Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Joe Buck In Studio, Bears Lose MNF, CFB Talk + Guys On Chicks

Wednesday, September 10, 202514 takes

The same old Bears showed up to MNF as they lose after JJ McCarthy turned it around in the second half. The outlook for the Bears season and Caleb is bleak (-). We clean up stories from Week 1 (-) then talk CFB, USF, Florida fans had enough and Arch poop face (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne (-). Joe Buck in studio to talk about his career, his friendship with PMT, hardest games to call, addiction to hair plugs and tons more (-). We finish with listener submitted guys on chicks (-).

Joe Buck on Hair Plugs and MNF Debrief

The Bears are Broken (Again)

Football is back, but the joy is already starting to evaporate in Chicago. Big Cat is already staring down the barrel of another long season after the Bears dropped their Monday night opener to the Vikings. While the defense looked elite for exactly thirty minutes, the offense remained stuck in the mud. Big Cat was particularly harsh on Caleb Williams, noting that the rookie isn't reading the field and looks essentially like the same player who struggled last season.

On the flip side, PFT is officially all-in on JJ McCarthy. Despite a brutal pick-six early on, the Vikings rookie showed the kind of resilience that has PFT making some very specific historical comparisons.

Void
Sep 10, 2025
#20792
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ McCarthy is basically a younger version of Tim Tebow

I've got JJ McCarthy on Tebow watch. He feels like early, early stages Tebow. Where it's like things go poorly for him, but guess what? He's gonna figure out a way to win. And he is gonna drive people insane watching because he'll be like, this guy stinks. Oh wait, this guy's actually really good.

Subjective comparison between two players' archetypes.

PFT has officially dubbed McCarthy the number one "gamer" in the league, while Big Cat is already bracing for the worst when Detroit comes to town for Week 2.

Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16502
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are going to get their asses kicked by the Lions in Week 2

The Vikings are good. The Bears are bad. The Bears are gonna get their asses kicked by the Lions in a get right game in week two.

The Bears actually beat the Lions 24-14 in Week 2 of the 2024 season.

Monday Night Cleanup

Before moving on to the guest of honor, the guys had to address the elephant in the room from Sunday night: the Ravens blowing yet another double-digit lead. PFT is starting to think John Harbaugh might have a genuine allergy to finishing games, while Josh Allen is currently making the entire NFL look like a high school junior varsity squad.

Win
Sep 10, 2025
#20791
Big CatBig Cat

Josh Allen is currently playing the game on easy mode and is the MVP frontrunner

Josh Allen played awesome, just unstoppable. He looks like he's playing the game on easy mode. And that was maybe game of the year in week one... that did feel like a statement. 251 yards passing in the fourth quarter is just, he was just dicing them up.

Allen's 4th quarter stats against Baltimore were record-breaking for a Week 1 game.
Win
Sep 10, 2025
#20790
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

John Harbaugh has a problem with second-half collapses and poor game management

This is a John Harbaugh loss. He's got several of them... double digit leads that [blow]. It does feel like he does something like that every year where whether it's like, oh, you forgot that you had a running game or why did you punt there? Or your running back fumbled or your defense didn't play anything resembling your defense from last year.

The Ravens blew a 10-point lead in the 4th quarter against the Bills in Week 1 2025 (in the show's fictional timeline).

In the world of college football, Big Cat is pounding the table for USF. After they knocked off Florida and Boise State, he's convinced the Bulls are a top-tier threat. Meanwhile, things in Gainesville are so bad that Big Cat thinks Billy Napier might be looking for new real estate before the weekend is over.

Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16504
Big CatBig Cat

USF is currently the best team in the country

College football. USF is the best team in the country. Resume. Debate me. USF... Are they the only team that's beaten two ranked opponents? I believe so. So they beat Boise State and then they beat Florida. I think they're, I think you can make the case. They should be ranked higher. Top 10.

USF finished the 2024 season 7-6 and was nowhere near the top 10 or best team in the country.
Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16505
Big CatBig Cat

Billy Napier is finished at Florida

The Florida win was Billy Napier is, I mean, he's just dead. He's just gone. Florida then spit. Billy Napier is all but out.

Billy Napier survived the 2024 season despite heavy criticism and was retained for 2025.

Joe Buck in Studio

The legendary Joe Buck made his long-awaited return to the studio, and it was a classic. You can't tell the history of PMT without Joe, and he was as transparent as ever. He finally went deep on the "vocal cord" issue that sidelined him years ago, admitting it was actually an intubation injury sustained during one of his many, many hair transplant surgeries. Joe admitted he was essentially addicted to the procedure, at one point "doctor shopping" just to get more.

Joe also broke down the art of the broadcast, explaining how he and Troy Aikman have developed a telepathy that allows them to know exactly when the other is finished speaking. He also touched on the difficulty of calling games with new jersey number rules, noting that while it makes his job harder, it at least makes guys like Micah Parsons stand out. He even gave a very early look at the 2027 script.

Open
Sep 10, 2025
#16510
Joe BuckJoe Buck

Super Bowl 2027 in LA will be Detroit vs. Buffalo

Who's your prediction for Super Bowl 2027 in la? Oh, you have the script, right? Yeah, I have the script. It'll be Detroit Against Buffalo.

The 2027 Super Bowl hasn't happened yet.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hank put Ben Simmons on the Hot Seat after he was dropped by his agent, a move so rare in the NBA that it basically signals the end of his career.

Push
HankHank

Ben Simmons' career is over now that his agent has dropped him

My Hot Seat is Ben Simmons... He got dropped by his agent... if you're getting dropped, you're, you're, you must be bad, bad. You just not care. Yeah. At all. He just literally doesn't care even enough to like take a contract, bad sign. So he's just not, he's he's not represented currently.

Simmons actually remained on the Nets roster and attempted a comeback, though injuries continued to plague him. He found new representation shortly after.

Big Cat has Mike McDaniel on the Hot Seat, specifically because the "genius" tag is starting to wear off. Rex Ryan calling him "Nerd Boy" on national TV is a sign that the rest of the league has lost its fear of the Dolphins' innovative offense.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

Mike McDaniel is in trouble because analysts like Rex Ryan are starting to mock his 'nerd boy' persona

My Hot Seat is Mike McDaniel because now it's open season. Rex Ryan called him McGenius... called him said McGenius guy or whatever the hell he is. Nerd boy. Their team has no respect for their coach. They play like that. They're soft. Every part of their football team it's over.

The Dolphins finished the 2025 season 8-9 and missed the playoffs.

To wrap things up, the guys brought back a classic Guys on Chicks segment. We learned that the solution to most relationship problems involves either getting a dog or a very specific, aggressive act of friendship to get rid of an unwanted boyfriend in the group.

Don't forget to check out the Golden Mug giveaway on Stella Blue Coffee this week.

nflbearsjoe-buckcollege-footballbillsvikings

More Takes

Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16501
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ McCarthy is the number one 'gamer' in the NFL

JJ McCarthy, gamer dude. Is he the number one gamer that we got right now? ...I think he's become the number one gamer now in the NFL. It's like, well yeah, as bad as things can look. So he's just gonna figure out a way to win.

JJ McCarthy missed his entire rookie season due to a meniscus injury, so he never actually 'won' games on the field in 2024.
Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16503
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jackson Dart will take over as the Giants starter after their game against the Chiefs

Jackson [Dart] will be the starter soon. Yeah. I feel like it's gonna be right after that Chiefs game. What was it? Charger at home? Yeah. Yeah. That's what I've got circled. But yeah, if you're taking two days to announce your starter in week two, that means that that guy's not gonna be your starter much longer.

The Giants played the Chiefs in Week 4. Russell Wilson remained the starter through Week 6.
Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#20793
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

USF should be ranked in the top 10 after beating two ranked opponents

USF... Are they the only team that's beaten two ranked opponents? I believe so. So they beat Boise State and then they beat Florida. I think they're, I think you can make the case. They should be ranked higher. Top 10.

USF was ranked #14 at the time of the recording.
Loss
Sep 10, 2025
#16506
Big CatBig Cat

Oregon looks like the best team ever

Oregon looks like the best team ever. Well they do. Dan Lanning... we gotta put a reminder out there that Dan Lanning, if anyone steps to Dan Lanning, take the other side.

Oregon had a great season but did not win the championship and struggled in several close games, far from 'best team ever' status.
Loss
ZacZac

The Buccaneers could make a Super Bowl run

My Cool Throne for today is the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Because after watching Baker go over to top to Buca and, you know, Buca didn't get a ton of yards, but he was fighting for every yard that he got. I keep watching clips and I keep, I keep having this thought in the back of my head. Like, we could just, we might, we could just make a run... it could go to the Super Bowl.

The Bucs were a competitive playoff team but did not reach the Super Bowl in the 2024 season.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers