Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Kirk Herbstreit, Mt Rushmore Of Water And Football Is Back

Monday, August 30, 202114 takes

Football is back and Nebraska is in the shitter. Chip Kelly brought back the visor and we talk soccer and F1 ( - ). Who’s back of the week ( - ). Kirk Herbstreit joins the show to talk about the upcoming football season, his new book, Lee Corso, fans being back and being a Dad ( - ). We wrap up with Mt Rushmore of water with special guest Hank’s dad

Kirk Herbstreit on College Football's Return, Nebraska's Meltdown, and Mt. Rushmore of Water

Football is officially back, and while the rest of the world is healing, Nebraska football has decided to remain a smoking crater in the middle of the Big 10. Big Cat and PFT opened the show reeling from Week 0, specifically the absolute masterclass in failure provided by Scott Frost. Between the safeties and the mistimed fumbles, the Scott Frost era in Lincoln has moved past the "growing pains" stage and settled firmly into "dumpster fire" territory.

Win
Aug 30, 2021
#9484
Big CatBig Cat

Nebraska football is a complete and utter dumpster fire under Scott Frost

Nebraska is a complete and utter dumpster fire. I don't know what you do. They, I don't know if you saw the graphics... but Scott Frost is now nine and 18 in big 10 football games, zero bowl games. He has the second worst record of any head coach in Nebraska history. And it's a complete failure.

Scott Frost was eventually fired in September 2022 after continuing to struggle, confirming the 'dumpster fire' assessment.

PFT has a theory on how to fix it, and it involves leaning into the villain arc. If you're going to lose this much, you might as well do it while being the most hated program in the country.

Void
Aug 30, 2021
#9485
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Nebraska needs to run the dirtiest, most unethical strength and conditioning program to win games

Seriously, if you're the next Nebraska coach, just buy all the steroids, just get all the steroids. If you get caught, I guarantee you that Cornhusker fans will not give a shit. If you get caught running the dirtiest strength and conditioning program in the history of college sports... it would be less embarrassing if you're Nebraska to get caught cheating than it is running whatever you have been running for the last 10 years.

Clearly satirical; obviously not a serious recommendation for the university, though it highlights the desperation of the fanbase.

On the flip side of that Week 0 coin, Bret Bielema returned to his natural habitat of grinding opponents into dust. Big Cat noted that while the rest of the world was watching the train wreck in Nebraska, Bielema was busy reminding everyone that Big 10 football is about 75-yard soul-crushing drives and sheer mass.

Win
Aug 30, 2021
#9486
Big CatBig Cat

Brett Bielema will be a good coach at Illinois

I credit to Brett Bielema because I actually think he's going to be a good coach at Illinois. And he plays Bret Bielema ball... that drive to start the second half where he was like, I'm just gonna run the ball down your throat for 75 yards was vintage Bielema.

Bielema has led Illinois to respectable seasons and bowl appearances, generally being viewed as a successful hire for the program's standards.

Moving West, Chip Kelly finally unveiled his secret weapon: the visor. After years of going hatless at UCLA, Chip brought back the headwear that defined his Oregon dynasty. Big Cat is convinced this wasn't a fashion choice, but a signal to the rest of the Pac-12.

Win
Aug 30, 2021
#9487
Big CatBig Cat

Chip Kelly only brought back the visor because he finally has a team that can compete

I'm a firm believer in weirdos, like Chip Kelly. Like he purposely didn't put on the visor until he knew he had a team that could compete. And now he's like, alright, I got my guys I'm ready to roll visor.

UCLA did improve significantly in 2021, finishing 8-4, their best record under Kelly to that point.

Soccer, F1, and the NFL Preseason

Beyond the college ranks, the guys hit on the chaos of the transfer window. Cristiano Ronaldo heading back to Manchester United feels like a glitch in the matrix, mostly because he seems to be hunting for very specific stats.

Void
Aug 30, 2021
#27245
Big CatBig Cat

Manchester United fans should feel dirty about Cristiano Ronaldo returning just to chase penalties

Cristiano Ronaldo is back at Manchester United... he basically last, last second of the transfer window [decided] 'where can I go get the most amount of penalties? I'm going to go back to Man U.' I, I don't, you know, Man U fans, you should feel dirty. You should feel bad about it yourself.

While Ronaldo did score many penalties and goals, the team struggled significantly during his return, leading to a polarizing tenure.

PFT is struggling even more with his loyalty, as Arsenal has reached a level of incompetence that makes Nebraska look like the 90s Bulls. Between 5-0 losses and questionable management, the patience has officially run out.

Loss
Aug 30, 2021
#27246
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arsenal is a trash franchise and I'm officially 'Arteta Out'

Man U's a trash franchise, although I'd still rather cheer for them than Arsenal at this point... they stink. I'm Arteta out now. I think they should bring back Wenger.

Arsenal stuck with Arteta, who eventually led them back to the top of the Premier League as title contenders in 2022-2024.

Turning to the NFL, the Mac Jones hype train has left the station in New England. While everyone is arguing about upside, PFT pointed out that the floor for Mac is significantly higher than his fellow rookies right now.

Win
Aug 30, 2021
#9491
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mac Jones is the most NFL-ready rookie quarterback in his class

One thing that I've heard and I love this line of dialogue. People saying, you know what, Mac Jones, he's not going to be the best rookie quarterback, but he's the most NFL-ready rookie quarterback right now.

Mac Jones was the only rookie QB to lead his team to a winning record and the playoffs in 2021, validating this take in the short term.

As for the rest of the league, Big Cat is already mapping out the inevitable arc of the Philadelphia Eagles. It’s a cycle as old as time: hope, followed by the league realizing exactly how to stop a mobile quarterback who lacks a supporting cast.

Loss
Aug 30, 2021
#27247
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles will start the season well, but will fall off once the league figures out Jalen Hurts

Philly's gonna play decent to start the season... and everyone's gonna say, 'wow, look at Jalen Hurts.' And then they're going to, because they don't have the super talented roster, then they're going to fall off and everyone's going to say, 'well, the league figured out Jalen Hurts.'

The Eagles actually did the opposite: they started 2-5 and then rallied to finish 9-8 and make the playoffs as Hurts improved.

Kirk Herbstreit

Recurring guest Kirk Herbstreit joined the show to talk about his new book *Out of the Pocket* and the general feeling of having fans back in the stands. Kirk admitted that calling games in empty stadiums was dreadful and that the energy of a college campus is what makes the sport actually work. However, he didn't hold back on the state of the playoffs. While the games on Saturday are perfect, the way we crown a champion is still broken.

Void
Aug 30, 2021
#9499
Kirk HerbstreitKirk Herbstreit

College football has the best regular season but the worst postseason in sports

We have to fix it. It's gotta get better. The best regular season, the worst post season right now in sports. So that has to be fixed. But that doesn't mean I can't enjoy when teams get together.

The postseason was eventually 'fixed' by expanding to a 12-team playoff starting in 2024, acknowledging the issues Herbstreit mentions.

Kirk also went deep on his relationship with Lee Corso, being a football dad, and why the tradition of the sport outweighs the lack of parity at the top. It’s always a great listen when Kirk drops by because he genuinely loves the sport as much as the fans do, even when he's calling a blowout.

Who’s Back and Mt. Rushmore

Who’s Back featured a heated debate over Trent Dilfer’s viral coaching moment. While the internet was calling for his head, Big Cat stood up for the idea of hard coaching in high school football.

Void
Aug 30, 2021·Who's Back
#9495
Big CatBig Cat

Trent Dilfer was coaching hard, not committing physical assault in his viral high school video

I hate the argument you never put your hands on a player it's like grabbing a guy by shoulder, grabbing him by the elbow. Come on. Are we really going to get upset about that. Obviously, if it's like punching choking... this, there was no malicious intent in this.

Dilfer issued an apology, but many football traditionalists agreed with Big Cat's view that it was standard tough coaching.

We also checked in on the "Football Guy" grind, specifically at Auburn. Brian Harsin is already instituting elevator bans to ensure his players are "blue collar," a move that Big Cat thinks plays right into the hands of the elite programs who focus on, you know, players.

Win
Aug 30, 2021·Who's Back
#27248
Big CatBig Cat

Coaches like Brian Harsin worrying about elevators is exactly why Nick Saban continues to dominate college football

Every time we hear something like this [Brian Harsin banning elevators], it makes you realize why Nick Saban just keeps kicking everyone's teeth in. Cause these guys are worrying about elevators and stairs and Nick Saban is just rolling out five star recruits... and just demolishing people.

Nick Saban went on to win the SEC and make the CFP title game in 2021, while Harsin's tenure at Auburn was a noted disaster.

Finally, the show wrapped up with a highly controversial Mt. Rushmore of Water. From fountain water to ice-cold bottled water, the stakes have never been higher, especially with a guest appearance from Hank's dad to help settle the score.

If you're not drinking room temperature water like a psychopath, you're doing it right.

college-footballnebraskanfl-preseasonchip-kellypremier-leaguef1

More Takes

Loss
Aug 30, 2021
#9493
Big CatBig Cat

Tua Tagovailoa has to make the playoffs this year to show he's a successful quarterback

I think the Dolphins have like a playoff caliber roster... I think too, it has to show something this year. Oh, I think they need to make the playoffs. I do.

The Dolphins finished 9-8 and narrowly missed the playoffs in 2021, making the season a failure by Big Cat's criteria.
Void
Aug 30, 2021
#9489
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NBA should return to best-of-five series for the first round of the playoffs

I think MBA absolutely should go back to the best of five... Dikembe Mutombo shocked the world... those are the moments that you get.

The NBA has not returned to best-of-five series, so this remains a subjective preference.
Loss
Aug 30, 2021·Who's Back
#9497
Billy FootballBilly Football

Sam Ehlinger would have beaten out Trevor Lawrence for the starting job if not for his injury

Unfortunately, Sam Ehlinger is out with a tweaked ACL... The Sam Ehlinger beating out Trevor Lawrence prediction has not come yet for now.

This was never a possibility; Trevor Lawrence was a locked-in #1 overall pick and Ehlinger was a late-round pick for a different team (Colts).

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers