-madnessaaron-rodgersbearscollege-basketball

More Takes

Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14392
Big CatBig Cat

The Browns signed Jameis Winston so Joe Flacco's popularity wouldn't overshadow Deshaun Watson

I think they brought in Jameis because they could have resigned Joe Flacco. I think Flacco was too popular... maybe some of Jameis Winston's leadership qualities will motivate Deshaun Watson to be a better human being.

OpinionFootballHotSarcastic
While the motive is speculative, the Browns did let Flacco walk and signed Winston, making the literal roster move correct.
Void
Mar 13, 2024
#14397
Big CatBig Cat

Tiki Barber is a loser for calling Saquon Barkley 'dead' to him for joining the Eagles

Tiki Barber, you're a loser dude. Dead to me. You are a loser. Some people, particularly radio personalities who will remain nameless, criticize [Tiki] for having a vision or a dream. Also, Tiki Barber... when we talks about like loyalty, you're not the guy to talk about loyalty. That was a crazy reaction by him.

This is a subjective moral/personality judgment, though fans widely sided with Saquon over Tiki.
Void
Mar 13, 2024
#14401
Big CatBig Cat

NFL owners should pay for their own stadiums without public tax money

I think billionaires should pay for their own fucking stadiums. Agreed. That's a spicy take. I know. Bleep that out. Please.

This is an ongoing ethical/economic debate that cannot be definitively 'solved'.
Loss
Mar 13, 2024
#14410
John FantaJohn Fanta

Shaka Smart's tournament struggles are real; he hasn't made the second weekend since VCU

Shaka Smart has not made it to the second weekend of the NCAA tournament, guys, since VCU. That's it. That's the only time he's ever made a run. So some would argue: Fade Marquette. Is Shaka gonna be able to break through?

In 2024, Shaka Smart actually broke this streak, leading Marquette to the Sweet 16.
Loss
Mar 13, 2024
#25285
John FantaJohn Fanta

Kentucky has its best chance to make a deep run in years

I think this is [Calipari's] best chance to now break through... There are no excuses for John Calipari. None. This is the week... I'm rooting for a Kentucky Tennessee round three.

Kentucky suffered a shocking first-round loss to Oakland in the 2024 NCAA Tournament, making this prediction highly incorrect.
Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14411
John FantaJohn Fanta

Dalton Knecht has the chance to be the face of March Madness

I think [Dalton] Knecht has a chance to be the face of March Madness with the way that he's going, with the way that he's scoring the basketball. He'll be able to score. He's a guy who can be a Doug McDermott, Jimmer Fredette type guy for their team.

Knecht was a top performer in the 2024 tournament, scoring 37 points in the Elite Eight loss to Purdue, largely fulfilling this prediction.
Void
Mar 13, 2024
#14412
John FantaJohn Fanta

Indiana State deserves an at-large bid over high-major bubble teams

Josh Schertz at Indiana State... you're better than all these other high majors that are just like decent to okay that are gonna get in because of their schedule. I wanna see Indiana State get to the dance. I'm all in on a two-bid Missouri Valley conference.

Indiana State was controversially left out of the 2024 NCAA tournament field, ending up as a #1 seed in the NIT.
Win
Mar 13, 2024
#25287
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Dolphins' roster is being picked to shreds due to Tua Tagovailoa's upcoming contract

That team has been picked to shreds in large part because they're in cap [trouble], but they're also readying to pay their quarterback. It's one of those guys, you're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't... I don't know if [Tua] takes you where Mahomes and Allen do.

The Dolphins did indeed lose several key starters in 2024 free agency (Christian Wilkins, Robert Hunt) and subsequently signed Tua to a massive extension.
Win
Mar 13, 2024
#25288
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Justin Fields has no market as a starter in the NFL

I don't think right now there's a starting job for him... The Raiders paid Gardner Minshew rather than making a move to go get Justin Fields. That should speak volumes about what the league thinks about Justin Fields.

Fields was eventually traded to the Steelers for a late-round conditional pick to serve as a backup/competitor to Russell Wilson, confirming the lack of a starting market.
Push
Mar 13, 2024
#14414
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Jayden Daniels will be the best quarterback in the 2024 draft class

My preliminary ranking is, I think Jayden Daniels will be the best of them. He's the most improved player I've ever seen in my entire life. I probably rank him slightly... them and Caleb Williams one and two.

Jayden Daniels showed great promise in 2024 and early 2025 but was shut down with injury mid-2025 season. CJ Stroud regressed significantly. Among the 2024 class, Daniels has the strongest case but injuries limited his 2025 evaluation.
Loss
Mar 13, 2024
#25289
Big CatBig Cat

The Falcons are the favorites to win the NFC South and will win 11 games

I think that they're like a top three, top four team in the NFC right now... having a safe quarterback [Kirk Cousins] I do think makes them the favorite to win that division. I think the Falcons can win 11 games.

The Falcons finished 8-9, not 11 wins as predicted. They did not win the NFC South (Buccaneers won it) and Kirk Cousins was benched mid-season for Michael Penix Jr. after throwing 16 interceptions.
Win
Mar 13, 2024
#14417
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

The Falcons will not win 11 games in the 2024 season

I don't think [the Falcons win 11 games]. I don't. It's a lot. 11 games is a lot. There's a lot of games. Even inside a division... the bucks are gonna be good. That's tough to get a lot [of wins].

The Falcons finished the 2024 regular season with 10 wins, making Prisco's 'under 11' prediction correct.
Loss
Mar 13, 2024
#14418
Pete PriscoPete Prisco

Calvin Ridley's difficulty learning the Jaguars' offense is why he wants to stay in Jacksonville

Here's why he wants to stay in Jacksonville. Let me tell you. He had trouble learning the offense last year and so he doesn't really wanna go somewhere else and have to learn another one. Serious. I'm not... that's notable.

Ridley ended up signing a massive 4-year, $92M deal with the Tennessee Titans shortly after this episode, contradicting the 'stay in Jacksonville' prediction.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers