Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Jimmy Tatro In Studio, Nick Wright Talking Chiefs And Super Bowl, Birthday Episode And Fyre Fest Of The Week

Friday, January 31, 202520 takes

Birthday episode for the boys. We talk national sports podcast takes and story lines (-). A little Super Bowl talk and our favorite props (-). Our good friend Jimmy Tatro joins the show to talk about his new movie out now, working with Will Ferrell, what’s next for him, the once proud Lakers and more (-). Nick Wright joins us from First Things First and What’s Wright With Nick Wright Podcast to talk Mahomes, Chiefs Derangement syndrome, Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson, Super Bowl and more (-). We finish with Fyre Fest of the week (-).

Jimmy Tatro on Lakers Drama, Nick Wright's Chiefs Mania, and Super Bowl Props

Big Cat and PFT Commenter are officially 40 years old, and they celebrated the only way they know how: by sharing an intimate, bearded birthday kiss on YouTube and immediately diving into a massive double-header episode. Before the guests arrived, the conversation centered on the coaching carousel and the impending Super Bowl matchup between the Eagles and the Chiefs. PFT is keeping a close eye on the Saints' vacancy and thinks a certain Eagles coordinator might be packing his bags for New Orleans soon.

Win
Jan 31, 2025
#16430
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kellen Moore has a good chance to be hired as the Saints head coach

I think it might be Kellen Moore. Yeah. I think he's been doing a lot of, he's been getting his staff together. He's been really focused on his interviews with the Saints. I think this bodes well for his chance of being hired.

Kellen Moore was eventually hired as the head coach of the New Orleans Saints in February 2025.

While the NFL dominates the headlines, the NBA is floating some experimental changes that didn't exactly sit well with everyone in the studio. Adam Silver’s idea of 10-minute quarters sparked a debate about star minutes and bench value, but Hank thinks he knows the real endgame for the league’s future structure.

Open
Jan 31, 2025
#16433
HankHank

The NBA will expand to Las Vegas and Seattle

They're gonna add two more teams, I think is my takeaway... Vegas and Seattle.

While heavily rumored and expected by the end of the current media deal cycle, no official announcement has been made.

Jimmy Tatro on Movie Stardom and the Once Proud Lakers

Our good friend Jimmy Tatro stopped by the Chicago studio to talk about his new movie, *You’re Cordially Invited*, and what it’s like working with the GOAT, Will Ferrell. Jimmy admitted he still has to remind himself to stay cool around his heroes, but he’s not a fan of how the rest of Hollywood operates when it comes to biopics.

Void
Jan 31, 2025
#20994
Jimmy TatroJimmy Tatro

I am officially anti-biopic; the industry needs to let stories finish before buying the rights.

I've taken a bit of a stance against Biopics. I'm somewhat antibio pic. I just think enough. We've done 'em all and people are starting to get the rights to stories before they're even done happening. Like the Luigi Mangione thing happens... and then it's like someone gets the rights the next day. Let the story at least end before you buy the rights to it and start casting someone.

This is a subjective opinion about artistic and industry trends.

Being a Diehard Lakers fan, Jimmy had to answer for the current state of the franchise. Between the LeBron James legacy tour and the drafting of Bronny, things have taken a turn for the surreal in Los Angeles. Jimmy remains a staunch defender of the franchise's history, but even he admits the current vibe is a bit different than the Showtime era.

Void
Jan 31, 2025
#20995
Jimmy TatroJimmy Tatro

The Lakers have become a 'novelty situation' because of the Bronny James drafting.

The second we drafted [Bronny], I knew, I was like, damnit, we've just signed up for like a novelty situation. Which I'm happy for 'em, but like, they got the photos already. They're on the court doing the dad son hug some passes. I think maybe they just are waiting to get an oop, and then that'll be it.

Whether a team's strategy is a 'novelty' or a genuine competitive move is subjective.

Naturally, Big Cat tried to bait Jimmy into admitting the 2020 Bubble title was a Mickey Mouse ring. Jimmy leaned into the defense, arguing that the lack of travel and distractions actually made it a purer test of basketball skill than any other championship in history.

Void
Jan 31, 2025
#16439
Jimmy TatroJimmy Tatro

The 2020 Lakers Bubble championship counts the most because it removed all distractions and travel advantages.

If anything, 2020 counts the most. Listen, you take out all the distractions and you just boil that game down to who's truly the best. Everyone plays on the same court, you get no traveling for the guy who's in his late thirties. No traveling. It's tougher on those young guys; they don't have families they had to deal with missing. The older guys have to deal with that. If anything, that was just a testament.

The 'value' of a championship is entirely subjective and a matter of fan debate.

Nick Wright Brings the Chiefs Derangement Syndrome

Nick Wright joined the show to do what he does best: defend Patrick Mahomes and agitate every other fan base in America. He started by defending his preseason Caleb Williams prediction with some of the most twisted logic we’ve ever heard, claiming that because he described a specific archetype of player that eventually made a run, he was basically right.

Void
Jan 31, 2025
#16441
Nick WrightNick Wright

I am '99 percent correct' about my Caleb Williams Super Bowl prediction because the player profile I described came true with Jayden Daniels.

If I said in June of 2028 an asteroid is gonna hit Peru and cause damage the likes of which we haven't seen in centuries... and then in June of 2028 an asteroid hit Uruguay, am I more right than the people who said it would never happen? I was off by 900 miles, but I'm 99% correct, 1% wrong. In calling the NFC this year, I basically called it. I was off by 900 miles, but I'm more right than everyone else.

Nick's claim of being '99% right' for being wrong about the specific player is a rhetorical device and subjective.

When the conversation turned to the GOAT debate, Nick stayed consistent. He believes Mahomes has reached a level of play no one has ever touched, but he acknowledges that the trophy case still belongs to Tom Brady—for now. He thinks the potential three-peat changes the conversation entirely.

Void
Jan 31, 2025
#16445
Nick WrightNick Wright

Patrick Mahomes is the best player ever, but Tom Brady is still the Greatest of All Time.

I already think [Mahomes] is the best player ever, but he's not the greatest quarterback of all time. I think accomplishments have to weigh a ton, and so Brady gets to be called the GOAT. I think that if they pull off the three-peat, you can, and someone wants to say he's now the greatest of all time, it's at least an allowed opinion.

The GOAT debate is a subjective matter of sports opinion.

Nick also took some shots at the other elite quarterbacks in the AFC. He compared Lamar Jackson to a MLB superstar who can't seem to find his swing in October, and he offered a backhanded compliment to Josh Allen's playoff future against the juggernaut in Kansas City.

Win
Jan 31, 2025
#16443
Nick WrightNick Wright

Lamar Jackson is the 'Aaron Judge' of the NFL

Lamar, everybody gets so mad at me Lamar's Aaron Judge... which is on a day in, day out basis in the regular season, you're like, is this the best player in the sport or certainly in the very, you know, top two or three and then come the playoffs. It's like, man, every time... every regular season it's Lamar's the best player in the league. And every Playoffs it's like, you know why they lost, they put the ball in Lamar's hands too much.

Lamar Jackson has a high regular season win percentage and multiple MVPs, but a poor postseason record (2-5 as of this episode).
Open
Jan 31, 2025
#20997
Nick WrightNick Wright

Josh Allen will beat the Chiefs in the playoffs exactly one time in his career.

I think [Josh Allen] will beat the Chiefs in the playoffs one time. He's too good and they're, the games are too close. Is it going to be hard psychologically to then recalibrate and be like, that wasn't the Super Bowl? But I think he'll beat the Chiefs in the playoffs one time.

Josh Allen currently has zero playoff wins over the Chiefs. This will resolve once he wins one or retires.

Super Bowl 59 Early Prop Picks

With the big game just a week away, everyone shared their favorite early looks at the prop board. Max is staying loyal to his Birds, looking for a big day from the Slim Reaper.

Win
Jan 31, 2025·Picks
#16434
MaxMax

DeVonta Smith will have 50+ receiving yards in Super Bowl 59

My prop. I think that DeVonta Smith is due. Oh, I think he, I 50 plus yards. I feel good about DeVonta Smith.

DeVonta Smith had a productive Super Bowl LIX performance for the Eagles in their 40-22 win over the Chiefs. He exceeded 50 receiving yards in the game.

Big Cat is also looking at the Eagles' passing attack, specifically targeting Dallas Goedert to exploit the middle of the field. Meanwhile, PFT is looking at the kicking game, expecting a "gremlin bet" to hit as both offenses potentially stall out in the red zone.

Loss
Jan 31, 2025·Picks
#16438
Big CatBig Cat

Dallas Goedert will have over 60 receiving yards in Super Bowl 59

I'm going, I think this has gotta be a huge Dallas Goedert game. So I'm going Dallas Goedert over 60 yards receiving plus one 19. So it's plus money. I think this is Dallas Goedert game. I think he's got to eat. He's also, he leads the Eagles in, in receiving yards in the Playoffs.

Dallas Goedert had only 2 catches for 27 yards in Super Bowl LIX, well under the 60-yard threshold Big Cat predicted. The Eagles built a massive early lead and didn't need to rely on the passing game.
Win
Jan 31, 2025·Picks
#20993
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I'm betting the over on 3.5 field goals in Super Bowl 59.

I am gonna be taking over three and a half field goals. The gremlin bet, it's at plus 1 25 right now. I like it. And I think they got two great kickers.

PFT Commenter bet the over on 3.5 field goals in Super Bowl 59. Jake Elliott kicked 4 field goals for the Eagles (48, 29, 48, and 50 yards), and the Chiefs kicked 0. The total of 4 field goals hits the over on 3.5.

To wrap things up, the crew went through a legendary Fyre Fest of the Week, featuring stolen clothes, 40th birthday anxieties, and Memes' mysterious plan to "stimulate" his hibernating tortoise.

Happy birthday to the 40-year-old toddlers.

nflsuper-bowllakerschiefseagleslebron-jamessports-betting

More Takes

Void
HankHank

10-minute quarters in the NBA would be bad for bench players and league parity.

I think it would be bad for bench players. There would be less parity in the league and there would just be, you know, all the stars could play more minutes. We do have a lot of stars, but I think for League parity it'd be bad.

This is a subjective opinion on league structure.
Loss
Jan 31, 2025
#16449
Nick WrightNick Wright

The Chiefs will beat the Eagles 34-24 in Super Bowl 59

I am leaning towards 34 24. Okay. Leaning. Okay... but that's, you know, write that in pencil. No, not in pen.

The Chiefs lost to the Eagles 22-40 in Super Bowl LIX. Nick Wright predicted Chiefs 34-24; instead the Eagles won convincingly.
Loss
Jan 31, 2025
#16451
Big CatBig Cat

The Kansas City Chiefs will win the AFC West in 2025

Congrats on the Kansas City Chiefs winning the AFC West in 2025. We're the first to report it. Oh, okay. Thank you. Yep. We are the first to report it. We've been reporting it around this time every single year.

The Chiefs did not win the AFC West in 2025. They went 6-11 and finished 3rd in the division. The Denver Broncos won the AFC West with a 14-3 record.
Win
Jan 31, 2025·Picks
#16436
HankHank

Patrick Mahomes will throw an interception in Super Bowl 59

The prop that I'll be betting that I'll be rooting for is Patrick Mahomes over one half interception. So Patrick Mahomes a throwing interception.

Patrick Mahomes threw 2 interceptions in Super Bowl LIX (both in the 2nd quarter, which the Eagles converted into touchdowns). Hank's prop bet on Mahomes throwing an interception was correct.
Open
Jan 31, 2025
#16447
Nick WrightNick Wright

Josh Allen will eventually win a Super Bowl

I think [Josh Allen] will win a Super Bowl eventually, but we're, we're, the, somebody is gonna be left without a chair... I would worry about for Josh is if, because I think he'll beat the Chiefs in the playoffs one time. He's too good.

Josh Allen has not won a Super Bowl yet.
Void
Jan 31, 2025
#20996
Jimmy TatroJimmy Tatro

The Patriots were once a proud franchise, but now they are not so proud.

Once proud would be like the Patriots. You know, the Patriots were once proud. Now they're not so proud.

The 'pride' of a franchise is a subjective matter of fan and media perception.
Void
Jan 31, 2025
#20998
Nick WrightNick Wright

If Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen swapped teams, Mahomes would have four Super Bowl appearances and two rings while Allen would have two appearances and one ring.

If it were flipped, I think Josh would've been to two and won one. And I think Mahomes would've been to four and won two. iHomes, because those Bills teams in 2022 with Mahomes instead of Josh... that team was awesome. I think 2021, it probably would've gone Josh's way in Kansas City last year with Tyreek. But I think the early Josh Allen Bills teams... you drop Mahomes on there, it's to me a similar situation as when you dropped him on Kansas City.

This is a counterfactual hypothetical that cannot be proven or disproven.
Void
Jan 31, 2025
#20999
Nick WrightNick Wright

Jalen Hurts' performance in Super Bowl 57 was the best individual performance ever for a player who also made the play that lost his team the game.

The best game Jalen Hurts ever played is that Super Bowl game. And I would argue it is the single best game any player has ever played that also included them making the play that lost their team of the game. I think of all the games where one guy made a totally unforced catastrophic error that cost his team a championship, he played the best in that game.

The evaluation of 'best performance in a loss' is an inherently subjective sports debate.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers