Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Void
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

The 90s Cowboys would have won five straight Super Bowls if Jimmy Johnson stayed

We often talk about we would've could've won five straight, [with Jimmy Johnson] but it didn't happen that way.

Counterfactual history that cannot be proven.

More from this episode

View episode
Win
Sep 3, 2025
#15959
HankHank

The Patriots' best-case scenario is 12 wins and an AFC Championship appearance

Best case, 12 wins, win the division. [Make] the AFC Championship. I don't want to get crazy.

The Patriots went 14-3, won the AFC, and reached the Super Bowl, exceeding the best-case of 12 wins and AFC Championship.
Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15960
Big CatBig Cat

Joe Burrow will win NFL MVP

I'm taking Joe Burrow this year. Joe Burrow's my pick.

Joe Burrow did not win 2025 MVP. Bengals went 6-11. Stafford won.
Loss
Sep 3, 2025
#15961
HankHank

Jordan Love will win NFL MVP

I'm taking Jordan Love. I think the Packers are gonna be filthy.

Jordan Love did not win 2025 MVP. Stafford won. Packers went 9-8-1.

More from Michael Irvin

View profile
Void
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

George Pickens will be a phenomenal talent for the Cowboys

Phenomenal talent [George Pickens]... imagine what he must feel like Right now with a Dak Prescott that quarterback. Yeah.

Fictional scenario within the episode's context.
Win
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

Tony Pollard is the best running back of the weekend over Derrick Henry

Tony Pollard's number one, because he took 15 rushes to get 131 yards. It's not just the number of yards. It's also how many times did I touch the ball to get it? Derrick Henry, I think had 32 carries for 219 yards... Parlor, we can't run him 30 times. That's not him. But yes, I believe that he's a true playmaker.

Pollard averaged 8.7 YPC while Henry averaged 6.8 YPC that weekend. While Henry's volume was higher, Irvin's point on efficiency is factually supported for that specific window.
Loss
Michael IrvinMichael Irvin

Odell Beckham Jr. would love to play for the Dallas Cowboys

I guarantee you I could tell you Odell would love to see Odell on the cowboy. Trust me. Trust me. I know Dale. Odell and I have had conversations about that a long time ago. Odell has to be in a place where the lights are bright. For him to be his best. You can't stick him in Cleveland. Put him in LA, put him in New York. You put him in Dallas where that light is bright.

OBJ flirted heavily with the Cowboys in 2022 but ultimately did not sign that season. He signed with the Ravens in 2023 and the Dolphins in 2024, never actually joining Dallas despite Irvin's 'guarantee'.