Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Ryan Whitney, Chargers Win A Game, CFB Talk + Guys On Panic With Jersey Jerry

Wednesday, November 18, 202628 takes · Transcript ↓

Chargers won a football game. We recap MNF and some clean up from Sunday including Drake Maye out for the year and the Jets passing on Liam Coen (-). CFB rankings have settled on chaos as everyone won Saturday plus LSU fallout and Wisconsin may be looking for a new coach (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including LeProp and new podcasts have hit the internet (-). Ryan Whitney joins the show to talk football, hockey, Internet invitational and more (-). We finish with Guys on Panic because Jersey Jerry thinks the world is ending.You can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or Netflix. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/pardon-my-take

The Chargers finally won a football game, which meant Jim Harbaugh could celebrate like he had just clinched the Super Bowl while Justin Herbert looked like he wanted absolutely no part of the high-five line. That was only the first crisis of the day. Hank's Patriots season ended with Drake Maye's ankle injury, Memes declared the Lamar Jackson dream dead, and Jersey Jerry arrived later to explain that the banking system, the FAA, China, and possibly the entire internet are all coming for us.

The Chargers Have Arrived

Big Cat believes Los Angeles can win four more games, which is either a reasonable schedule read or the first step toward Shane putting the paper bag back on his head. The Jets, Patriots, Raiders, Dolphins, and a Week 18 Broncos team with nothing to play for are all sitting there. PFT's takeaway was less about the Chargers and more about Baltimore: Lamar Jackson has been covering up an alarming number of Ravens problems, and without him the whole operation looks like a house held together by one very talented quarterback and some tape.

Memes was not interested in a Lamar-to-the-Jets rescue mission. His position was simple: Lamar gets hurt every year, so the Jets should take a young quarterback and move on. Big Cat pushed back with the obvious counterargument that Lamar, when healthy, is one of the best players in football and would still bring back multiple first-round picks.

Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31936
MemesMemes

The Lamar Jackson dream is dead

I think the Lamar Dream is dead. Okay. He's hurt every year.

This is a subjective evaluation of Lamar's future value to the Jets.

The Jets somehow got even more Jets when the Liam Coen story surfaced. The rumor is that Mike Tannenbaum refused to interview Coen because somebody else tried to put the candidate in Woody Johnson's ear. PFT still thinks the roster could be a nine- or ten-win team with a league-average quarterback, which is a bold amount of faith in a defense that finds new ways to screw up every Sunday.

Hank, meanwhile, is officially on to 2027. With Tommy DeVito as the apparent quarterback plan, tanking no longer requires much intentionality. It just happens naturally.

College Football's Calm Before the Playoff

Saturday was a rare college football weekend where every team that needed to lose actually lost, and every team with a playoff pulse kept winning. Big Cat thinks UCLA should be ahead of two-loss Alabama, while Indiana remains the most entertaining version of “I have no idea if this team is good.” The Hoosiers can apparently win every playoff game 13-10 and still leave the country asking what they just watched.

Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31940
Big CatBig Cat

Indiana can reach the national championship by winning ugly

I could envision a world where Indiana gets to the national title by winning 13 to 10 in their playoff games. And everyone still is like, are they good? I think, I don't know. I have no idea. It's just what they keep doing.

Indiana's eventual playoff performance will determine whether this scenario occurs.

The Lane Kiffin conversation was more complicated than the usual “fire the coach” cycle. Big Cat thinks LSU simply got the quarterback wrong with Sam Leavitt, and he is buying Lane stock while it is cheap. That is a dangerous investment, but the argument makes sense: a $50 million roster does not matter much if the quarterback is not the guy.

Wisconsin, on the other hand, may be ready to move on from Luke Fickell after another loss to Maryland. Big Cat's dream replacement list is extremely Wisconsin: Jason Eck, Jake Dickert, or Jim Leonhard. Preferably somebody who looks like he could explain inside zone to a cow and then personally coach the defense.

Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31941
Big CatBig Cat

Georgia is the best team and will win the national title

I've said all season, I think Georgia is the best college football team and I think they're gonna win it all.

The prediction resolves when the college football national champion is crowned.

Hot Seat, Cool Throne, and One Very Sick Hippo

Hank's Hot Seat was the growing fleet of AI sports podcasts, each one equipped with bland human names, aggressive theme music, and suspicious sexual tension between the hosts. PFT thinks the current robots are bad, but warned that they will get better with reps. The PMT training data may be their biggest obstacle, considering how many names this show has already pronounced incorrectly.

Then came Luke Littler, who hit three bullseyes when he needed all three to win. Hank said it was somehow more electric than a nine-darter, which is the kind of darts take that makes you want to immediately find a bar in England and pretend you know what a checkout is.

PFT put Rex Ryan on the Cowboys' defensive coordinator wishlist, and Big Cat agreed that Rex could get the same roster to league-average or better simply by calling everyone soft until they became angry enough to tackle. Big Cat's Cool Throne was Fiona the hippo, who had swallowed a visitor's knit hat. His medical opinion: hippos have better digestive systems than this and Fiona is going to pass it.

Open
Big CatBig Cat

Fiona the hippo will pass the swallowed hat

I'm gonna say it. I think she's gonna pass this hat. Hippos have to have better digestive systems than this.

The prediction is resolved by whether Fiona passes the hat and recovers.

Whitney on McDavid, Ovechkin, and the Blackhawks

Ryan Whitney joined to be welcomed by PFT immediately asking him to make fun of the Commanders and Bears. Whitney instead attacked PFT's transformation into a full-time Glenn tape watcher, while Big Cat tried to prove he is secretly a true friend of the Oilers. The evidence was a 75-to-1 Bears-Oilers championship parlay and Big Cat screaming for Whitney during the Internet Invitational playoff hole.

The hockey portion got serious quickly. Whitney said Connor McDavid is the best player he has ever seen, currently operating in a regular season that feels like a video game. He also rejected the idea that McDavid's playoff struggles prove anything, because hockey is the ultimate team sport and one player cannot drag an entire roster across the finish line.

Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31946
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Connor McDavid is the greatest player Whitney has ever seen

He's the greatest player I've ever seen. Yes, he has to win a Stanley Cup for that statement to really live on and people to agree with me. But what we're watching, I've never seen. I've never seen anything close to it.

Greatest-ever assessments are inherently subjective, even though McDavid's career achievements can continue to affect the debate.

Whitney still sees the Oilers as a real contender, with improved defensive play, multiple goalies, and the two best players in the sport doing absurd things every night. He was much less optimistic about the Blackhawks, warning that the franchise could eventually be in danger of moving if the rebuild continues to collapse around Connor Bedard.

The most enthusiastic scouting report belonged to Matthew Schaefer. Whitney called the Islanders defenseman a franchise-changing player who will win multiple Norris Trophies and eventually sign a contract beginning with a $20 million annual salary. That is not a prospect ranking. That is a full adoption.

Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31949
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Matthew Schaefer will win multiple Norris Trophies

The Islanders happen to get it the year where they get this guy who's, he's gonna win multiple Norris Trophies. His next contract will probably start with a two in terms of the money per year. He's a franchise-changing player.

Schaefer's future awards and contract value will take multiple seasons to evaluate.

The Capitals conversation became uncomfortable when PFT suggested that Alex Ovechkin may be hurting Washington and should not simply play the entire season out of respect for his legacy. Whitney countered that healthy-scratching Ovechkin would be one of the most embarrassing ways for a legend to leave the sport. The compromise was the classic hockey solution: a mysterious injury, some Russian gas, and a month off.

Golf's Most Personal Grudge Match

Whitney loved the Internet Invitational precisely because the tournament has started to mash together golf purists, Barstool personalities, drinking videos, and people who edit 90-second grievance videos with 15 cuts. Big Cat thinks that collision is the whole point. If the fan bases hate each other, they are going to keep watching.

Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31953
Big CatBig Cat

The Internet Invitational will grow because rival fan bases hate each other

I actually think this is why the Internet Invitational's gonna get bigger and bigger because of the clash of fan bases. ... You want people to either love something or hate something.

This is a subjective prediction/opinion about the event's audience growth and entertainment value.

The Celine drama was still fresh. After losing the finale, Celine apparently texted the Happy Dad group from a private jet celebrating the event, unaware that Whitney was sitting on Dave's plane processing the loss and watching the video in real time. Whitney and Big John came out looking like the adults in the room, which is a sentence nobody expected to write about that tournament.

Hank's own golf future is now tied to Grinnell. If Hank loses the upcoming left-handed grudge match, he says he is retiring from the experiment forever. Ryan Whitney backed Grinnell, mostly because Grinnell is desperate to enter the YouTube golf world and keeps telling everyone he is nasty.

Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31954
HankHank

If I lose to Grinnell, I will retire as a lefty golfer

It is a retirement match. If I lose to Grinnell, it's a retirement match. ... If I lose to Grinnell, I'll quit. It's that simple.

The claim resolves when Hank and Grinnell play their planned match and the result is known.

Jersey Jerry Has Seen the Future

Jersey Jerry's special Guys on Panic segment began with a company-wide emergency email encouraging employees to buy gold, silver, water, pasta, rice, and guns. The trigger was a series of short outages: the FAA, Outlook, and the banks for roughly 15 minutes. To Jerry, this is not a series of glitches. It is the opening act.

Jerry believes a Chinese AI bot swarm is attacking American systems and that Barstool is not prepared for the day everything goes dark. PFT tried to determine whether China has an actual bot army or just a billion people typing at once. Jerry's answer was essentially that the distinction does not matter, which is exactly how a panic theory survives every follow-up question.

Open
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

A Chinese AI bot swarm is attacking American systems

I'm pretty certain these are, this is a full-on Chinese bot swarm.

Whether the cited outages were caused by a Chinese AI bot swarm would require credible confirmation; the claim is not established here.

His apocalypse go-bag contains guns, 1,500 to 2,000 rounds of ammunition, a pallet of water, rice, ramen, canned goods, fire starters, firewood, candles, and flashlights. He also believes 80% of the population could make it 120 days after society collapses. Big Cat, by contrast, gave himself four days. The only thing that briefly disrupted the segment was Max proving that the Apple App Store still worked.

Open
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

Most people could survive 120 days after society collapses

I think 80% of the population would last 120 days.

This prediction would require a societal-collapse scenario that has not occurred, so it remains unresolved.

The episode ended with numbers, birthdays, and the usual scramble to make the final number feel important. Jerry never got his perfect number, but he did get a birthday wish and a platform to prepare Barstool for the robot war. Keep your water close and your headphones working.

ryan-whitneyconnor-mcdavidcollege-football-playoffchargersnhlinternet-invitationaljersey-jerryai

More Takes

Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31935
Big CatBig Cat

The Chargers will win four more games

I think they can get to four or five wins. I think they're gonna win four games, 'cause again, the Jets, the Patriots, the Raiders and Dolphins, those are four games that they could. Even if they go two and two, you gotta win one other game.

The Chargers' final win total will determine whether this prediction was accurate.
Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31957
Big CatBig Cat

Lamar Jackson is still worth multiple first-round picks

When he plays, he's one of the best. ... Lamar's still getting multiple first-rounders.

This is a valuation opinion about a hypothetical trade market for Lamar Jackson.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31937
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Jets are a nine- or ten-win team with an average quarterback

I think that you add a league average quarterback or above average quarterback, I think this is like a nine or 10 win team.

The claim depends on the Jets adding a league-average-or-better quarterback and then winning roughly nine or ten games.
Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31938
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Burrow has reached prime Aaron Rodgers territory

He's reaching to me in that prime Aaron Rodgers zone where when his back foot hits the ground on his drop, it's gonna be a completion.

This is an evaluative comparison of quarterback performance and is inherently subjective.
Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31939
Big CatBig Cat

UCLA should be ranked ahead of Alabama

UCLA's been awesome. They're undefeated. They should absolutely be ahead of Alabama who's lost twice.

This is a subjective ranking opinion that could be debated but cannot be definitively judged.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31958
Big CatBig Cat

Lane Kiffin will have LSU rolling if he gets the quarterback right

I will buy stock if people are selling stock in Lane Kiffin. ... If Lane gets his quarterback, they'll be good.

Whether LSU becomes good under Kiffin after correcting the quarterback position will be evaluated over future seasons.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31942
Big CatBig Cat

Luke Fickell is probably out at Wisconsin

I think it's probably a it for Luke Fickell. That's a bad loss. ... You can't keep doing this.

Wisconsin's eventual decision on Luke Fickell will resolve the claim.
Open
HankHank

AI sports podcasts are on the hot seat

My Hot Seat is US Sports Podcasts. There's a company that has come out with just an entire fleet of AI podcasts covering basically every sports team.

Whether AI sports podcasts materially displace human shows is a future, testable media trend.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

AI podcasts will get better with more reps

No, but yes. But they're gonna get better at it. You give them reps and they'll get better.

The quality trajectory of AI-generated sports podcasts is a future media question and has not been definitively resolved.
Void
HankHank

Luke Littler's three-bullseye finish was better than a nine-darter

Obviously we talk about the nine-darter, the most electric thing in sports. He was in a match where he needed to hit three bullseyes to win and he did it. It was somehow better than the nine-darter.

The relative excitement of the two darts moments is inherently subjective.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Rex Ryan could make the Cowboys defense average or better

Rex Ryan ... immediately suggested that he could be the defensive coordinator for the Cowboys and get them to play with the exact same roster at like a league-average to maybe above-average level. I think he might not be wrong.

This is a hypothetical coaching evaluation and cannot be definitively judged without the proposed change occurring.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31947
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Oilers are a true Stanley Cup contender

Right now we can ride these guys all the way hopefully to a Presidents' Trophy, if not at least winning the Pacific.

The Oilers' regular-season finish and playoff result will determine these forecasts.
Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31961
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Hockey is the sport where one player cannot carry a team

Hockey's the number one sport that you can't do it with one guy. ... It's the greatest team game in the world.

This is a subjective comparison of how much individual players can influence championships across sports.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31948
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

The Blackhawks could be in danger of losing the franchise

I mentioned Chicago, and they're in some danger of losing their team. Of them having to move. It's ugly. It's gross. It sucks.

Whether the Blackhawks relocate is a future organizational outcome and has not been resolved.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31950
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Ovechkin should not play the whole season if he keeps hurting Washington

He's hurting the team and he knows that he's hurting the team. ... If it's just, it continues like this, I would say that we'd have to have a talk with him.

This is a conditional coaching and roster-management judgment that depends on Ovechkin's continued performance.
Void
Nov 18, 2026
#31951
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Georgia is the best team in college football by a mile

Georgia, Georgia's the best team in college football by a mile.

This is a subjective assessment of team quality.
Open
Nov 18, 2026
#31952
Ryan WhitneyRyan Whitney

Georgia will win the national championship

At this point, like there's so much parity in college football ... now watching Georgia and seeing what they have, I don't see anyone that can play with them.

The prediction resolves when the college football national champion is crowned.
Open
Jersey JerryJersey Jerry

A major outage could leave Barstool dark for weeks

I'm predicting in the next coming days, weeks, months, it's possible years, there will be a time where Barstool hasn't prepped for this and then we're at home. ... Something's gonna happen to where we go dark for like a couple weeks.

The prediction would be resolved by a prolonged outage that prevents Barstool from operating for multiple weeks.

Transcript

Loading transcript…

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!