Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Jon Rothstein Breaking Down The NCAA Tournament, We Have Our Brackets In Our Hands Ready For The Best Week + Who's Back Of The Week

Monday, March 17, 202530 takes

The brackets have arrived. We talk about who got screwed and go through the matchups and celebrate one of the best sports weeks of the year. Hank also may be a little hungover from St Patricks day but we get his picks and they may be genius (-). Who's back of the week including one of the dumbest debates weve had about a video posted by MLB account (-). Jon Rothstein joins the show to talk Tournament, how each region is going to go, saying "This Is March" as he paces around in his house, how many coaches he texts, and who's going to win it all (-). We wrap up with some breaking news about the Bengals and say. goodbye to Oldie (-).

Jon Rothstein on Selection Sunday Snubs, Bracket Breakdown, and Bengals News

The brackets are officially in our hands, which means the most glorious week of the year has arrived. Big Cat and PFT opened the show celebrating the tactile joy of a physical bracket, even if some members of the office are taking the "bracket love" a bit too far. While the vibes are high, the selection committee managed to ruin the mood early by letting North Carolina slide into the field despite a resume that looks like a crime scene.

The Bubba Cunningham Invitational

Big Cat didn't hold back on the clear conflict of interest regarding UNC’s inclusion. When the Tar Heels’ Athletic Director is in the room while the committee is deciding which bubble teams to screw, the math starts to look a little fuzzy.

Void
Mar 17, 2025
#15964
Big CatBig Cat

UNC getting into the tournament over West Virginia and Indiana is a result of committee member Bubba Cunningham being the UNC AD

UNC got into the tournament with one quad, one win. And Bubba Cunningham, who is part of the selection committee is also the ad at UNC. What I would say to that is that doesn't fucking matter at all [that he recused himself] because you spend an entire weekend hanging out with this people... Everyone in that room has to decide on UNC and then have him come back in the room and he's gonna be like, so how we looking?

It wasn’t just the UNC inclusion that raised eyebrows. Big Cat pointed out that the seeding across the board feels like the committee clocked out early to beat the Friday traffic. From Louisville getting an eight seed to Michigan landing at five, the logic was hard to find.

Void
Mar 17, 2025
#15966
Big CatBig Cat

The NCAA selection committee stopped working on Friday night

The committee. It's very clear they stopped working on Friday night. Maybe that's why Leonard's been sleeping because it makes no sense that UNC is in this tournament. It makes no sense that Michigan got a five. It makes no sense that Louisville got an eight.

Despite the weird seeding, Big Cat is cautioning fans against overthinking their picks this year. While everyone wants to find the next 15-over-2 upset, the top tier of college basketball is currently operating at a historic level of efficiency that suggests we might be headed for a very chalky Final Four.

Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15976
MemesMemes

St. John's is going to win the National Championship

St. John's win it all. I filled out my entire bracket. It's kind of, it's a weird final four... Michigan State. St. John's. BYU. Kentucky.

St. John's did not win the National Championship. As a 2-seed, they were upset by 10-seed Arkansas in the second round. Michigan State, BYU, and Kentucky also did not make the Final Four. The actual Final Four was all 1-seeds: Florida, Duke, Auburn, and Houston.

Jon Rothstein: This Is March

Friend of the program and the most well-rested man in America, Jon Rothstein, joined the show to give us the definitive breakdown of every region. Before he could even get into his legendary nicknames for the brackets, he had to address the "miscarriage of justice" that was the bubble. Rothstein, who has every coach’s number on speed dial, shared some significant injury updates including the status of Bama’s Grant Nelson and Houston’s J’Wan Roberts.

Win
Mar 17, 2025
#15980
Big CatBig Cat

Don't get cute with brackets this year; the one seeds are historically dominant

This is the year that don't be afraid to just do chalk. Only four teams since 2000 have entered the tournament [with a] plus 35 net rating... this year, four teams have 35 net rating or higher. Wow. So that's insane. Yeah. Like that, that just shows you that the one seeds this year are playing at such a high level and are so dominant... don't be afraid to just go chalk.

The factual claim about net rating is likely accurate based on KenPom data as of episode date; the strategy advice depends on tournament outcomes.

Rothstein walked us through his predicted path to the Final Four, including a heavy dose of Big Ten respect and a belief that Tom Izzo is ready for another deep run.

Void
Mar 17, 2025·Who's Back
#15982
HankHank

Borgs (Blackout Rage Gallons) are ratchet

My other, who's back of the week is... Borg. Blackout rage gallon. Foul... I've seen... people name 'em and stuff... it's so ratchet.

He also gave his official prediction for the national title, leaning into the "No Mercy" philosophy of a certain coach in Houston.

Void
Mar 17, 2025
#15985
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

UNC getting into the tournament is the biggest miscarriage of justice in 20 years

This is one of the biggest miscarriage of justices that I have seen in all my years covering college basketball... North Carolina was one and 12 against quad one opponents. That is just a fact of life... My heart breaks for West Virginia, it breaks for Indiana that North Carolina got this opportunity instead of them.

Who’s Back and Breaking Moose

Hank’s "Who’s Back" featured a deep dive into the "Borg" phenomenon sweeping college campuses, which he finds absolutely revolting. PFT countered with a conspiracy theory about the sun being replaced 40 years ago, and Big Cat shared his theory on why Chernobyl was actually a Russian marketing ploy to protect gas interests.

Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#29752
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The winner of the East region will win the National Championship

I think whoever wins the East winning it all.

Duke won the East region but did not win the National Championship. Duke lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal. Florida won the title.

Just as the show was wrapping up, the Cincinnati Bengals decided to end their reputation for being cheap by opening the checkbook for their star wide receivers. Hank delivered the "Breaking Moose" that Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins are officially staying in Cincy for the long haul.

Void
Mar 17, 2025
#15986
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Automatic Qualifiers (AQs) should always play on Thursday/Friday, while at-large teams play in the First Four

I think if you're good enough to get an automatic qualifier to the NCAA tournament, you deserve to partake in the Thursday and Friday of the first week... put the last eight at large teams in the first four, it would reward these programs again at the lower level and give them the NCAA tournament experience.

We also said goodbye to Oldie, who spent the weekend watching 50 hours of hoops and cleaning the office like a man possessed. He’s headed back to Canada, but not before giving us a few last-minute Cinderella picks and confirming that Rico Bosco’s phone is indeed the most powerful device on the Eastern Seaboard.

Good luck with your brackets, try not to get too cute, and remember that sleep is death.

nflcollege-basketballmarch-madnessbengalsjon-rothstein

More Takes

Void
Mar 17, 2025
#15963
Big CatBig Cat

The NCAA Tournament bracket reveal is the best non-sporting sporting event of the year

I actually think that this is the best non-sporting, sporting event of the year. I think that bracket reveal is the best sporting event that does not actually contain sports of the year. Oh, it's, it's incredible.

Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15968
Big CatBig Cat

Louisville will beat Creighton in the first round because Chucky Hepburn will stifle Steven Ashworth

Louisville being an eight seed, but if Louisville wins their first game, which I actually kind of like them to win that game. 'Cause I think Chucky Hepburn's gonna put Steven Ashworth in a torture chamber.

Creighton defeated Louisville 89-75 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament. Creighton shot 57.1% from the field and hit 11-of-24 threes.
Push
Mar 17, 2025
#15970
Big CatBig Cat

Michigan has turned the corner and is a dangerous team after winning the Big 10 tournament

Michigan obviously beat Wisconsin Big 10 title today. Dusty May called it correctly. He was like, our team needs a reset. They got their reset and then they won the big 10 tournament and they looked really good doing it. So maybe they've turned the corner and gotten that reset they needed.

Michigan did make the NCAA Tournament after winning the Big Ten tournament and reached the Sweet 16, losing to Auburn. However, they were not a deep threat as hoped.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#29748
Big CatBig Cat

Yale will upset Texas A&M in the first round

I also kind of like Yale is over [Texas] A&M. Yale's a good team. I feel like Yale also just, that's just a Yale does it every year kind of guy.

Big Cat predicted Yale would upset Texas A&M in the first round. Texas A&M defeated Yale 80-71 in the first round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15972
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Michigan State will win the South region

I have Michigan State winning this bracket [South Region].

Auburn won the South region, defeating Michigan State 70-64 in the Elite Eight. Michigan State did not win the region.
Void
Mar 17, 2025
#29749
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Kansas is going to be a bummer to watch and a 'pain in the ass' in the tournament

Kansas is a bummer to watch. Because you're gonna look at them and think, oh wait, it's Kansas. Kansas is the tournament Bill Self and the tournament. They're gonna be a pain in the ass to watch.

This is a subjective assessment of a team's playstyle and watchability.
Push
Mar 17, 2025
#15974
Big CatBig Cat

Florida will crush UConn by a hundred if they meet in the second round

I'm rooting for UConn just so that I can bet Florida against UConn. Everyone's gonna be like, watch out for UConn and Florida's gonna beat 'em by a hundred... Florida will kill him. Very. Florida's would be, that would be my take on that.

Florida did beat UConn in the second round 77-75, snapping UConn's 13-game tournament winning streak, but it was a very close game, not a blowout as predicted.
Void
Mar 17, 2025
#29750
Big CatBig Cat

Maryland was under-seeded and should have been a 3-seed

Maryland Grand Canyon's gonna be a good game. Maryland kind of got screwed too. I feel like they probably could have been a three [seed].

The quality of seeding is a matter of opinion compared to tournament results.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15978
Big CatBig Cat

Duke is going to win the National Championship

I've come to the realization that I think Duke's gonna win the whole thing. Doesn't matter [about Cooper Flagg's injury]. They're so good. I they're gonna win it all. I've just come to accept that. I it would, they're just so well-rounded, so deep.

Duke did not win the 2025 NCAA Championship. They lost to Houston 70-67 in the Final Four semifinal. Florida won the title.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15979
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Oregon will beat Arizona in the second round and Caleb Love will shoot 3-for-21

I have Oregon, beating Arizona in the second round. Because that will be, I think that's gonna be the Caleb Love masterpiece. Yeah. I think he'll go three for 21 for 14 points.

Arizona defeated Oregon 87-83 in the second round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament. Caleb Love actually scored 29 points for Arizona, leading them to victory, not shooting poorly as predicted.
Open
Mar 17, 2025
#29751
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Vanderbilt has a legitimate chance to upset Duke

I think Vandy could beat Duke. Why? I think they could. They're good. I think they possibly could too.

This prediction relies on both teams advancing or meeting in their bracket path.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15981
HankHank

Alabama will beat Auburn in the National Championship game

In this bracket... I have Bama beating Wisconsin and then Duke on the way to the Final Four... And they're going to beat Auburn to win it all.

Alabama was eliminated by Duke 85-65 in the Elite Eight. Auburn made the Final Four but lost to Florida. Neither played each other in the championship.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025·Who's Back
#15983
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The sun was switched out 40 years ago for a new, worse sun

I found guys... that think that actually this is a different sun that was, that we switched the sun out like 40 years ago and it's the new sun and it's worse for you... I gotta do some more research on the new sun guys.

Hot TakeLifeScorchingSarcastic
Scientifically, there is only one sun and it has not been replaced.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025·Who's Back
#15984
Big CatBig Cat

Chernobyl was an inside job by Russia to discourage nuclear energy and protect their gas interests

I had one the other day that actually I completely believe that Chernobyl was on purpose. Everyone was doing nuclear power plants and Russia has a shitload of oil and gas and so they're like, Hey, let's blow up a nuclear PowerPoint plant and scare the fuck outta everyone about nuclear energy. And everyone stopped doing nuclear energy or inside job.

The generally accepted cause of Chernobyl is design flaws and operator error, not a state-sponsored conspiracy to sabotage the nuclear industry.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15987
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Tom Izzo and Michigan State will return to the Final Four this year

I've got Auburn against then Michigan State in a regional final Atlanta. And I've got Tom Izzo getting back to the final four.

Michigan State lost to Auburn in the Elite Eight (70-64) and did not make the Final Four. Auburn advanced instead.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15988
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Florida will play St. John's in the West regional final

I have Florida, UConn, Colorado State, Maryland, Drake, Texas Tech... I've got St. John's against Drake in the Sweet 16. And I've got Florida against Maryland in the region of Prestige. I'm going Florida over St. John's in a regional final.

Florida played Texas Tech in the Elite Eight (winning 84-79), not St. John's. The actual regional final matchups did not match this prediction.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15989
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Duke will play Wisconsin in the East regional final (Elite Eight)

I've got Duke, Oregon, Wisconsin to the Sweet 16 to take on Alabama. And then I am going to take in a rematch of the 2015 national title... Duke over Wisconsin in Newark to go to the final four.

Duke played Alabama in the Elite Eight, not Wisconsin. Wisconsin was eliminated in the second round by BYU. Duke beat Alabama 85-65 in the Elite Eight.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#15990
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Houston will win the National Championship

I got Houston going on the final four... Houston against Duke on one side. Houston comes outta the region of toughness on the other side... I got Houston finally breaking through under Kelvin Sampson and winning the national championship.

Houston made the Final Four and beat Duke 70-67 in the semifinal but lost to Florida 65-63 in the championship game.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#29753
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Illinois will beat Tennessee and Houston to reach the Final Four

I'm gonna take Illinois against Tennessee in the Sweet 16 and I'm gonna take Illinois against Houston in the Elite Eight. And I got Houston going on the final four. [Correction: He says Illinois over Houston at 1:48:02, but then says Houston in his Final Four at 1:48:10. Transcript is slightly contradictory but he later says Houston wins it all].

Jon Rothstein predicted Illinois would beat Tennessee in the Sweet 16 and Houston in the Elite Eight. Illinois was eliminated in the second round by Kentucky (84-75) and never made it to the Sweet 16. The Final Four was Florida, Duke, Houston, and Auburn — all 1-seeds.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025
#29754
Jon RothsteinJon Rothstein

Wisconsin will make a run to at least the second weekend of the tournament

Wisconsin has enough here to at least get to the second weekend. I know you live and die with that team and they got the best off guard [in] America.

Jon Rothstein predicted Wisconsin would make at least the second weekend (Sweet 16) of the tournament. Wisconsin, a 3-seed, lost to BYU in the second round (Round of 32) and did not advance to the Sweet 16.
Open
Mar 17, 2025
#15991
Big CatBig Cat

The Bengals will be a championship threat for the next 3-4 years after signing Chase and Higgins

I am very happy for Bengals fans... Bengals fans, I think were very nervous about this entire off season. Will the Bengals be cheap? ... Those two guys are really fucking good at football and they're both still young... you have Joe Burrow and you basically are saying, you know yeah they gotta make some some right decisions on defense... But they're always gonna be in the mix with those three guys. You basically guaranteed the next three to four years are gonna be fun.

The longevity of this window depends on health and roster building over the next several seasons.
Loss
Mar 17, 2025·Picks
#29755
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trey Hendrickson will be traded by the Bengals following the Chase and Higgins extensions

It also probably means that Trey Hendrickson will definitely get traded at some point, right?

Trey Hendrickson was NOT traded by the Bengals. After the Chase and Higgins extensions, the Bengals gave Hendrickson a $14M raise to $30M for 2025 on a reworked contract. He played 7 games before season-ending surgery. The Bengals later declined to franchise tag him, letting him walk as a free agent instead.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers