Skip to content
PMTPMT DB
Void
MaxMax

Justin Herbert is a 'big stupid pick guy' who throws interceptions in critical moments.

I just think that Justin Herbert is the biggest, like what if, what if, what if quarterback of all time. ... this guy like just shows time and time again that he, he, he's just like a big stupid pick guy. He throws out stupid picks.

Subjective evaluation of a player's tendency/narrative.

More from this episode

View episode
Void
Oct 20, 2025
#2024
Big CatBig Cat

Trevor Lawrence is the most sackable quarterback in the NFL because his spin moves never work.

I think [Trevor Lawrence] is the most sackable quarterback we have... Trevor Lawrence I think is over for a hundred on spin moves that don't work. He like, he'll spin or try to sidestep and a guy will get one arm on him and he'll be sacked.

This is a subjective evaluation of Lawrence's pocket presence and sack rate.
Push
Oct 20, 2025
#2025
Big CatBig Cat

The Rams are officially Super Bowl contenders.

The Rams are for real, for real. They basically are in the, can we get everyone healthy for the playoffs? Can we be healthy when the playoffs come around? ... Matthew Stafford is still just as good as ever. ... Super Bowl contenders.

The Rams were Super Bowl contenders (12-5, Stafford MVP, NFCCG) but lost to Seahawks 27-31 in the NFCCG.
Void
Oct 20, 2025
#20982
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Trayvon Walker is the most forgettable number one overall pick in NFL history.

Trayvon Walker. I think he's got to be the most forgettable number one overall pick ever. And it was two years ago. ... He isn't terrible. ... but he, but he's not like, he doesn't do those flashes of anything spectacular.

Subjective opinion on legacy and memorability.

More from Max

View profile
Open
MaxMax

The Chiefs will bounce back and win the AFC West

The Chiefs are gonna come back. Everyone's down. The Chiefs are gonna come back.

The 2026 AFC West standings have not been resolved as of the episode date.
Open
MaxMax

The Eagles will win the Super Bowl over the Chargers

Eagles still win the Super Bowl over the Chargers. The Chargers are gonna get healthy throughout the year.

The 2026 Super Bowl has not occurred as of the episode date.
Void
MaxMax

I would take Jalen Hurts over Trevor Lawrence

I would take Jalen Hurts.

Quarterback preference is inherently subjective and cannot be definitively judged.