Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL Divisional Round Recap, Fastest 2 Minutes, Mahomes Concussion, And Brees' Last Ride

Monday, January 18, 202120 takes

Fastest 2 Minutes ( - ). We recap every game from the weekend starting with Brees vs Brady and the last game of Drew Brees HoF career ( - ). Packers vs Rams and Aaron Rodgers possibly cheating because it doesnt make sense how good he is ( - ). Ravens vs Bills in a rock fight and the correct Lamar Jackson take ( - ). Browns vs Chiefs and the NFL is already working to make sure Mahomes plays in the AFC Championship Game ( - ). Coaching Carousel and Urban Meyer is back. Football guy of the week and who's back of the week including skinny James Harden

Divisional Round Recap: Brees Bows Out, Mahomes Goes Down, and Urban Meyer Arrives

A legendary weekend of football is in the books, even if the games themselves occasionally left something to be desired. We officially have our final four set for Championship Sunday, and the path there was paved with concussed superstars, washed-up icons, and the realization that the old guard is finally, truly handing over the keys. Big Cat and PFT broke down every snap while grappling with the fact that we might be seeing the end of an era in more ways than one.

The Last Ride of Drew Brees

Watching the Saints fall to the Buccaneers felt like watching a glitch in the matrix. Drew Brees looked every bit of 42 years old, unable to push the ball downfield and ultimately sinking a Saints roster that seemed ready for a deep run. PFT has been shouting from the mountaintops about the decline in New Orleans for a while now, and Sunday night was the definitive proof.

Win
Jan 18, 2021
#8080
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Drew Brees is clearly washed

Drew Brees clearly looked very washed. I've been on the Drew Brees is washed train for two years now and I've said that the Saints have a Super Bowl roster and the only thing that's holding them back is Drew Brees.

Brees threw 3 interceptions and averaged 4.0 yards per attempt in this game, and retired shortly after, confirming he was at the end of his career.

Big Cat agreed, noting that while the mind is still sharp, the arm has simply quit. It was a somber exit for a Hall of Famer, but one that felt inevitable given how little zip was left on those throws. The guys wondered how Saints fans will reconcile the Brees-Payton era only resulting in a single ring.

Void
Jan 18, 2021
#8083
Big CatBig Cat

Saints fans will eventually regret only winning one Super Bowl with Brees and Payton

If you asked a Saints fan, like, hey, that was incredible, awesome memories, but there's definitely a small part of you that's saying to yourself, shit, how do we only win one? That absolutely exists.

This is a subjective sentiment among a fanbase, though commonly cited in NFL media circles.

The Frozen Tundra and the New King of Coaching

Aaron Rodgers and the Packers made a very good Rams defense look like a high school unit. It wasn't even Rodgers' best game, yet the Packers offense operated with such surgical precision that it felt illegal to watch. Big Cat noted that the old mantra of "defense wins championships" has been officially retired in favor of high-flying schemes.

Void
Jan 18, 2021
#8084
Big CatBig Cat

In the modern NFL, good offense always beats good defense

At this point in time, it used to be the saying, good defense trumps all, defense wins championships. That's not the case anymore. Good offense beats good defense in the NFL today.

While broadly true in terms of league trends, the 2020-21 Bucs (who won the Super Bowl) and the 2021-22 Rams showed that elite defensive lines still play massive roles in titles.

This led to a heated debate about the coaching hierarchy. Matt LaFleur has now reached back-to-back NFC Championship games, and PFT is ready to crown him over his former mentor, Sean McVay.

Loss
Jan 18, 2021
#8085
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Matt LaFleur is a better coach than Sean McVay

If LeFleur gets there, gets a two NFC championship games in a row, beats his old master on the way there, I think he might be [better] because McVay got to that Super Bowl on the pass interference call, laid an egg in the Super Bowl.

McVay went on to win a Super Bowl the following season while LaFleur struggled to get past the NFCCG despite high seeds.

Looking ahead to the matchup with the Bucs, the internal bias was real. Big Cat is already eyeing an emotional hedge with the Packers in the Can't Lose Parlay, while PFT is convinced Green Bay is a wagon that can't be stopped in the cold.

Loss
Jan 18, 2021
#8086
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Packers will beat the Buccaneers in the NFC Championship Game

Packers are going to win. Probably. Packers are a wagon right now. And they're going to win. It's going to be boring. Nope. They're still going to score 33 points.

The Buccaneers beat the Packers 31-26 to advance to the Super Bowl.

Rock Fight in Buffalo and the Mahomes Scare

The Bills and Ravens gave us a classic Western New York rock fight, complete with Justin Tucker missing two field goals and Lamar Jackson struggling against the wind. Big Cat remains a believer in Lamar's playmaking ability, even if the passing game isn't quite there yet.

Void
Jan 18, 2021
#8088
Big CatBig Cat

Lamar Jackson is the second best playmaker in the NFL behind Mahomes

Lamar, to me, is... if you want to say playmaker, he's probably the second best behind Patrick Mahomes. But all-around quarterback, he is still limited as a thrower.

Subjective ranking of 'playmakers', though generally accepted as a top-tier athlete at the position.

But the real story was the Buffalo Bills proving they are a legit threat to win the whole thing. They haven't even played their best football yet, and they're still moving on. Big Cat thinks the Chiefs need to be on high alert.

Loss
Jan 18, 2021
#8093
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills could blowout the Chiefs in the AFC Championship Game

There's part of me that thinks the Bills might fucking blow out the Chiefs. I wouldn't be shocked if the Bills dominated the AFC Championship. I wouldn't be like, oh my God, where'd this come from? I really think they have that in them as a complete football team.

The Chiefs won the game 38-24, never trailing by more than 9 points.

Speaking of the Chiefs, the NFL world held its breath when Patrick Mahomes was wobbling off the field. Between the toe injury and the "choked out" concussion protocol, the drama is at an all-time high. Big Cat isn't buying the idea that the league lets its biggest star sit out the AFC Championship Game.

Win
Jan 18, 2021
#8097
Big CatBig Cat

Patrick Mahomes will play in the AFC Championship Game regardless of the concussion protocol because the NFL needs him

Mahomes... I think Mahomes will be fine. He's going to play. I'm not saying it's right. What I'm saying is he's going to play. Andy Reid's already planting the seed. The NFL would never allow an AFC championship game to be played with Chad fucking Henney.

Mahomes was indeed cleared from the concussion protocol and played the entire AFC Championship game.

Coaching Carousel and Houston's Holy Mess

Urban Meyer is officially a Jaguar, and the guys have mixed feelings. Big Cat thinks the pairing with Trevor Lawrence will actually result in some winning, while PFT is already setting the over-under on how long Urban lasts before a mysterious health issue or family commitment pulls him back to TV.

Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Urban Meyer won't last longer than three and a half years in the NFL

Urban Meyer, I don't think he'll last... longer than three years in the NFL. I think it's three and a half. Three and a half is the over-under.

Meyer lasted only 13 games (less than one season).

Meanwhile, the situation in Houston has devolved into a full-blown religious hijacking. Jack Easterby has seemingly used the power of prayer to seize control of the franchise, much to the horror of Deshaun Watson and NFL fans everywhere. Big Cat and PFT can't get enough of the dysfunction.

Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Houston Texans have been hijacked by Jack Easterby and it's a complete shit show

The Texans are being... they essentially, like... the owner got duped by a guy who's reading palms and being like, hey, here's what our future tells us. It's crazy. It's nuts. Jack Easterby is essentially making the McNair family pray with him for his own success.

Easterby was eventually fired in October 2022 after years of reported internal turmoil, validating the 'shit show' assessment.

Whether it's Tony Romo obsessing over momentum or the chaos of the fumble-out-of-the-end-zone rule, playoff football is officially back in its peak form.

Get ready for a week of speculating on Mahomes' brain and Rodgers' smile.

nfl-playoffsdrew-breespatrick-mahomesurban-meyerbuffalo-billsgreen-bay-packers

More Takes

Win
Jan 18, 2021
#8081
Big CatBig Cat

Drew Brees' physical limitations cost the Saints the game

It was clear. [Brees] can't throw the ball over 15 yards. His mind is still there, but he doesn't have any of the physical abilities. And that cost the Saints the game. Drew Brees unfortunately lost them the game.

Stats and film from the game showed Brees unable to push the ball downfield, which allowed the Bucs to compress their defense.
Loss
Jan 18, 2021
#8082
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Jameis Winston's one touchdown pass against the Bucs will earn him a massive contract next year

That one pass made Jameis Winston $25 million next year. I don't know about that much, but it definitely... whoever comes in second with the Deshaun Watson jackpot, they're going to have to pony up some cash for Big J-Dog.

Hot TakeFootballHotSarcastic
Jameis Winston signed a one-year, $5.5 million deal to stay with the Saints, which is significantly less than the $25 million mentioned.
Win
Jan 18, 2021
#8087
HankHank

The Buccaneers will beat the Packers straight up

I think the Bucs are going to win straight up.

The Buccaneers won 31-26.
Win
Jan 18, 2021
#22095
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The wind is a bigger factor in NFL games when there are no fans in the stands

The wind with no fans, with less than a full house, will be whipping more. I think we saw it... enough bodies will just stop the wind.

The physics of wind in empty vs full stadiums is a real phenomenon often discussed by kickers and architects, making this a surprisingly astute observation.
Push
Jan 18, 2021
#8090
Big CatBig Cat

The Bills are a complete team that hasn't played their best game yet

The Bills are a complete team... and it's crazy to me that the Bills – I never thought I'd be sitting here saying the Bills are in the AFC Championship game... and they haven't even come close to playing their best playoff game.

The Bills lost the AFC Championship game 38-24 to the Chiefs, suggesting they may have already peaked or weren't as 'complete' as Mahomes.
Loss
Jan 18, 2021
#8095
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield is definitively the 'guy' for the Browns

Is Baker our guy? Baker's your guy. Baker is your guy. It's definitive as can be. Baker is your guy. If you can get any type of defense around that offense, you guys are going to be really good next year.

The Browns traded for Deshaun Watson just over a year later, clearly deciding Baker was NOT their guy.
Void
Jan 18, 2021
#22096
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL's 'fumble through the end zone' touchback rule is actually good because it's the only rule that favors the defense

Everyone says it's a bad rule... I disagree. I think that it's not a bad rule. In fact, I think it's a good rule. It's the only rule that favors the defense at all. The way that the game's going, every rule change is in favor of the offense... This is the one rule that on defense, it gives you a little bit of [help].

The rule remains highly controversial but unchanged, making this a permanent philosophical debate.
Void
Jan 18, 2021
#22097
Big CatBig Cat

The fumble through the end zone rule should result in the offense keeping the ball but facing 3rd and Goal from the 50-yard line

The offense should get to keep the ball, but it should be third and 50 from the 50. Third and goal from the 50. That would just be fun. That would be cool. Most of the time it will end up being a punt and the defense would end up getting the ball anyway.

This is a humorous rule proposal that will never be implemented but captures the show's spirit.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer will get the Jaguars to an AFC Championship Game

I'm going to say that Urban Meyer won't be an abject failure. Now, what does that mean? I think Urban Meyer will get the Jags to an AFC championship game. I don't know if he'll last more than five years.

Urban Meyer was fired before his first season even ended, finishing with a 2-11 record.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Eagles have a problem because Howie Roseman treats Carson Wentz like he won the Super Bowl

There was one line in it that was like, Howie Roseman treats Carson Wentz like he won that Super Bowl. It's like, well, that's a problem. They chose him. He essentially has just been like, yeah, Carson Wentz is the best quarterback of all time, even though he hasn't... played like six snaps in the playoffs.

The Eagles traded Wentz to the Colts in February 2021, proving they eventually moved on from this 'problem'.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers