Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Miami HC Mario Cristobal, CFB With Tom Fornelli, Jerry From Meow Mix + Playoff Baseball, Jaguars Big Win And FAQ's

Wednesday, October 8, 202521 takes

The Yankees survive game 3 after Aaron Judge's pinstripe moment (-:11). Big Dumper goes poo poo and the Mariners go up 2-1 (-). Cubs and Phillies are down bad ahead of Game 3 (-). Jaguars win a game they never usually win and the Chiefs are mortal (-). Joe Flacco to the Bengals (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Jerry Jones flipping people off, Lebron's fake retirement and more (-). Tom Fornelli joins us to talk about a crazy Week 6, James Franklin, Sark in Texas, who's going to win the SEC, UNC is a disaster and is Ohio State better this year (-)? Miami Hurricanes Head Coach Mario Cristobal joins the show to talk about the season, how to stop complacency, building teams, trench play, and more (-). Jerry from the Carolina Panthers Meow Mix podcast joins the show to talk about ending his podcast because the Panthers are so bad at football (-). We finish with listener submitted FAQ's (-).

Mario Cristobal and Tom Fornelli on College Football, Playoff Baseball, and the Mortal Chiefs

The Bronx is burning and Aaron Judge finally had his pinstripe moment. PFT admitted that even as a certified Yankees hater, seeing Judge hit a 450-foot bomb to tie the game was objectively cool, though he remains skeptical of the math coming out of the stadium.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#20923
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Statcast measurements for home run distances are a lie

Stack Cast said [the Aaron Judge home run went] like 473. I don't believe that for a second. ... When they say like 373 feet on their like internal measurement system, there's no way that was only 373 feet, right? No, I don't believe any of that.

This is a subjective opinion on the accuracy of tracking technology, which cannot be definitively proven wrong without independent data.

While the Yankees staved off elimination against the Blue Jays, PFT has already run the numbers on how this ends. After 2,000 mental simulations, he’s convinced there is only one team capable of stopping the Dodgers' juggernaut.

Loss
Oct 8, 2025
#10494
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Blue Jays are the only team with the mental criteria to beat the Dodgers in the World Series

I ran a mental simulation last night to, 'cause I was pissed off. 'cause it seems like the Dodgers were gonna win the World Series and there's nothing anybody else could do about it. I did 2000 mental simulations. I was laying in bed envisioning a team that I could picture beating the Dodgers in the World Series. And the only team that fits my mental criteria is the Blue Jays.

This is a subjective mental exercise and the Blue Jays didn't win the 2025 World Series (the Dodgers did).

Hank, however, isn't buying the organic drama. He’s convinced the league is pulling the strings to make sure these series don't end too early, specifically when it involves the big market teams.

Loss
Oct 8, 2025
#20924
HankHank

MLB is rigging playoff games and juicing baseballs to extend series

If the Yankees had got swept, it's in like MLB needs to do something territory. Someone's, you know, someone's gotta extend a series. ... I'm saying like MLB is gonna rig games to advance the series. ... when the Brewers and Dodgers are pitching, they'd give him the, the juiced ones.

OpinionBaseballHotSarcastic
While MLB has admitted to varying ball properties in the past, there is no evidence of specific rigging to extend series in 2025.

Playoff Desperation and 50/50 Jinxes

Things are significantly bleaker for Big Cat and Max. The Cubs and Phillies are both down 0-2, and the vibes are at an all-time low. Big Cat is already bracing for the worst-case scenario where his team is the only one heading home early.

Win
Oct 8, 2025
#10495
Big CatBig Cat

The Cubs will be the only team to get swept in the Division Series

I think the Cubs are screwed because I saw Tom Fornelli our good friend who's on later on in the show, who does not like the Cubs tweets. So we're gonna get three out of four of the DS series as sweeps, and now the Yankees won. That means a Phillies are gonna win and the Cubs are gonna be the only team that gets swept.

The Cubs were indeed swept by the Brewers in the 2025 NLDS.

Max is ready to break out the emergency overalls for Game 3, mostly because he’s fed up with Rob Thomson’s decision-making. He wants the best arms on the mound, regardless of "big time" reputation.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#20927
MaxMax

Rob Thomson is coaching the Phillies like a loser

Rob Thompson is coaching like a loser. ... His reasoning for Aaron Nola is that he's a, he's a big time pitcher. Ranger Suarez is a big time pitcher. Pitch your best guys. ... it's the momentum that, that just really pissed me off. Is that it was the first time the stadium was feeling something and just ride it. Just ride it.

Whether a manager 'coached like a loser' is subjective, though the Phillies' eventual exit or success in the 2025 postseason would provide context.

The drama even extends to the Wrigley Field 50/50 raffle. Big Cat is terrified that winning the raffle has become a cursed omen for the Cubs. He’s made a vow that if the pattern holds, his gambling days in the bleachers are over.

Open
Oct 8, 2025
#20928
Big CatBig Cat

I will retire from 50/50 raffles forever if the Cubs lose when I win

If the Cubs lose tomorrow and I win the 50 50, I will 100% retire from 50 50 for the rest of my life. That's a fact. Because then it would just be like, you literally only won on losses, on big playoff losses. That is a fact.

This is a personal vow. If he wins and they lose, we'll see if he actually stops participating in 50/50 raffles.

The Chiefs Look Like Us

The Jaguars pulled off a win they usually find a way to lose, taking down the Chiefs on Monday Night Football. Trevor Lawrence was erratic but effective, while the Chiefs finally looked like a team that can actually be beaten. PFT thinks the "Chiefs Kingdom" aura is officially wearing off.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#10496
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Chiefs have regressed into a normal good football team that loses like everyone else

It's that the Chiefs, they're starting to lose games in ways that are familiar to every other team out there to every other fan base. It's they, they look like all of us now. ... I'm starting to think that it, it might kind of be their, their regression back to being just like kind of a normal good football team.

Whether a team is 'normal good' or has 'lost its magic' is a subjective framing of their results.

Watching the AFC South suddenly look competent gave Big Cat an idea for how the NFL should handle its image problem. He wants every division to have a dedicated hype man—and a dedicated hater.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#10497
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL should have a commissioner for every division to run PR and attack ads

Wouldn't it be cool if there was a commissioner for each division? I mean, just had like commercials and stuff and you're like, yeah, hey, here at the AFC South, we actually played winning football now. ... I just wanna watch a football game and see just an attack ad on a certain division. Like, 'The NFC South sucks... they have the Bucs, but what else?'

This is a purely creative/subjective proposal for how the NFL should be structured.

Tom Fornelli on College Chaos

Tom Fornelli joined to break down a wild Week 6 and look ahead to the Red River Shootout. The conversation immediately turned to Penn State and whether James Franklin is finally on the hot seat. Fornelli thinks there’s one specific coach who would jump at the chance to take over in Happy Valley.

Loss
Oct 8, 2025
#20930
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Curt Cignetti would leave Indiana for the Penn State head coaching job

I think Penn State is one of the jobs [Curt Cignetti] would definitely leave Indiana for. I think there are a lot of jobs that have come open or or likely to come open that he's been mentioned for that I don't really see as upgrades over Indiana. ... I feel like if you're gonna replace James Franklin, you'd need to find your own Dan Lanning kind of hire.

This depends on Penn State firing James Franklin and offering the job to Cignetti, and Cignetti accepting. James Franklin remained at Penn State through the 2025 cycle.

Over in Austin, the honeymoon phase for Arch Manning might be ending before it even really started. Fornelli noted that despite the pedigree, the young QB still has a lot of growing up to do on the field.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#10501
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Arch Manning looks like an unpolished freshman and is not ready for the SEC

I thought like the last few years sitting on the bench developing behind Quinn Ewers is like we were gonna see a much more polished player than what we have seen to this point. He just looks like a freshman even though he is now in his third year on campus. So I think that is very alarming.

Subjective evaluation of talent, but Manning's subsequent performances were inconsistent.

Mario Cristobal and the Trenches

Miami Head Coach Mario Cristobal stopped by to talk about the Hurricanes' 5-0 start and the relentless culture he’s building in Coral Gables. He doesn't believe in the "Miami is back" talk, preferring to focus on the adults in the room setting the standard.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#10504
Mario CristobalMario Cristobal

The adults and coaches set the tone for a program, not the players

People always saying, well, players nowadays bullshit. Right? It the adults, the adults set the tone right and the players will follow. And we have the right kind of players with the right kind of mentality is full throttle every day, man. And you and you're honest, don't, we don't sugarcoat anything.

This is a fundamental coaching philosophy and is inherently subjective.

Cristobal also shared his thoughts on the college football awards circuit, specifically why the timing of the most prestigious trophy in the sport makes zero sense to a football guy.

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#10505
Mario CristobalMario Cristobal

Awarding the Heisman Trophy before postseason games are played is bizarre

The only thing I would wish for the Heisman Trophy that it was awarded when all the games were done. That whole award before these postseason games are played is absolutely bizarre to me. Like, I don't, I can't comprehend it. Never will.

This is a subjective opinion on the structure of sports awards.

We wrapped up with Jerry from the Meow Mix podcast, who gave a heartbreaking eulogy for his Panthers show. When a team is so bad it makes its most dedicated fans stop talking into microphones for fun, you know things are dire in Carolina.

Try not to think about Bryce Young too much today.

nflcollege-footballmlb-playoffsyankeesjaguarsmiami-hurricanes

More Takes

Void
Oct 8, 2025
#20925
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Cheating in baseball is legal as long as it doesn't involve electronics or batteries

Cheating in baseball is legal except if you use electronics. That's my, that's my rule. Like use electronics then at that, if a battery is involved, then that's against the rules.

The MLB rulebook does prohibit sign-stealing via electronic means, but 'cheating' is generally illegal in all forms; PFT is making a satirical point about the culture of the sport.
Push
Oct 8, 2025
#20926
MemesMemes

The Bucks leaked the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade rumors to attract teams with better draft assets

I think the Bucks leaked this because they wanna move on from Giannis so they could rebuild. The Knicks don't have any first round picks. So they want a team that has first round picks to be like, oh, he is available for trade, let me come in. ... and there was also a report that his wife's moving to Greece, so he might go play in Greece.

Memes predicted the Bucks leaked the Giannis trade rumors to attract teams with better draft picks than the Knicks. At the 2026 deadline, the Warriors did aggressively pursue Giannis with draft picks and players, but ultimately the Bucks chose not to trade him. The leak-to-attract-offers theory may have had some merit since multiple teams reportedly engaged, but Giannis was not traded.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

LeBron James will not retire until the 2028 Olympics in Los Angeles

I was talking to [Mark] Titus about it... he was saying that he doesn't think LeBron's gonna retire till 2028 when the Olympics are in LA. That's so much more LeBron. ... He will, that will be the last basketball. He plays the Olympics in 2028.

LeBron is still playing as of this date; the 2028 Olympics will be the definitive test.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Conor McDavid's team-friendly contract was designed to make him easily tradable to a contender

This seems like it would be very easily tradable. Very, very easily tradable contract. He basically, I mean smart by him. If in a year and a half the Oilers aren't competing and he can go somewhere for a year and a half and it doesn't fuck up some team's cap.

McDavid has not been traded, and the Oilers have remained competitive.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Hurts catching his own Hail Mary rebound would be the coolest play in sports history

The wide angle of the Hail Mary came out and Jalen Hurts tried to get his own rebound. ... I'll say this right now, if that ever happens, that will be the coolest play in all of sports. ... That was sports history. If there, the fact that he got as far down as he did was... if there was a, if there was two bobs, he would've been there.

The 'coolness' of a hypothetical play is entirely subjective.
Loss
Oct 8, 2025
#10500
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Texas A&M is the most surprising SEC team that could run the table the rest of the season

I would say Texas A&M. I do think that they're legitimately good. ... They've kind of figured things out and gotten their act together the last few weeks. ... I'm not saying that they will, I'm just saying they strike me as a team that is much better than anybody truly expected.

Texas A&M did not run the table, losing key late-season matchups.
Void
Oct 8, 2025
#20931
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Billy Napier is the best coach ever when his back is against the wall and he's almost fired

Billy Napier with his back against the wall might be the best coach ever. He literally just, just get him, get him almost fired and he'll start performing.

This is a subjective characterization of Napier's coaching tenure and 'clutch' ability under pressure.
Win
Oct 8, 2025
#10502
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Ohio State's defense is definitively better than it was last year

I do think there is an argument to be made that the defense is better than last year's defense. I think [Jim Knowles] is just confusing the ever living crap out of all the quarterbacks that he has faced so far. ... Once they get to the red zone, they're just absolutely clamping down and not giving up anything.

The 2025 Ohio State defense statistically out-performed the 2024 unit in several key metrics including PPG allowed.
Win
Oct 8, 2025
#10503
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Michigan is a better team than USC and will beat them on the money line

I think the wrong team is favorite in Los Angeles. I think Michigan's a better football team than USC. ... I'm probably just gonna be on the Michigan money line. ... I think Michigan's just much better than they are along the lines of scrimmage.

Michigan defeated USC 27-24.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers