Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Smylie Kaufman Talking PGA Championship, Knicks Whomp The Celtics, Thunder To The WCF, Miami Marlins Kyle Stowers And Tyler Phillips In Studio And A Goodbye To Mr Bing Bong

Monday, May 19, 202521 takes

We had a weekend full of sports and Hank is trying to avoid talking about Friday night and the Knicks whomping of the Celtics so we talk about everything else first. Thunder take down the Nuggets and grow up in front of our eyes (-). Scottie Scheffler dominates the PGA Championship and wins his third major (-). Maple Leafs lose in Game 7 and the Stars advance (-). We talk some WNBA and Hank empties the clip on other stories (-). We finally get to Friday night and talk Knicks Celtics and Hank's mental state and whether hes smashing the rebuild button (-). Who's back of the week (-). Smylie Kaufman joins the show to talk PGA Championship, just how good Scottie Scheffler is, mud balls, Rory not talking to the media and tons more (-). We then welcome on Miami Marlins Kyle Stowers and Tyler Phillips talking baseball, making it to the big leagues, hitting dingers, and tons more (-). We finish with a recap of Max's AWL Bachelor party and a surprise farewell to Mr Bing Bong (-).

Smylie Kaufman on Scottie's Greatness, Knicks Whomp Celtics, and the Marlins

Monday morning and the sports world is officially on fire. We just witnessed a weekend that featured two NBA Game 7s, a PGA Championship masterclass, and the absolute destruction of Hank’s soul. PFT opened by pointing out that the hype leading up to these win-or-go-home games usually exceeds the actual product, which ended up being a prophetic observation given the blowouts we saw in the NBA and the NHL.

Void
May 19, 2025
#17532
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The anticipation for a Game 7 is better than the actual Game 7

The anticipation for the game seven is way better than the actual game sevens. This is making me disagree with LeBron's take... I might be a game six guy. That's the new game seven.

The Thunder handled the Nuggets in a game that felt like a changing of the guard. Big Cat noted that the NBA has entered a rare era where the trophy is truly up for grabs every single year, as the Nuggets' early exit guarantees a fresh face on the podium.

Win
May 19, 2025
#17533
Big CatBig Cat

NBA parity is officially back with seven different champions in seven years

Parity is back. NBA parity is officially back this now with the thunder beating the nuggets in game seven. There are going to be, it's guaranteed seven different champions in seven different years in the NBA.

The NBA did indeed have a streak of different champions (Raptors, Lakers, Bucks, Warriors, Nuggets, etc.).

While Nikola Jokic is still the MVP, the guys weren't ready to let him off the hook for a quiet Game 7. Big Cat argued that if you're the undisputed best player on the planet, you have to be the one to drag your team across the finish line when the shots aren't falling.

Void
May 19, 2025
#17536
Big CatBig Cat

Nikola Jokic failed the 'best player in the world' standard in the series against the Thunder

I think it's fair to hold him to the standard of best player in the world. And if he was the best player in the world, game four and seven, he could have played better and they could have won this series. The conversation of Jokic is best player in the world... can sometimes be like, I'm gonna take over this series and win this series. He didn't do that and that didn't happen.

The Knicks Are Back and New York is Scary

The biggest story of the weekend was Friday night’s beatdown where the Knicks essentially ended the Celtics' season. New York is buzzing in a way we haven't seen in decades, and Big Cat thinks the city is primed for a level of chaos that would put other sports towns to shame if they actually go all the way.

Void
May 19, 2025
#28175
Big CatBig Cat

New York City is the most likely city to 'burn down' proverbially during a championship celebration

I think the Knicks might be the number one city to proverbially burn down in a championship. And I was thinking about this... just the most chaotic scenes possible after a championship.

Subjective ranking of fan intensity.

Hank, looking visibly broken, was forced to watch a compilation of his most confident (and wrong) takes from the last few months. He finally conceded that the better team won the series, admitting that Jalen Brunson has completely shifted the power dynamic in the East.

Win
May 19, 2025
#17540
HankHank

The New York Knicks were a better team than the Boston Celtics in their playoff series

The Nicks were the better team than the Celtics. They're... a better team than the Celtics. I'm not gonna argue that right now because I was wrong too. I thought the Knicks, I did not think the Knicks would be in the Eastern Conference final.

The Knicks defeated the Celtics in the series described, making them literally the better team for that matchup.

Speaking of Jalen Brunson, Big Cat isn't waiting for a ring to start building the statue. He believes Brunson has already surpassed most of the franchise legends who have come through the Garden over the last fifty years.

Void
May 19, 2025
#17539
Big CatBig Cat

Jalen Brunson is already a top-five New York Nick of all time

I think Jalen Brunson is already a top five Nick. I think it's the list now is Patrick Ewing, Willis Reed and Walt Frazier and then it's like, yeah, Earl Pearl and then like Mellow is somewhere in there. I think he's a top five nick of all time in the three years that he's been there.

Scottie Scheffler’s World and WNBA Drama

Smylie Kaufman joined the show to break down Scottie Scheffler’s third major win and the absolute clinic he put on at Quail Hollow. Smylie highlighted that while Jon Rahm and Rory McIlroy have their moments, Scottie's consistency and ball-striking are reaching heights we haven't seen since the red polo era. Big Cat thinks we’re looking at a guy who is going to need a bigger trophy room before he’s even thirty.

Open
May 19, 2025
#17537
Big CatBig Cat

Scottie Scheffler will eventually reach double-digit majors

If everything stays like, you know, if he stays healthy and plays for 15 more years, like it does feel like he will be in that double digit majors territory.

Scheffler has three majors currently in the episode's timeline. Reaching ten is a very high bar that only two players have ever hit.

They also touched on the opening of the WNBA season and the blossoming rivalry between Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese. While the discourse on social media is toxic enough to melt a hazmat suit, Big Cat pointed out the glaring gap in on-court production between the two stars.

Void
May 19, 2025
#17538
Big CatBig Cat

The Caitlin Clark vs. Angel Reese rivalry is awkward because Clark is much better at basketball

Caitlyn Clark is so much better than Angel Reese at basketball that it's not, it doesn't feel fair. I actually feel bad for Angel Reese at this point. She wants a rivalry and she has history with Kaitlyn Clark, but it's nowhere near equal footing in terms of play... Kaitlyn Clark needs a different rival because this one is just not fair.

Marlins in Studio and Max's Bachelor Party

Kyle Stowers and Tyler Phillips from the Miami Marlins stopped by to talk about the grind of the big leagues and the transition from being a starter to a reliever. They discussed the psychology of the game, including the terrifying reality of getting hit by a 93-mph fastball. Tyler Phillips even humored the guys on the age-old debate of whether a regular person could survive an inning in the majors.

Void
May 19, 2025
#17544
Tyler PhillipsTyler Phillips

An average person could likely get three outs in a Major League game eventually

I think you get three outs. Yeah. Like, honestly... The ball is bound to go to somebody. Yeah. Like there's no, like, it just goes against odds for the ball to just keep landing in the grass somewhere. Right.

We closed out the show with a recap of Max's bachelor party in the woods, which involved backyard football, rolled ankles, and an appearance by a "Wild Card" friend who took a dart to the foot without flinching. Big Cat remains a firm believer that these isolated cabin trips are the gold standard for sending a guy off to marriage.

Void
May 19, 2025
#28180
Big CatBig Cat

The best bachelor parties are 'cabin in the woods' trips rather than going to bars in a city

Best bachelor party. So when you, when you're with your boys and there's not like a oh, like let's go out to this bar and then everyone gets, you know, separated. It's like just the boys hanging.

Purely a matter of personal preference.

Before letting him go, Mr. Bing Bong made a final, glorious appearance to taunt Hank one last time before his "retirement" and eventual move to Mostly Sports.

Good luck finding your eardrums by Wednesday, Hank.

nba-playoffspga-championshipknickscelticsthundernuggets

More Takes

Void
May 19, 2025
#17534
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Gordon is a beast for playing through a grade two hamstring injury

Aaron Gordon played in game seven with a grade two hammy. And if the Lakers were in this game, LeBron would still be two weeks away from coming back because LeBron, remember when he got hurt in the last game of the Laker season, they some, for some reason put out a timetable for his return, which no one needed or asked for.

The comparison of toughness is subjective, but Gordon did play through a significant hamstring injury during that playoff run.
Void
May 19, 2025
#17535
Big CatBig Cat

Alex Caruso is underrated because two different franchises let him go for nothing

Alex Caruso... he is underrated because two franchises basically got rid of Caruso for nothing. The Lakers let 'em walk because they were cheap and didn't wanna go in the luxury tax and the Bulls didn't get a pick for 'em. Even though they should have.

Win
May 19, 2025
#28174
Big CatBig Cat

The Maple Leafs didn't choke this year; they simply lost to a better Florida Panthers team

I don't think you can wa i this wasn't one of those Leafs choked Haha. Leaf choked seasons. They played a better team and went to seven games and lost.

The Panthers were indeed the defending champions in this scenario and played 'perfect hockey' according to Big Cat.
Void
May 19, 2025
#17541
HankHank

I'm leaning towards the Boston Celtics needing a rebuild

I trust Brad Stevens with my life, but I'm leaning towards rebuild ish. Probably. Someone needs to figure out how we can keep Jalen Brown and Jason Tatum and still have good enough players around them to compete. It doesn't, not a tax guy at all. It doesn't look, I can't wrap my head around it yet.

Void
May 19, 2025
#28176
HankHank

I am rooting for the Knicks to reach the NBA Finals specifically so I can watch them get their hearts broken

I'll be rooting for the Knicks to win the Eastern Conference... Ooh, that's huge... I want, I want the Knicks to get their heart broken.

Stated rooting interest.
Win
May 19, 2025
#28177
Big CatBig Cat

The Thunder are the best team remaining in the NBA playoffs

I think the Thunder are probably the best team still standing.

The Thunder were indeed the best team remaining in the playoffs. They had a league-best 68-14 regular season record and went on to win the 2025 NBA Championship, beating the Pacers in 7 games.
Void
May 19, 2025·Who's Back
#17542
HankHank

The show 'The Librarians: The Next Chapter' looks like the dumbest show of all time

The librarians, the next chapter. They're showing these commercials in all these games. It like it. I can't believe it's a real show that is being made. It looks like this is the best whose guy ever dumb this fucking show of all time.

Void
May 19, 2025
#28178
Big CatBig Cat

Rory McIlroy's potential Masters victory will have an asterisk because he's been using an illegal driver

Rory had an illegal driver at the Masters asterisk. He needs to still win the masters to complete the grand slam.

Subjective application of an asterisk to a future or past hypothetical win.
Void
May 19, 2025
#17543
Smylie KaufmanSmylie Kaufman

Ludvig Åberg's game is built for winning major championships

Ludwig Åberg would be another guy too, who's, I think his game is built for major championships. Ludwig is already contended at the Masters a couple different times.

Whether Ludvig Aberg's game is 'built for winning major championships' is a subjective assessment of a golfer's style and potential.
Open
May 19, 2025
#28179
Smylie KaufmanSmylie Kaufman

Jon Rahm is still a top-five talent in the world and could win the next major

He's still one of the, one of the top five most talented players in the world. There's no doubt about it. Yes, he can win a major if you can win the next major. That's how good [Jon Rahm] is.

The 'top five' part is subjective, while the prediction of winning a major is pending.
Loss
May 19, 2025
#28181
Big CatBig Cat

The Indiana Pacers will beat the New York Knicks in seven games

I think it's gonna be Pacers and seven.

The Pacers beat the Knicks in six games (4-2) in the Eastern Conference Finals, not seven as predicted. Then the Pacers lost the NBA Finals to the Thunder in seven games.

PMTDB Comments

This generates your username. Same passphrase = same name. Make it unique and memorable!

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers