Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Shane Gillis In Studio, NFL Rule Changes, Shohei Speak + Mad Online

Wednesday, March 27, 202419 takes

NFL league meetings this week and we have some big time rule changes (-). Shohei finally speaks to the media and we talk Sweet 16 and Caitlin Clark (-). Hot Seat/Cool Throne including Flaco the Owl had pigeon herpes and Robert Kraft is trying to find the guy who made a negative Patriots documentary (-). Shane Gillis joins the show in studio to talk Football, hosting SNL, comedy, Notre Dame and tons more (-). We finish with mad online (-).

Shane Gillis on SNL, Notre Dame Football, and New NFL Rules

The NFL is back to its favorite hobby: changing the rules of the game to confuse everyone. The big news out of the league meetings is the banning of the hip-drop tackle, a move that Big Cat and PFT are already predicting will lead to a 15-yard disaster in a crucial playoff moment. It’s a subjective call that’s going to make life a nightmare for defensive players who are just trying to stop a 250-pound tight end from steamrolling them.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13881
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Banning the hip drop tackle is a massive mistake for the NFL

Banning that [swivel hip drop tackle] would be a massive, massive mistake. Mistake, mistake... It's such a subjective call because you have to have certain elements that are involved in the speed that the game's played at. You're gonna have referees that are like, 'I think that was a hip drop tackle. I'm not really sure.'

The rule has been highly controversial in the 2024 season, with many fans and analysts sharing PFT's sentiment about its subjectivity.

PFT thinks the referees are going to be guessing half the time, while Big Cat is looking at the ripple effect on the field. If you can't bring a guy down from behind by dropping your weight, certain positions are about to see a massive boost in production.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13886
Big CatBig Cat

Banning the hip drop tackle makes tight ends even more valuable

I also think this now makes the tight end position even more valuable because a lot of the hip drop tackles are defensive back, smaller guys getting beat a little bit and trying to slow down a bigger guy with a hip drop tackle where he is trying to, you know, don't ride on top of him and let him get a couple extra yards. Try to stop his momentum and bring him backwards. I now that you can't do that, I think tight ends are gonna eat in the flats.

Tight end usage remains high, but it's hard to definitively attribute their success solely to the hip-drop ban versus general offensive trends.

On the brighter side, we’re finally getting some life back in the kickoff. The NFL is adopting the XFL-style kickoff where everyone stands still until the ball is caught. PFT is convinced the league played a long game here by making the old kickoff so boring that we’d accept literally anything else.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13887
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The NFL intentionally made kickoffs unwatchable for years to force fans to accept the new XFL-style rule

What the NFL did was they made kickoffs so shitty for the last couple seasons that now we're welcoming anything that involves a return... The NFL, it was a good job on their part in the long term to make kickoffs unwatchable and so shitty that now they add any sort of element that has return game in it and people are like, 'yeah, this rocks now.'

The logic follows a 'New Coke' strategy, but there's no way to verify the league's intentionality in tanking a product to sell a replacement.

Shohei and the Sweet 16

Shohei Ohtani finally spoke to the media about the gambling scandal involving his interpreter, Ippei Mizuhara. Big Cat is taking the path of believing the face of baseball until the forensic accountants prove otherwise, but PFT is skeptical of the timing regarding Shohei’s surprise marriage reveal right before the news broke.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#21700
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Shohei Ohtani revealed his wife as part of a crisis management strategy to distract from the impending gambling scandal

Shohei found out about the investigation, hired a crisis team and then part of their crisis team was like, we need to get ahead of the negative publicity. Let's show everybody your superstar wife.

The timing is suspicious but cannot be definitively proven as a calculated distraction.

In college hoops, the Sweet 16 is set. Big Cat is looking for an ironic champion to punish the show for their lack of respect toward a certain ACC program. He’s already preparing to eat a massive amount of crow if the Tigers keep dancing.

Loss
Mar 27, 2024
#21699
Big CatBig Cat

Clemson is the most likely underdog to win the national championship because it would be the perfect ironic ending to the tournament

I think Clemson is most likely because Clemson has been ignored by this podcast... So when we say we put out that graphic listing every team but Clemson as teams that could win the national title, they have that bookmark that will be the perfect ending to March Madness if Clemson wins it all.

Clemson lost in the Elite Eight to Alabama.

Shane Gillis in Studio

The long-awaited Shane Gillis interview finally happened. Shane came by the Chicago studio to talk about the whirlwind of hosting SNL, his upcoming Netflix series *Tires*, and his deep-rooted obsession with Notre Dame football. Despite being a superstar, Shane is still the same guy who quit West Point after three weeks and spent his early twenties coaching peewee football to fulfill community service requirements.

Big Cat asked the tough questions, specifically about which championship Shane would value more: his beloved Eagles or the Fighting Irish. Shane didn't hesitate.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13895
Shane GillisShane Gillis

I would trade an Eagles Super Bowl victory for a Notre Dame National Championship

Wait, would you rather have a Notre Dame national title than an Eagles Super Bowl? [Shane Gillis]: Yes. Without a doubt. No doubt. Yeah.

Personal preference of a fan cannot be right or wrong.

They also got into the return of the NCAA Football video game. Shane is planning to go off the grid once it drops, though PFT has some theories on why Arch Manning decided to keep his likeness out of the game for now.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#21703
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Arch Manning opted out of the college football video game to protect his teammate Quinn Ewers from fan pressure

I think it's because... if you're a Texas fan, every Texas fan that plays the Longhorns would [put in Arch]. And then everyone's gonna be like, yo fuck Quinn Ewers. Why is he playing in real life? Because everyone's playing his Arch in the video game. And I think Arch was trying to be a good teammate to be like, I don't want all this pressure on my teammate Quinn.

Manning eventually reversed his decision and joined the game later, but his initial motivations remain speculative.

Shane shared what it was like returning to SNL years after being fired, including the awkwardness of sitting in the same offices where his "cancellation" originally went down. He credited Lorne Michaels for having his back during the monologue and letting him be himself, even if that meant making some people in the front row a little uncomfortable.

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13899
Shane GillisShane Gillis

The upcoming election cycle will swing the comedy pendulum back toward censorship and sensitivity

I think this election's gonna swing it back. It'll go back to being [sensitive]. It'll go back... It's gonna get hot on the streets.

Cultural trends are difficult to measure objectively, but this is a common sentiment in the comedy world.

Hot Seat/Cool Throne

Hot Seat is Jontay Porter, who is currently under investigation for prop betting irregularities. It’s a bad look for the NBA when a guy’s "under" becomes the most popular bet of the night right before he leaves a game with an eye injury.

Win
HankHank

The NBA investigation into Jontay Porter for prop betting irregularities is a bad look

My Hot Seat is Jontay Porter. Raptors center is under an NBA investigation into irregularities on his prop betting involving him. There was a couple times where he basically started a game, took himself out because of a eye injury. And on those games there was a bunch of action on his prop bets. Unders... This is bad.

Jontay Porter was banned from the NBA for life shortly after this episode for betting on games and disclosing confidential info to other bettors.

Cool Throne is Caleb Williams, who showed up to a USC game with a pink phone and matching nails. While the internet was losing its mind, Big Cat was busy defending his future quarterback’s honor.

Void
Big CatBig Cat

Caleb Williams having a pink phone and pink nails is cool and masculine

Speaking of Caleb Williams, he's got a cool pink phone... He was at the USC game last night. He has a pink phone. Got people really upset. I say maybe think differently. He's so advanced. He knows that pink phones are cool.

Whether something is 'cool' or 'masculine' is inherently subjective.

We wrapped things up with some Mad Online, where Hank expressed the frustration every golf fan feels when they realize they still can't watch the most important tournament of the year without navigating five different apps.

Void
Mar 27, 2024·Mad Online
#13901
HankHank

Masters TV coverage is a joke because fans can't watch it all live

Best golf tournament of the year. And we cannot watch all of it live in 2024. It's a joke. Put it all on TV or online. I don't care. But I wanna watch it Thursday morning.

Broadcasting rights for the Masters are notoriously restrictive, though the Masters App offers some relief.

Keep an eye on those tight ends this fall, because the hip-drop ban is basically an invitation to run through everyone in the secondary.

nflsnlnotre-dameshohei-ohtanicollege-basketball

More Takes

Void
Mar 27, 2024
#13884
Big CatBig Cat

A big NFL game will be decided by a hip drop tackle penalty this year

The first reason in my mind is we have just added a rule that is going to be debated similar to can't land on the quarterback. There will be a big, big game decided by the hip drop. Because what is it, what's the penalty now? Is it 15 yards?

Whether a 'big game' was decided specifically by a hip drop tackle penalty is hard to definitively verify. The rule was implemented but no singular iconic game-deciding hip drop tackle penalty dominated headlines.
Void
Mar 27, 2024
#21698
Big CatBig Cat

The perfect answer for onside kicks is replacing them with a fourth-and-20 play for the offense

I do think the perfect answer for onside kicks is you should just have it a be a fourth and 20 play for offense. Yeah. Because everyone would love that.

This is a subjective proposal for a rule change.
Win
Mar 27, 2024
#13890
Big CatBig Cat

I believe Shohei Ohtani's story about Ippei Mizuhara stealing his money

Shohei, I believe him. I don't know why... but I just think like, I'm gonna believe him until they do the forensic accounting. I'm waiting for the forensic accounting to come out.

Forensic accounting and federal investigations later confirmed Ippei Mizuhara stole over $17 million from Ohtani without his knowledge, fully vindicating Ohtani.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

JJ McCarthy will not be drafted second overall

I don't think he's [JJ McCarthy] going second overall... there's a lot of like misinformation that gets put out there this time of year.

JJ McCarthy was drafted 10th overall by the Minnesota Vikings; Jayden Daniels went 2nd.
Open
Big CatBig Cat

JJ McCarthy has the potential to be the greatest quarterback of all time because of his winning pedigree and untapped upside

JJ McCarthy's a perfect quarterback where you can look at it and if you wanna look at it glass half full, he could be the greatest quarterback of all time. 'cause you can essentially say he played winning football, he made the throws he needed to make, and they also asked him not to do anything. So there's so much more. There's upside.

McCarthy's NFL career is still in its infancy; he missed his entire rookie season due to injury.
Void
Mar 27, 2024
#21704
Shane GillisShane Gillis

New Orleans and Miami are bad comedy towns because they are just parades of drunk people

There's like New Orleans and Miami [that are bad towns]... It's a parade of drunk people. Yeah... everything... it's like, it's a parade of drunk people.

This is a subjective professional opinion.
Push
Mar 27, 2024
#13897
Shane GillisShane Gillis

Notre Dame will go 11-1 this season and then get smoked in the playoffs

But you see the schedule, they're probably [going] 11 and one. And then get fucking smoked in the playoffs against somebody.

Notre Dame went 11-1 in the regular season as Shane Gillis predicted. However, they did not get 'smoked' in the playoffs — they won three playoff games before losing to Ohio State 23-34 in the National Championship. The regular season prediction was spot-on, but they performed better in the playoffs than expected.
Void
Mar 27, 2024·Mad Online
#21705
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

College football should adopt multi-year contracts for players to improve the sport's quality and television ratings

I tend to agree with Jay Bilas take that it should just be multi-year contracts for players. Because the big thing is if you get one year of a player, then they leave. That stinks. I think it's bad for the sport overall... doing multi-year contracts would keep players around you. And then the fan base would grow custom these players.

This is a proposal for institutional change.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers