Skip to content
PMTPMT DB

Takes

Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McGlinchey is a better offensive lineman than Quenton Nelson.

My take is that Mike McGlinchey is actually the better offensive lineman from Notre Dame this year [than Quenton Nelson].

Quenton Nelson was an immediate First-Team All-Pro as a rookie and is widely considered the superior player, while McGlinchey has had a solid but less decorated career.
Loss
Sean SalisburySean Salisbury

Drew Brees is the NFL MVP

If this continues, you can't not give Brees the MVP. You have to give it to him.

Patrick Mahomes won the 2018 NFL MVP award.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

No work gets done in corporate America between the day before Thanksgiving and January 3rd

I would go one step further than that and say the year's over. No work gets done in corporate America between the day before Thanksgiving and, you know, after New Year's... and January 3rd. Get those out-of-office replies ready.

This is a subjective observation of corporate culture, though many would agree the 'holiday slide' is real.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

I am rooting for Washington State to get into the College Football Playoff

I now am rooting for Washington State to get into the playoff just to piss off... Mike Leach... is going to make [Saban or Harbaugh] so angry because they're all serious.

Washington State lost the Apple Cup to Washington and failed to reach the CFP in 2018.
Void
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Jalen Ramsey could eventually play in the fourth-tier SPHL with six months of training

If he had six months of elite training as far as becoming a hockey player, I think that he could maybe make the ECHL... I'll bump that down even more. Maybe the SPHL, which is the fourth league. And at that point, you're making $250 a week... but mentally he wouldn't understand the game much.

Ramsey never attempted to play professional hockey, so this remains a hypothetical.
Void
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

The NBA off-court drama is more entertaining than the actual games

The NBA is like – I find the off-court stuff more entertaining than the actual product itself and that's why I think that it's it's such a [successful] league... because people are just obsessed with the drama. It's like an episode of WAGS but you don't even need the wives or girlfriends, you need the players.

Subjective opinion on entertainment value.
Void
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

NHL parity is what makes it superior to all other major sports

To me, the parity is what strengthens the NHL over all the other major sports... things are constantly shaken up because of those rules... in the NBA, it's just like, hey, who's going to play the Warriors?

Whether parity makes a sport 'superior' is entirely subjective.
Void
Paul BissonnettePaul Bissonnette

Judge Judy is extremely rude and needs to mind her own business

I'm not a big Judge Judy fan. She's just very rude to people. Like, 'no, shut up.' I'm not down with that... [She] grabbed my friend's hat and took it off and said, 'you know, take your hat off in a restaurant' and walked away. I was fuming when he told me this. My blood was boiling... I would have given her the finger wave and I would have went back at her.

Subjective opinion on personality and etiquette.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Washington Wizards need to blow up their roster because the players hate each other

Washington Wizards are a dumpster fire... The whole team just hates each other. The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over, expecting a different result... Why wouldn't you trade someone? Because, I mean, they tried, and it still hasn't worked. Just blow the whole thing up.

The Wizards eventually traded Wall in 2020 and Beal in 2023, effectively blowing it up as suggested.
Void
Mike MillerMike Miller

LeBron James is by far the best player I ever played with

Well, clearly [LeBron James] is the best by far. I think you give D-Wade the nod [for second] because he has three championships, but T-Mac to me was the hardest cover ever.

This is a subjective evaluation of talent/greatness.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The New Orleans Saints are clearly the best team in football right now

The Saints are clearly, in my mind, the best team in football right now. Drew Brees is insane... 21 touchdowns, one interception, 77% completion percentage. The punter for the Saints... he's punted eight times in the last six games. That's insane.

The Saints finished 13-3 with the #1 seed in the NFC and were widely considered the best team at this point in the season.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Colt McCoy is a gamer who can tread water but won't win a big drive

Colt McCoy is the type of – he's a gamer. He's going to win you a lot of games like – 21-17, and then when you get to a big moment and you need a big drive, he's not that guy anymore.

McCoy went 0-3 as a starter in 2018 before getting injured himself. He did not lead any significant winning drives.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

James Conner has replaced Le'Veon Bell's production, but Bell is still 100% better as a receiver

James Conner made Le'Veon Bell almost expendable. If you watch that game, there were so many times that James Conner just missed a pass or didn't make a play that Le'Veon Bell 100% would have made. And so it's funny that the stats, the running stats are there, but they forget how good Le'Veon Bell is as basically a wide receiver.

Bell was widely considered the premier receiving back of his era, but the Steelers moved on successfully with Conner and others.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Bears are the third best team in the NFC

Would you say the Bears are the third best team in the NFC right now as we're sitting here? I mean, they're 7-3.

The Bears finished 12-4, which was the 3rd best record in the NFC behind the Saints and Rams. In terms of record, this was exactly correct.
Win
Jon TafferJon Taffer

The craft beer industry is currently being killed by bankers

Craft beer is getting freaking killed right now. And what's happened in the craft beer world... originally when people started making craft beers, they were into the beer. Now they're freaking bankers that are into the money. So half the craft beers now suck.

Craft beer growth slowed significantly in the late 2010s and early 2020s, and many regional breweries were indeed bought by larger conglomerates or private equity, supporting his 'bankers' point.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

Millennials ruined the service industry because they prioritize social media gratification over hard work

There is a difference between the people that we hire today and the people we hired 15, 20 years ago... When you grow up with social media today, you can post a picture of yourself looking the worst you've ever looked and somebody's going to say, man, you look great today... So we grow up getting this instant gratification all the time... when millennials now go get jobs, the gratification isn't as quick as they're used to, so they leave and they don't stay very long.

This is a subjective generational critique of workforce trends.
Void
Jon TafferJon Taffer

I would immediately fire any server who posted a celebrity's bad tip on social media

[If a server took a picture of a celebrity's bad tip and posted it on social media], I would fire him. Absolutely. [As an owner] I would probably tip her... and I'm going to promote [the celebrity visit]. I'm going to try to turn it into something good... You can't determine who's good enough for you and who's not.

This is a professional management philosophy.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Urban Meyer's sideline health issues are dramatic acting based on game flow

Urban Meyer... every single time Maryland scored, he looked like he was going to pass out. He was doing the most dramatic things on the sidelines, going to his knees and throwing his headset... And then Ohio State would come down the field and score, and he'd have his hands up, and he'd be like, I'm back, I'm good.

Meyer did have a genuine arachnoid cyst that caused him pain, but he also retired at the end of this season (after winning the Rose Bowl), fitting Big Cat's 'retiring when things get tough/weird' narrative.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Green Bay Packers are dead

Today is Friday, November 16th, and the Green Bay Packers are dead. They are. The Packers gave it their all. They really tried hard, but to fall short and to punt fourth and two with three and a half minutes left... I just do not understand that ever.

The Packers finished 6-9-1 and missed the playoffs. Mike McCarthy was fired shortly after.
Loss
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Aaron Rodgers has lost his magic

I think it's time for us to put the done shit on them. I think they're done. I think the magic has gone away from Aaron Rodgers. Listen. I think the pendulum has swung.

While Rodgers had a down year in 2018, he went on to win MVPs in 2020 and 2021, proving his 'magic' was not gone.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike McCarthy is basically just Jason Garrett without the clapping

Mike McCarthy is basically Jason Garrett. I think they're actually comparable coaches, except [McCarthy] can't do the clap thing because his short little hands won't reach around his body and just clap all the time.

McCarthy and Garrett were both eventually fired by their respective teams after years of playoff underperformance, reinforcing the comparison.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Aaron Rodgers is passionless and nonchalant about his throws

Aaron Rodgers is an exceptional talent... But doesn't it feel like he is very nonchalant about a lot of his throws? He does the flick the wrist thing. And he can do it better than anyone, and it feels like he just is very nonchalant about a lot of his throws.

Body language is subjective, but Rodgers' performance remained elite for years after this.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Doug Baldwin is a timeless, unbelievable player

Someone who doesn't get, I think, enough credit in the NFL... Doug Baldwin is like a timeless, unbelievable player... if you watched him play, you're like, 'yeah, that guy can always break a big play.'

Baldwin is widely regarded as one of the best undrafted receivers in NFL history and a key part of the Seahawks' success.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Cowboys will give their fans just enough hope to break their hearts

The Cowboys can't go out in a normal way. They can't lose and not make the playoffs by just being bad. They have to do it in a heartbreaking way. So we have not heard the last of the Cowboys this season.

The Cowboys won the division but lost in the Divisional Round to the Rams, arguably a standard 'heartbreaking' exit.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Never bet on the Oakland Raiders

Don't bet on the Raiders. Also, here's another tip. I bet on the Raiders like five times this year. They will find new ways to reach levels of incompetence that we have not seen in this country in the last 200 years.

OpinionFootballMediumSarcastic
The 2018 Raiders finished 4-12 and were one of the worst ATS (Against The Spread) teams that year.
Win
George KittleGeorge Kittle

Kyle Shanahan's offensive installs are outrageous

Every install meeting that [Shanahan] does is absolutely outrageous... he explains it so fast. He'll go through 60 plays in about 15 minutes and then you guys got all that, and we're out on the field practicing.

Shanahan's complexity and offensive success are widely documented by players and analysts.
Void
George KittleGeorge Kittle

Pancaking a defender is better than catching a touchdown

If you can take a defensive end and bend him over backwards and put his back on the turf, that's one of the greatest feelings of all time.

This is a subjective preference of the athlete.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Nick Saban definitely uses the internet and is lying about it

I think he does have all those things... I just feel like that's a guy who has the internet who's ashamed of having the internet... he always says rat poison... how does he find this stuff out if he doesn't have the internet?

While Saban maintains he doesn't use it, it's widely believed his staff monitors it for him, making the 'no internet' claim a technicality at best.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Mike Wilbon thinks analytics have hijacked baseball

Wilbon... actually thinks that we're under an analytics hijacking... Analytics have hijacked his sport, baseball. And he says that we've gone so far and we undervalue wins. He doesn't care about ERA... He cares about wins.

Wilbon did publicly state that wins should matter more and deGrom shouldn't have won.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Draymond Green definitely thinks the Warriors are his team

If I can get inside Draymond Green's head, I'm fairly confident Draymond thinks it's his team. He's the straw that serves the drink on this team.

While subjective, Draymond was often cited as the 'heartbeat' of the team, even if Curry was the star.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If a podcast lasts seven years, it is Radio Hall of Fame worthy

If you do a podcast for more than seven [years]... the 95% of podcasts go for exactly one month and end. And then the other 5%, if you can get past seven years, then you're officially Radio Hall of Fame worthy.

This is a subjective standard for hall of fame worthiness.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Bridges are more beautiful than tunnels and I love looking at them

Bridges. They're beautiful. Are you kidding me? Dude, bridges are so beautiful. The architecture, come on. ... Bridges and stadiums. I'll look at bridges and empty stadiums all day.

Purely a matter of personal taste.
Void
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

I prefer being in tunnels over bridges because bridges make me nervous

I would much rather be in a tunnel than on a bridge. ... my hands clam up when I'm driving on a bridge sometimes. I love bridges [to look at], but [driving on them]... yeah.

Subjective personal preference based on driving anxiety.
Push
Big CatBig Cat

Eli Manning is definitely going to be in the Hall of Fame

He's going to be in the Hall of Fame, which we can embrace debate. I actually looked through his numbers. I did some deep diving. It's interesting to be like he's a Hall of Famer for sure and then look at his career and be like half the seasons you had to even ask if he was good.

Eli Manning was not inducted into the Hall of Fame in his first year of eligibility (2025 class), despite being a finalist. He is a finalist again for the 2026 class. The take said 'definitely going to be in' — he likely will eventually, but he wasn't first-ballot.
Push
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The addition of Kevin Durant to the Warriors was bound to screw up the team's chemistry

This is a classic. There's just one ball. We all predicted this when [Durant] went out there that it was going to screw up the team chemistry. We were right. It just took us a longer time than we thought to get there.

While there was a public spat between Green and Durant, the Warriors still won 57 games and made the NBA Finals that season, though they did eventually lose and Durant left.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

If a foreign actor plays an American in more than three movies, they are officially American

If you are in more than three movies where you're in America in the movie, you're American. Like Idris Elba, that guy's American. He was in The Wire. When I found out he had an English accent, it blew my fucking mind... Christian Bale? American. 100%. Russell Crowe? American.

This is an entirely subjective personal rule for Big Cat.
Open
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

Bill O'Brien is a bad coach who will never win a Super Bowl

Bill O'Brien's a bad coach and no way he's going to win a Super Bowl. Yeah, exactly. No way he's going to win a Super Bowl.

Bill O'Brien was fired by the Texans in 2020 and has not won a Super Bowl as a head coach.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Kansas football should run the triple option because they will always suck otherwise

Kansas should just start running the triple option. Why not? Like, you suck. You're always going to suck unless you bring back Mark Mangino. You suck, so just run the triple option and just fuck everyone up. No one wants to play against the triple option.

Kansas hired Les Miles shortly after this, who did not run the triple option and the program remained poor for several more years.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

The holiday season officially starts right now (November 14th)

My cool throne is actually for everyone who wants to get drunk all the time, because I think we can officially say it's holiday season. Starting right now.

This is a subjective matter of social etiquette.
Void
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

Kansas football is a joke and deserved the treatment I gave them

Kansas football [is] a joke. And then you kick the shit out of them, and then you obviously are like, yeah, you guys are a joke. They should get everything that they deserve in that respect... I think it was more about being the bigger man in that one and letting them just—like you described Kansas football—letting them do that. And letting them stay at that level.

The sentiment is subjective, though Kansas football was statistically one of the worst programs in the Power 5 at the time.
Void
Baker MayfieldBaker Mayfield

I would love to run the Oklahoma offense in the NFL

Obviously the easiest answer would be, yeah, I'd love to run the offense at Oklahoma. That's because I had three years to do it, and I got so comfortable in it.

Baker's NFL career saw him struggle under various offensive systems that were often quite different from Lincoln Riley's air raid concepts.
Win
PFT CommenterPFT Commenter

The Eagles are playing like a pile of shit

They [the Eagles] are playing like a pile of shit. Offensively, they look boring. I don't know what it is that's so different from last year.

The 2018 Eagles struggled significantly compared to their Super Bowl season, finishing 9-7 and barely making the playoffs as a Wild Card.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Baker Mayfield is officially a franchise quarterback

Baker Mayfield saying, 'I woke up this morning feeling dangerous.' That's a franchise quarterback.

While Mayfield had a rocky tenure in Cleveland, he eventually led them to a playoff win and proved to be a legitimate NFL starter, later revitalizing his career in Tampa.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

Matt Patricia has officially lost the Lions' locker room

Remember the start of the season when we said Matt Patricia lost the locker room and everyone was like, 'No, you were wrong.' I think he actually has. And it's a disaster.

Patricia's tenure was famously disastrous and he was eventually fired mid-season in 2020 after numerous reports of players disliking his style.
Win
Big CatBig Cat

The Jets need to fire Todd Bowles

Todd Bowles has got to get fired. He does. He does. No, don't change the subject here. Todd Bowles has got to get fired. I remain faithful [that they should].

Todd Bowles was fired by the Jets on December 30, 2018, following the conclusion of the regular season.
Void
Big CatBig Cat

Louisville is no longer fun without Pitino and Petrino

I wish they didn't fire Pitino and Petrino, because now I feel like Louisville's just not going to be as fun anymore. They went from the horniest campus in America to now just a really boring campus.

This is subjective but reflects the general sentiment that Louisville athletics lost its 'villain' appeal following these departures.
Void
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Michigan is currently a better team than Notre Dame

I honestly think Michigan, even though it lost to Notre Dame to start the year, is better than Notre Dame. At least it's playing better... I think Michigan just overall, special teams, defense, and offense has been a better team than Notre Dame.

Subjective, but Notre Dame won the head-to-head and made the playoff while Michigan lost to Ohio State and didn't.
Loss
Big CatBig Cat

Oklahoma should not make the College Football Playoff because their defense is terrible

Oklahoma stinks. And if they somehow sneak into the college football playoff, I will be absolutely furious because their defense is so bad... Tell me there's order in this world [and they won't make it].

Oklahoma did make the College Football Playoff in 2018, finishing the regular season at 12-1 and winning the Big 12.
Win
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Ben Mason is the clear number one fullback in college football

Mason's my clear number one. No, Mason, to me, is clearly the best fullback in college right now. He just destroys dudes.

Mason was widely considered one of the best fullbacks of his era and was drafted into the NFL as one.
Void
Tom FornelliTom Fornelli

Dino Babers would be the ideal hire for USC

If I'm the Trojans, I'd go after [Dino] Babers, honestly. Because I think that he runs an exciting offense. You know, in L.A., you have to sell excitement. I think Babers is a good coach.

USC kept Clay Helton for several more seasons and eventually hired Lincoln Riley. Babers stayed at Syracuse and his stock eventually cooled.

Search

Search takes, episodes, and speakers