Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

JJ Redick Talking NBA Playoffs, Tyrese Maxey Saves The Sixers + Are Travis Kelce And Taylor Swift On The Rocks?

Wednesday, May 1, 202417 takes

Tyrese Maxey saves the Sixers season with an all time Game 5 performance at MSG. We talk NBA and NHL playoff action from Tuesday night plus the Lakers got bounced and somehow people still think they were so close to beating the Nuggets in a series (-). Shams is eviscerating coach's moments after games and we have our first bee delay of the year in MLB (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including NFL scouting and the biggest loser gambler of all time (-). JJ Redick joins the show to talk NBA playoffs, how good Ant is, what do the Suns and Lakers do, is this the death of the superteam and his son going to basketball camp at Duke (-). We finish with listener submitted FAQ's (-).

JJ Redick on NBA Superteams, the Lakers Post-Mortem, and Maxey's Legacy

The vibes in the studio were at an all-time high after Tyrese Maxey snatched the souls of everyone inside Madison Square Garden. Big Cat and PFT break down one of the craziest endings in playoff history, where Maxey somehow erased a six-point deficit in the final 28 seconds to keep Philly's season alive. While Joel Embiid was hobbling around with a headache and one good leg, Maxey put the entire franchise on his back.

Void
May 1, 2024
#23344
Big CatBig Cat

Tyrese Maxey saved his legacy and had a double legacy game in Game 5 against the Knicks.

Tyrese Maxey basically saved. Did Tyrese Maxey save his legacy while also a legacy game for [Embiid]? It was a double legacy game.

This is subjective praise for a performance, but Maxey did score 7 points in the final 25 seconds of regulation to force OT, which is objectively a 'legacy' type moment.

Max tried to keep his composure, but even he couldn't ignore the fact that Nicolas Batum turned into a defensive wizard when the Sixers needed it most.

Win
May 1, 2024
#23347
Big CatBig Cat

The Knicks/76ers Game 5 defense by Nicolas Batum on Jalen Brunson was game-defining.

Shout out to your guy [Batum] with incredible, incredible defense. Both at the end of regulation and the end of OT being able to stay with Jalen Brunson as he drive to the, to the hoop. And he had two huge, I think the first one was a block... those were, those were game defining plays.

Most analysts agreed Batum's block and contest on Brunson were the pivotal defensive plays of the win.

Lakers Post-Mortem and Playoff Realities

The Lakers finally got put out of their misery by the Nuggets, leading to the inevitable shams-bombing of Darvin Ham. Big Cat isn't buying the narrative from Lakers fans that they were "right there" just because they led for most of the minutes in the series. The reality is that Denver is just a better basketball team, and the Lakers lacked the depth to compete over 48 minutes.

Win
May 1, 2024
#15800
Big CatBig Cat

The Lakers were never winning a title because their roster was the problem, not coaching.

I still think that the roster is the problem that they just don't have enough guys. And the Nuggets were a better basketball team no matter how many minutes the Lakers led. Execution and being able to win games late is what makes the team better... They were a good team. They were never a great team.

The Lakers were eliminated 4-1 by the Nuggets and fired Darvin Ham shortly after, confirming the 'failed season' part, though the root cause (roster vs coach) remains a debate.

Speaking of toughness, the guys discussed the injury bug hitting the Bucks and whether they can survive the Pacers. Big Cat admitted he would play through almost anything in a Game 5, with one very specific caveat.

Void
May 1, 2024
#23346
Big CatBig Cat

I would play in an NBA playoff Game 5 unless I got less than six hours of sleep.

I tweaked my knee. I'd play no pro. I I would, I would play, I'm just gonna say it right now. I you can't keep me outta game five with the season on the line... Unless I got less than six, six hours of sleep. Then I would probably be like, you know what Gametime decision, I'm out.

This is a hypothetical claim about himself for comedic effect.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hot Seat/Cool Throne covered everything from Ryan Whitney's AI bear controversy to the latest NFL scouting tropes. The guys looked at Bo Nicks' backpack contents as the new "Stetson Bennett is old" meme. PFT also had some thoughts on the veteran presence of certain draft picks.

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michael Penix Jr. probably had an AARP card in his backpack during his scouting meetings.

An a a RP card. That's what Michael Penix had without a [doubt].

Likely incorrect as he was only 23-24 at the time, though comedic hyperbole.

Then the conversation turned to the world's most famous couple. With Travis Kelce signing a massive new deal to stay the highest-paid tight end, Big Cat questioned why he isn't taking the "Tom Brady discount" considering his girlfriend is a literal billionaire.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Taylor Swift hates the Chiefs because she won't give Travis Kelce money to take a league-minimum contract.

If Taylor Swift was a real fan of the, the Chiefs... She would realize for the good of the franchise that she should not do a prenup with Travis Kelce, therefore letting Travis Kelce sign value contracts with the Chiefs and extending their championship window. She she would give... Money's no problem for us. Sounds like she hates the Chiefs. Yeah.

Satirical claim about interpersonal motivations and fandom that cannot be verified.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Taylor Swift should give up half her money to men to prove she believes in equality.

Basically what we're saying is that Taylor Swift should give up half of her money to men. Is that too much to ask? No, I thought we were about equality. Equality matters 50%.

Satirical demand that is not a factual claim.

JJ Redick on the Evolution of the NBA

JJ Redick joined the show to provide a much-needed tactical breakdown of the playoffs. He didn't hold back on the Suns' failure or the Lakers' situation, but he was most excited about the rising talent in the West. JJ is particularly high on the Timberwolves and their ability to actually give the Nuggets a run for their money.

Win
May 1, 2024
#15802
JJ RedickJJ Redick

The Minnesota Timberwolves match up better against the Denver Nuggets than anyone else in the NBA.

I think this Minnesota team probably matches up as well as anyone in the NBA versus the Denver Nuggets. I'm really fascinated by this series.

The Timberwolves went on to beat the Nuggets in a 7-game series, proving they were indeed an excellent matchup.

As the conversation shifted toward the construction of modern rosters, JJ explained why the era of simply trading for three stars and filling the rest with minimum contracts might be over due to the new CBA rules.

Win
May 1, 2024
#15804
JJ RedickJJ Redick

The current NBA landscape marks the beginning of the death of the 'Super Team'.

I said at the beginning of the year... this year could be the beginning of the death of the super team. Part of that is the new second apron in the CBA... you have to build through the draft. And then be positioned... to then make an impactful trade.

The 2024 playoffs saw the Suns, Lakers, and Warriors (teams with high concentrations of veteran star salary) exit early, while homegrown teams like the Celtics, Nuggets, and Thunder thrived, supporting this take.

JJ also defended his stance on Nikola Jokic’s place in history, even as Big Cat tried to protect the top 15 list from modern intruders.

Void
May 1, 2024
#15801
JJ RedickJJ Redick

Nikola Jokic is already a top 15 player of all time.

Nikola Jokic to me is already a top 15 player of all time. And I know that that's maybe a hot take. I don't really care.

Subjective all-time ranking.

Finally, Big Cat and JJ found common ground on the most important topic in New York: Jalen Brunson is officially him.

Win
May 1, 2024
#15805
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Brunson is a 'true 1A' superstar.

They've got a true leader. And I'll say it a true one A. I agree. Jalen Brunson a true one A.

Brunson finished 5th in MVP voting and made 2nd Team All-NBA in 2024, cementing his status as a top-tier star.

The show wrapped up with listener FAQs and a negotiation for the return of "Cocky Hank" if the Celtics manage to actually finish off the Heat.

Let's hope the bees stay away from the ballpark so we can get through the rest of the week.

nflnba-playoffslakers76erstaylor-swiftknicks

More Takes

Loss
May 1, 2024
#23345
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Bucks are alive in their series against the Pacers and could win if they force a Game 7.

The bucks are alive. For sure. And what happened in the last game was they just had everybody get hurt or ejected from the game... I don't think that they're like, they probably won't be favored to win this series, even with Giannis coming back. But if they can get it to a game seven, then yes [they can win].

The Bucks lost the series in Game 6, so they never reached Game 7.
Win
May 1, 2024
#15807
HankHank

The Boston Bruins will win their series against the Toronto Maple Leafs.

Just gotta win in Toronto. Now it's a tough, it's tough to win in the playoffs. You know, the leaves are a good team. They, they battled through adversity tonight. And, and we gotta come back stronger. Put Swayman in the net and, and we're gonna win.

The Bruins won the series in 7 games on May 4th, 2024.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Tyson could be 90 years old and still knock someone out.

I'm pumped up. 'cause I think everybody that is, most people that are paying attention to this would just like to see another Mike Tyson knockout. Yes. Just bring us back to the glory days. Yes. And he could be 90 years old and I would still believe that he'd be able to knock somebody out.

Subjective claim about potential power, though Tyson lost the actual fight against Jake Paul (which took place later in 2024) by decision, not knockout.
Void
May 1, 2024
#23350
JJ RedickJJ Redick

The overall talent depth in the NBA is as high as it's ever been and is spread out across more teams.

I think the overall talent depth, meaning the amount of really good players in the NBA is as high as it's ever been. And that depth of talent is spread out more than it's ever been. There's not the concentration of three really good players on one team... There's the concentration of two or three really good players on a bunch of teams.

This is a subjective assessment of league-wide talent, though shared by many modern analysts.
Win
May 1, 2024
#15808
JJ RedickJJ Redick

The Phoenix Suns' issues are about team building and personalities meshing, not just one specific player or coach.

I would look at sort of team building in a very holistic way beyond just, oh, we gotta trade this guy... You have to look at any roster, any team, and look at how personalities mesh together and how skill sets mesh together... and you have to be willing, I think to, as an owner, you have to be willing to be patient with that.

The Suns fired Frank Vogel shortly after this and continued to struggle with roster balance issues in the following offseason.
Win
May 1, 2024
#15806
JJ RedickJJ Redick

The New York Knicks are going to win their series against the Philadelphia 76ers.

I think the Knicks are gonna win the series.

The Knicks won the series in 6 games on May 2nd, 2024.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers