Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

NFL With Brian Baldinger, 1 Question With Drake Maye, CFB Talk And Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Wednesday, October 18, 202314 takes

The Phillies are the hottest team in baseball and on a collision course with the Rangers (-). Monday Night Football was a disaster for Justin Herbert and the Chargers (-). We talk College Football, Washington's big win, Heisman race, people being mad about Iowa and more (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including John Fisher being the worst (-). Brian Baldinger joins the show to talk NFL, what he's seeing on the film, can the Dolphins be stopped, are the Lions for real? and more (-). 1 question with UNC quarterback Drake Maye (-). We then wrap up with Jimbo's (-).

Brian Baldinger on Lions Realism, Drake Maye on Tar Heel Lore, and Jimbo's Oil Price Buyout

The Phillies are currently an unstoppable force of nature, and the guys are fully leaning into the chaos. Between Kyle Schwarber mashing leadoff dingers and Bryce Harper pouring beer on people while being a noted non-drinker, the vibes in Philadelphia are at an all-time high. PFT thinks we are witnessing a historic offensive explosion that will leave the record books looking completely different by November.

Loss
Oct 18, 2023
#14123
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Phillies will destroy the all-time postseason record for team home runs

The all time record for Homers in a playoff, it was the Tampa Bay Rays in 2020 with 34 home runs in those playoffs. These Phillies are on pace to destroy that record. And it's unreal.

The Phillies finished the 2023 postseason with 24 home runs, falling short of the 2020 Rays' record of 34, primarily because they were eliminated in the NLCS.

Max is already looking ahead to the Fall Classic, and while he respects the pedigree of the Astros, he's definitely rooting for a specific opponent to come out of the American League.

Void
Oct 18, 2023
#14125
MaxMax

I would rather the Phillies play the Rangers than the Astros in the World Series

I would rather play the Rangers. [than the Astros]

The Phillies did not reach the World Series, losing to the Diamondbacks in the NLCS.

The Justin Herbert Debate and College Chaos

Monday Night Football gave the Herbert haters plenty of ammo. While the talent is undeniable, the late-game execution against the Cowboys left a lot to be desired. PFT has officially seen enough to place the Chargers' signal-caller in a very specific tier of NFL quarterbacks.

Void
Oct 18, 2023
#14127
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Justin Herbert is basically Kirk Cousins in powder blue

I think we just need to intentionally recalibrate our Justin Herbert expectations. Like officially right now, Justin Herbert is basically Kirk Cousins in powder blue.

Herbert struggled with injuries and inconsistent play in 2023, failing to reach the elite status predicted by some, though the 'Kirk Cousins' label remains a point of heavy debate.

In the college world, Washington's massive win over Oregon dominated the weekend. The conversation shifted to the post-game scenes where fans rushed the field, specifically the interaction between a Notre Dame fan and Caleb Williams. Big Cat has a new proposal for how players should be allowed to handle fans who cross the line.

Void
Oct 18, 2023
#14129
Big CatBig Cat

Players should be allowed to open-hand slap any fan who talks shit to them immediately after a loss

I really do think that Caleb Williams, like every player, if a fan goes up to you and talks shit after a devastating loss, you have like a ten second period where you can just open hand slap 'em. Yeah. Not punch. We're civilized. But I think that that would actually, if that just became a law and a rule, 'cause then fans would start acting accordingly.

This is a hyperbolic suggestion for a rule change in sports culture and cannot be 'correct'.

Speaking of delusional fanbases, the guys turned their attention to College Station. Big Cat broke down the numbers on Texas A&M, pointing out that for a program that thinks it's a blue blood, the win totals tell a much different story.

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#14130
Big CatBig Cat

Texas A&M has the most delusional fanbase in college football because they think they are a perennial 11-win team

Texas a and m to me, most delusional fan base in college football... Why is it that Texas a and m thinks that they are a perennial 10 11 win team... Since 1995, they have won over 10 games twice. They won 11 games in 1998. And then Johnny Football. It's just a very funny like to, I again, you should aspire to be great, but to pretend like Texas a m is like, we deserve to be winning 10 games.

His factual claims about their 10-win seasons are accurate based on their record in the SEC and Big 12 eras.

Meanwhile, the Jimbo Fisher buyout remains the most fascinating sub-plot in the sport. PFT has been doing some deep-state research into the correlation between the global energy market and Jimbo's job security.

Push
Oct 18, 2023
#14132
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

If oil reaches $95 a barrel, Jimbo Fisher will get bought out of his contract

I'm setting a price target right now. I'm setting a personal price target. If oil reaches $95 a barrel, then I predict that Jimbo Fisher will get bought out of his contract.

Jimbo Fisher was fired on Nov 12, 2023, with a $77M buyout. However, crude oil prices (WTI) were around $77-78 a barrel at the time of his firing, not $95.

However, the real crown jewel of the season remains the Iowa Hawkeyes. They are the ultimate 'sickos' team, winning games with an offense that belongs in the 1920s while driving the rest of the country insane.

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#22848
Big CatBig Cat

Iowa is the best team in college football to follow because they make people so angry by winning while being terrible on offense

I love this Iowa team so much because they make people so angry. They're so bad for their offense... People are going to be so, so angry about them playing in the Big 10 championship game. They have found, they've hacked the system. Offense is irrelevant. You could just win games in the Big 10 West by just playing defense and special teams.

Iowa did indeed win the Big 10 West and reach the Championship game with a historically bad offense, frustrating many fans.

Brian Baldinger Breaks the Tape

Brian Baldinger joined the show to do what he does best: live, breathe, and sleep football. Baldy is convinced that the Detroit Lions have officially graduated from 'nice story' to 'legitimate contender' because of their massive shift in identity on the defensive side of the ball.

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#22847
Brian BaldingerBrian Baldinger

The Detroit Lions are for real because they have transformed from the worst run defense into the best

I don't think [the Lions are fool's gold]. I think Jared's been playing incredible football... Last year they were the worst defensive football. Nobody was even close... They're the number one ranked run defensive football right now. Tampa Bay couldn't get two yards a carry last week. They play the game the right way.

The Lions finished the 2023 season 12-5, won their division, and reached the NFC Championship game.

He also gave Jared Goff his flowers, noting that the connection between Goff and offensive coordinator Ben Johnson has reached a level where the Lions' quarterback belongs in the highest individual award discussions.

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#14137
Brian BaldingerBrian Baldinger

Jared Goff is legitimately in the MVP conversation

No, they're 5 0 1. He's playing great football. The offense is dynamic. The guy's tough as can be. ... You're not gonna find a better quarterback than Jared Goff. And he knows, first of all, he's a lockstep with a really talented offense coordinator... He's not gonna play any better or go anywhere else like he is right now in Detroit.

Goff finished 2nd in passing yards in 2023 and led the Lions to a 12-5 record. While he wasn't a finalist, he was widely discussed in the top tier of QBs that year.

Baldy also touched on the Browns' terrifying defense. While Miles Garrett is a freak who 'dribbles' before the snap to mess with centers, the real architect of the destruction is the man calling the plays.

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#14135
Brian BaldingerBrian Baldinger

Jim Schwartz is the most important person on the Cleveland Browns defense

The defensive coordinator? Yeah. Jim Schwartz. He's the most important guy. They've had talent there in Cleveland. Now it's, it's elite right now... But you know, he's, he's a, he's a statistician mathematician. So numbers like he gets all that. But then he lets you know that this scheme and what we're running, this is why we're doing it... and then he just, you know, they just dog pressed [the 49ers] right outta the stadium.

The Browns defense finished 2023 ranked 1st in total yards allowed, largely credited to Schwartz's arrival and scheme.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne and Drake Maye

Hot Seat/Cool Throne featured a heated negotiation regarding Hank's future work schedule. Hank is attempting to pioneer a 'European model' where he grinds in the winter to secure a summer filled with nothing but 18-hole rounds.

Void
HankHank

I will work twice as hard in the winter so I can work half as much in the summer for golf

All I said is that I'm gonna work twice as hard as the winter so that I don't have to work. I can work twice as less and all in the summer. In the summer. Right. And then it all evens out. ... Europe, Europeans do it. Right. They take midday naps, siestas.

This is a personal lifestyle/work proposal and is subjective to Hank's future performance and management's approval.

PFT's Hot Seat was the Chargers' social media team. While everyone loves the anime schedules and the funny tweets, there's a growing theory that being the 'funny' team might actually be a curse for the actual football players.

Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Chargers' social media account being too funny is hurting the team's culture

I think that the Chargers Twitter account is, is too funny. And and it's resulted in actual on the field losses for you. Yeah. Be serious. This is culture matters. ... If you're asking guys, Hey, is water wet when they come off the field, they're probably, that's gonna break their brains. ... I actually, I'm starting to think that Chargers truther, he might be true. It affects team culture.

Subjective claim about the causal link between social media and team performance.

To wrap things up, UNC quarterback Drake Maye stopped by for one question. He tried his best to explain the origin of a 'Tar Heel'—hitting on the grit and the war history—before the guys schooled him on the pine tar industry. They also checked in on his relationship with Sam Howell after Big Cat's previous 'chubby' comments.

At the end of the day, whether you're a Pacific Manta or just a guy getting towed at the American Dream mall, football season remains the greatest time of year.

nflcollege-footballphilliesjustin-herbertjimbo-fisherdetroit-lions

More Takes

Win
Oct 18, 2023
#22846
Brian BaldingerBrian Baldinger

Jalen Carter is already a top-tier defensive player because he hits people differently than most 21-year-olds

He's a freak though. Like physically when you see him, you go, that's like, he's as wide as a refrigerator... he's got advanced skills for 21, 22 years old... Jalen Carter hits you, like he rocks you. He's just, he just hits people differently.

Carter went on to be a finalist for Defensive Rookie of the Year and was widely considered one of the best interior linemen in the league in 2023.
Void
Oct 18, 2023
#14136
Brian BaldingerBrian Baldinger

If Tom Brady played for the Falcons right now, they could win a Super Bowl

I feel like if you could get Tom Brady away from some celebrity of function he's at right now and put him in a Falcon uniform, I feel like they could win a Super Bowl. Yeah. Like the quarterback is just, it's, it's too up and down. They got the town is ridiculous. ... London and what they have, like they've got a and they got a solid offensive line.

This is a hypothetical 'what if' that cannot be proven, though the Falcons struggled with QB play all season and finished 7-10.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers