Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Giants should trade for JJ McCarthy

The idea is that JJ McCarthy—you trade for JJ McCarthy. If he does well, you can then trade JJ McCarthy. You have options at quarterback because he's still young, and if he does poorly, you're gonna have a top-five pick anyway. That's kind of a no-lose situation for the Giants.

Whether the Giants should make this trade is a subjective roster-construction judgment.

More from this episode

View episode
Open
Sep 25, 2026
#31475
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Falcons can win the NFC South with Michael Penix

I think that the Falcons can win with him. He, I think that Stefanski is a good enough coach and I think that he's accurate enough and he's a good enough passer that they could win a good amount of football games with the rushing attack that they have. And if they have a half decent defense, I think he might be—I don't know that he's gonna be the guy that you would trade up for in the draft—but I think he's going to be a good enough quarterback where they should win that division.

The 2026 season was still ongoing, so the division prediction had not resolved.
Void
Sep 25, 2026
#31476
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers might simply be a bad football team

The Packers might be that bad. Like they might just be that bad.

Whether the Packers were truly a bad team is a season-long subjective judgment.
Void
Sep 25, 2026
#31477
Big CatBig Cat

PCA is the National League MVP

But PCA going 40-40 was awesome. He's the best. He's the N-L-M-V-P.

MVP is an award judgment and inherently subjective, even though the eventual award could provide an external benchmark.

More from Big Cat

View profile
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The Packers might simply be a bad football team

The Packers might be that bad. Like they might just be that bad.

Whether the Packers were truly a bad team is a season-long subjective judgment.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

PCA is the National League MVP

But PCA going 40-40 was awesome. He's the best. He's the N-L-M-V-P.

MVP is an award judgment and inherently subjective, even though the eventual award could provide an external benchmark.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The NFL is becoming the No Fun League again

We're back to the no fun league. It's no fun league. Every player in solidarity should pretend to chug a beer in the end zone this weekend.

Whether the NFL is a No Fun League is a subjective characterization.